Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

An Analytic Approach to Probability Theory in Quantum Mechanics

Viktoras Rimsha, Laimontas Rimsha

Published Jan 29, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Born’s probabilistic interpretation of quantum mechanics is commonly assumed to rely on classical probability theory in the sense of Kolmogorov. In this paper we argue that this assumption is methodologically unjustified. We show that quantum probabilities naturally arise from an analytic method fundamentally different from the synthetic approach underlying classical probability theory. In the analytic framework, the whole (the totality of alternatives) is primary, while probabilities of individual alternatives are derived quantities. Interference appears at the level of the realization probability of the whole, whereas conditional probabilities of alternatives remain additive within a given context. We demonstrate that many well-known quantum paradoxes originate from the inappropriate application of synthetic probabilistic reasoning. The proposed formulation is consistent with the Born rule, its extensions developed in our earlier works, and with Birkhoff–von Neumann quantum logic. Classical probability theory appears only as a degenerate formal limit and is not methodologically universal.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.18411732

Related papers

Quantum Probability as a Generalized Logical Structure: From Interference Statistics to Quantum Logic and the Classical Limit

Viktoras Rimsha, Laimontas Rimsha

In this paper we propose a unified conceptual framework in which quantum probability, quantum logic, and classical probability theory are understood as different structural levels of a single theoretical hierarchy. Starting from a statistical interpretation of quantum interference, previously developed by the authors, we argue that quantum probability is not an alternative to classical Kolmogorov probability, but a more general structure. Classical probability theory emerges as a limiting case corresponding to the disappearance of interference and the effective decomposition of the whole into independent elements. Within this framework, the Birkhoff–von Neumann quantum logic appears as a natural logical expression of quantum probability rather than as an abstract algebraic construction detached from physical meaning. The priority of the whole over its parts plays a central role in both quantum probability and quantum logic, while classical logic and probability arise when this priority becomes trivial. We emphasize that the proposed interpretation does not reject existing quantum formalism, but reinterprets its logical and probabilistic foundations. This approach may have implications for the conceptual understanding of quantum algorithms and quantum information processing.

•Dec 23, 2025•0 citations

A Formula of Total Probability with the Interference Term and the Hilbert Space Representation of the Contextual Kolmogorovian Model

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

We compare the classical Kolmogorov and quantum probability models. We show that the gap between these models is not so huge as was commonly believed. The main structures of quantum theory (interference of probabilities, Born's rule, complex probabilistic amplitudes, Hilbert state space, representation of observables by operators) are present in a latent form in the Kolmogorov model. In particular, we obtain “interference of probabilities” without appealing to the Hilbert space formalism. We interpret “interference of probabilities” as a perturbation (by a cos-term) of the conventional formula of total probability. Our classical derivation of quantum probabilistic formalism can stimulate applications of quantum methods outside of the microworld, for instance, in psychology, biology, economy, and other domains of science.

Theory of Probability and Its Applications•Jan 1, 2007•8 citations

From Quantum Probability to Quantum Logic: A Structural Derivation of the Birkhoff–von Neumann Framework

Viktoras Rimsha, Laimontas Rimsha

In this paper we provide a structural derivation of Birkhoff–von Neumann quantum logic starting from an extended statistical interpretation of quantum mechanics. Quantum logic is not introduced as an independent logical hypothesis, but is shown to arise naturally from the non-classical structure of quantum probability, in particular from interference, non-additivity, and the priority of the whole over its alternatives. We demonstrate that the failure of Boolean logic in quantum mechanics is not a semantic or philosophical anomaly, but a direct consequence of the probabilistic structure encoded in Hilbert space. Within this framework, quantum logic appears as the logical form of quantum probability itself. This interpretation clarifies the physical meaning of quantum logic and highlights its contemporary relevance in quantum information and quantum computation.

•Dec 21, 2025•0 citations

A formula of total probability with interference term and the Hilbert space representation of the contextual Kolmogorovian model

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

We compare the classical Kolmogorov and quantum probability models. We show that the gap between these model is not so huge as it was commonly believed. The main structures of quantum theory (interference of probabilities, Born's rule, complex probabilistic amplitudes, Hilbert state space, representation of observables by operators) are present in a latent form in the Kolmogorov model. In particular, we obtain ``interference of probabilities'' without to appeal to the Hilbert space formalism. We interpret ``interference of probabilities'' as a perturbation (by a $\cos$-term) of the conventional formula of total probability. Our classical derivation of quantum probabilistic formalism can stimulate applications of quantum methods outside of microworld : in psychology, biology, economy,...

arXiv:math/0609197•Sep 7, 2006•4 citations

The Transformation of the Concept of Alternatives in the Analytic Approach to Quantum Probability: From Isolated Properties to Equivalence Classes

Viktoras Rimsha, Laimontas Rimsha

In our previous works [1], it was demonstrated that quantum probability calculus requires an analytic approach where the whole (the totality of alternatives) is primary, while the probabilities of individual alternatives are derived quantities. In this paper, we take an essential methodological step forward by clarifying and updating the very concept of an alternative. We argue that within the analytic framework, alternatives cannot be treated as isolated, atomized elements, as is done in the synthetic Kolmogorovian model. Instead, they function as elements of a mathematical equivalence class and never lose their global contextual feature. This refinement allows us to reconcile the local realization of historical events with the global preservation of quantum interference. Consequently, this opening offers a completely new perspective for quantum cosmology without relying on the hypothesis of an external observer.

•May 22, 2026•0 citations

Reconstruction of quantum theory on the basis of the formula of total probability

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

The notion of context (complex of physical conditions) is basic in this paper. We show that the main structures of quantum theory (interference of probabilities, Born’s rule, complex probabilistic amplitudes, Hilbert state space, representation of observables by operators) are present in a latent form in the classical Kolmogorov probability model. However, this model should be considered as a calculus of contextual probabilities. In our approach it is forbidden to consider abstract context independent probabilities: “first context and then probability.” We start with the conventional formula of total probability for contextual (conditional) probabilities and then we rewrite it by eliminating combinations of incompatible contexts from consideration. In this way we obtain interference of probabilities without to appeal to the Hilbert space formalism or wave mechanics. However, we did not just reconstruct the probabilistic formalism of conventional quantum mechanics. Our contextual probabilistic model is essentially more general and, besides the projection to the complex Hilbert space, it has other projections. The most important new prediction is the possibility (at least theoretical) of appearance of hyperbolic interference. A projection of the classical contextual probabilistic model to the hyperbolic Hilbert space (a module over the commutative two dimensional Clifford algebra) has some similarities with the projection to the complex Hilbert space. However, in the hyperbolic quantum mechanics the principle of superposition is violated. Our realistic (but contextual!) approach to quantum mechanics does not contradict to various “no‐go theorems”, e.g., von Neumann, Bell, Kochen‐Specker. We emphasize that our projection of the classical probabilistic model to the complex Hilbert space is based on two incompatible observables (“reference observables”), e.g., the position and the momentum, or the position and the energy. Only these two observables can be considered as objective properties of quantum systems.

arXiv:quant-ph/0302194•AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2005•16 citations
Born’s probabilistic interpretation of quantum mechanics is commonly assumed to rely on classical probability theory in the sense of Kolmogorov. In this paper we argue that this assumption is methodologically unjustified. We show that quantum probabilities naturally arise from an analytic method fundamentally different from the synthetic approach underlying classical probability theory. In the analytic framework, the whole (the totality of alternatives) is primary, while probabilities of individual alternatives are derived quantities. Interference appears at the level of the realization probability of the whole, whereas conditional probabilities of alternatives remain additive within a given context. We demonstrate that many well-known quantum paradoxes originate from the inappropriate application of synthetic probabilistic reasoning. The proposed formulation is consistent with the Born rule, its extensions developed in our earlier works, and with Birkhoff–von Neumann quantum logic. Classical probability theory appears only as a degenerate formal limit and is not methodologically universal.
In this paper we propose a unified conceptual framework in which quantum probability, quantum logic, and classical probability theory are understood as different structural levels of a single theoretical hierarchy. Starting from a statistical interpretation of quantum interference, previously developed by the authors, we argue that quantum probability is not an alternative to classical Kolmogorov probability, but a more general structure. Classical probability theory emerges as a limiting case corresponding to the disappearance of interference and the effective decomposition of the whole into independent elements. Within this framework, the Birkhoff–von Neumann quantum logic appears as a natural logical expression of quantum probability rather than as an abstract algebraic construction detached from physical meaning. The priority of the whole over its parts plays a central role in both quantum probability and quantum logic, while classical logic and probability arise when this priority becomes trivial. We emphasize that the proposed interpretation does not reject existing quantum formalism, but reinterprets its logical and probabilistic foundations. This approach may have implications for the conceptual understanding of quantum algorithms and quantum information processing.
We compare the classical Kolmogorov and quantum probability models. We show that the gap between these models is not so huge as was commonly believed. The main structures of quantum theory (interference of probabilities, Born's rule, complex probabilistic amplitudes, Hilbert state space, representation of observables by operators) are present in a latent form in the Kolmogorov model. In particular, we obtain “interference of probabilities” without appealing to the Hilbert space formalism. We interpret “interference of probabilities” as a perturbation (by a cos-term) of the conventional formula of total probability. Our classical derivation of quantum probabilistic formalism can stimulate applications of quantum methods outside of the microworld, for instance, in psychology, biology, economy, and other domains of science.
In this paper we provide a structural derivation of Birkhoff–von Neumann quantum logic starting from an extended statistical interpretation of quantum mechanics. Quantum logic is not introduced as an independent logical hypothesis, but is shown to arise naturally from the non-classical structure of quantum probability, in particular from interference, non-additivity, and the priority of the whole over its alternatives. We demonstrate that the failure of Boolean logic in quantum mechanics is not a semantic or philosophical anomaly, but a direct consequence of the probabilistic structure encoded in Hilbert space. Within this framework, quantum logic appears as the logical form of quantum probability itself. This interpretation clarifies the physical meaning of quantum logic and highlights its contemporary relevance in quantum information and quantum computation.
We compare the classical Kolmogorov and quantum probability models. We show that the gap between these model is not so huge as it was commonly believed. The main structures of quantum theory (interference of probabilities, Born's rule, complex probabilistic amplitudes, Hilbert state space, representation of observables by operators) are present in a latent form in the Kolmogorov model. In particular, we obtain ``interference of probabilities'' without to appeal to the Hilbert space formalism. We interpret ``interference of probabilities'' as a perturbation (by a cos⁡\coscos-term) of the conventional formula of total probability. Our classical derivation of quantum probabilistic formalism can stimulate applications of quantum methods outside of microworld : in psychology, biology, economy,...
In our previous works [1], it was demonstrated that quantum probability calculus requires an analytic approach where the whole (the totality of alternatives) is primary, while the probabilities of individual alternatives are derived quantities. In this paper, we take an essential methodological step forward by clarifying and updating the very concept of an alternative. We argue that within the analytic framework, alternatives cannot be treated as isolated, atomized elements, as is done in the synthetic Kolmogorovian model. Instead, they function as elements of a mathematical equivalence class and never lose their global contextual feature. This refinement allows us to reconcile the local realization of historical events with the global preservation of quantum interference. Consequently, this opening offers a completely new perspective for quantum cosmology without relying on the hypothesis of an external observer.
The notion of context (complex of physical conditions) is basic in this paper. We show that the main structures of quantum theory (interference of probabilities, Born’s rule, complex probabilistic amplitudes, Hilbert state space, representation of observables by operators) are present in a latent form in the classical Kolmogorov probability model. However, this model should be considered as a calculus of contextual probabilities. In our approach it is forbidden to consider abstract context independent probabilities: “first context and then probability.” We start with the conventional formula of total probability for contextual (conditional) probabilities and then we rewrite it by eliminating combinations of incompatible contexts from consideration. In this way we obtain interference of probabilities without to appeal to the Hilbert space formalism or wave mechanics. However, we did not just reconstruct the probabilistic formalism of conventional quantum mechanics. Our contextual probabilistic model is essentially more general and, besides the projection to the complex Hilbert space, it has other projections. The most important new prediction is the possibility (at least theoretical) of appearance of hyperbolic interference. A projection of the classical contextual probabilistic model to the hyperbolic Hilbert space (a module over the commutative two dimensional Clifford algebra) has some similarities with the projection to the complex Hilbert space. However, in the hyperbolic quantum mechanics the principle of superposition is violated. Our realistic (but contextual!) approach to quantum mechanics does not contradict to various “no‐go theorems”, e.g., von Neumann, Bell, Kochen‐Specker. We emphasize that our projection of the classical probabilistic model to the complex Hilbert space is based on two incompatible observables (“reference observables”), e.g., the position and the momentum, or the position and the energy. Only these two observables can be considered as objective properties of quantum systems.