Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:cond-mat/0503124 · Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences

Nearsightedness of electronic matter

Emil V. Prodan, Walter Kohn

Published Aug 8, 2005• 582 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In an earlier paper, W. Kohn had qualitatively introduced the concept of "nearsightedness" of electrons in many-atom systems. It can be viewed as underlying such important ideas as Pauling's "chemical bond," "transferability," and Yang's computational principle of "divide and conquer." It describes the fact that, for fixed chemical potential, local electronic properties, such as the density n(r), depend significantly on the effective external potential only at nearby points. Changes of that potential, no matter how large, beyond a distance R have limited effects on local electronic properties, which rapidly tend to zero as a function of R. In the present paper, the concept is first sharpened for representative models of uncharged fermions moving in external potentials, and then the effects of electron-electron interactions and of perturbing external charges are discussed.

DOI
10.1073/pnas.0505436102

Related papers

Advantageous nearsightedness of many-body perturbation theory contrasted with Kohn-Sham density functional theory

Jack Wetherell, M. J. P. Hodgson, Leopold Talirz +1 more

For properties of interacting electron systems, Kohn-Sham (KS) theory is often favored over many-body perturbation theory (MBPT), owing to its low computational cost. However, the exact KS potential can be challenging to approximate, for example in the presence of localized subsystems where the exact potential is known to exhibit pathological features such as spatial steps. By modeling two electrons, each localized in a distinct potential well, we illustrate that the step feature has no counterpart in MBPTs (including Hartree-Fock and $GW)$ or hybrid methods involving Fock exchange because the spatial nonlocality of the self-energy renders such pathological behavior unnecessary. We present a quantitative illustration of the orbital-dependent nature of the nonlocal potential, and a numerical demonstration of Kohn's concept of the nearsightedness for self-energies, when two distant subsystems are combined, in contrast to the KS potential. These properties emphasize the value of self-energy-based approximations in developing future approaches within KS-like theories.

arXiv:1812.02661•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jan 16, 2019•11 citations

Density functional theory

Philip L. Taylor, Olle Heinonen

The Hohenberg–Kohn theorem In Chapter 2 we explored some of the consequences of electron–electron interactions, albeit in some simple perturbative approaches and within the random phase approximation. There we found that the problem of treating these interactions is exceedingly difficult, even in the case where there is no external one–particle potential applied to the system. We have also explored some of the properties of noninteracting electrons in an external potential, in this case the periodic lattice potential. This led to the concepts of electron bands and band structure, subjects of fundamental importance in understanding the physics of metals, insulators, and semiconductors. Of course, in the real world, electrons in matter are subjected both to electron–electron interactions and to external potentials. How to include systematically and correctly the electron–electron interactions in calculations of real systems is truly a formidable problem. Why that is so is easily demonstrated. Suppose that we want to solve the problem of N electrons interacting in some external potential. The N -electron wavefunction can be expanded in Slater determinants of some suitable single-particle basis such as plane waves. We can describe the Slater determinants by occupation numbers in our second–quantized notation. Suppose furthermore that we have a basis of a total of N k plane wave states at our disposal. Here N k must be large enough that all reasonable “wiggles” of the many-body wavefunction can be included.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 28, 2002•4 citations

Nearsightedness-related indices of finite systems based on linear response function: one-dimensional cases

Yuki Mitsuta, Shusuke Yamanaka, Tôru Saitô +4 more

We have investigated nearsightedness of electronic matter (NEM) of finite systems on the basis of linear response function to examine theoretical foundation of contemporary computational chemistry such as quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics methods. In this study, we introduce several nearsightedness-related indices to assess the magnitude of localisability of responses for one-dimensional finite model systems. We started from two electrons' systems, which are beyond the scope of the original concept of NEM, and increased the number of electrons (N) to a hundred electrons to analyse dependency of such indices on N. In the process of construction of the indices, we analysed the factors, because of which the magnitude of nonlocal parts of linear response functions becomes small, into several ones, and extracted purely the magnitude of propagation of responses.

Molecular Physics•Sep 15, 2015•2 citations

Nearsightedness in Materials with Indirect Band Gaps

Huajie Chen, Feng, Juerong, Christoph Ortner +1 more

We investigate the nearsightedness property in the linear tight binding model at zero Fermi-temperature. We focus on the decay property of the density matrix for materials with indirect band gaps. By representing the density matrix in reciprocal space, we establish a qualitatively sharp estimate for the exponential decay rate in homogeneous systems, possibly with localized perturbations. This work refines the estimates presented in (Ortner, Thomas & Chen, 2020) for systems with small band gaps.

arXiv:2501.01188•Jan 2, 2025•0 citations

Independent-particle model for fermions in finite systems

We can obtain useful descriptions for finite systems comprised of fermions by identifying a one-body potential that already generates some of the physics associated with the interaction between the particles. This onebody potential combined with the kinetic energy and pertinent external potentials, like the Coulomb attraction to the nucleus for electrons in atoms, forms a good baseline to discuss the physics of these systems. In particular, it leads to a shell-model picture that is appropriate for atoms, nuclei, and other localized many-fermion systems. In addition, such a Hamiltonian may be used as a starting point of the perturbation expansion of relevant physical quantities, to be presented in Ch. 8. The general discussion of this independent-particle description, where fermions do not interact but are aware of each other’s identity, will be given in Sec. 3.1. The application of the independent-particle model (IPM) to electrons in atoms is presented in Sec. 3.2, and for nucleons in nuclei in Sec. 3.3. An important hypothetical system entitled “nuclear matter” is introduced in Sec. 3.3.1. It describes an idealized way to represent and study the global properties of the interior of nuclei which exhibit strikingly similar features for nuclei heavier than 16 O. In Sec. 3.4 the method of second quantization is applied to the concept of isospin as it is relevant for the description of nuclei.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Oct 13, 2025•0 citations

Signatures of electron correlation

Richard M. Martin, Lucia Reining, David M. Ceperley

Real knowledge is to know the extent of one's ignorance. Confucius, 500 BCE Summary The topic of this chapter is a small selection of the vast array of experimentally observed phenomena chosen to exemplify crucial roles played by the electron– electron interaction. Examples in the present chapter bring out the effects of correlation in ground and excited states as well as in thermal equilibrium. These raise challenges for theory and quantitative many-body methods in treating interacting electrons, the topics of the following chapters. The title of this book is Interacting Electrons . Of course, there are no non-interacting electrons: in any system with more than one electron, the electron–electron interaction affects the energy and leads to correlation between the electrons. All first-principles theories deal with the electron–electron interaction in some way, but often they treat the electrons as independent fermions in a static mean-field potential that contains interaction effects approximately. As described in Ch. 4, the Hartree–Fock method is a variational approximation with a wavefunction for fermions that are uncorrelated, except for the requirement of antisymmetry. The Kohn–Sham approach to DFT defines an auxiliary system of independent fermions that is chosen to reproduce the ground-state density. It is exact in principle and remarkably successful in practice. However, many properties such as excitation energies are not supposed to be taken directly from the Kohn–Sham equations, even in principle. Various other methods attempt to incorporate some effect of correlation in the choice of the potential. This chapter is designed to highlight a few examples of experimentally observed phenomena that demonstrate qualitative consequences of electron–electron interactions beyond independent-particle approximations. Some examples illustrate effects that cannot be accounted for in any theory where electrons are considered as independent particles. Others are direct experimental measurements of correlation functions that would vanish if the electrons were independent. In yet other cases, a phenomenon can be explained in terms of independent particles in some effective potential, but it is deeply unsatisfying if one has to invent a different potential for every case, even for different properties in the same material. A satisfactory theory ultimately requires us to confront the problem of interacting, correlated electrons.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•May 31, 2016•0 citations
In an earlier paper, W. Kohn had qualitatively introduced the concept of "nearsightedness" of electrons in many-atom systems. It can be viewed as underlying such important ideas as Pauling's "chemical bond," "transferability," and Yang's computational principle of "divide and conquer." It describes the fact that, for fixed chemical potential, local electronic properties, such as the density n(r), depend significantly on the effective external potential only at nearby points. Changes of that potential, no matter how large, beyond a distance R have limited effects on local electronic properties, which rapidly tend to zero as a function of R. In the present paper, the concept is first sharpened for representative models of uncharged fermions moving in external potentials, and then the effects of electron-electron interactions and of perturbing external charges are discussed.
For properties of interacting electron systems, Kohn-Sham (KS) theory is often favored over many-body perturbation theory (MBPT), owing to its low computational cost. However, the exact KS potential can be challenging to approximate, for example in the presence of localized subsystems where the exact potential is known to exhibit pathological features such as spatial steps. By modeling two electrons, each localized in a distinct potential well, we illustrate that the step feature has no counterpart in MBPTs (including Hartree-Fock and GW)GW)GW) or hybrid methods involving Fock exchange because the spatial nonlocality of the self-energy renders such pathological behavior unnecessary. We present a quantitative illustration of the orbital-dependent nature of the nonlocal potential, and a numerical demonstration of Kohn's concept of the nearsightedness for self-energies, when two distant subsystems are combined, in contrast to the KS potential. These properties emphasize the value of self-energy-based approximations in developing future approaches within KS-like theories.
The Hohenberg–Kohn theorem In Chapter 2 we explored some of the consequences of electron–electron interactions, albeit in some simple perturbative approaches and within the random phase approximation. There we found that the problem of treating these interactions is exceedingly difficult, even in the case where there is no external one–particle potential applied to the system. We have also explored some of the properties of noninteracting electrons in an external potential, in this case the periodic lattice potential. This led to the concepts of electron bands and band structure, subjects of fundamental importance in understanding the physics of metals, insulators, and semiconductors. Of course, in the real world, electrons in matter are subjected both to electron–electron interactions and to external potentials. How to include systematically and correctly the electron–electron interactions in calculations of real systems is truly a formidable problem. Why that is so is easily demonstrated. Suppose that we want to solve the problem of N electrons interacting in some external potential. The N -electron wavefunction can be expanded in Slater determinants of some suitable single-particle basis such as plane waves. We can describe the Slater determinants by occupation numbers in our second–quantized notation. Suppose furthermore that we have a basis of a total of N k plane wave states at our disposal. Here N k must be large enough that all reasonable “wiggles” of the many-body wavefunction can be included.
We have investigated nearsightedness of electronic matter (NEM) of finite systems on the basis of linear response function to examine theoretical foundation of contemporary computational chemistry such as quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics methods. In this study, we introduce several nearsightedness-related indices to assess the magnitude of localisability of responses for one-dimensional finite model systems. We started from two electrons' systems, which are beyond the scope of the original concept of NEM, and increased the number of electrons (N) to a hundred electrons to analyse dependency of such indices on N. In the process of construction of the indices, we analysed the factors, because of which the magnitude of nonlocal parts of linear response functions becomes small, into several ones, and extracted purely the magnitude of propagation of responses.
We investigate the nearsightedness property in the linear tight binding model at zero Fermi-temperature. We focus on the decay property of the density matrix for materials with indirect band gaps. By representing the density matrix in reciprocal space, we establish a qualitatively sharp estimate for the exponential decay rate in homogeneous systems, possibly with localized perturbations. This work refines the estimates presented in (Ortner, Thomas & Chen, 2020) for systems with small band gaps.
We can obtain useful descriptions for finite systems comprised of fermions by identifying a one-body potential that already generates some of the physics associated with the interaction between the particles. This onebody potential combined with the kinetic energy and pertinent external potentials, like the Coulomb attraction to the nucleus for electrons in atoms, forms a good baseline to discuss the physics of these systems. In particular, it leads to a shell-model picture that is appropriate for atoms, nuclei, and other localized many-fermion systems. In addition, such a Hamiltonian may be used as a starting point of the perturbation expansion of relevant physical quantities, to be presented in Ch. 8. The general discussion of this independent-particle description, where fermions do not interact but are aware of each other’s identity, will be given in Sec. 3.1. The application of the independent-particle model (IPM) to electrons in atoms is presented in Sec. 3.2, and for nucleons in nuclei in Sec. 3.3. An important hypothetical system entitled “nuclear matter” is introduced in Sec. 3.3.1. It describes an idealized way to represent and study the global properties of the interior of nuclei which exhibit strikingly similar features for nuclei heavier than 16 O. In Sec. 3.4 the method of second quantization is applied to the concept of isospin as it is relevant for the description of nuclei.
Real knowledge is to know the extent of one's ignorance. Confucius, 500 BCE Summary The topic of this chapter is a small selection of the vast array of experimentally observed phenomena chosen to exemplify crucial roles played by the electron– electron interaction. Examples in the present chapter bring out the effects of correlation in ground and excited states as well as in thermal equilibrium. These raise challenges for theory and quantitative many-body methods in treating interacting electrons, the topics of the following chapters. The title of this book is Interacting Electrons . Of course, there are no non-interacting electrons: in any system with more than one electron, the electron–electron interaction affects the energy and leads to correlation between the electrons. All first-principles theories deal with the electron–electron interaction in some way, but often they treat the electrons as independent fermions in a static mean-field potential that contains interaction effects approximately. As described in Ch. 4, the Hartree–Fock method is a variational approximation with a wavefunction for fermions that are uncorrelated, except for the requirement of antisymmetry. The Kohn–Sham approach to DFT defines an auxiliary system of independent fermions that is chosen to reproduce the ground-state density. It is exact in principle and remarkably successful in practice. However, many properties such as excitation energies are not supposed to be taken directly from the Kohn–Sham equations, even in principle. Various other methods attempt to incorporate some effect of correlation in the choice of the potential. This chapter is designed to highlight a few examples of experimentally observed phenomena that demonstrate qualitative consequences of electron–electron interactions beyond independent-particle approximations. Some examples illustrate effects that cannot be accounted for in any theory where electrons are considered as independent particles. Others are direct experimental measurements of correlation functions that would vanish if the electrons were independent. In yet other cases, a phenomenon can be explained in terms of independent particles in some effective potential, but it is deeply unsatisfying if one has to invent a different potential for every case, even for different properties in the same material. A satisfactory theory ultimately requires us to confront the problem of interacting, correlated electrons.