Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

World Scientific series in 20th century physics

Paper 3.18: N. Bloembergen, “The stimulated raman effect,” American Journal of Physics 11, 989–1023, 1967.

Published Sep 1, 1996• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

This review deals with the first five or six years of the stimulated raman effect. I have received more requests for reprints (over one thousand) for this paper than for any other. In an editorial, “Sixty years of the American Journal of Physics ( Am. J. Phys. 61 , 103, 1993), R.H. Romer states that this paper ranked third in frequency of citation for his journal in the Science Citation Index. The paper was written by invitation of the editor of the journal, Forrest I. Boley, in 1966. I even received a check for five hundred dollars from him, but shortly thereafter he wrote me a letter suggesting that I withdraw the paper on the basis of criticism he had received. He did not request restitution of the money. I replied that he should send me the critical comments to which he was referring. They were insignificant. I made a few minor corrections in response and insisted on publication. I have not been able to trace the source of this curious incident. Forrest Boley wrote me last year that he does not remember anything unusual. At any rate, the only critical comment I have received since its publication is that the paper did not mention that a US patent for raman lasers was issued to Gisela Eckart. I had given adequate credit to the contributions of the Hughes Research group as a whole, but I did not know about the individual credits within this group. It is hoped that the paper can still serve as an introduction for new workers entering this ever-active field and that it is not only of historic but also of educational significance.

DOI
10.1142/9789812795793_0038

Related papers

Paper 1.7: N. Bloembergen, “Nonlinear optics and spectroscopy,” Rev. Mod. Phys. 54, 685–695, 1982.

This paper is the Nobel lecture, which I presented at the Swedish Academy of Sciences in Stockholm in December 1981. Although the Review of Modern Physics is a readily accessible journal and this paper has also appeared in Science and in special volumes of Nobel lectures, it is included in this reprint volume because these journals are not regularly consulted by the quantum electronics community. The paper sketches a broad overview of nonlinear optical phenomena and their historic link to nonlinear phenomena in magnetic resonance. One half of the 1981 Nobel Prize for Physics was awarded to Kai Siegbahn for “his contribution to the development of high resolution electron spectroscopy” while the other half was awarded jointly to Arthur L. Schawlow and myself for “their contributions to the development of laser spectroscopy”. While this citation is most suitable for the work of my colleague Art Schawlow, I believe that a citation for “contributions to nonlinear optics” would have been a more appropriate description of my work. Of course, I did not protest the decision by the Nobel Physics Award Committee. My whole family had a wonderful time in Stockholm. We enjoyed the pomp and circumstance as well as the friendly hospitality of the occasion.

World Scientific series in 20th century physics•Sep 1, 1996•0 citations

Paper 3.19: N. Bloembergen, “A quarter century of stimulated raman scattering,” International Journal of Modern Physics B1, 1–8, 1987.

This paper was prepared for a plenary lecture I was invited to present at the International Conference on Raman Spectroscopy, ICORS X, held in Eugene, Oregon in September 1986. It gives a cursory overview of some of the major developments from 1961 to 1986. It was used to start the first issue of a new journal, International Journal of Modern Physics B , devoted to atomic, molecular, and condensed matter physics.

World Scientific series in 20th century physics•Sep 1, 1996•0 citations

Paper 1.3: N. Bloembergen and Y.R. Shen, “Quantum theoretical comparison of nonlinear susceptibilities in parametric media, lasers and raman lasers,” Phys. Rev. 133, A37–A49, 1964.

The quantum mechanical calculation of the nonlinear susceptibilities presented in Paper 1.1 applies only to purely parametric, non-dissipative processes. It yields real values for the nonlinear susceptibilities. I realized in the fall of 1962 that the general scheme for calculating complex susceptibilities in magnetic resonance, based on a density matrix description of the material system, would also be applicable in optics. These ideas are worked out explicitly for two- and three-level systems in this paper. It mentions the interference of one- and two-photon transitions between the same initial and final states This gives rise to an imaginary part of χ (2) , the lowest order nonlinear susceptibility. The imaginary χ (3) describes both raman processes and two-photon absorption processes. I was fortunate to keep my graduate student Ron Shen, who obtained his Ph.D. degree from Harvard University in 1962, for another year as a postdoctoral fellow. His approach to physics was very similar to that of Peter Pershan and myself. He combined experimental and theoretical skills in an efficient manner. We were able to connect the results of quantum mechanical analysis with the experimental results of raman lasers and parametric processes. This paper has not attracted much attention and is not often cited. It appears that too many details are hidden in the general formalism. There are a great number of papers published during the past three decades on two- and three-level systems subjected to electromagnetic fields at two or more frequencies. There are so many variants, depending on the detuning, the damping constants, and the amplitudes, or the “Rabi frequencies”, of the applied fields that different terms are selected from the general expression in each particular situation. If our paper accomplished little else, it certainly contributed to our own understanding of nonlinear phenomena. Circumstances conspired so that Ron Shen and I were able to collaborate again on some joint papers during the academic year 1964–1965. Ron had been appointed as an assistant professor at the University of California in Berkeley and I had independently made plans to spend a sabbatical leave there. I wanted to work with Charles Kittel on solid state problems in the physics department, and to give a course on nonlinear optics in the electrical engineering department which had a lot of activity in quantum electronics. My course was attended by two of Prof. John R. Whinnery's students, Eric Ippen and Robert V. Shank. These two later became well known for the generation of femtosecond pulses which opened up many new avenues of research. Ron Shen stayed in Berkeley as a professor of physics, and he continues to lead a very productive research group in nonlinear optics. He wrote a well-known textbook, Principles of Nonlinear Optics , published by Wiley in 1984. He and his family have also remained life-long friends of ours.

World Scientific series in 20th century physics•Sep 1, 1996•5 citations

Paper 3.12: N. Bloembergen, H. Lotem and R.T. Lynch, Jr., “Line shapes in coherent resonant raman scattering,” Indian Journal of Pure and Applied Physics 16, 151–158, 1978.

In the mid-seventies there was considerable confusion and controversy about the correct treatment of damping terms in CARS spectroscopy. I maintained that the general density matrix approach described in papers 1.3 and 1.4 should yield unambiguous results. Rob Lynch systematically kept track of all the terms in the calculation of χ (2) and χ (3) , and rearranged them in such a manner that terms arising only in the presence of damping are clearly separated. In the absence of damping, only resonances between the ground state and an excited level occur in the denominators. Damping introduces extra resonances between pairs of excited states. Their numerators vanish if the only damping is the natural width caused by spontaneous emission decay to the ground state. For collisional or other types of damping, their numerators are still small, but non-vanishing. I decided to publish the elaborate algebraic results as an appendix to a paper on line shapes of resonant raman scattering, which was our contribution to a special issue of an Indian journal commemorating the 50th anniversary, or golden jubilee, of the discovery by Raman of the effect named after him. Our results agreed, except for a few minor algebraic errors, with the independent calculations by J.P. Taran and M. Denariez at ONERA near Paris, the French institute for studies of the upper atmosphere. At scientific meetings, we had a difficult time convincing chemists who carried out the bulk of resonant raman experiments of the correctness of our approach. Taran summarized the situation at the end of one international conference to me in the following words, “Perhaps we won this battle, but we have lost the war. ” This reinforced my resolve to demonstrate the physical reality of the “extra” terms explicitly exhibited in this note.

World Scientific series in 20th century physics•Sep 1, 1996•2 citations

Comment on “Anomalous Stimulated Brillouin Scattering via Ultraslow Light”

Valeri I. Kovalev

A Comment on the Letter by A. B. Matsko et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 86, 2006 (2001). The authors of the Letter offer a Reply.Received 25 June 2001DOI:https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.88.239301©2002 American Physical Society

Physical Review Letters•May 28, 2002•2 citations

George W Series Memorial Essays

Johnny Dodd

I would like to recall my experiences when I joined George Series when on study leave from the University of Otago in 1959. Like George, we had decided, some years previously, to pursue the line of research opened up by the double-resonance experiment of Brossel and Bitter. Up to that time both groups had been applying the new technique to traditional spectroscopic problems, those of measuring the fine structure, hyperhe structure, g -factors and nuclear moments. But here, in Oxford, was something new and exciting - experiments that studied the nature of light itself, questioning some long-held views. George had come to the view that, in a double-resonance experiment, one could demonstrate the inner coherence that could exist between superposition states of an atom. He, and his students Wilf Fox and Mike Taylor, had already obtained promising evidence; but he needed more definite results if he was going to allay the doubts and suspicions of some others in the Clarendon. At the time, people generally thought that light, being a superposition of radiations from many atoms with no obvious phase relation to each other, was an incoherent wave phenomenon. One could observe small scale coherence (for example, in the Young interference experiment) but it would be largely concealed by the incoherent nature of the radiation from many atoms in a source. In the experiments that had been performed the coherence was introduced between a pair of excited states (Zeeman sub-states) by the application of an oscillating magnetic field - was it not likely, according to the doubters, that the modulation observed in the fluorescence was due to "pick-up" in the amplifiers from the source of oscillations? George had to prove that this was not the cause. I well remember him saying at the time "I have a hunch that I am correct". That typified his approach to physics. The work of 1959 demonstrated beyond all doubt that substantial coherence, manifested as strong beats in the intensity of the light, could be obtained. The experiments demonstrated this to be the case. We also worked out the theory of the effect. In the theoretical explanation of the experiments, both George and I were impressed by the success of a semi-classical approach - i.e. by treating the atom as a quantum-mechanical structure and the light as an electromagnetic wave. This viewpoint dominated much of George's work in later times. As he stated in the Memoirs, "I came to the conclusion that the key problem in the interaction of electromagnetic fields and atoms was the nature of spontaneous emission. I accept the quantum field theory as giving an adequate mathematical explanation, but this seems to me to be deficient as a physical explanation". I think it is fair to say that George was always seeking a deeper physical meaning than was provided by a mere mathematical description. This philosophy certainly rubbed off on people who worked with him. That year, 1959, was also the year when coherence in light beams was being studied in other laboratories across the Atlantic. It was the year the laser was born. There was no doubt then about coherence in light. I would also like to mention the great regard that George had for S. Pancharatnam who came to work at the Clarendon in 1964. George and Panch spent many hours in discussions. Although they never published anything jointly, George recalled that, if he was doubtful about some point of physics, he would refer to Panch. As he wrote in a moving review for the Pancharatnam Memorial Issue of Current Science (Vol. 67, August 1994), "Panch was not easily moved from the conventional view [of the nature of the interactions of light and atoms]. I was more impetuous; Panch was generally right". George edited the collected works of Pancharatnam; he went to India as a Raman Visiting Professor in 1982 and was made an Honorary Fellow of the Indian Academy of Sciences in 1984. At Reading [from 1968 to 1982], he increasingly turned to spectroscopy with tuneable lasers, generally with the emphasis on understanding the underlying physics rather than accumulating data. He had a highly original mind, which showed both in his choice of research topics and in his method of approach. He did not follow fashion; his instinct for an interesting problem was at odds with the modem policy of direct funding and the identification of "growth areas". His applications for research grants were often unsuccessful, despite his high international standing and integrity. He was never interested in building up a large research team, and had comparatively few research students, but his enthusiasm and commitment to the quality of his science attracted a succession of overseas visitors to his laboratory. Following my own year at the Clarendon, and some subsequent visits both to Oxford and to Reading, there was a continuing strong association between the Clarendon and Otago Physics that continues until today. George Series was the William Evans Visiting Professor to Otago University in 1972. He never lost his interest in the fundamentals of physics inspired by his first researches into the structure of the hydrogen atom; he wrote on the Rydberg constant, the physics of spontaneous emission, and on the fine-structure constant α = e 2 / hc . He donated a garden seat to St Edmund Hall (Oxford), of which he was a Fellow. On it he placed a plaque* in recognition of the ubiquitous nature of this constant; it almost had magical significance for him. He served physics in many ways outside research. He was for a number of years the Editor of the European Journal of Physics and was also Editor of the Journal of Physics B: Atomic and Molecular Physics , He was also on the Editorial Board of a number of journals. He was elected to Fellowship of a number of physics societies. The Editorial Board of these Memorial Essays dedicate them to George's memory, and to his wife Annette and his family.

Physica Scripta•Jan 1, 1997•0 citations
This review deals with the first five or six years of the stimulated raman effect. I have received more requests for reprints (over one thousand) for this paper than for any other. In an editorial, “Sixty years of the American Journal of Physics ( Am. J. Phys. 61 , 103, 1993), R.H. Romer states that this paper ranked third in frequency of citation for his journal in the Science Citation Index. The paper was written by invitation of the editor of the journal, Forrest I. Boley, in 1966. I even received a check for five hundred dollars from him, but shortly thereafter he wrote me a letter suggesting that I withdraw the paper on the basis of criticism he had received. He did not request restitution of the money. I replied that he should send me the critical comments to which he was referring. They were insignificant. I made a few minor corrections in response and insisted on publication. I have not been able to trace the source of this curious incident. Forrest Boley wrote me last year that he does not remember anything unusual. At any rate, the only critical comment I have received since its publication is that the paper did not mention that a US patent for raman lasers was issued to Gisela Eckart. I had given adequate credit to the contributions of the Hughes Research group as a whole, but I did not know about the individual credits within this group. It is hoped that the paper can still serve as an introduction for new workers entering this ever-active field and that it is not only of historic but also of educational significance.
This paper is the Nobel lecture, which I presented at the Swedish Academy of Sciences in Stockholm in December 1981. Although the Review of Modern Physics is a readily accessible journal and this paper has also appeared in Science and in special volumes of Nobel lectures, it is included in this reprint volume because these journals are not regularly consulted by the quantum electronics community. The paper sketches a broad overview of nonlinear optical phenomena and their historic link to nonlinear phenomena in magnetic resonance. One half of the 1981 Nobel Prize for Physics was awarded to Kai Siegbahn for “his contribution to the development of high resolution electron spectroscopy” while the other half was awarded jointly to Arthur L. Schawlow and myself for “their contributions to the development of laser spectroscopy”. While this citation is most suitable for the work of my colleague Art Schawlow, I believe that a citation for “contributions to nonlinear optics” would have been a more appropriate description of my work. Of course, I did not protest the decision by the Nobel Physics Award Committee. My whole family had a wonderful time in Stockholm. We enjoyed the pomp and circumstance as well as the friendly hospitality of the occasion.
The quantum mechanical calculation of the nonlinear susceptibilities presented in Paper 1.1 applies only to purely parametric, non-dissipative processes. It yields real values for the nonlinear susceptibilities. I realized in the fall of 1962 that the general scheme for calculating complex susceptibilities in magnetic resonance, based on a density matrix description of the material system, would also be applicable in optics. These ideas are worked out explicitly for two- and three-level systems in this paper. It mentions the interference of one- and two-photon transitions between the same initial and final states This gives rise to an imaginary part of χ (2) , the lowest order nonlinear susceptibility. The imaginary χ (3) describes both raman processes and two-photon absorption processes. I was fortunate to keep my graduate student Ron Shen, who obtained his Ph.D. degree from Harvard University in 1962, for another year as a postdoctoral fellow. His approach to physics was very similar to that of Peter Pershan and myself. He combined experimental and theoretical skills in an efficient manner. We were able to connect the results of quantum mechanical analysis with the experimental results of raman lasers and parametric processes. This paper has not attracted much attention and is not often cited. It appears that too many details are hidden in the general formalism. There are a great number of papers published during the past three decades on two- and three-level systems subjected to electromagnetic fields at two or more frequencies. There are so many variants, depending on the detuning, the damping constants, and the amplitudes, or the “Rabi frequencies”, of the applied fields that different terms are selected from the general expression in each particular situation. If our paper accomplished little else, it certainly contributed to our own understanding of nonlinear phenomena. Circumstances conspired so that Ron Shen and I were able to collaborate again on some joint papers during the academic year 1964–1965. Ron had been appointed as an assistant professor at the University of California in Berkeley and I had independently made plans to spend a sabbatical leave there. I wanted to work with Charles Kittel on solid state problems in the physics department, and to give a course on nonlinear optics in the electrical engineering department which had a lot of activity in quantum electronics. My course was attended by two of Prof. John R. Whinnery's students, Eric Ippen and Robert V. Shank. These two later became well known for the generation of femtosecond pulses which opened up many new avenues of research. Ron Shen stayed in Berkeley as a professor of physics, and he continues to lead a very productive research group in nonlinear optics. He wrote a well-known textbook, Principles of Nonlinear Optics , published by Wiley in 1984. He and his family have also remained life-long friends of ours.
In the mid-seventies there was considerable confusion and controversy about the correct treatment of damping terms in CARS spectroscopy. I maintained that the general density matrix approach described in papers 1.3 and 1.4 should yield unambiguous results. Rob Lynch systematically kept track of all the terms in the calculation of χ (2) and χ (3) , and rearranged them in such a manner that terms arising only in the presence of damping are clearly separated. In the absence of damping, only resonances between the ground state and an excited level occur in the denominators. Damping introduces extra resonances between pairs of excited states. Their numerators vanish if the only damping is the natural width caused by spontaneous emission decay to the ground state. For collisional or other types of damping, their numerators are still small, but non-vanishing. I decided to publish the elaborate algebraic results as an appendix to a paper on line shapes of resonant raman scattering, which was our contribution to a special issue of an Indian journal commemorating the 50th anniversary, or golden jubilee, of the discovery by Raman of the effect named after him. Our results agreed, except for a few minor algebraic errors, with the independent calculations by J.P. Taran and M. Denariez at ONERA near Paris, the French institute for studies of the upper atmosphere. At scientific meetings, we had a difficult time convincing chemists who carried out the bulk of resonant raman experiments of the correctness of our approach. Taran summarized the situation at the end of one international conference to me in the following words, “Perhaps we won this battle, but we have lost the war. ” This reinforced my resolve to demonstrate the physical reality of the “extra” terms explicitly exhibited in this note.
I would like to recall my experiences when I joined George Series when on study leave from the University of Otago in 1959. Like George, we had decided, some years previously, to pursue the line of research opened up by the double-resonance experiment of Brossel and Bitter. Up to that time both groups had been applying the new technique to traditional spectroscopic problems, those of measuring the fine structure, hyperhe structure, g -factors and nuclear moments. But here, in Oxford, was something new and exciting - experiments that studied the nature of light itself, questioning some long-held views. George had come to the view that, in a double-resonance experiment, one could demonstrate the inner coherence that could exist between superposition states of an atom. He, and his students Wilf Fox and Mike Taylor, had already obtained promising evidence; but he needed more definite results if he was going to allay the doubts and suspicions of some others in the Clarendon. At the time, people generally thought that light, being a superposition of radiations from many atoms with no obvious phase relation to each other, was an incoherent wave phenomenon. One could observe small scale coherence (for example, in the Young interference experiment) but it would be largely concealed by the incoherent nature of the radiation from many atoms in a source. In the experiments that had been performed the coherence was introduced between a pair of excited states (Zeeman sub-states) by the application of an oscillating magnetic field - was it not likely, according to the doubters, that the modulation observed in the fluorescence was due to "pick-up" in the amplifiers from the source of oscillations? George had to prove that this was not the cause. I well remember him saying at the time "I have a hunch that I am correct". That typified his approach to physics. The work of 1959 demonstrated beyond all doubt that substantial coherence, manifested as strong beats in the intensity of the light, could be obtained. The experiments demonstrated this to be the case. We also worked out the theory of the effect. In the theoretical explanation of the experiments, both George and I were impressed by the success of a semi-classical approach - i.e. by treating the atom as a quantum-mechanical structure and the light as an electromagnetic wave. This viewpoint dominated much of George's work in later times. As he stated in the Memoirs, "I came to the conclusion that the key problem in the interaction of electromagnetic fields and atoms was the nature of spontaneous emission. I accept the quantum field theory as giving an adequate mathematical explanation, but this seems to me to be deficient as a physical explanation". I think it is fair to say that George was always seeking a deeper physical meaning than was provided by a mere mathematical description. This philosophy certainly rubbed off on people who worked with him. That year, 1959, was also the year when coherence in light beams was being studied in other laboratories across the Atlantic. It was the year the laser was born. There was no doubt then about coherence in light. I would also like to mention the great regard that George had for S. Pancharatnam who came to work at the Clarendon in 1964. George and Panch spent many hours in discussions. Although they never published anything jointly, George recalled that, if he was doubtful about some point of physics, he would refer to Panch. As he wrote in a moving review for the Pancharatnam Memorial Issue of Current Science (Vol. 67, August 1994), "Panch was not easily moved from the conventional view [of the nature of the interactions of light and atoms]. I was more impetuous; Panch was generally right". George edited the collected works of Pancharatnam; he went to India as a Raman Visiting Professor in 1982 and was made an Honorary Fellow of the Indian Academy of Sciences in 1984. At Reading [from 1968 to 1982], he increasingly turned to spectroscopy with tuneable lasers, generally with the emphasis on understanding the underlying physics rather than accumulating data. He had a highly original mind, which showed both in his choice of research topics and in his method of approach. He did not follow fashion; his instinct for an interesting problem was at odds with the modem policy of direct funding and the identification of "growth areas". His applications for research grants were often unsuccessful, despite his high international standing and integrity. He was never interested in building up a large research team, and had comparatively few research students, but his enthusiasm and commitment to the quality of his science attracted a succession of overseas visitors to his laboratory. Following my own year at the Clarendon, and some subsequent visits both to Oxford and to Reading, there was a continuing strong association between the Clarendon and Otago Physics that continues until today. George Series was the William Evans Visiting Professor to Otago University in 1972. He never lost his interest in the fundamentals of physics inspired by his first researches into the structure of the hydrogen atom; he wrote on the Rydberg constant, the physics of spontaneous emission, and on the fine-structure constant α = e 2 / hc . He donated a garden seat to St Edmund Hall (Oxford), of which he was a Fellow. On it he placed a plaque* in recognition of the ubiquitous nature of this constant; it almost had magical significance for him. He served physics in many ways outside research. He was for a number of years the Editor of the European Journal of Physics and was also Editor of the Journal of Physics B: Atomic and Molecular Physics , He was also on the Editorial Board of a number of journals. He was elected to Fellowship of a number of physics societies. The Editorial Board of these Memorial Essays dedicate them to George's memory, and to his wife Annette and his family.