Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Macroscopic quantum tunneling and quantum many-body dynamics in Bose-Einstein condensates

Diego A. Alcala

Published Dec 31, 2019• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

Quantum mechanics revolutionized the previous century, not only in technology with lasers and semiconductors but also our fundamental view of the world with Bell's inequality and entanglement. Quantum tunneling was the first experimental verification of quantum mechanics, by solving the mystery of radioactive decay, that a particle can escape the nucleus without sufficient energy to overcome the classical energy barrier. In this century, many-body quantum mechanics is bringing about a second revolution, with the possibility of quantum simulators, quantum computers, and a deeper understanding the nature. However, in order to fully harness the power of these systems, a detailed understanding of many-body effects is required, such as fluctuations, correlations, and entanglement. In this thesis, we seek to understand these observables in the context of macroscopic quantum tunneling. We quantify the macroscopic quantum tunneling dynamics, showing how interactions alter tunneling and quantum phase transitions modify non-equilibrium dynamics, providing a road maps of future experiments. The first experimental realization of mean-field interactions producing non-exponential decay of a tunneling Bose-Einstein condensate has been achieved. We develop an effective semi-classical model which accounts for the repulsive atom-atom interactions via an additional mean-field potential. This captures the 3D quantum tunneling via classical oscillations in an effective 1D trap and tunneling through a barrier with time-dependent height due to mean-field interactions. Mean-field treatments work well for Bose-Einstein condensates with negligible many-body effects, such as fragmentation, depletion, and fluctuations away from the mean. We show how a Bose-Einstein condensate with non-negligible fragmentation and depletion can be described with a renormalized mean-field. This suggest mean-field models are more widely applicable than previously thought, and that many-body physics may be hiding in such experiments and systems. Next, we explicitly look at the dynamics of many-body tunneling from a meta-stable trap, described by the Bose-Hubbard Hamiltonian in the superfluid quantum phase. The many-body physics are simulated using matrix product state methods, which allow exploration of lowly-entangled dynamics via data compression methods, and can calculate a wide range of quantum observables, like number fluctuations, correlations, and entanglement entropy. We compare many-body and mean-field dynamics, explicitly showing many-body tunneling times converge to mean-field tunneling times with increasing number of atoms in the system. We find rich dynamics with different time scales for the escape time, fluctuations, and quantum entropy in the system. With a firm grasp on the superfluid dynamics in the Bose-Hubbard Hamiltonian, we turn our attention to the superfluid to Mott insulating quantum phase transition, and understanding how the initial quantum phase alters macroscopic quantum tunneling. We examine this for both the double-well and quantum escape systems. We find that the dynamics of tunneling are strongly dependent on the quantum phase of the ground state. Qualitatively, the superfluid regime has wave-like dynamics, while the Mott regime has particle-like dynamics, and near the critical point there is a mixture of the two. The dynamics of many-body observables, fluctuations and correlations, have distinct signatures of their quantum phases, fingerprints pointing to the quantum phase transition. Finally, we provide a road map for future macroscopic quantum tunneling experiments, in particular for two accessible trap configurations in both semi-classical and strongly interacting regimes. Using a semi-classical method, we study the gross features of macroscopic quantum tunneling in symmetric offset Gaussian barriers, and a linearly ramped Gaussian barrier. Because the tunneling probability depends exponentially on the barrier area, large, heavy, or many interacting atoms can have tunneling rates too slow to be experimentally viable. We show how to overcome this time-scale issue, quantifying the time and length scales regarding macroscopic quantum tunneling of Bose-Einstein condensates of rubidium, lithium, and sodium, deriving scaling laws for the various trap parameters; the experimental ``knobs''. Scaling laws clearly demonstrate when oscillations in the well or tunneling probabilities dominate. We find the emergence of mean-field islands inside the traps, resulting in multiple oscillations. In the strongly interacting regime, preliminary evidence is provided for pulsed and continuous-wave regimes of a correlation-based atom laser utilizing macroscopic quantum tunneling in both barrier and interaction control.

Related papers

Many-body quantum tunneling of ultracold bosonic gases : quantum phase transitions, bosonic Josephson junctions, and Mott switch atomtronics

Marie A. McLain

Ultracold Bose gases as precise quantum simulators have emerged amongst the leaders in the current race -- a second quantum revolution -- toward the promise of unfathomable sensitivity, scope, and speed of a new era of technology. The only path leading to these advancements is through many-body descriptions, especially in regimes where interatomic interactions render many approximations incompatible with the physics. The research in this dissertation unlocks a piece of this mystery through investigations of many-body quantum tunneling of ultracold bosons in optical lattices. A key mechanism to characterizing the dynamics, matrix product state simulations equip the many-body toolbox with efficient optimization of large Hilbert spaces together with correlation and entropy measures that help clarify when semiclassical or mean-field approximations fail. In this thesis we obtain the following results. Macroscopic quantum tunneling escape of a Bose-Einstein condensate -- comprised of tens of thousands of 87Rb atoms -- from a single well, as portrayed through both experiment and theory, highlights non-exponential decay in the number of atoms trapped behind the barrier. Additionally, explicit symmetry breaking of a biperiodic optical lattice ring trap to a uniform one illustrates a critical symmetry-breaking strength at which the system transitions from a state of remembering to a state of forgetting its initial symmetry state; this symmetry memory indicates a new form of quantum dynamics that requires the quantum advantage for scaling up particle number and lattice sites. Extensive characterization of dynamical regimes in a bosonic Josephson junction -- underlaid by an optical lattice as described by the Bose-Hubbard model -- reveal substantial deviation of many body dynamics from the mean field or semiclassical predictions underlying the usual operating regime of Josephson junctions. Initial state population and phase yield insight into dynamic tunneling regimes of a quasi one-dimensional double well potential, through the Z2 spontaneous symmetry-breaking phase transition from Josephson oscillations to macroscopic self-trapping. We demonstrate that with increasing repulsive interaction strength, the U(1) superfluid-Mott insulator phase transition induces localized dynamics in the number density, such as particle-hole and soliton formation. Moreover, g^(2) correlations unveil a new dynamic regime -- the Fock flashlight. The new field of atomtronics -- or atomic circuits -- has emerged with many studies of weakly-interacting condensates. In contrast, and building on our work on many-body effects in the double wells underlying Josephson junctions, we present a proof-of-principle of a Mott-insulating atomtronic switch that requires strongly-interacting bosons. Through transient analysis, we reveal that hole conductance can be modulated via tuning interaction strength through a critical value, thus propelling the state to the next ``wedding cake'' layer of the Mott insulating structure. This critical interaction strength is a result of the confining potential and corresponds with critical phenomena in transport properties as measured via transmission and fidelity. g^(2) two-point correlators provide an experimentally viable means of identifying superfluid fragments as a means of identifying switching state. Finally, the research presented in this dissertation provides a foundation for many-body quantum tunneling that can be further expanded to the emerging field of quantum atomtronics. The highly precise architectures needed for such technologies are conducive to understanding many-body phenomena for the creation of quantum-engineered devices, from atomic clocks and simulation techniques to biomedical magnetic sensors and secure communications.

•Jan 1, 2018•0 citations

Quantum Phases and Correlations Drive the Dynamics of Macroscopic Quantum Tunneling Escape in Quantum Simulators

Diego A. Alcala, Marie A. McLain, Lincoln D. Carr

Quantum tunneling remains unexplored in many regimes of many-body quantum physics, including the effect of quantum phase transitions on tunneling dynamics. In general, the quantum phase is a statement about the ground state and has no relation to far-from-equilibrium dynamics. Although tunneling is a highly dynamical process involving many excited states, we find that the quantum phase of the Bose-Hubbard model determines phase-dependent tunneling outcomes for the quantum tunneling escape, or quasi-bound problem. Superfluid and Mott insulator correlations lead to a new quantum tunneling rate, the quantum fluctuation rate. This rate shows surprising and highly dynamical features, such as oscillatory interference between trapped and escaped atoms and a completely different macroscopic quantum tunneling behavior for superfluid and Mott insulator phases. In the superfluid phase we find that escape dynamics are wave-like and coherent, leading to interference patterns in the density with a rapid decay process which is non-exponential. Quantum entropy production peaks when about half the atoms have escaped. In the Mott phase, despite stronger repulsive interactions, tunneling is significantly slowed by the presence of a Mott gap, creating an effective extra barrier to overcome. Only one atom can tunnel at a time, yet the decay process is nearly linear, completely defying the single-particle exponential model. Moreover, quantum entropy peaks when only about one quarter of the atoms have escaped. These and many other such effects go beyond the usual notions of single-particle quantum tunneling, quantum statistical effects on tunneling, and well-known semi-classical approaches from WKB to instanton theory. These results thus open up a new regime of exploration of far-from-equilibrium dynamics for quantum simulators and quantum dynamics.

arXiv:2004.07372•Apr 15, 2020•1 citation

Macroscopic Quantum Tunneling of Solitons in Bose-Einstein Condensates

Glick, J. A., Lincoln D. Carr

We study the quantum tunneling dynamics of many-body entangled solitons composed of ultracold bosonic gases in 1D optical lattices. A bright soliton, confined by a potential barrier, is allowed to tunnel out of confinement by reducing the barrier width and for varying strengths of attractive interactions. Simulation of the Bose Hubbard Hamiltonian is performed with time-evolving block decimation. We find the characteristic $1/e$ time for the escape of the soliton, substantially different from the mean field prediction, and address how many-body effects like quantum fluctuations, entanglement, and nonlocal correlations affect macroscopic quantum tunneling; number fluctuations and second order correlations are suggested as experimental signatures. We find that while the escape time scales exponentially in the interactions, the time at which both the von Neumann entanglement entropy and the slope of number fluctuations is maximized scale only linearly.

arXiv:1105.5164•May 25, 2011•17 citations

Quantum many-body tunneling of Bose-Einstein condensates

Glick, Joseph, Lincoln D. Carr

Consider the tunneling of a many-body wavefunction through a potential barrier. Specifically we examine quantum many-body tunneling of ultracold bosons in one dimensional optical lattice potentials. Such systems are described by the Bose-Hubbard model, and serve as an ideal testbed for the observation of quantum phenomena on macroscopic length scales. Bright solitons, self-sustaining nonlinear waves, are confined by a thin potential barrier. By decreasing the size of the barrier or by tuning the nonlinearity, we find that the bound states can be transformed into quasi-bound ones as the soliton tunnels collectively out of confinement. The lowly entangled 1D many-body problem can be numerically solved via time-evolving block decimation: a time-adaptive density matrix renormalization group routine. As a sanity check the results can be compared to mean-field theory predictions obtained from numerical analysis of the Nonlinear Schrodinger equation. The goal behind this effort is to explore the previously intractable physics in regimes where the mean-field theory fails, and to provide a stringent test on the validity of quantum mechanics for complex entangled systems.

•Jan 1, 2007•0 citations

Quantum tunneling dynamics of an interacting Bose-Einstein condensate through a Gaussian barrier

Manju Perumbil, Kyle S. Hardman, M. A. Sooriyabandara +5 more

The transmission of an interacting Bose-Einstein condensate incident on a repulsive Gaussian barrier is investigated through numerical simulation. The dynamics associated with interatomic interactions are studied across a broad parameter range not previously explored. Effective one-dimensional Gross-Pitaevskii equation (GPE) simulations are compared to classical Boltzmann-Vlasov equation (BVE) simulations in order to isolate purely coherent matter-wave effects. Quantum tunneling is then defined as the portion of the GPE transmission not described by the classical BVE. An exponential dependence of transmission on barrier height is observed in the classical simulation, suggesting that observing such an exponential dependence is not a sufficient condition for quantum tunneling. Furthermore, the transmission is found to be predominately described by classical effects, although interatomic interactions are shown to modify the magnitude of the quantum tunneling. Interactions are also seen to affect the amount of classical transmission, producing transmission in regions where the noninteracting equivalent has none. This theoretical investigation clarifies the contribution quantum tunneling makes to overall transmission in many-particle interacting systems, potentially informing future tunneling experiments with ultracold atoms.

arXiv:1808.07196•Physical Review A•Nov 26, 2018•22 citations

Macroscopic quantum escape of Bose-Einstein condensates: Analysis of experimentally realizable quasi-one-dimensional traps

Diego A. Alcala, Gregor Urban, Matthias Weidemüller +1 more

The variational JWKB method is used to determine experimentally accessible macroscopic quantum tunneling regimes of quasibound Bose-Einstein condensates in two quasi-one-dimensional trap configurations. The potentials can be created by magnetic and optical traps: a symmetric trap from two offset Gaussian barriers and a tilt trap from a linear gradient and Gaussian barrier. Scaling laws in barrier parameters, ranging from inverse polynomial to square root times exponential, are calculated and used to elucidate different dynamical regimes, such as when classical oscillations dominate tunneling rates in the symmetric trap. The symmetric trap is found to be versatile, with tunneling times at and below 1 s, able to hold ${10}^{3}--{10}^{4}$ atoms, and realizable for atoms ranging from rubidium to lithium, with unadjusted scattering lengths. The tilt trap produces subsecond tunneling times, is able to hold a few hundred atoms of lighter elements such as lithium, and requires the use of Feshbach resonance to reduce scattering lengths. To explore a large parameter space, an extended Gaussian variational ansatz is used, which can approximate large traps with Thomas-Fermi profiles. Nonlinear interactions in the Gross-Pitaevskii equation are shown to produce additional effective mean-field barriers, affecting scaling laws.

arXiv:1805.04970•Physical Review A•Aug 15, 2018•9 citations
Quantum mechanics revolutionized the previous century, not only in technology with lasers and semiconductors but also our fundamental view of the world with Bell's inequality and entanglement. Quantum tunneling was the first experimental verification of quantum mechanics, by solving the mystery of radioactive decay, that a particle can escape the nucleus without sufficient energy to overcome the classical energy barrier. In this century, many-body quantum mechanics is bringing about a second revolution, with the possibility of quantum simulators, quantum computers, and a deeper understanding the nature. However, in order to fully harness the power of these systems, a detailed understanding of many-body effects is required, such as fluctuations, correlations, and entanglement. In this thesis, we seek to understand these observables in the context of macroscopic quantum tunneling. We quantify the macroscopic quantum tunneling dynamics, showing how interactions alter tunneling and quantum phase transitions modify non-equilibrium dynamics, providing a road maps of future experiments. The first experimental realization of mean-field interactions producing non-exponential decay of a tunneling Bose-Einstein condensate has been achieved. We develop an effective semi-classical model which accounts for the repulsive atom-atom interactions via an additional mean-field potential. This captures the 3D quantum tunneling via classical oscillations in an effective 1D trap and tunneling through a barrier with time-dependent height due to mean-field interactions. Mean-field treatments work well for Bose-Einstein condensates with negligible many-body effects, such as fragmentation, depletion, and fluctuations away from the mean. We show how a Bose-Einstein condensate with non-negligible fragmentation and depletion can be described with a renormalized mean-field. This suggest mean-field models are more widely applicable than previously thought, and that many-body physics may be hiding in such experiments and systems. Next, we explicitly look at the dynamics of many-body tunneling from a meta-stable trap, described by the Bose-Hubbard Hamiltonian in the superfluid quantum phase. The many-body physics are simulated using matrix product state methods, which allow exploration of lowly-entangled dynamics via data compression methods, and can calculate a wide range of quantum observables, like number fluctuations, correlations, and entanglement entropy. We compare many-body and mean-field dynamics, explicitly showing many-body tunneling times converge to mean-field tunneling times with increasing number of atoms in the system. We find rich dynamics with different time scales for the escape time, fluctuations, and quantum entropy in the system. With a firm grasp on the superfluid dynamics in the Bose-Hubbard Hamiltonian, we turn our attention to the superfluid to Mott insulating quantum phase transition, and understanding how the initial quantum phase alters macroscopic quantum tunneling. We examine this for both the double-well and quantum escape systems. We find that the dynamics of tunneling are strongly dependent on the quantum phase of the ground state. Qualitatively, the superfluid regime has wave-like dynamics, while the Mott regime has particle-like dynamics, and near the critical point there is a mixture of the two. The dynamics of many-body observables, fluctuations and correlations, have distinct signatures of their quantum phases, fingerprints pointing to the quantum phase transition. Finally, we provide a road map for future macroscopic quantum tunneling experiments, in particular for two accessible trap configurations in both semi-classical and strongly interacting regimes. Using a semi-classical method, we study the gross features of macroscopic quantum tunneling in symmetric offset Gaussian barriers, and a linearly ramped Gaussian barrier. Because the tunneling probability depends exponentially on the barrier area, large, heavy, or many interacting atoms can have tunneling rates too slow to be experimentally viable. We show how to overcome this time-scale issue, quantifying the time and length scales regarding macroscopic quantum tunneling of Bose-Einstein condensates of rubidium, lithium, and sodium, deriving scaling laws for the various trap parameters; the experimental ``knobs''. Scaling laws clearly demonstrate when oscillations in the well or tunneling probabilities dominate. We find the emergence of mean-field islands inside the traps, resulting in multiple oscillations. In the strongly interacting regime, preliminary evidence is provided for pulsed and continuous-wave regimes of a correlation-based atom laser utilizing macroscopic quantum tunneling in both barrier and interaction control.
Ultracold Bose gases as precise quantum simulators have emerged amongst the leaders in the current race -- a second quantum revolution -- toward the promise of unfathomable sensitivity, scope, and speed of a new era of technology. The only path leading to these advancements is through many-body descriptions, especially in regimes where interatomic interactions render many approximations incompatible with the physics. The research in this dissertation unlocks a piece of this mystery through investigations of many-body quantum tunneling of ultracold bosons in optical lattices. A key mechanism to characterizing the dynamics, matrix product state simulations equip the many-body toolbox with efficient optimization of large Hilbert spaces together with correlation and entropy measures that help clarify when semiclassical or mean-field approximations fail. In this thesis we obtain the following results. Macroscopic quantum tunneling escape of a Bose-Einstein condensate -- comprised of tens of thousands of 87Rb atoms -- from a single well, as portrayed through both experiment and theory, highlights non-exponential decay in the number of atoms trapped behind the barrier. Additionally, explicit symmetry breaking of a biperiodic optical lattice ring trap to a uniform one illustrates a critical symmetry-breaking strength at which the system transitions from a state of remembering to a state of forgetting its initial symmetry state; this symmetry memory indicates a new form of quantum dynamics that requires the quantum advantage for scaling up particle number and lattice sites. Extensive characterization of dynamical regimes in a bosonic Josephson junction -- underlaid by an optical lattice as described by the Bose-Hubbard model -- reveal substantial deviation of many body dynamics from the mean field or semiclassical predictions underlying the usual operating regime of Josephson junctions. Initial state population and phase yield insight into dynamic tunneling regimes of a quasi one-dimensional double well potential, through the Z2 spontaneous symmetry-breaking phase transition from Josephson oscillations to macroscopic self-trapping. We demonstrate that with increasing repulsive interaction strength, the U(1) superfluid-Mott insulator phase transition induces localized dynamics in the number density, such as particle-hole and soliton formation. Moreover, g^(2) correlations unveil a new dynamic regime -- the Fock flashlight. The new field of atomtronics -- or atomic circuits -- has emerged with many studies of weakly-interacting condensates. In contrast, and building on our work on many-body effects in the double wells underlying Josephson junctions, we present a proof-of-principle of a Mott-insulating atomtronic switch that requires strongly-interacting bosons. Through transient analysis, we reveal that hole conductance can be modulated via tuning interaction strength through a critical value, thus propelling the state to the next ``wedding cake'' layer of the Mott insulating structure. This critical interaction strength is a result of the confining potential and corresponds with critical phenomena in transport properties as measured via transmission and fidelity. g^(2) two-point correlators provide an experimentally viable means of identifying superfluid fragments as a means of identifying switching state. Finally, the research presented in this dissertation provides a foundation for many-body quantum tunneling that can be further expanded to the emerging field of quantum atomtronics. The highly precise architectures needed for such technologies are conducive to understanding many-body phenomena for the creation of quantum-engineered devices, from atomic clocks and simulation techniques to biomedical magnetic sensors and secure communications.
Quantum tunneling remains unexplored in many regimes of many-body quantum physics, including the effect of quantum phase transitions on tunneling dynamics. In general, the quantum phase is a statement about the ground state and has no relation to far-from-equilibrium dynamics. Although tunneling is a highly dynamical process involving many excited states, we find that the quantum phase of the Bose-Hubbard model determines phase-dependent tunneling outcomes for the quantum tunneling escape, or quasi-bound problem. Superfluid and Mott insulator correlations lead to a new quantum tunneling rate, the quantum fluctuation rate. This rate shows surprising and highly dynamical features, such as oscillatory interference between trapped and escaped atoms and a completely different macroscopic quantum tunneling behavior for superfluid and Mott insulator phases. In the superfluid phase we find that escape dynamics are wave-like and coherent, leading to interference patterns in the density with a rapid decay process which is non-exponential. Quantum entropy production peaks when about half the atoms have escaped. In the Mott phase, despite stronger repulsive interactions, tunneling is significantly slowed by the presence of a Mott gap, creating an effective extra barrier to overcome. Only one atom can tunnel at a time, yet the decay process is nearly linear, completely defying the single-particle exponential model. Moreover, quantum entropy peaks when only about one quarter of the atoms have escaped. These and many other such effects go beyond the usual notions of single-particle quantum tunneling, quantum statistical effects on tunneling, and well-known semi-classical approaches from WKB to instanton theory. These results thus open up a new regime of exploration of far-from-equilibrium dynamics for quantum simulators and quantum dynamics.
We study the quantum tunneling dynamics of many-body entangled solitons composed of ultracold bosonic gases in 1D optical lattices. A bright soliton, confined by a potential barrier, is allowed to tunnel out of confinement by reducing the barrier width and for varying strengths of attractive interactions. Simulation of the Bose Hubbard Hamiltonian is performed with time-evolving block decimation. We find the characteristic 1/e1/e1/e time for the escape of the soliton, substantially different from the mean field prediction, and address how many-body effects like quantum fluctuations, entanglement, and nonlocal correlations affect macroscopic quantum tunneling; number fluctuations and second order correlations are suggested as experimental signatures. We find that while the escape time scales exponentially in the interactions, the time at which both the von Neumann entanglement entropy and the slope of number fluctuations is maximized scale only linearly.
Consider the tunneling of a many-body wavefunction through a potential barrier. Specifically we examine quantum many-body tunneling of ultracold bosons in one dimensional optical lattice potentials. Such systems are described by the Bose-Hubbard model, and serve as an ideal testbed for the observation of quantum phenomena on macroscopic length scales. Bright solitons, self-sustaining nonlinear waves, are confined by a thin potential barrier. By decreasing the size of the barrier or by tuning the nonlinearity, we find that the bound states can be transformed into quasi-bound ones as the soliton tunnels collectively out of confinement. The lowly entangled 1D many-body problem can be numerically solved via time-evolving block decimation: a time-adaptive density matrix renormalization group routine. As a sanity check the results can be compared to mean-field theory predictions obtained from numerical analysis of the Nonlinear Schrodinger equation. The goal behind this effort is to explore the previously intractable physics in regimes where the mean-field theory fails, and to provide a stringent test on the validity of quantum mechanics for complex entangled systems.
The transmission of an interacting Bose-Einstein condensate incident on a repulsive Gaussian barrier is investigated through numerical simulation. The dynamics associated with interatomic interactions are studied across a broad parameter range not previously explored. Effective one-dimensional Gross-Pitaevskii equation (GPE) simulations are compared to classical Boltzmann-Vlasov equation (BVE) simulations in order to isolate purely coherent matter-wave effects. Quantum tunneling is then defined as the portion of the GPE transmission not described by the classical BVE. An exponential dependence of transmission on barrier height is observed in the classical simulation, suggesting that observing such an exponential dependence is not a sufficient condition for quantum tunneling. Furthermore, the transmission is found to be predominately described by classical effects, although interatomic interactions are shown to modify the magnitude of the quantum tunneling. Interactions are also seen to affect the amount of classical transmission, producing transmission in regions where the noninteracting equivalent has none. This theoretical investigation clarifies the contribution quantum tunneling makes to overall transmission in many-particle interacting systems, potentially informing future tunneling experiments with ultracold atoms.
The variational JWKB method is used to determine experimentally accessible macroscopic quantum tunneling regimes of quasibound Bose-Einstein condensates in two quasi-one-dimensional trap configurations. The potentials can be created by magnetic and optical traps: a symmetric trap from two offset Gaussian barriers and a tilt trap from a linear gradient and Gaussian barrier. Scaling laws in barrier parameters, ranging from inverse polynomial to square root times exponential, are calculated and used to elucidate different dynamical regimes, such as when classical oscillations dominate tunneling rates in the symmetric trap. The symmetric trap is found to be versatile, with tunneling times at and below 1 s, able to hold 103−−104{10}^{3}--{10}^{4}103−−104 atoms, and realizable for atoms ranging from rubidium to lithium, with unadjusted scattering lengths. The tilt trap produces subsecond tunneling times, is able to hold a few hundred atoms of lighter elements such as lithium, and requires the use of Feshbach resonance to reduce scattering lengths. To explore a large parameter space, an extended Gaussian variational ansatz is used, which can approximate large traps with Thomas-Fermi profiles. Nonlinear interactions in the Gross-Pitaevskii equation are shown to produce additional effective mean-field barriers, affecting scaling laws.