Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:cond-mat/0102117

Reply to Comment on 'A new method to calculate the spin-glass order parameter of the two-dimensional $\pm J$ Ising model'

Hidetsugu Kitatani, A. Sinada

Published Feb 7, 2001• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In response to the comment made by Dr. Shirakura {\it et al} (cond-mat/0011235), we explain that their scaling forms of the order parameter distribution are inadequate. We then present an appropriate scaling form of the order parameter distribution, which gives a good scaling plot of the order parameter distribution itself and also gives consistent results with our pevious results[1].

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.cond-mat/0102117

Related papers

Comment on 'A new method to calculate the spin-glass order parameter of the two-dimensional $\pm J$ Ising model'

Takayuki Shirakura, Fumitaka Matsubara, Michinori Shiomi

Contrary to the suggestion of Kitatani and Sinada (2000 J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. {\bf 33} 3545-3553), the scaling analysis of the order parameter distributions suggests the existence of a finite-temperature spin-glass phase transition $T_c\ne 0$, even if the corrections to scaling are taken into account.

arXiv:cond-mat/0011235•Nov 14, 2000•2 citations

A new method to calculate the spin-glass order parameter of the two-dimensional ±JIsing model

Hidetsugu Kitatani, Akira Sinada

A new method to numerically calculate the n th moment of the spin overlap of the two-dimensional ± J Ising model is developed using the identity derived by one of the authors (HK) several years ago. By using the method, the n th moment of the spin overlap can be calculated as a simple average of the n th moment of the total spins with a modified bond probability distribution. The values of the Binder parameter etc have been extensively calculated with the linear size, L , up to L = 23. The accuracy of the calculations in the present method is similar to that in the conventional transfer matrix method with about 10 5 bond samples. The simple scaling plots of the Binder parameter and the spin-glass susceptibility indicate the existence of a finite-temperature spin-glass phase transition. We find, however, that the estimation of T c is strongly affected by the corrections to scaling within the present data ( L ⩽ 23). Thus, there still remains the possibility that T c = 0, contrary to the recent results which suggest the existence of a finite-temperature spin-glass phase transition.

arXiv:cond-mat/9908370•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•May 5, 2000•9 citations

Reply to Comment on "Universal Fluctuations in Correlated Systems", by B. Zheng and S. Trimper, cond-mat/0109003

S. T. Bramwell, Kim Christensen, Jean-Yves Fortin +7 more

We reply to the comment on our published paper `` Universal Fluctuations in Correlated Systems'',Phys. Rev. Lett. Vol; 84, p3744 (2000), by B. Zheng and S. Trimper, cond-mat/0109003. We argue that their results confirm our conjecture, that the probability distribution for order parameter fluctuations in the 2D and 3D Ising models at a temperature $T^{\ast}(L)$ slightly below $T_C$ for the infinite, system approximates the universal functional form of the 2D-XY model in its low temperature phase. We discuss the relevance of the temperature interval $T_C-T^{\ast}$, considered to be large by Zheng and Trimper and explain why the observed phenomena is a critical phenomena.

arXiv:cond-mat/0109107•Sep 6, 2001•0 citations

Rejoinder to the Response to ‘Comment on a recent conjectured solution of the three-dimensional Ising model’

Fa Yueh Wu, Barry M. McCoy, Michael Ellis Fisher +1 more

We add here a few sentences concerning the author's Response 1 to our Comment 2 criticizing his original claims regarding his conjectured solution of the three-dimensional Ising model 3. First, we ...

arXiv:0812.2837•The Philosophical Magazine A Journal of Theoretical Experimental and Applied Physics•Sep 11, 2008•15 citations

Reply to Skorik's Comment

Paul Fendley, Ludwig, A. W. W., Hubert Saleur

In a series of papers we combined the Bethe ansatz with a kinetic (Boltzmann) equation in order to compute exactly transport properties in a Luttinger liquid with an impurity. In a recent comment [cond-mat/9708163], Skorik claimed that while our results were correct in linear response, there was a ``serious flaw'' in our calculation at finite voltage. We explain here why Skorik's arguments are inappropriate, and that there is no flaw in our work [cond-mat/9408068; cond-mat/9505031; cond-mat/9503172].

arXiv:cond-mat/9710205•Oct 20, 1997•1 citation

Novel order parameter to describe the critical behavior of Ising spin glass models

FEDERICO J. ROMÁ, F. Nieto, Antonio Jose Ramirez-Pastor +1 more

arXiv:cond-mat/0506767•Physica A Statistical Mechanics and its Applications•Sep 20, 2005•7 citations
Reply to Comment on 'A new method to calculate the spin-glass order parameter of the two-dimensional ±J\pm J±J Ising model'
In response to the comment made by Dr. Shirakura {\it et al} (cond-mat/0011235), we explain that their scaling forms of the order parameter distribution are inadequate. We then present an appropriate scaling form of the order parameter distribution, which gives a good scaling plot of the order parameter distribution itself and also gives consistent results with our pevious results[1].
Comment on 'A new method to calculate the spin-glass order parameter of the two-dimensional ±J\pm J±J Ising model'
Contrary to the suggestion of Kitatani and Sinada (2000 J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. {\bf 33} 3545-3553), the scaling analysis of the order parameter distributions suggests the existence of a finite-temperature spin-glass phase transition Tc≠0T_c\ne 0Tc​=0, even if the corrections to scaling are taken into account.
A new method to numerically calculate the n th moment of the spin overlap of the two-dimensional ± J Ising model is developed using the identity derived by one of the authors (HK) several years ago. By using the method, the n th moment of the spin overlap can be calculated as a simple average of the n th moment of the total spins with a modified bond probability distribution. The values of the Binder parameter etc have been extensively calculated with the linear size, L , up to L = 23. The accuracy of the calculations in the present method is similar to that in the conventional transfer matrix method with about 10 5 bond samples. The simple scaling plots of the Binder parameter and the spin-glass susceptibility indicate the existence of a finite-temperature spin-glass phase transition. We find, however, that the estimation of T c is strongly affected by the corrections to scaling within the present data ( L ⩽ 23). Thus, there still remains the possibility that T c = 0, contrary to the recent results which suggest the existence of a finite-temperature spin-glass phase transition.
We reply to the comment on our published paper `` Universal Fluctuations in Correlated Systems'',Phys. Rev. Lett. Vol; 84, p3744 (2000), by B. Zheng and S. Trimper, cond-mat/0109003. We argue that their results confirm our conjecture, that the probability distribution for order parameter fluctuations in the 2D and 3D Ising models at a temperature T∗(L)T^{\ast}(L)T∗(L) slightly below TCT_CTC​ for the infinite, system approximates the universal functional form of the 2D-XY model in its low temperature phase. We discuss the relevance of the temperature interval TC−T∗T_C-T^{\ast}TC​−T∗, considered to be large by Zheng and Trimper and explain why the observed phenomena is a critical phenomena.
In a series of papers we combined the Bethe ansatz with a kinetic (Boltzmann) equation in order to compute exactly transport properties in a Luttinger liquid with an impurity. In a recent comment [cond-mat/9708163], Skorik claimed that while our results were correct in linear response, there was a ``serious flaw'' in our calculation at finite voltage. We explain here why Skorik's arguments are inappropriate, and that there is no flaw in our work [cond-mat/9408068; cond-mat/9505031; cond-mat/9503172].