Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2206.05152 · Nanomaterials

Toward a New Theory of the Fractional Quantum Hall Effect

Sergey A. Mikhailov

Published Jan 31, 2024• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The fractional quantum Hall effect was experimentally discovered in 1982. It was observed that the Hall conductivity σyx of a two-dimensional electron system is quantized, σyx=e2/3h, in the vicinity of the Landau level filling factor ν=1/3. In 1983, Laughlin proposed a trial many-body wave function, which he claimed described a “new state of matter”—a homogeneous incompressible liquid with fractionally charged quasiparticles. Here, I develop an exact diagonalization theory that allows one to calculate the energy and other physical properties of the ground and excited states of a system of N two-dimensional Coulomb interacting electrons in a strong magnetic field. I analyze the energies, electron densities, and other physical properties of the systems with N≤7 electrons continuously as a function of magnetic field in the range 1/4≲ν<1. The results show that both the ground and excited states of the system resemble a sliding Wigner crystal whose parameters are influenced by the magnetic field. Energy gaps in the many-particle spectra appear and disappear as the magnetic field changes. I also calculate the physical properties of the ν=1/3 Laughlin state for N≤8 and compare the results with the exact ones. This comparison, as well as an analysis of some other statements published in the literature, show that the Laughlin state and its fractionally charged excitations do not describe the physical reality, neither at small N nor in the thermodynamic limit. The results obtained shed new light on the nature of the ground and excited states in the fractional quantum Hall effect.

DOI
10.3390/nano14030297

Related papers

Effect of the Landau Level Mixing on the Ground State of Two-Dimensional Electrons

D. Yoshioka

Two dimensional electrons in a strong magnetic field show the fractional quantum Hall effect at low temperatures. This effect is explained successfully by a discovery of a new liquid type ground state. However the infinitely strong magnetic field has been assumed in existing theories. Here the ground state around one third filling of the lowest Landau level is investigated at a finite magnetic field by numerical diagonalization of the Hamiltonian. When the cyclotron energy is not too small compared to a typical Coulomb energy, no qualitative change of the ground state is found: A natural generalization of the liquid state at the infinite magnetic field describes the ground state. Excitation energies of quasiparticles decrease as the magnetic field decreases.

Journal of the Physical Society of Japan•Nov 15, 1984•82 citations

Ground state of the two-dimensional charged particles in a strong magnetic field and the fractional quantum Hall effect

D. Yoshioka

Finite-size two-dimensional systems are investigated by numerical diagonalization of the Hamiltonian. Both fermion systems and boson systems are investigated. The energy of the liquidlike ground state of the fermion system shows a downward cusp at $\frac{1}{3}$ filling of the lowest Landau level. This behavior is consistent with the observed fractional quantum Hall effect. The short-range behavior of the pair distribution function of the ground state is analyzed and good agreement with Laughlin's trial wave function is obtained.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Jun 15, 1984•165 citations

Exactly Solvable Model for Strongly Interacting Electrons in a Magnetic Field

Abhishek Anand, Jainendra K. Jain, G. J. Sreejith

States of strongly interacting particles are of fundamental interest in physics and can produce exotic emergent phenomena and topological structures. We consider here two-dimensional electrons in a magnetic field, and, departing from the standard practice of restricting to the lowest LL, introduce a model short-range interaction that is infinitely strong compared to the cyclotron energy. We demonstrate that this model lends itself to an exact solution for the ground as well as excited states at arbitrary filling factors ν<1/2p and produces a fractional quantum Hall effect at fractions of the form ν=n/(2pn+1), where n and p are integers. The fractional quantum Hall states of our model share many topological properties with the corresponding Coulomb ground states in the lowest Landau level, such as the edge physics and the fractional charge of the excitations.

arXiv:2010.12594•Physical Review Letters•Mar 29, 2021•6 citations

Cooperative ring exchange and the fractional quantum Hall effect

Steven Allan Kivelson, Catherine Kallin, Daniel P. Arovas +1 more

We study the transition of the interacting two-dimensional electron gas at high magnetic field from a low-density Wigner crystal to a higher-density correlated state which exhibits the fractionally quantized Hall effect. The phase transition is precipitated by a condensation of ring-exchange processes, which by nature of their sensitivity to enclosed magnetic flux allow for especially low-energy exchange condensates at certain values of the Landau-level filling factor, \ensuremath{\nu}=${\ensuremath{\nu}}_{i}$. In the condensate, the exchanges mediate a logarithmic potential between local-density fluctuations, leading to a cusp in the ground-state energy as a function of \ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\nu}-${\ensuremath{\nu}}_{i}$\ensuremath{\Vert} in the vicinity of a preferred state. In addition, we derive quasiparticle excitations of sharp fractional charge which are analogous to the excitations derived by Laughlin.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Jul 15, 1987•93 citations

Fractional Quantum Hall States and Wigner Crystal of Quasiparticles

Z. F. Ezawa, Aiichi Iwazaki

By using a bosonic Chern-Simons gauge theory the ground state of the planar electron system is analyzed in the presence of an external magnetic field. The distinctive feature of our theory is that a renormalization counter term (|α|/ M )|ψ| 4 which represents explicitly a hard-core condition plays important roles, where α and M are the statistics parameter and the mass of the electron. The following results are obtained systematically in the semiclassical approximation. When ν=1/ k ( k odd) with ν being the Landau level filling factor, the ground state is incompressible and described by the Laughlin wavefunction. On the other hand, when ν∼1/ k , the ground state is compressible and it is given by the Wigner crystal made of quasiholes (antivortices). The wavefunction of the Wigner crystal is also calculated, which is found to coincide with that of the Laughlin quasiholes. In these analyses the Coulomb interaction between electrons plays a crucial role.

Journal of the Physical Society of Japan•Nov 15, 1992•12 citations

Fractional quantum Hall states in two-dimensional electron systems with anisotropic interactions

Hao Wang, Rajesh Narayanan, Xin Wan +1 more

We study the anisotropic effect of the Coulomb interaction on a 1/3-filling fractional quantum Hall system by using an exact diagonalization method on small systems in torus geometry. For weak anisotropy the system remains to be an incompressible quantum liquid, although anisotropy manifests itself in density correlation functions and excitation spectra. When the strength of anisotropy increases, we find the system develops a Hall-smectic-like phase with a one-dimensional charge density wave order and is unstable towards the one-dimensional crystal in the strong anisotropy limit. In all three phases of the Laughlin liquid, Hall-smectic-like, and crystal phases the ground state of the anisotropic Coulomb system can be well described by a family of model wave functions generated by an anisotropic projection Hamiltonian. We discuss the relevance of the results to the geometrical description of fractional quantum Hall states proposed by Haldane [Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 116801 (2011)].

arXiv:1203.1982•Physical Review B•Jul 16, 2012•56 citations
The fractional quantum Hall effect was experimentally discovered in 1982. It was observed that the Hall conductivity σyx of a two-dimensional electron system is quantized, σyx=e2/3h, in the vicinity of the Landau level filling factor ν=1/3. In 1983, Laughlin proposed a trial many-body wave function, which he claimed described a “new state of matter”—a homogeneous incompressible liquid with fractionally charged quasiparticles. Here, I develop an exact diagonalization theory that allows one to calculate the energy and other physical properties of the ground and excited states of a system of N two-dimensional Coulomb interacting electrons in a strong magnetic field. I analyze the energies, electron densities, and other physical properties of the systems with N≤7 electrons continuously as a function of magnetic field in the range 1/4≲ν<1. The results show that both the ground and excited states of the system resemble a sliding Wigner crystal whose parameters are influenced by the magnetic field. Energy gaps in the many-particle spectra appear and disappear as the magnetic field changes. I also calculate the physical properties of the ν=1/3 Laughlin state for N≤8 and compare the results with the exact ones. This comparison, as well as an analysis of some other statements published in the literature, show that the Laughlin state and its fractionally charged excitations do not describe the physical reality, neither at small N nor in the thermodynamic limit. The results obtained shed new light on the nature of the ground and excited states in the fractional quantum Hall effect.
Two dimensional electrons in a strong magnetic field show the fractional quantum Hall effect at low temperatures. This effect is explained successfully by a discovery of a new liquid type ground state. However the infinitely strong magnetic field has been assumed in existing theories. Here the ground state around one third filling of the lowest Landau level is investigated at a finite magnetic field by numerical diagonalization of the Hamiltonian. When the cyclotron energy is not too small compared to a typical Coulomb energy, no qualitative change of the ground state is found: A natural generalization of the liquid state at the infinite magnetic field describes the ground state. Excitation energies of quasiparticles decrease as the magnetic field decreases.
Finite-size two-dimensional systems are investigated by numerical diagonalization of the Hamiltonian. Both fermion systems and boson systems are investigated. The energy of the liquidlike ground state of the fermion system shows a downward cusp at 13\frac{1}{3}31​ filling of the lowest Landau level. This behavior is consistent with the observed fractional quantum Hall effect. The short-range behavior of the pair distribution function of the ground state is analyzed and good agreement with Laughlin's trial wave function is obtained.
States of strongly interacting particles are of fundamental interest in physics and can produce exotic emergent phenomena and topological structures. We consider here two-dimensional electrons in a magnetic field, and, departing from the standard practice of restricting to the lowest LL, introduce a model short-range interaction that is infinitely strong compared to the cyclotron energy. We demonstrate that this model lends itself to an exact solution for the ground as well as excited states at arbitrary filling factors ν<1/2p and produces a fractional quantum Hall effect at fractions of the form ν=n/(2pn+1), where n and p are integers. The fractional quantum Hall states of our model share many topological properties with the corresponding Coulomb ground states in the lowest Landau level, such as the edge physics and the fractional charge of the excitations.
We study the transition of the interacting two-dimensional electron gas at high magnetic field from a low-density Wigner crystal to a higher-density correlated state which exhibits the fractionally quantized Hall effect. The phase transition is precipitated by a condensation of ring-exchange processes, which by nature of their sensitivity to enclosed magnetic flux allow for especially low-energy exchange condensates at certain values of the Landau-level filling factor, \ensuremath{\nu}=${\ensuremath{\nu}}_{i}$. In the condensate, the exchanges mediate a logarithmic potential between local-density fluctuations, leading to a cusp in the ground-state energy as a function of \ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\nu}-${\ensuremath{\nu}}_{i}$\ensuremath{\Vert} in the vicinity of a preferred state. In addition, we derive quasiparticle excitations of sharp fractional charge which are analogous to the excitations derived by Laughlin.
By using a bosonic Chern-Simons gauge theory the ground state of the planar electron system is analyzed in the presence of an external magnetic field. The distinctive feature of our theory is that a renormalization counter term (|α|/ M )|ψ| 4 which represents explicitly a hard-core condition plays important roles, where α and M are the statistics parameter and the mass of the electron. The following results are obtained systematically in the semiclassical approximation. When ν=1/ k ( k odd) with ν being the Landau level filling factor, the ground state is incompressible and described by the Laughlin wavefunction. On the other hand, when ν∼1/ k , the ground state is compressible and it is given by the Wigner crystal made of quasiholes (antivortices). The wavefunction of the Wigner crystal is also calculated, which is found to coincide with that of the Laughlin quasiholes. In these analyses the Coulomb interaction between electrons plays a crucial role.
We study the anisotropic effect of the Coulomb interaction on a 1/3-filling fractional quantum Hall system by using an exact diagonalization method on small systems in torus geometry. For weak anisotropy the system remains to be an incompressible quantum liquid, although anisotropy manifests itself in density correlation functions and excitation spectra. When the strength of anisotropy increases, we find the system develops a Hall-smectic-like phase with a one-dimensional charge density wave order and is unstable towards the one-dimensional crystal in the strong anisotropy limit. In all three phases of the Laughlin liquid, Hall-smectic-like, and crystal phases the ground state of the anisotropic Coulomb system can be well described by a family of model wave functions generated by an anisotropic projection Hamiltonian. We discuss the relevance of the results to the geometrical description of fractional quantum Hall states proposed by Haldane [Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 116801 (2011)].