The Hohenberg–Kohn theorem In Chapter 2 we explored some of the consequences of electron–electron interactions, albeit in some simple perturbative approaches and within the random phase approximation. There we found that the problem of treating these interactions is exceedingly difficult, even in the case where there is no external one–particle potential applied to the system. We have also explored some of the properties of noninteracting electrons in an external potential, in this case the periodic lattice potential. This led to the concepts of electron bands and band structure, subjects of fundamental importance in understanding the physics of metals, insulators, and semiconductors. Of course, in the real world, electrons in matter are subjected both to electron–electron interactions and to external potentials. How to include systematically and correctly the electron–electron interactions in calculations of real systems is truly a formidable problem. Why that is so is easily demonstrated. Suppose that we want to solve the problem of N electrons interacting in some external potential. The N -electron wavefunction can be expanded in Slater determinants of some suitable single-particle basis such as plane waves. We can describe the Slater determinants by occupation numbers in our second–quantized notation. Suppose furthermore that we have a basis of a total of N k plane wave states at our disposal. Here N k must be large enough that all reasonable “wiggles” of the many-body wavefunction can be included.
The Hohenberg–Kohn theorem In Chapter 2 we explored some of the consequences of electron–electron interactions, albeit in some simple perturbative approaches and within the random phase approximation. There we found that the problem of treating these interactions is exceedingly difficult, even in the case where there is no external one–particle potential applied to the system. We have also explored some of the properties of noninteracting electrons in an external potential, in this case the periodic lattice potential. This led to the concepts of electron bands and band structure, subjects of fundamental importance in understanding the physics of metals, insulators, and semiconductors. Of course, in the real world, electrons in matter are subjected both to electron–electron interactions and to external potentials. How to include systematically and correctly the electron–electron interactions in calculations of real systems is truly a formidable problem. Why that is so is easily demonstrated. Suppose that we want to solve the problem of N electrons interacting in some external potential. The N -electron wavefunction can be expanded in Slater determinants of some suitable single-particle basis such as plane waves. We can describe the Slater determinants by occupation numbers in our second–quantized notation. Suppose furthermore that we have a basis of a total of N k plane wave states at our disposal. Here N k must be large enough that all reasonable “wiggles” of the many-body wavefunction can be included.
If there were no Coulomb interaction among electrons, it would be relatively straightforward to solve the many-electron Schrödinger equation. It is, however, precisely this interaction that is at the heart of numerous fascinating phenomena in condensed matter physics such as superconductivity, Kondo physics, magnetism, etc. Due to the large number of electrons in a material being of the order of Avogadro's number, it is at present — and perhaps in the foreseeable future — not feasible or even desirable to solve the Schrödinger equation to obtain the many-electron wavefunction. Fortunately, a large number of important physical properties can be calculated without explicit knowledge of the wavefunction. Two of the most important formalisms for dealing with the many-electron problem which avoid a direct use of the many-electron wavefunction are the Green function and the density functional theory. Within the Kohn-Sham scheme the latter is used to calculate ground-state properties whereas the former for excitation spectra. The book presents the fundamentals of these two theories in detail with essential many-body tools, such as the occupation number representation and Grassmann algebra developed from scratch. Prior knowledge of many-body theory is not a prerequisite so that it is readable for final-year undergraduates and graduate students in physics and chemistry as well as researchers in the field of electronic structure and many-body theory. The book includes in the last chapter an exposition of a density-functional path for determining the Green function, a new formalism recently proposed by the author. The book should be a valuable companion for those embarking in the field of many-electron physics.
The formalism of Kohn and Sham uses a specific (model) hamiltonian which highly simplifies the many-electron problem to that of noninteracting fermions. The theorem of Hohenberg and Kohn tells us that, for a given ground state density, this hamiltonian is unique. In principle, this density can be chosen as that of the real, interacting system. To obtain the energy, or other properties of the real system, approximations are needed. Working with non interacting fermions is an important simplification, but it may be easier to produce approximations with different choices of the model hamiltonian. The feature that the exact density is (ideally) reproduced can be kept in the newly defined fictitious systems. Using model hamiltonians having the same form as the physical one, that is, being built of one- and two-body operators, allows to approach the physical hamiltonian arbitrarily close, and thus a systematic reduction of the approximations.
Real knowledge is to know the extent of one's ignorance. Confucius, 500 BCE Summary The topic of this chapter is a small selection of the vast array of experimentally observed phenomena chosen to exemplify crucial roles played by the electron– electron interaction. Examples in the present chapter bring out the effects of correlation in ground and excited states as well as in thermal equilibrium. These raise challenges for theory and quantitative many-body methods in treating interacting electrons, the topics of the following chapters. The title of this book is Interacting Electrons . Of course, there are no non-interacting electrons: in any system with more than one electron, the electron–electron interaction affects the energy and leads to correlation between the electrons. All first-principles theories deal with the electron–electron interaction in some way, but often they treat the electrons as independent fermions in a static mean-field potential that contains interaction effects approximately. As described in Ch. 4, the Hartree–Fock method is a variational approximation with a wavefunction for fermions that are uncorrelated, except for the requirement of antisymmetry. The Kohn–Sham approach to DFT defines an auxiliary system of independent fermions that is chosen to reproduce the ground-state density. It is exact in principle and remarkably successful in practice. However, many properties such as excitation energies are not supposed to be taken directly from the Kohn–Sham equations, even in principle. Various other methods attempt to incorporate some effect of correlation in the choice of the potential. This chapter is designed to highlight a few examples of experimentally observed phenomena that demonstrate qualitative consequences of electron–electron interactions beyond independent-particle approximations. Some examples illustrate effects that cannot be accounted for in any theory where electrons are considered as independent particles. Others are direct experimental measurements of correlation functions that would vanish if the electrons were independent. In yet other cases, a phenomenon can be explained in terms of independent particles in some effective potential, but it is deeply unsatisfying if one has to invent a different potential for every case, even for different properties in the same material. A satisfactory theory ultimately requires us to confront the problem of interacting, correlated electrons.
Let us now discuss how to go beyond single electron quantum mechanics to that of multiple electrons. We will discuss how to account for Pauli exclusion principle properly in the bandstructure, and not just in the occupation statistics. To explore many particle rules systematically, we will need to understand second quantization. Readers may choose to skip this chapter and come back to it later when we discuss interacting systems, particularly, scattering and correlation effects. We will introduce creation and annihilation operators as a way to enforce wavefunction symmetry under particle exchange, and how it leads to the second quantized Hamiltonian. A simple limit is the Hartree Fock theory that marries Coulomb interactions with Pauli exclusion. In this context, we discuss Feynman diagrams as a way to visually describe the underlying processes. We also discuss symmetry of phonon operators, the use of Green's functions to solve their responses to external perturbations, and the concept of self energies as a way to capture complicated interactions not directly included in the electronic potential.
In the previous chapters DMFT has been developed as a methodology for calculation of dynamical and thermodynamic properties of many-body systems, with applications to model systems. In order for DMFT to be a general method for quantitative calculations, there must be systematic procedures to derive all the ingredients from first principles. In this chapter we consider the most prominent examples, materials with partially filled 3 d , 4 f , or 5 f localized, atomic-like states, and set up the characteristic form of the hamiltonian. This is the basis for DFT+DMFT methods discussed here and used in the examples in Ch. 20, and for the combination of DMFT with many-body perturbation theory in Ch. 21. Simpler techniques, including self-interaction correction, DFT+U, and DFT+Gutzwiller, are also useful and are summarized in the last sections of this chapter. Up to this point, dynamical mean-field theory has been developed for model systems with Hubbard-type hamiltonians, where the hopping matrix elements and interactions are considered as parameters. For problems with strong interactions, DMFT leads to renormalized bands, satellites in the one-particle spectra, magnetic phase transitions and local moments, metal–insulator transitions, and many other phenomena observed in real materials, as brought out in Ch. 2. The purpose of this chapter is to provide the framework for a quantitative theory of these materials. These are difficult problems, experimentally, theoretically, and computationally, and the first step is to identify the aspects of the materials that must be treated explicitly as the local strongly interacting system, and the “rest” that are treated by a different method. This division of the problem is useful because a real material involves many degrees of freedom, i.e., the electronic states must be described in a basis sufficiently large to describe all the relevant states. However, the part that can be treated by non-perturbative solvers (Ch. 18) is limited by the computational cost that scales rapidly with the number of states included in the embedded site or cluster. Thus one must choose a small number of localized orbitals that inevitably are non-unique. This may seem like a step backward for quantitative methods; however, it opens a window for methods to treat these interesting problems and it presents a challenge to overcome the limitations.
The analysis in this paper shows that the Hohenberg-Kohn theorem is the constellation of two statements: (i) the mathematically rigorous Hohenberg-Kohn lemma, which demonstrates that the same ground-state density cannot correspond to two different potentials of an external field, and (ii) the hypothesis of the existence of the universal density functional. Based on the obtained explicit expression for the nonrel-ativistic particle energy in a local external field, we prove that the energy of the system of more than two non-interacting electrons cannot be a functional of the inhomogeneous density. This result is generalized to the system of interacting electrons. It means that the Hohenberg-Kohn lemma cannot provide justification of the universal density functional for fermions. At the same time, statements of the density functional theory remain valid when considering any number of noninteracting ground-state bosons due to the Bose condensation effect. In the framework of the density matrix functional theory, the hypothesis of the existence of the universal density matrix functional corresponds to the cases of noninteracting particles and to interaction in the Hartree-Fock approximation.