Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:hep-th/0609164

Positive and Negative Charges in Relativistic Schroedinger Theory

Beck, T., M. Sorg

Published Sep 23, 2006• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Relativistic Schroedinger Theory (RST), as a general gauge theory for the description of relativistic N-particle systems, is shown to be a mathematically consistent and physically reasonable framework for an arbitrary assemblage of positive and negative charges. The electromagnetic plus exchange interactions within the subset of {\it identical} particles are accounted for in a consistent way, whereas {\it different} particles can undergo only the electromagnetic interactions. The origin of this different interaction mechanism for the subsets of identical and non-identical particles is traced back to the fundamental conservation laws for charge and energy-momentum: in order that these conservation laws can hold also for different particles, the structure group $\mathcal U(N)$ of the fibre bundles must be reduced to its maximal Abelian subgroup $\mathcal U(1) \times \mathcal U(1) \times ... \times \mathcal U(1)$, which eliminates the exchange part of the bundle connection. The persisting Abelian gauge symmetry adopts the meaning of the proper gauge group for the electromagnetic interactions which apply to the identical and non-identical particles in the same way. Thus in RST there is an intrinsic dynamical foundation of the emergence of exchange effects for identical particles, whereas the conventional theory is invaded by the exchange phenomenon via a purely kinematical postulate, namely the antisymmetrization postulate for the wave functions due to Pauli's exclusion principle. As a concrete demonstration, a three-particle system is considered which consists of a positively charged particle of arbitrary rest mass and of two negatively charged particles of equal spin, mass and charge (e.g. electrons).

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.hep-th/0609164

Related papers

Exchange Interactions and Principle of Minimal Energy in Relativistic Schroedinger Theory

Margarete Mattes, M. Sorg

The principle of minimal energy, which has been set up in the preceding papers for systems of non-identical particles (e.g. positronium), is now generalized to include also identical particles. Since the latter kind of particles feels also the exchange forces (besides the usual electromagnetic forces), one has to deal with non-zero exchange potentials which render the theory nonlinear, according to the non-Abelian character of Relativistic Schroedinger Theory (RST). However, the present extension of the variational principle refers only to the linearized version of RST in order to keep the calculations sufficiently simple. It is also demonstrated that in RST the Dirac particles can occur in fermionic and bosonic quantum states; and the mathematical and physical consistency of the variational principle is validated for both types of states (concretely the fermionic hydrogen state 2p_3/2 and the bosonic positronium state 2^1P_1).

arXiv:0809.4692•Sep 26, 2008•3 citations

Quantum Charge as a Particle/Antiparticle Label

Alexander D. Popov

We show that the concept of particles and antiparticles is related to the Weyl-Heisenberg group $W\!H_3$. Its generators are the position operators $\hat x^a$, the momentum operators $\hat p_a$, and the central element $Q_{\sf{v}}$, which defines a subgroup U(1)$_{\sf v}$ of $W\!H_3$. We show that the wave functions have a charge relative to the group U(1)$_{\sf{v}}$ equal to either $q_+=1/\hbar$ (particle $ψ_+$) or $q_-=-1/\hbar$ (antiparticle $ψ_-$). We call these eigenvalues of the operator $Q_{\sf{v}}$ quantum charges: $Q_{\sf{v}}ψ_\pm^{}=q_\pm^{}ψ_\pm^{}$. The wave functions $ψ_+$ and $ψ_-$ belong to the Hilbert spaces $\mathcal{H}_+$ and $\mathcal{H}_-$, on which unitarily inequivalent representations $π_\hbar$ and $π_{-\hbar}$ of the Weyl-Heisenberg group $W\!H_3$ are defined. These representations are related to each other by the antilinear charge conjugation operator $\hat C$, which maps $\mathcal{H}_+, q_+$ to $\mathcal{H}_-, q_-$. Charges $q_\pm^{}$ are intrinsic characteristics of the wave functions $ψ_\pm^{}$, similar to spin and electric charge. The wave function possesses one of these charges, $q_+$ or $q_-$, prior to the specification of any equations. We show that negative probabilities/energies and the Klein paradox in Klein-Gordon and Dirac theories are consequences of the violation of U(1)$_{\sf v}$-invariance in these theories. Restoring this invariance separates particle and antiparticles and eliminates all paradoxes at the level of first-quantized relativistic theories.

math-phCross-listedarXiv:2610.29791•Oct 22, 2026•0 citations

Two-particle systems in relativistic Schrödinger theory

Margarete Mattes, M. Sorg

The relativistic Schrödinger theory (RST) is applied to a general 2-particle system with electromagnetic interactions. The emphasis of the investigation lies on the exchange and overlap effects in connection with the development of adequate single-particle and 2-particle concepts. It is possible to eliminate the 2-particle quantities and to formulate the 2-particle theory exclusively in terms of single-particle quantities but then there arises a new unobservable field degree of freedom: ` renormalization '.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Jan 1, 1999•5 citations

Geometry and Topology of Relativistic Two-Particle Quantum Mixtures

S. Pruss-Hunzinger, Margarete Mattes, M. Sorg

Within the framework of Relativistic Schroedinger Theory (an alternative form of quantum mechanics for relativistic many-particle systems) it is shown that a general N-particle system must occur in one of two forms: either as a ``positive'' or as a ``negative'' mixture, in analogy to the fermion-boson dichotomy of matter in the conventional theory. The pure states represent a limiting case between the two types of mixtures which themselves are considered as the RST counterparts of the entangled (fermionic or bosonic) states of the conventional quantum theory. Both kinds of mixtures are kept separated from dynamical as well as from topological reasons. The 2-particle configurations (N=2) are studied in great detail with respect to their geometric and topological properties which are described in terms of the Euler class of an appropriate bundle connection. If the underlying space-time manifold (as the base space of the fibre bundles applied) is parallelisable, the 2-particle configurations can be thought to be generated geometrically by an appropriate (2+2) splitting of the local tangent space.

arXiv:hep-th/0301205•Jan 25, 2003•1 citation

About Non-relativistic Quantum Mechanics and Electromagnetism

L. Bányai, M. Bundaru

We describe here the coherent formulation of electromagnetism in the non-relativistic quantum-mechanical many-body theory of interacting charged particles. We use the mathematical frame of the field theory and its quantization in the spirit of the quantum electrodynamics (QED). This is necessary because a manifold of misinterpretations emerged especially regarding the magnetic field and gauge invariance. The situation was determined by the historical development of quantum mechanics, starting from the Schrödinger equation of a single particle in the presence of given electromagnetic fields, followed by the many-body theories of many charged identical particles having just Coulomb interactions. Our approach to the non-relativistic QED emphasizes the role of the gauge-invariance and of the external fields. We develop further the approximation of this theory allowing a closed description of the interacting charged particles without photons. The resulting Hamiltonian coincides with the quantized version of the Darwin Hamiltonian containing besides the Coulomb also a current-current diamagnetic interaction. We show on some examples the importance of this extension of the many-body theory.

arXiv:2207.14390•Recent Progress in Materials•Dec 8, 2022•5 citations

Exchange interactions and mass-eigenvalues of relativistic two-particle quantum mixtures

S. Rupp, M. Sorg

Within the framework of Relativistic Schrodinger Theory (RST), the static two-particle solutions of the RST dynamics in an external binding force field (Coulomb potential) are studied in detail. The typical quantum effects occurring in bound two-particle systems (such as particle indistinguishability, entanglement, and ortho-para splitting of the energy levels) turn out to be implications of the RST dynamics itself, not implications of an additional (anti-)symmetrization postulate as in the conventional quantum theory. The RST lowest-order approximations for the 2-particle energy levels are closer to the experimental values than the corresponding predictions of the conventional theory by (roughly) one order of magnitude.

Il Nuovo Cimento B•May 1, 2002•0 citations
Relativistic Schroedinger Theory (RST), as a general gauge theory for the description of relativistic N-particle systems, is shown to be a mathematically consistent and physically reasonable framework for an arbitrary assemblage of positive and negative charges. The electromagnetic plus exchange interactions within the subset of {\it identical} particles are accounted for in a consistent way, whereas {\it different} particles can undergo only the electromagnetic interactions. The origin of this different interaction mechanism for the subsets of identical and non-identical particles is traced back to the fundamental conservation laws for charge and energy-momentum: in order that these conservation laws can hold also for different particles, the structure group U(N)\mathcal U(N)U(N) of the fibre bundles must be reduced to its maximal Abelian subgroup U(1)×U(1)×...×U(1)\mathcal U(1) \times \mathcal U(1) \times ... \times \mathcal U(1)U(1)×U(1)×...×U(1), which eliminates the exchange part of the bundle connection. The persisting Abelian gauge symmetry adopts the meaning of the proper gauge group for the electromagnetic interactions which apply to the identical and non-identical particles in the same way. Thus in RST there is an intrinsic dynamical foundation of the emergence of exchange effects for identical particles, whereas the conventional theory is invaded by the exchange phenomenon via a purely kinematical postulate, namely the antisymmetrization postulate for the wave functions due to Pauli's exclusion principle. As a concrete demonstration, a three-particle system is considered which consists of a positively charged particle of arbitrary rest mass and of two negatively charged particles of equal spin, mass and charge (e.g. electrons).
The principle of minimal energy, which has been set up in the preceding papers for systems of non-identical particles (e.g. positronium), is now generalized to include also identical particles. Since the latter kind of particles feels also the exchange forces (besides the usual electromagnetic forces), one has to deal with non-zero exchange potentials which render the theory nonlinear, according to the non-Abelian character of Relativistic Schroedinger Theory (RST). However, the present extension of the variational principle refers only to the linearized version of RST in order to keep the calculations sufficiently simple. It is also demonstrated that in RST the Dirac particles can occur in fermionic and bosonic quantum states; and the mathematical and physical consistency of the variational principle is validated for both types of states (concretely the fermionic hydrogen state 2p_3/2 and the bosonic positronium state 2^1P_1).
We show that the concept of particles and antiparticles is related to the Weyl-Heisenberg group W ⁣H3W\!H_3WH3​. Its generators are the position operators x^a\hat x^ax^a, the momentum operators p^a\hat p_ap^​a​, and the central element QvQ_{\sf{v}}Qv​, which defines a subgroup U(1)v_{\sf v}v​ of W ⁣H3W\!H_3WH3​. We show that the wave functions have a charge relative to the group U(1)v_{\sf{v}}v​ equal to either q+=1/ℏq_+=1/\hbarq+​=1/ℏ (particle ψ+ψ_+ψ+​) or q−=−1/ℏq_-=-1/\hbarq−​=−1/ℏ (antiparticle ψ−ψ_-ψ−​). We call these eigenvalues of the operator QvQ_{\sf{v}}Qv​ quantum charges: Qvψ±=q±ψ±Q_{\sf{v}}ψ_\pm^{}=q_\pm^{}ψ_\pm^{}Qv​ψ±​=q±​ψ±​. The wave functions ψ+ψ_+ψ+​ and ψ−ψ_-ψ−​ belong to the Hilbert spaces H+\mathcal{H}_+H+​ and H−\mathcal{H}_-H−​, on which unitarily inequivalent representations πℏπ_\hbarπℏ​ and π−ℏπ_{-\hbar}π−ℏ​ of the Weyl-Heisenberg group W ⁣H3W\!H_3WH3​ are defined. These representations are related to each other by the antilinear charge conjugation operator C^\hat CC^, which maps H+,q+\mathcal{H}_+, q_+H+​,q+​ to H−,q−\mathcal{H}_-, q_-H−​,q−​. Charges q±q_\pm^{}q±​ are intrinsic characteristics of the wave functions ψ±ψ_\pm^{}ψ±​, similar to spin and electric charge. The wave function possesses one of these charges, q+q_+q+​ or q−q_-q−​, prior to the specification of any equations. We show that negative probabilities/energies and the Klein paradox in Klein-Gordon and Dirac theories are consequences of the violation of U(1)v_{\sf v}v​-invariance in these theories. Restoring this invariance separates particle and antiparticles and eliminates all paradoxes at the level of first-quantized relativistic theories.
The relativistic Schrödinger theory (RST) is applied to a general 2-particle system with electromagnetic interactions. The emphasis of the investigation lies on the exchange and overlap effects in connection with the development of adequate single-particle and 2-particle concepts. It is possible to eliminate the 2-particle quantities and to formulate the 2-particle theory exclusively in terms of single-particle quantities but then there arises a new unobservable field degree of freedom: ` renormalization '.
Within the framework of Relativistic Schroedinger Theory (an alternative form of quantum mechanics for relativistic many-particle systems) it is shown that a general N-particle system must occur in one of two forms: either as a ``positive'' or as a ``negative'' mixture, in analogy to the fermion-boson dichotomy of matter in the conventional theory. The pure states represent a limiting case between the two types of mixtures which themselves are considered as the RST counterparts of the entangled (fermionic or bosonic) states of the conventional quantum theory. Both kinds of mixtures are kept separated from dynamical as well as from topological reasons. The 2-particle configurations (N=2) are studied in great detail with respect to their geometric and topological properties which are described in terms of the Euler class of an appropriate bundle connection. If the underlying space-time manifold (as the base space of the fibre bundles applied) is parallelisable, the 2-particle configurations can be thought to be generated geometrically by an appropriate (2+2) splitting of the local tangent space.
We describe here the coherent formulation of electromagnetism in the non-relativistic quantum-mechanical many-body theory of interacting charged particles. We use the mathematical frame of the field theory and its quantization in the spirit of the quantum electrodynamics (QED). This is necessary because a manifold of misinterpretations emerged especially regarding the magnetic field and gauge invariance. The situation was determined by the historical development of quantum mechanics, starting from the Schrödinger equation of a single particle in the presence of given electromagnetic fields, followed by the many-body theories of many charged identical particles having just Coulomb interactions. Our approach to the non-relativistic QED emphasizes the role of the gauge-invariance and of the external fields. We develop further the approximation of this theory allowing a closed description of the interacting charged particles without photons. The resulting Hamiltonian coincides with the quantized version of the Darwin Hamiltonian containing besides the Coulomb also a current-current diamagnetic interaction. We show on some examples the importance of this extension of the many-body theory.
Within the framework of Relativistic Schrodinger Theory (RST), the static two-particle solutions of the RST dynamics in an external binding force field (Coulomb potential) are studied in detail. The typical quantum effects occurring in bound two-particle systems (such as particle indistinguishability, entanglement, and ortho-para splitting of the energy levels) turn out to be implications of the RST dynamics itself, not implications of an additional (anti-)symmetrization postulate as in the conventional quantum theory. The RST lowest-order approximations for the 2-particle energy levels are closer to the experimental values than the corresponding predictions of the conventional theory by (roughly) one order of magnitude.