Molecular Orbital Theory of the gaseous Bose-Einstein condensate: Natural Orbital analysis of strongly correlated ground and excited states of an atomic condensate in a double well
The possibility, envisaged in 1925 by Einstein following the suggestion of Bose, of a dilute gas of atoms being condensed into a single quantum state was experimentally achieved in 1995 following decades of research. An avalanche of experiment and theory has followed, leading to the awarding of the 2001 Nobel Prizes in Physics to three of the pioneering experimentalists. Theory, mostly couched in the language and formalism of condensed matter physics, has developed apace. What we point out here is that a condensate in a double well trap may be thought of exactly as a diatomic molecule with delocalized molecular orbitals (MOs) filled with Bosons, rather than electrons. As in quantum chemistry, configuration interaction must be included to supplement the MO picture if dissociation is to be correctly described. Such dissociation is called condensate fragmentation in the condensed matter theory literature. Natural orbitals and their occupation numbers provide a clear and succinct way of determining where the atoms are in highly correlated states as fragmentation occurs, and are particularly helpful in understanding what is actually happening when energy levels with macroscopic occupancy cross as a function of breaking the symmetry between the trap wells. It is seen that only a few particles are actually active in the level crossing. Recent experiments in super-conductive Josephson loops showing tunneling of macroscopic quantum states are easily included in this picture.
The possibility, envisaged in 1925 by Einstein following the suggestion of Bose, of a dilute gas of atoms being condensed into a single quantum state was experimentally achieved in 1995 following decades of research. An avalanche of experiment and theory has followed, leading to the awarding of the 2001 Nobel Prizes in Physics to three of the pioneering experimentalists. Theory, mostly couched in the language and formalism of condensed matter physics, has developed apace. What we point out here is that a condensate in a double well trap may be thought of exactly as a diatomic molecule with delocalized molecular orbitals (MOs) filled with Bosons, rather than electrons. As in quantum chemistry, configuration interaction must be included to supplement the MO picture if dissociation is to be correctly described. Such dissociation is called condensate fragmentation in the condensed matter theory literature. Natural orbitals and their occupation numbers provide a clear and succinct way of determining where the atoms are in highly correlated states as fragmentation occurs, and are particularly helpful in understanding what is actually happening when energy levels with macroscopic occupancy cross as a function of breaking the symmetry between the trap wells. It is seen that only a few particles are actually active in the level crossing. Recent experiments in super-conductive Josephson loops showing tunneling of macroscopic quantum states are easily included in this picture.
Classically identical particles become quantum mechanically indistinguishable. Satyendra Nath Bose taught us, in 1924, how to correctly count the distinct microstates for the indistinguishables, and for a gas of light quanta (later photons), whose number is not conserved , e.g. can vary with temperature, he gave a proper derivation of Planck's law of black body radiation. Einstein, in 1925, generalized the Bose statistics to a quantum gas of material particles whose number is now fixed , or conserved, e.g. 4 He, and thus opened a new direction in condensed matter physics: He showed that for low enough temperatures (∼1 Kelvin and below), a macroscopic number of the particles must accumulate in the lowest one-particle state. This degenerate gas with an extensively occupied single one-particle state is the Bose–Einstein condensate, now called BEC. (Fragmented BEC involving a multiplicity of internal states of non-scalar Bose atoms is, however, also realizable now.) Initially thought to be a pathology of an ideal non-interacting Bose system, the BEC turned out to be robust against interactions. Thus, the Bose–Einstein condensation is a quantum phase transition, but one with a difference — it is a purely quantum statistical effect, and requires no inter-particle interaction for its occurrence. Indeed, it happens in spite of it. The condensate fraction, however, diminishes with increasing interaction strength — to less than ten per cent for 4 He. The BEC turned out to underlie superfluidity, namely that the superfluid may flow through finest atomic capillaries without any viscosity. Interaction, however, seems essential to superfluidity. But, the precise connection between BEC and the superfluidity remains elusive. Thus, for example, we may have superfluidity in two-dimensions where there is no condensate! Seventy years later now, the BEC has come alive with the breakthrough in 1995 when near-ideal BEC was created in dilute alkali gases of 87 Rb and 23 Na atoms cooled in the gaseous state down to nanokelvins and localized in a trap. There are reasons why we ought to be mindful of the BEC — if only because here even the interaction between the particles is tunable at will — the sign as well as the strength of it. BEC has now become an ideal laboratory for basic and condensed matter experiments, and for high resolution applications. Properly viewed, it is indeed a new state of matter. This article is about the saga of BEC that really began with Einstein in 1925.
Linear response of simple (i.e., condensed) Bose-Einstein condensates is known to lead to the Bogoliubov--de Gennes equations. Here, we derive linear response for fragmented Bose-Einstein condensates, i.e., for the case where the many-body wave function is not a product of one, but of several single-particle states (orbitals). This gives one access to excitation spectra and response amplitudes of systems beyond the Gross-Pitaevskii description. Our approach is based on the number-conserving variational time-dependent mean-field theory [Alon, Streltsov, and Cederbaum, Phys. Lett. A 362, 453 (2007)], which describes the time evolution of best-mean-field states. Correspondingly, we call our linear-response theory for fragmented states LR-BMF. In the derivation it follows naturally that excitations are orthogonal to the ground-state orbitals. As applications excitation spectra of Bose-Einstein condensates in double-well potentials are calculated. Both symmetric and asymmetric double wells are studied for several interaction strengths and barrier heights. The cases of condensed and twofold fragmented ground states are compared. Interestingly, even in such situations where the response frequencies of the two cases are computed to be close to each other, which is the situation for the excitations well below the barrier, striking differences in the density response in momentum space are found. For excitations with an energy of the order of the barrier height, both the energies and the density response of condensed and fragmented systems are very different. In fragmented systems there is a class of ``swapped'' excitations where an atom is transferred to the neighboring well. The mechanism of its origin is discussed. In asymmetric wells, the response of a fragmented system is purely local (i.e., finite in either one or the other well) with different frequencies for the left and right fragments. This finding is in stark contrast to that for condensed systems.
In 1925 Einstein predicted that at low temperatures particles in a gas could all reside in the same quantum state. This gaseous state, a Bose–Einstein condensate, was produced in the laboratory for the first time in 1995 and investigating such condensates has become one of the most active areas in contemporary physics. The study of Bose–Einstein condensates in dilute gases encompasses a number of different subfields of physics, including atomic, condensed matter, and nuclear physics. The authors of this graduate-level textbook explain this exciting new subject in terms of basic physical principles, without assuming detailed knowledge of any of these subfields. Chapters cover the statistical physics of trapped gases, atomic properties, cooling and trapping atoms, interatomic interactions, structure of trapped condensates, collective modes, rotating condensates, superfluidity, interference phenomena, and trapped Fermi gases. Problem sets are also included in each chapter.
Bose–Einstein condensates of particles behave in many ways like coherent radiation fields, and the realization of Bose–Einstein condensation in dilute gases has opened up the experimental study of interactions between coherent matter waves. In addition, the existence of these dilute trapped quantum gases has prompted a re-examination of a number of theoretical issues. In Sec. 13.1 we discuss Josephson tunnelling of a condensate between two wells and the role of fluctuations in particle number and phase. The number and phase variables play a key role in the description of the classic interference experiment, in which two clouds of atoms are allowed to expand and overlap (Sec. 13.2). Rather surprisingly, an interference pattern is produced even though initially the two clouds are completely isolated. Density fluctuations in a Bose gas are studied in Sec. 13.3, where we relate atomic clock shifts to the two-particle correlation function. The ability to manipulate gaseous Bose–Einstein condensates by lasers has made possible the study of coherent matter wave optics and in Sec. 13.4 we describe applications of these techniques to observe solitons, Bragg scattering, and non-linear mixing of matter waves. How to characterize Bose–Einstein condensation in terms of the density matrix is the subject of Sec. 13.5, where we also consider fragmented condensates.
Quantum mechanics revolutionized the previous century, not only in technology with lasers and semiconductors but also our fundamental view of the world with Bell's inequality and entanglement. Quantum tunneling was the first experimental verification of quantum mechanics, by solving the mystery of radioactive decay, that a particle can escape the nucleus without sufficient energy to overcome the classical energy barrier. In this century, many-body quantum mechanics is bringing about a second revolution, with the possibility of quantum simulators, quantum computers, and a deeper understanding the nature. However, in order to fully harness the power of these systems, a detailed understanding of many-body effects is required, such as fluctuations, correlations, and entanglement. In this thesis, we seek to understand these observables in the context of macroscopic quantum tunneling. We quantify the macroscopic quantum tunneling dynamics, showing how interactions alter tunneling and quantum phase transitions modify non-equilibrium dynamics, providing a road maps of future experiments. The first experimental realization of mean-field interactions producing non-exponential decay of a tunneling Bose-Einstein condensate has been achieved. We develop an effective semi-classical model which accounts for the repulsive atom-atom interactions via an additional mean-field potential. This captures the 3D quantum tunneling via classical oscillations in an effective 1D trap and tunneling through a barrier with time-dependent height due to mean-field interactions. Mean-field treatments work well for Bose-Einstein condensates with negligible many-body effects, such as fragmentation, depletion, and fluctuations away from the mean. We show how a Bose-Einstein condensate with non-negligible fragmentation and depletion can be described with a renormalized mean-field. This suggest mean-field models are more widely applicable than previously thought, and that many-body physics may be hiding in such experiments and systems. Next, we explicitly look at the dynamics of many-body tunneling from a meta-stable trap, described by the Bose-Hubbard Hamiltonian in the superfluid quantum phase. The many-body physics are simulated using matrix product state methods, which allow exploration of lowly-entangled dynamics via data compression methods, and can calculate a wide range of quantum observables, like number fluctuations, correlations, and entanglement entropy. We compare many-body and mean-field dynamics, explicitly showing many-body tunneling times converge to mean-field tunneling times with increasing number of atoms in the system. We find rich dynamics with different time scales for the escape time, fluctuations, and quantum entropy in the system. With a firm grasp on the superfluid dynamics in the Bose-Hubbard Hamiltonian, we turn our attention to the superfluid to Mott insulating quantum phase transition, and understanding how the initial quantum phase alters macroscopic quantum tunneling. We examine this for both the double-well and quantum escape systems. We find that the dynamics of tunneling are strongly dependent on the quantum phase of the ground state. Qualitatively, the superfluid regime has wave-like dynamics, while the Mott regime has particle-like dynamics, and near the critical point there is a mixture of the two. The dynamics of many-body observables, fluctuations and correlations, have distinct signatures of their quantum phases, fingerprints pointing to the quantum phase transition. Finally, we provide a road map for future macroscopic quantum tunneling experiments, in particular for two accessible trap configurations in both semi-classical and strongly interacting regimes. Using a semi-classical method, we study the gross features of macroscopic quantum tunneling in symmetric offset Gaussian barriers, and a linearly ramped Gaussian barrier. Because the tunneling probability depends exponentially on the barrier area, large, heavy, or many interacting atoms can have tunneling rates too slow to be experimentally viable. We show how to overcome this time-scale issue, quantifying the time and length scales regarding macroscopic quantum tunneling of Bose-Einstein condensates of rubidium, lithium, and sodium, deriving scaling laws for the various trap parameters; the experimental ``knobs''. Scaling laws clearly demonstrate when oscillations in the well or tunneling probabilities dominate. We find the emergence of mean-field islands inside the traps, resulting in multiple oscillations. In the strongly interacting regime, preliminary evidence is provided for pulsed and continuous-wave regimes of a correlation-based atom laser utilizing macroscopic quantum tunneling in both barrier and interaction control.
The two-site version of the Bose-Hubbard model can be used as a simplified model of N bosons confined to two quantum wells. We study the behavior of low-temperature Bose-Einstein condensates as a function of the strength of the repulsive interactions between the bosons and of the size of the quantum-mechanical tunneling between the quantum wells. The ground-state of weakly interacting bosons tends to be one in which almost all particles are in the same quantum-mechanical state (‘Bose-Einstein Condensate’, or ‘BEC’). It is found that even very small amounts of interwell tunneling lead to a BEC, but that zero tunneling leads to two separate BECs, one in each well (‘fragmentation’). We study systematically the transition between a single BEC comprised of bosons in both wells, and a fragmented condensate consisting of two BECs, one for each well. Our analysis will use matrix computational methods to solve the Schrödinger equation of the two-well boson system, and obtain the energies and wavefunctions as eigenvalues and eigenvectors of the Hamiltonian matrix. We will compare the results obtained with previous analyses, and against analytical approximations developed for the limiting case of a large number of bosons (large N).