Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:cond-mat/0011235

Comment on 'A new method to calculate the spin-glass order parameter of the two-dimensional $\pm J$ Ising model'

Takayuki Shirakura, Fumitaka Matsubara, Michinori Shiomi

Published Nov 14, 2000• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Contrary to the suggestion of Kitatani and Sinada (2000 J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. {\bf 33} 3545-3553), the scaling analysis of the order parameter distributions suggests the existence of a finite-temperature spin-glass phase transition $T_c\ne 0$, even if the corrections to scaling are taken into account.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.cond-mat/0011235

Related papers

A new method to calculate the spin-glass order parameter of the two-dimensional ±JIsing model

Hidetsugu Kitatani, Akira Sinada

A new method to numerically calculate the n th moment of the spin overlap of the two-dimensional ± J Ising model is developed using the identity derived by one of the authors (HK) several years ago. By using the method, the n th moment of the spin overlap can be calculated as a simple average of the n th moment of the total spins with a modified bond probability distribution. The values of the Binder parameter etc have been extensively calculated with the linear size, L , up to L = 23. The accuracy of the calculations in the present method is similar to that in the conventional transfer matrix method with about 10 5 bond samples. The simple scaling plots of the Binder parameter and the spin-glass susceptibility indicate the existence of a finite-temperature spin-glass phase transition. We find, however, that the estimation of T c is strongly affected by the corrections to scaling within the present data ( L ⩽ 23). Thus, there still remains the possibility that T c = 0, contrary to the recent results which suggest the existence of a finite-temperature spin-glass phase transition.

arXiv:cond-mat/9908370•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•May 5, 2000•9 citations

Reply to Comment on 'A new method to calculate the spin-glass order parameter of the two-dimensional $\pm J$ Ising model'

Hidetsugu Kitatani, A. Sinada

In response to the comment made by Dr. Shirakura {\it et al} (cond-mat/0011235), we explain that their scaling forms of the order parameter distribution are inadequate. We then present an appropriate scaling form of the order parameter distribution, which gives a good scaling plot of the order parameter distribution itself and also gives consistent results with our pevious results[1].

arXiv:cond-mat/0102117•Feb 7, 2001•0 citations

Phase transition in the three-dimensional ±J Ising spin glass

Naoki Kawashima, A. P. Young

We have studied the three-dimensional Ising spin glass with a $\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}J$ distribution by Monte Carlo simulations. Using larger sizes and much better statistics than in earlier work, a finite-size scaling analysis shows quite strong evidence for a finite transition temperature ${T}_{c}$ with ordering below ${T}_{c}$. Our estimate of the transition temperature is rather lower than in earlier work, and the value of the correlation length exponent $\ensuremath{\nu}$ is somewhat higher. Because there may be (unknown) corrections to finite-size scaling, we do not completely rule out the possibility that ${T}_{c}=0$ or that ${T}_{c}$ is finite but with no order below ${T}_{c}$. However, from our data, these possibilities seem less likely.

arXiv:cond-mat/9510009•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Jan 1, 1996•169 citations

A New Method to Calculate the Spin-Glass Order Parameter -the Spin-Glass Phase Transition of the Two-Dimensional +/-J Ising Model-

Hidetsugu Kitatani, A. Sinada

A new method to calculate the n−th moment of the spin overlap of the two-dimensional ±J Ising model is presented, where the n−th moment of the spin overlap can be calculated as a simple average of the n−th moment of the total spins with a modified bond probability distribution. By this method, the values of the Binder parameter etc. have been calculated extensively with the linear size, L, up to L = 23. The accuracy of the present calculations is similar to that calculated by the conventional transfer matrix method averaging over about 10 5 bond samples. Our results show that the estimation of Tc is strongly affected by the corrections to scaling. Thus, there still remains the possibility of Tc = 0, contrary to the recent results which insist the existence of a finite temperature spin-glass phase transition. 75.50.Lk,02.70.Lq,64.60.Cn,05.50.+q Typeset using REVTEX 1 In the last two decades, investigations of spin-glass problems have been performed

•Aug 26, 1999•0 citations

RECENT DEVELOPMENTS IN ISING SPIN GLASSES

A. P. Young, Naoki Kawashima

We have studied the three-dimensional Ising spin glass with a ± J distribution by Monte Carlo simulations. Using larger sizes and much better statistics than in earlier work, a finite size scaling analysis shows quite strong evidence for a finite transition temperature, Tc, with ordering below Tc. Our estimate of the transition temperature is rather lower than in earlier work, and the value of the correlation length exponent, ν, is somewhat higher. Because there may be (unknown) corrections to finite size scaling, we do not completely rule out the possibility that Tc = 0 or that Tc is finite but with no order below Tc. However, from our data, these possibilities seem less likely.

International Journal of Modern Physics C•Jun 1, 1996•2 citations

Domain-wall scaling near the Ising spin-glass transition

Andrew T. Ogielski

The distribution of energy and free energy of domain walls near the spin-glass transition is studied numerically in the three-dimensional Ising spin-glass model with discrete $\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}J$ interactions. Temperature dependence of the width of the free-energy distribution clearly shows a phase transition to a low-temperature phase with long-range spin correlations at $\frac{k{T}_{g}}{J}\ensuremath{\simeq}1.2$. Simple scaling analysis is consistent with previous studies of this system.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Nov 1, 1986•4 citations
Comment on 'A new method to calculate the spin-glass order parameter of the two-dimensional ±J\pm J±J Ising model'
Contrary to the suggestion of Kitatani and Sinada (2000 J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. {\bf 33} 3545-3553), the scaling analysis of the order parameter distributions suggests the existence of a finite-temperature spin-glass phase transition Tc≠0T_c\ne 0Tc​=0, even if the corrections to scaling are taken into account.
A new method to numerically calculate the n th moment of the spin overlap of the two-dimensional ± J Ising model is developed using the identity derived by one of the authors (HK) several years ago. By using the method, the n th moment of the spin overlap can be calculated as a simple average of the n th moment of the total spins with a modified bond probability distribution. The values of the Binder parameter etc have been extensively calculated with the linear size, L , up to L = 23. The accuracy of the calculations in the present method is similar to that in the conventional transfer matrix method with about 10 5 bond samples. The simple scaling plots of the Binder parameter and the spin-glass susceptibility indicate the existence of a finite-temperature spin-glass phase transition. We find, however, that the estimation of T c is strongly affected by the corrections to scaling within the present data ( L ⩽ 23). Thus, there still remains the possibility that T c = 0, contrary to the recent results which suggest the existence of a finite-temperature spin-glass phase transition.
Reply to Comment on 'A new method to calculate the spin-glass order parameter of the two-dimensional ±J\pm J±J Ising model'
We have studied the three-dimensional Ising spin glass with a $\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}J$ distribution by Monte Carlo simulations. Using larger sizes and much better statistics than in earlier work, a finite-size scaling analysis shows quite strong evidence for a finite transition temperature Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ with ordering below Tc{T}_{c}Tc​. Our estimate of the transition temperature is rather lower than in earlier work, and the value of the correlation length exponent $\ensuremath{\nu}$ is somewhat higher. Because there may be (unknown) corrections to finite-size scaling, we do not completely rule out the possibility that Tc=0{T}_{c}=0Tc​=0 or that Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ is finite but with no order below Tc{T}_{c}Tc​. However, from our data, these possibilities seem less likely.
A new method to calculate the n−th moment of the spin overlap of the two-dimensional ±J Ising model is presented, where the n−th moment of the spin overlap can be calculated as a simple average of the n−th moment of the total spins with a modified bond probability distribution. By this method, the values of the Binder parameter etc. have been calculated extensively with the linear size, L, up to L = 23. The accuracy of the present calculations is similar to that calculated by the conventional transfer matrix method averaging over about 10 5 bond samples. Our results show that the estimation of Tc is strongly affected by the corrections to scaling. Thus, there still remains the possibility of Tc = 0, contrary to the recent results which insist the existence of a finite temperature spin-glass phase transition. 75.50.Lk,02.70.Lq,64.60.Cn,05.50.+q Typeset using REVTEX 1 In the last two decades, investigations of spin-glass problems have been performed
We have studied the three-dimensional Ising spin glass with a ± J distribution by Monte Carlo simulations. Using larger sizes and much better statistics than in earlier work, a finite size scaling analysis shows quite strong evidence for a finite transition temperature, Tc, with ordering below Tc. Our estimate of the transition temperature is rather lower than in earlier work, and the value of the correlation length exponent, ν, is somewhat higher. Because there may be (unknown) corrections to finite size scaling, we do not completely rule out the possibility that Tc = 0 or that Tc is finite but with no order below Tc. However, from our data, these possibilities seem less likely.
The distribution of energy and free energy of domain walls near the spin-glass transition is studied numerically in the three-dimensional Ising spin-glass model with discrete $\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}J$ interactions. Temperature dependence of the width of the free-energy distribution clearly shows a phase transition to a low-temperature phase with long-range spin correlations at $\frac{k{T}_{g}}{J}\ensuremath{\simeq}1.2$. Simple scaling analysis is consistent with previous studies of this system.