Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:chao-dyn/9702006 · European Journal of Physics

The elliptic billiard: subtleties of separability

Ramses van Zon, Th.W. Ruijgrok

Published Jan 1, 1998• 9 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Some of the subtleties of the integrability of the elliptic quantum billiard are discussed. Considering a well known classical constant of the motion in the quantum case, we find that a naive calculation of the commutator with the Hamiltonian does not show whether or not it is zero. It is shown how this problem can be solved. A geometric picture is given that reveals why levels of a separable system cross. It is shown that the repulsions found by Ayant and Arvieu are computational effects and that the method used by Traiber et al is related to the present picture which explains the crossings they find. An asymptotic formula for the energy levels is derived and it is found that the statistical quantities of the spectrum P ( s ) and have the form expected for an integrable system.

DOI
10.1088/0143-0807/19/1/011

Related papers

Level crossings and commuting observables for the quantum elliptic billiard

Ariel J.S. Traiber, A. J. Fendrik, M. Bernath

The energy spectrum of the quantum elliptic billiard is obtained by solving the Schrodinger equation in elliptic coordinates. The corresponding eigenstates also diagonalise an operator B which commutes with H. A numerical search of the exact eigenvalues of B and H permits one to follow each state as a function of the deformation parameter mu . Geometrical arguments, also valid for the simpler problem of the rectangular box, allow one to understand the results obtained.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•May 7, 1989•15 citations

Quantum integrability and nonintegrability of Hamiltonian systems with two degrees of freedom

Vyacheslav V. Stepanov

The subject of the four manuscripts which make up this dissertation is the concept of integrability in quantum mechanical systems with two degrees of freedom, including the relation between quantum integrability and classical integrability in such systems. In the first manuscript, I consider a two-spin model both classically and quantum mechanically. In the six-dimensional parameter space of this model, classical integrability is satisfied on a five-dimensional hypersurface, and level crossings occur on four-dimensional manifolds that are completely embedded in the integrability hypersurface except for some lower-dimensional sub-manifolds. Under mild assumptions, the classical integrability condition can be reconstructed from a purely quantum mechanical study of level degeneracies in finite-dimensional invariant blocks of the Hamiltonian matrix. In the second manuscript, I analyze the functional dependence [special characters omitted] of the Hamiltonian operator on the action operators for an integrable quantum system, and I compare it with the corresponding functional relationship H (p1, q1; p2, q 2) = HC(J1, J2) in the classical limit of that system. It is demonstrated that the functional dependence is not the same quantum mechanically and (semi-)classically. The former is shown to converge toward the latter in some asymptotic regime associated with the classical limit, but the convergence may be non-uniform. This analysis is carried out for an integrable one- parameter two-spin model. Additional results presented for the (integrable) circular billiard model exhibit similar quantum corrections to the predictions of semiclassical quantization. In the third and the fourth manuscripts, I investigate the relations between symmetry, integrability, and the assignment of quantum numbers to eigenstates for two-spin and spin-boson models. I calculate quantum invariants in the form of expectation values for selected operators and monitor their dependence on the Hamiltonian parameters along loops within, without, and across the integrability region in parameter space. I find clear-cut signatures of integrability and nonintegrability in the observed traces of quantum invariants evaluated in invariant Hilbert subspaces. The results support the notion that quantum integrability depends on the existence of action operators as constituent elements of the Hamiltonian.

Journal of Media Literacy Education•Jan 1, 1999•0 citations

Behaviour of boundary functions for quantum billiards

A B cker, S F rstberger, R Schubert +1 more

We study the behaviour of the normal derivative of eigenfunctions of the Helmholtz equation inside billiards with Dirichlet boundary condition. These boundary functions are of particular importance because they uniquely determine the eigenfunctions inside the billiard and also other physical quantities of interest. Therefore, they form a reduced representation of the quantum system, analogous to the Poincaré section of the classical system. For the normal derivatives we introduce an equivalent to the standard Green function and derive an integral equation on the boundary. Based on this integral equation we compute the first two terms of the mean asymptotic behaviour of the boundary functions for large energies. The first term is universal and independent of the shape of the billiard. The second one is proportional to the curvature of the boundary. The asymptotic behaviour is compared with numerical results for the stadium billiard, different limaçon billiards and the circle billiard, and good agreement is found. Furthermore, we derive an asymptotic completeness relation for the boundary functions.

arXiv:nlin/0207034•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Nov 19, 2002•20 citations

The link between integrability, level crossings and exact solution in quantum models

Haile Owusu, K Wagh, Emil A. Yuzbashyan

We investigate the connection between energy level crossings in integrable systems and their integrability, i.e. the existence of a set of non-trivial integrals of motion. In particular, we consider a general quantum Hamiltonian linear in the coupling u , H ( u ) = T + uV , and require that it has the maximum possible number of nontrivial commuting partners also linear in u . We demonstrate how this commutation requirement alone leads to: (1) an exact solution for the energy spectrum and (2) level crossings, which are always present in these Hamiltonians in violation of the Wigner–von Neumann non-crossing rule. Moreover, we construct these Hamiltonians explicitly by resolving the above commutation requirement and show their equivalence to a sector of Gaudin magnets (central spin Hamiltonians). In contrast, fewer than the maximum number of conservation laws does not guarantee level crossings.

arXiv:0807.0259•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Dec 9, 2008•41 citations

Duality between quantum and classical dynamics for integrable billiards

W. T. Lu, Weiqiao Zeng, S. Sridhar

We establish a duality between the quantum wave vector spectrum and the eigenmodes of the classical Liouvillian dynamics for integrable billiards. Signatures of the classical eigenmodes appear as peaks in the correlation function of the quantum wave vector spectrum. A semiclassical derivation and numerical calculations are presented in support of the results. These classical eigenmodes can be observed in physical experiments through the autocorrelation of the transmission coefficient of waves in quantum billiards. Exact classical trace formulas of the resolvent are derived for the rectangle, equilateral triangle, and circle billiards. We also establish a correspondence between the classical periodic orbit length spectrum and the quantum spectrum for integrable polygonal billiards.

arXiv:nlin/0601022•Physical Review E•Apr 4, 2006•2 citations

What Kind of Insight Provide Analytical Solutions of Quantum Models?

Daniel Braak

Abstract There are several concepts of what constitutes the analytical solution of a quantum model, as opposed to the mere “numerically exact” one. This applies even if one considers only the determination of the discrete spectrum of the corresponding Hamiltonian, setting aside such important questions as the asymptotic dynamics for long times. In the simplest case, the spectrum can be given in closed form, the eigenvalues $$E_{j}, j=0,\ldots ,N\le \infty $$ E j , j = 0 , … , N ≤ ∞ read $$E_{j} =f(j,\{p_{k}\})$$ E j = f ( j , { p k } ) , where f is a known function of the label $$j\in \mathbb {N}_{0}$$ j ∈ N 0 and the $$\{p_k\}$$ { p k } are a set of numbers parameterizing the Hamilton operator. This kind of solution exists only in cases where the classical limit of the model is Liouville-integrable. Some quantum-mechanical many-body systems allow the determination of the spectrum in terms of auxiliary parameters $$[\{k_j\},\{n_l\}]$$ [ { k j } , { n l } ] as $$E(\{n_l\}) = f(\{k_{j}(\{n_{l}\})\})$$ E ( { n l } ) = f ( { k j ( { n l } ) } ) where the $$\{k_{j}(\{n_{l}\})\}$$ { k j ( { n l } ) } satisfy a coupled set of transcendental equations, following from a certain ansatz for the eigenfunctions. These systems (integrable in the sense of Yang-Baxter (Eckle 2019)) may have a Hilbert space dimension growing exponentially with the system size L, i.e., $$N\sim e^{L}$$ N ∼ e L . The simple enumeration of the energies with the label j is replaced by the multi-index $$\{n_{l}\}$$ { n l } . Although no priori knowledge about the spectrum is available, its statistical properties can be computed exactly (Berry and Tabor 1977). Other integrable and also non-integrable models exist where N depends polynomially on L and the energies $$E_j$$ E j are the zeroes of an analytically computable transcendental function, the so-called G-function $$G(E,\{p_k\})$$ G ( E ,

Mathematics for industry•Oct 22, 2020•0 citations
Some of the subtleties of the integrability of the elliptic quantum billiard are discussed. Considering a well known classical constant of the motion in the quantum case, we find that a naive calculation of the commutator with the Hamiltonian does not show whether or not it is zero. It is shown how this problem can be solved. A geometric picture is given that reveals why levels of a separable system cross. It is shown that the repulsions found by Ayant and Arvieu are computational effects and that the method used by Traiber et al is related to the present picture which explains the crossings they find. An asymptotic formula for the energy levels is derived and it is found that the statistical quantities of the spectrum P ( s ) and have the form expected for an integrable system.
The subject of the four manuscripts which make up this dissertation is the concept of integrability in quantum mechanical systems with two degrees of freedom, including the relation between quantum integrability and classical integrability in such systems. In the first manuscript, I consider a two-spin model both classically and quantum mechanically. In the six-dimensional parameter space of this model, classical integrability is satisfied on a five-dimensional hypersurface, and level crossings occur on four-dimensional manifolds that are completely embedded in the integrability hypersurface except for some lower-dimensional sub-manifolds. Under mild assumptions, the classical integrability condition can be reconstructed from a purely quantum mechanical study of level degeneracies in finite-dimensional invariant blocks of the Hamiltonian matrix. In the second manuscript, I analyze the functional dependence [special characters omitted] of the Hamiltonian operator on the action operators for an integrable quantum system, and I compare it with the corresponding functional relationship H (p1, q1; p2, q 2) = HC(J1, J2) in the classical limit of that system. It is demonstrated that the functional dependence is not the same quantum mechanically and (semi-)classically. The former is shown to converge toward the latter in some asymptotic regime associated with the classical limit, but the convergence may be non-uniform. This analysis is carried out for an integrable one- parameter two-spin model. Additional results presented for the (integrable) circular billiard model exhibit similar quantum corrections to the predictions of semiclassical quantization. In the third and the fourth manuscripts, I investigate the relations between symmetry, integrability, and the assignment of quantum numbers to eigenstates for two-spin and spin-boson models. I calculate quantum invariants in the form of expectation values for selected operators and monitor their dependence on the Hamiltonian parameters along loops within, without, and across the integrability region in parameter space. I find clear-cut signatures of integrability and nonintegrability in the observed traces of quantum invariants evaluated in invariant Hilbert subspaces. The results support the notion that quantum integrability depends on the existence of action operators as constituent elements of the Hamiltonian.
We study the behaviour of the normal derivative of eigenfunctions of the Helmholtz equation inside billiards with Dirichlet boundary condition. These boundary functions are of particular importance because they uniquely determine the eigenfunctions inside the billiard and also other physical quantities of interest. Therefore, they form a reduced representation of the quantum system, analogous to the Poincaré section of the classical system. For the normal derivatives we introduce an equivalent to the standard Green function and derive an integral equation on the boundary. Based on this integral equation we compute the first two terms of the mean asymptotic behaviour of the boundary functions for large energies. The first term is universal and independent of the shape of the billiard. The second one is proportional to the curvature of the boundary. The asymptotic behaviour is compared with numerical results for the stadium billiard, different limaçon billiards and the circle billiard, and good agreement is found. Furthermore, we derive an asymptotic completeness relation for the boundary functions.
We investigate the connection between energy level crossings in integrable systems and their integrability, i.e. the existence of a set of non-trivial integrals of motion. In particular, we consider a general quantum Hamiltonian linear in the coupling u , H ( u ) = T + uV , and require that it has the maximum possible number of nontrivial commuting partners also linear in u . We demonstrate how this commutation requirement alone leads to: (1) an exact solution for the energy spectrum and (2) level crossings, which are always present in these Hamiltonians in violation of the Wigner–von Neumann non-crossing rule. Moreover, we construct these Hamiltonians explicitly by resolving the above commutation requirement and show their equivalence to a sector of Gaudin magnets (central spin Hamiltonians). In contrast, fewer than the maximum number of conservation laws does not guarantee level crossings.
We establish a duality between the quantum wave vector spectrum and the eigenmodes of the classical Liouvillian dynamics for integrable billiards. Signatures of the classical eigenmodes appear as peaks in the correlation function of the quantum wave vector spectrum. A semiclassical derivation and numerical calculations are presented in support of the results. These classical eigenmodes can be observed in physical experiments through the autocorrelation of the transmission coefficient of waves in quantum billiards. Exact classical trace formulas of the resolvent are derived for the rectangle, equilateral triangle, and circle billiards. We also establish a correspondence between the classical periodic orbit length spectrum and the quantum spectrum for integrable polygonal billiards.
Abstract There are several concepts of what constitutes the analytical solution of a quantum model, as opposed to the mere “numerically exact” one. This applies even if one considers only the determination of the discrete spectrum of the corresponding Hamiltonian, setting aside such important questions as the asymptotic dynamics for long times. In the simplest case, the spectrum can be given in closed form, the eigenvalues Ej,j=0,…,N≤∞E_{j}, j=0,\ldots ,N\le \infty Ej​,j=0,…,N≤∞ E j , j = 0 , … , N ≤ ∞ read Ej=f(j,{pk})E_{j} =f(j,\{p_{k}\})Ej​=f(j,{pk​}) E j = f ( j , { p k } ) , where f is a known function of the label j∈N0j\in \mathbb {N}_{0}j∈N0​ j ∈ N 0 and the {pk}\{p_k\}{pk​} { p k } are a set of numbers parameterizing the Hamilton operator. This kind of solution exists only in cases where the classical limit of the model is Liouville-integrable. Some quantum-mechanical many-body systems allow the determination of the spectrum in terms of auxiliary parameters [{kj},{nl}][\{k_j\},\{n_l\}][{kj​},{nl​}] [ { k j } , { n l } ] as E({nl})=f({kj({nl})})E(\{n_l\}) = f(\{k_{j}(\{n_{l}\})\})E({nl​})=f({kj​({nl​})}) E ( { n l } ) = f ( { k j ( { n l } ) } ) where the {kj({nl})}\{k_{j}(\{n_{l}\})\}{kj​({nl​})} { k j ( { n l } ) } satisfy a coupled set of transcendental equations, following from a certain ansatz for the eigenfunctions. These systems (integrable in the sense of Yang-Baxter (Eckle 2019)) may have a Hilbert space dimension growing exponentially with the system size L, i.e., N∼eLN\sim e^{L}N∼eL N ∼ e L . The simple enumeration of the energies with the label j is replaced by the multi-index {nl}\{n_{l}\}{nl​} { n l } . Although no priori knowledge about the spectrum is available, its statistical properties can be computed exactly (Berry and Tabor 1977). Other integrable and also non-integrable models exist where N depends polynomially on L and the energies EjE_jEj​ E j are the zeroes of an analytically computable transcendental function, the so-called G-function G(E,{pk})G(E,\{p_k\})G(E,{pk​}) G ( E ,