Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:cond-mat/9409012 · Physical Review Letters

Compressible ν=1/2 state in a finite size study?

Jainendra K. Jain

Published Aug 15, 1994• 7 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

For a meaningful numerical investigation of thermodynamic properties, systems bigger than the correlation length need to be studied. Fortunately, due to the existence of a gap, the incompressible fractional quantum Hall states have a finite correlation length, which, for some states (e.g., 1/3, 2/5) happens to be smaller than the system sizes that can be studied. On the other hand, since the Fermi liquid is a critical state with power law correlations, one might expect that finite system studies are less likely to provide any conclusive results. Rezayi and Read (RR) [1] have recently claimed that their numerical study provides “convincing evidence for the correctness of the Halperin-Lee-Read [2] theory of a compressible fermi-liquid-like state ” at ν = 1/2. We argue below that their study sheds little light on the on the thermodynamic nature of the compressible state at ν = 1/2. RR have studied N-electron systems at flux Nφ = 2(N − 1) in the spherical geometry. Their numerical calculations test a special case of the composite fermion theory [3], which provides a general relationship between the low-energy spectra and eigenstates of the systems at Nφ and N ∗ φ = Nφ − 2(N − 1). Extensive calculations of this type have been performed in the past, including for Nφ = 2(N −1) [4–6]. RR merely interpret the results differently. For

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.73.1051

Related papers

Interaction-tuned compressible-to-incompressible phase transitions in quantum Hall systems

Zlatko Papić, Nicolas Regnault, S. Das Sarma

We analyze transitions between quantum Hall ground states at prominent filling factors $\ensuremath{\nu}$ in the spherical geometry by tuning the width parameter of the Zhang-Das Sarma interaction potential. We find that incompressible ground states evolve adiabatically under this tuning, whereas the compressible ones are driven through a first-order phase transition. Overlap calculations show that the resulting phase is increasingly well described by appropriate analytic model wave functions (Laughlin, Moore-Read, Read-Rezayi). This scenario is shared by both odd $(\ensuremath{\nu}=1/3,1/5,3/5,7/3,11/5,13/5)$ and even denominator states $(\ensuremath{\nu}=1/2,1/4,5/2,9/4)$. In particular, the Fermi-liquid-like state at $\ensuremath{\nu}=1/2$ gives way, at large enough value of the width parameter, to an incompressible state identified as the Moore-Read Pfaffian on the basis of its entanglement spectrum.

arXiv:0907.4603•Physical Review B•Nov 2, 2009•43 citations

Bulk and edge correlations in the compressible half-filled quantum Hall state

Milica V. Milovanović, Efrat Shimshoni

We study bulk and edge correlations in the compressible half-filled state [B. I. Halperin et al., Phys. Rev. B 47, 7312 (1993) and, E. Rezayi and N. Read, Phys. Rev. Lett. 72, 900 (1994); 73, 1052 (1994)] using a modified version of the plasma analogy. The corresponding plasma has anomalously weak screening properties, and as a consequence, we find that the correlations along the edge do not decay algebraically as in the Laughlin (incompressible) case, while the bulk correlations decay in the same way. The results suggest that due to the strong coupling between charged modes on the edge and the neutral fermions in the bulk, reflected by the weak screening in the plasma analog, the (attractive) correlation hole is not well defined on the edge. Hence, the system there can be modeled as a free Fermi gas of electrons (with an appropriate boundary condition). We finally comment on a possible scenario in which the Laughlin-like dynamical edge correlations may nevertheless be realized.

arXiv:cond-mat/9812254•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Apr 15, 1999•7 citations

Composite edges in the ν=2/3 fractional quantum Hall effect

M. Johnson, Allan H. MacDonald

The quantum Hall effect is due to discontinuities in the chemical potential at certain bulk electron densities. It has been conjectured that the resulting edge states in some fractional Hall gaps can have an intricate composite structure which reflects the correlations in the incompressible bulk fluid. We present direct numerical evidence obtained from exact-diagonalization studies in favor of this conjecture. We show that the states on the \ensuremath{\nu}=2/3 fractional quantum Hall edge constitute a two-component system in which a \ensuremath{\nu}=1/3 droplet of holes is contained within a \ensuremath{\nu}=1 droplet of electrons.

Physical Review Letters•Oct 1, 1991•123 citations

DISORDERING OF THE CORRELATED STATE OF THE QUANTUM HALL BILAYER AT FILLING FACTOR ν = 1

Zlatko Papić, Milica V. Milovanović

The phase diagram of a quantum Hall bilayer at total filling ν = 1 contains an incompressible superfluid for small distances d between the layers, as well as the compressible phase corresponding to two uncoupled Fermi liquids for large d. Using exact diagonalization on the sphere and torus geometry, we investigate a long-standing question of the nature of the transition between the two regimes, and the possibility for the existence of a paired phase in the transition region. We find considerable evidence for a direct transition between the superfluid and the Fermi liquid phase, based in particular on the behavior of the ground state energy on the sphere (including appropriate finite-size corrections) as a function of d. At the critical distance dC ≈ 11.6ℓB the topological number ("shift") of the ground state changes, suggesting that tuning the layer separation d in experiment likely leads to a direct transition between the superfluid and the Fermi liquid phase.

Modern Physics Letters B•Jul 16, 2012•4 citations

Transition from Quantum Hall to Compressible States in the Second Landau Level: New Light on the ν=5/2 Enigma

R. Morf

Quantum Hall states at filling fraction $\ensuremath{\nu}\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}5/2$ are examined by numerical diagonalization. Spin-polarized and spin-unpolarized states of systems with $N\ensuremath{\le}18$ electrons are studied, neglecting effects of Landau level mixing. We find that the ground state is spin polarized. It is incompressible and has a large overlap with paired states like the Pfaffian. For a given sample, the energy gap is about 11 times smaller than at $\ensuremath{\nu}\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}1/3$. Evidence is presented of phase transitions to compressible states, driven by the interaction strength at short distance. A reinterpretation of experiments is suggested.

arXiv:cond-mat/9809024•Physical Review Letters•Feb 16, 1998•417 citations

Toward a New Theory of the Fractional Quantum Hall Effect

Sergey A. Mikhailov

The fractional quantum Hall effect was experimentally discovered in 1982. It was observed that the Hall conductivity σyx of a two-dimensional electron system is quantized, σyx=e2/3h, in the vicinity of the Landau level filling factor ν=1/3. In 1983, Laughlin proposed a trial many-body wave function, which he claimed described a “new state of matter”—a homogeneous incompressible liquid with fractionally charged quasiparticles. Here, I develop an exact diagonalization theory that allows one to calculate the energy and other physical properties of the ground and excited states of a system of N two-dimensional Coulomb interacting electrons in a strong magnetic field. I analyze the energies, electron densities, and other physical properties of the systems with N≤7 electrons continuously as a function of magnetic field in the range 1/4≲ν<1. The results show that both the ground and excited states of the system resemble a sliding Wigner crystal whose parameters are influenced by the magnetic field. Energy gaps in the many-particle spectra appear and disappear as the magnetic field changes. I also calculate the physical properties of the ν=1/3 Laughlin state for N≤8 and compare the results with the exact ones. This comparison, as well as an analysis of some other statements published in the literature, show that the Laughlin state and its fractionally charged excitations do not describe the physical reality, neither at small N nor in the thermodynamic limit. The results obtained shed new light on the nature of the ground and excited states in the fractional quantum Hall effect.

arXiv:2206.05152•Nanomaterials•Jan 31, 2024•4 citations
For a meaningful numerical investigation of thermodynamic properties, systems bigger than the correlation length need to be studied. Fortunately, due to the existence of a gap, the incompressible fractional quantum Hall states have a finite correlation length, which, for some states (e.g., 1/3, 2/5) happens to be smaller than the system sizes that can be studied. On the other hand, since the Fermi liquid is a critical state with power law correlations, one might expect that finite system studies are less likely to provide any conclusive results. Rezayi and Read (RR) [1] have recently claimed that their numerical study provides “convincing evidence for the correctness of the Halperin-Lee-Read [2] theory of a compressible fermi-liquid-like state ” at ν = 1/2. We argue below that their study sheds little light on the on the thermodynamic nature of the compressible state at ν = 1/2. RR have studied N-electron systems at flux Nφ = 2(N − 1) in the spherical geometry. Their numerical calculations test a special case of the composite fermion theory [3], which provides a general relationship between the low-energy spectra and eigenstates of the systems at Nφ and N ∗ φ = Nφ − 2(N − 1). Extensive calculations of this type have been performed in the past, including for Nφ = 2(N −1) [4–6]. RR merely interpret the results differently. For
We analyze transitions between quantum Hall ground states at prominent filling factors $\ensuremath{\nu}$ in the spherical geometry by tuning the width parameter of the Zhang-Das Sarma interaction potential. We find that incompressible ground states evolve adiabatically under this tuning, whereas the compressible ones are driven through a first-order phase transition. Overlap calculations show that the resulting phase is increasingly well described by appropriate analytic model wave functions (Laughlin, Moore-Read, Read-Rezayi). This scenario is shared by both odd $(\ensuremath{\nu}=1/3,1/5,3/5,7/3,11/5,13/5)$ and even denominator states $(\ensuremath{\nu}=1/2,1/4,5/2,9/4)$. In particular, the Fermi-liquid-like state at $\ensuremath{\nu}=1/2$ gives way, at large enough value of the width parameter, to an incompressible state identified as the Moore-Read Pfaffian on the basis of its entanglement spectrum.
We study bulk and edge correlations in the compressible half-filled state [B. I. Halperin et al., Phys. Rev. B 47, 7312 (1993) and, E. Rezayi and N. Read, Phys. Rev. Lett. 72, 900 (1994); 73, 1052 (1994)] using a modified version of the plasma analogy. The corresponding plasma has anomalously weak screening properties, and as a consequence, we find that the correlations along the edge do not decay algebraically as in the Laughlin (incompressible) case, while the bulk correlations decay in the same way. The results suggest that due to the strong coupling between charged modes on the edge and the neutral fermions in the bulk, reflected by the weak screening in the plasma analog, the (attractive) correlation hole is not well defined on the edge. Hence, the system there can be modeled as a free Fermi gas of electrons (with an appropriate boundary condition). We finally comment on a possible scenario in which the Laughlin-like dynamical edge correlations may nevertheless be realized.
The quantum Hall effect is due to discontinuities in the chemical potential at certain bulk electron densities. It has been conjectured that the resulting edge states in some fractional Hall gaps can have an intricate composite structure which reflects the correlations in the incompressible bulk fluid. We present direct numerical evidence obtained from exact-diagonalization studies in favor of this conjecture. We show that the states on the \ensuremath{\nu}=2/3 fractional quantum Hall edge constitute a two-component system in which a \ensuremath{\nu}=1/3 droplet of holes is contained within a \ensuremath{\nu}=1 droplet of electrons.
The phase diagram of a quantum Hall bilayer at total filling ν = 1 contains an incompressible superfluid for small distances d between the layers, as well as the compressible phase corresponding to two uncoupled Fermi liquids for large d. Using exact diagonalization on the sphere and torus geometry, we investigate a long-standing question of the nature of the transition between the two regimes, and the possibility for the existence of a paired phase in the transition region. We find considerable evidence for a direct transition between the superfluid and the Fermi liquid phase, based in particular on the behavior of the ground state energy on the sphere (including appropriate finite-size corrections) as a function of d. At the critical distance dC ≈ 11.6ℓB the topological number ("shift") of the ground state changes, suggesting that tuning the layer separation d in experiment likely leads to a direct transition between the superfluid and the Fermi liquid phase.
Quantum Hall states at filling fraction $\ensuremath{\nu}\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}5/2$ are examined by numerical diagonalization. Spin-polarized and spin-unpolarized states of systems with $N\ensuremath{\le}18$ electrons are studied, neglecting effects of Landau level mixing. We find that the ground state is spin polarized. It is incompressible and has a large overlap with paired states like the Pfaffian. For a given sample, the energy gap is about 11 times smaller than at $\ensuremath{\nu}\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}1/3$. Evidence is presented of phase transitions to compressible states, driven by the interaction strength at short distance. A reinterpretation of experiments is suggested.
The fractional quantum Hall effect was experimentally discovered in 1982. It was observed that the Hall conductivity σyx of a two-dimensional electron system is quantized, σyx=e2/3h, in the vicinity of the Landau level filling factor ν=1/3. In 1983, Laughlin proposed a trial many-body wave function, which he claimed described a “new state of matter”—a homogeneous incompressible liquid with fractionally charged quasiparticles. Here, I develop an exact diagonalization theory that allows one to calculate the energy and other physical properties of the ground and excited states of a system of N two-dimensional Coulomb interacting electrons in a strong magnetic field. I analyze the energies, electron densities, and other physical properties of the systems with N≤7 electrons continuously as a function of magnetic field in the range 1/4≲ν<1. The results show that both the ground and excited states of the system resemble a sliding Wigner crystal whose parameters are influenced by the magnetic field. Energy gaps in the many-particle spectra appear and disappear as the magnetic field changes. I also calculate the physical properties of the ν=1/3 Laughlin state for N≤8 and compare the results with the exact ones. This comparison, as well as an analysis of some other statements published in the literature, show that the Laughlin state and its fractionally charged excitations do not describe the physical reality, neither at small N nor in the thermodynamic limit. The results obtained shed new light on the nature of the ground and excited states in the fractional quantum Hall effect.