Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:cond-mat/0401561

A close look at Jeckelmann's weak-coupling results: Reply to the Comment by Jeckelmann

G. P. Zhang

Published Jan 27, 2004• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We are pleased to see that Jeckelmann has made many changes to the original version of his comment on our paper as a result of our response. Here is a copy of this powerful response that reveals problems in his previous results. However, since this response was written before his revised comment came out, new issues in his new comment, which will be commented if necessary, are not discussed at present. Although some changes are made in his new comment as we suggested in the response, we still see many other new and old misleading statements and results. We kindly suggest the author correct them since evidence is very compelling.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.cond-mat/0401561

Related papers

Further comments on the Aharonov-Bohm effect

Michel Bawin, André Burnel

Lettere al nuovo cimento della societa italiana di fisica/Lettere al nuovo cimento•Jan 1, 1980•9 citations

Reply to “Comment on ‘Accurate ground-state phase diagram of the one-dimensional extended Hubbard model at half filling’ ”

G. P. Zhang

We respond to Jeckelman's Comment on our paper [G. P. Zhang, Phys. Rev. B 68, 153101 (2003)], which discusses his previous work [E. Jeckelmann, Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 236401 (2002)]. We feel that it is important to point out that his previous results show a trend contradicting the weak-coupling limit, a conclusion that is independent of our calculation. Therefore, our comments on his previous results remain valid and our conclusion is unchanged.

Physical Review B•May 4, 2005•1 citation

Paper 3.18: N. Bloembergen, “The stimulated raman effect,” American Journal of Physics 11, 989–1023, 1967.

This review deals with the first five or six years of the stimulated raman effect. I have received more requests for reprints (over one thousand) for this paper than for any other. In an editorial, “Sixty years of the American Journal of Physics ( Am. J. Phys. 61 , 103, 1993), R.H. Romer states that this paper ranked third in frequency of citation for his journal in the Science Citation Index. The paper was written by invitation of the editor of the journal, Forrest I. Boley, in 1966. I even received a check for five hundred dollars from him, but shortly thereafter he wrote me a letter suggesting that I withdraw the paper on the basis of criticism he had received. He did not request restitution of the money. I replied that he should send me the critical comments to which he was referring. They were insignificant. I made a few minor corrections in response and insisted on publication. I have not been able to trace the source of this curious incident. Forrest Boley wrote me last year that he does not remember anything unusual. At any rate, the only critical comment I have received since its publication is that the paper did not mention that a US patent for raman lasers was issued to Gisela Eckart. I had given adequate credit to the contributions of the Hughes Research group as a whole, but I did not know about the individual credits within this group. It is hoped that the paper can still serve as an introduction for new workers entering this ever-active field and that it is not only of historic but also of educational significance.

World Scientific series in 20th century physics•Sep 1, 1996•1 citation

On the weak coupling limit problem

Luigi Accardi, A. Frigerio, Yun Gang Lu

Lecture notes in mathematics•Jan 1, 1989•15 citations

Strong Coupling Limit and Some Exact Results

Lecture notes in physics. M, Monographs•Jan 1, 1995•0 citations

On perspectivism and relationalism of Relational Quantum Mechanics

Joanna Luc, Tomasz Placek

This paper discusses perspectivism and relationalism in the two versions of Relational Quantum Mechanics (RQM): that initiated by Rovelli ( Int. J. Theor. Phys. , 35 (8), 1637–1678 1996) and the other, by Adlam and Rovelli ( Philos. Phys. , 1 (1) 2023). To this end, we offer a substantial discussion of this interpretation. We investigate the issue of the disagreement of results between different observers; distinguish four senses of agreement: strong, weak, very weak, and perspectival; and argue that the old version guarantees only the very weak and perspectival agreement, whereas the new version guarantees the weak agreement as well. The problem that individuals in RQM need to be propertyless when they do not interact is also investigated. Concerning the issue of probabilities in RQM, we argue that to express probabilities involving events relative to different systems, a new kind of probability spaces needs to be devised. The final problem that we identify concerns underspecified dynamics; we argue that some additional postulates are indispensable to make RQM’s dynamics fully specified. The last two points lead to the conclusion that, contrary to declarations of RQM proponents, this interpretation requires some modifications of quantum formalism and not merely conceptual changes. Finally, concerning the problem of testimony, while the new version of RQM was devised to solve it, we argue that in the old version, this problem can be alleviated to the extent that perspectivism permits.

Foundations of Physics•Oct 30, 2025•2 citations
We are pleased to see that Jeckelmann has made many changes to the original version of his comment on our paper as a result of our response. Here is a copy of this powerful response that reveals problems in his previous results. However, since this response was written before his revised comment came out, new issues in his new comment, which will be commented if necessary, are not discussed at present. Although some changes are made in his new comment as we suggested in the response, we still see many other new and old misleading statements and results. We kindly suggest the author correct them since evidence is very compelling.
This review deals with the first five or six years of the stimulated raman effect. I have received more requests for reprints (over one thousand) for this paper than for any other. In an editorial, “Sixty years of the American Journal of Physics ( Am. J. Phys. 61 , 103, 1993), R.H. Romer states that this paper ranked third in frequency of citation for his journal in the Science Citation Index. The paper was written by invitation of the editor of the journal, Forrest I. Boley, in 1966. I even received a check for five hundred dollars from him, but shortly thereafter he wrote me a letter suggesting that I withdraw the paper on the basis of criticism he had received. He did not request restitution of the money. I replied that he should send me the critical comments to which he was referring. They were insignificant. I made a few minor corrections in response and insisted on publication. I have not been able to trace the source of this curious incident. Forrest Boley wrote me last year that he does not remember anything unusual. At any rate, the only critical comment I have received since its publication is that the paper did not mention that a US patent for raman lasers was issued to Gisela Eckart. I had given adequate credit to the contributions of the Hughes Research group as a whole, but I did not know about the individual credits within this group. It is hoped that the paper can still serve as an introduction for new workers entering this ever-active field and that it is not only of historic but also of educational significance.
This paper discusses perspectivism and relationalism in the two versions of Relational Quantum Mechanics (RQM): that initiated by Rovelli ( Int. J. Theor. Phys. , 35 (8), 1637–1678 1996) and the other, by Adlam and Rovelli ( Philos. Phys. , 1 (1) 2023). To this end, we offer a substantial discussion of this interpretation. We investigate the issue of the disagreement of results between different observers; distinguish four senses of agreement: strong, weak, very weak, and perspectival; and argue that the old version guarantees only the very weak and perspectival agreement, whereas the new version guarantees the weak agreement as well. The problem that individuals in RQM need to be propertyless when they do not interact is also investigated. Concerning the issue of probabilities in RQM, we argue that to express probabilities involving events relative to different systems, a new kind of probability spaces needs to be devised. The final problem that we identify concerns underspecified dynamics; we argue that some additional postulates are indispensable to make RQM’s dynamics fully specified. The last two points lead to the conclusion that, contrary to declarations of RQM proponents, this interpretation requires some modifications of quantum formalism and not merely conceptual changes. Finally, concerning the problem of testimony, while the new version of RQM was devised to solve it, we argue that in the old version, this problem can be alleviated to the extent that perspectivism permits.