arXiv:2610.29791
Quantum Charge as a Particle/Antiparticle Label
Alexander D. Popov
Abstract
We show that the concept of particles and antiparticles is related to the Weyl-Heisenberg group $W\!H_3$. Its generators are the position operators $\hat x^a$, the momentum operators $\hat p_a$, and the central element $Q_{\sf{v}}$, which defines a subgroup U(1)$_{\sf v}$ of $W\!H_3$. We show that the wave functions have a charge relative to the group U(1)$_{\sf{v}}$ equal to either $q_+=1/\hbar$ (particle $ψ_+$) or $q_-=-1/\hbar$ (antiparticle $ψ_-$). We call these eigenvalues of the operator $Q_{\sf{v}}$ quantum charges: $Q_{\sf{v}}ψ_\pm^{}=q_\pm^{}ψ_\pm^{}$. The wave functions $ψ_+$ and $ψ_-$ belong to the Hilbert spaces $\mathcal{H}_+$ and $\mathcal{H}_-$, on which unitarily inequivalent representations $π_\hbar$ and $π_{-\hbar}$ of the Weyl-Heisenberg group $W\!H_3$ are defined. These representations are related to each other by the antilinear charge conjugation operator $\hat C$, which maps $\mathcal{H}_+, q_+$ to $\mathcal{H}_-, q_-$. Charges $q_\pm^{}$ are intrinsic characteristics of the wave functions $ψ_\pm^{}$, similar to spin and electric charge. The wave function possesses one of these charges, $q_+$ or $q_-$, prior to the specification of any equations. We show that negative probabilities/energies and the Klein paradox in Klein-Gordon and Dirac theories are consequences of the violation of U(1)$_{\sf v}$-invariance in these theories. Restoring this invariance separates particle and antiparticles and eliminates all paradoxes at the level of first-quantized relativistic theories.
AI Summary
The paper asks whether particle–antiparticle labels can be defined before specifying relativistic wave equations. It proposes identifying them with opposite central characters of the Weyl–Heisenberg group $WH_3$, called “quantum charges” $q_\pm=\pm1/\hbar$, distinct from electric charge. The construction uses the principal $U(1)_{\sf v}$ bundle $WH_3\to\mathbb R^6$ and associated conjugate complex line bundles. Polarized, square-integrable sections give Hilbert spaces carrying unitarily inequivalent representations with central parameters $\hbar$ and $-\hbar$, related antiunitarily. Conjugate canonical commutation relations and energy operators $\hat E_\pm=\pm i\hbar\partial_t$ then yield conjugate Schrödinger and Pauli equations. For free relativistic motion, geometric quantization of the two mass-shell trajectory spaces $T^*H^3_\pm$ supplies separate particle and antiparticle sectors satisfying Klein–Gordon or Dirac equations. The central claim is that assigning opposite $U(1)_{\sf v}$ weights to these sectors makes cross-terms in the usual unsplit Lagrangians non-invariant. Separate invariant Lagrangians are proposed, with independently conserved sector charges and positive energies under the sector-dependent energy operators. The paper argues that this removes negative-probability/energy problems and the Klein paradox within first quantization. These conclusions are supported by geometric constructions, Noether-current calculations, and nonrelativistic limits rather than an explicit barrier-scattering calculation. The detailed relativistic phase-space construction treats free particles; the general construction with external forces is explicitly left aside. Pair creation and annihilation remain outside the proposed first-quantized framework and are assigned to second quantization.
Central claim may not hold: Section 6 assigns particle/antiparticle meaning to conjugate Weyl–Heisenberg representations without deriving that physical identification from their central charges. The probability densities claimed positive in Section 11 can be locally negative even for purely positive-frequency Klein–Gordon wave packets, as interference between two unequal-energy modes demonstrates. The proposed U(1)-invariant Lagrangians still yield equations admitting both frequency signs, so their symmetry does not derive the frequency-sector restriction imposed separately for free particles. The asserted elimination of the Klein paradox under external fields is not established, because conserved U(1) charge does not imply preservation of positive- or negative-frequency subspaces under the retained minimally coupled equations. Equation (7.5) expands to canonical momentum plus eA rather than the canonical momentum minus eA stated immediately before it.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 28 pages