Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Mathematics for industry

What Kind of Insight Provide Analytical Solutions of Quantum Models?

Daniel Braak

Published Oct 22, 2020• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract There are several concepts of what constitutes the analytical solution of a quantum model, as opposed to the mere “numerically exact” one. This applies even if one considers only the determination of the discrete spectrum of the corresponding Hamiltonian, setting aside such important questions as the asymptotic dynamics for long times. In the simplest case, the spectrum can be given in closed form, the eigenvalues $$E_{j}, j=0,\ldots ,N\le \infty $$ E j , j = 0 , … , N ≤ ∞ read $$E_{j} =f(j,\{p_{k}\})$$ E j = f ( j , { p k } ) , where f is a known function of the label $$j\in \mathbb {N}_{0}$$ j ∈ N 0 and the $$\{p_k\}$$ { p k } are a set of numbers parameterizing the Hamilton operator. This kind of solution exists only in cases where the classical limit of the model is Liouville-integrable. Some quantum-mechanical many-body systems allow the determination of the spectrum in terms of auxiliary parameters $$[\{k_j\},\{n_l\}]$$ [ { k j } , { n l } ] as $$E(\{n_l\}) = f(\{k_{j}(\{n_{l}\})\})$$ E ( { n l } ) = f ( { k j ( { n l } ) } ) where the $$\{k_{j}(\{n_{l}\})\}$$ { k j ( { n l } ) } satisfy a coupled set of transcendental equations, following from a certain ansatz for the eigenfunctions. These systems (integrable in the sense of Yang-Baxter (Eckle 2019)) may have a Hilbert space dimension growing exponentially with the system size L, i.e., $$N\sim e^{L}$$ N ∼ e L . The simple enumeration of the energies with the label j is replaced by the multi-index $$\{n_{l}\}$$ { n l } . Although no priori knowledge about the spectrum is available, its statistical properties can be computed exactly (Berry and Tabor 1977). Other integrable and also non-integrable models exist where N depends polynomially on L and the energies $$E_j$$ E j are the zeroes of an analytically computable transcendental function, the so-called G-function $$G(E,\{p_k\})$$ G ( E ,

DOI
10.1007/978-981-15-5191-8_2

Related papers

The Interpretation of Quantum-Mechanical Models with Non-Hermitian Hamiltonians and Real Spectra

R. Kretschmer, L. Szymanowski

We study the quantum-mechanical interpretation of models with non-Hermitian Hamiltonians and real spectra. We set up a general framework for the analysis of such systems in terms of Hermitian Hamiltonians defined in the usual Hilbert space $L_2(-\infty,\infty)$. Special emphasis is put on the correct definition of the algebra of physical observables. Within this scheme we consider various examples, including the model recently introduced by Cannata et al. and the model of Hatano and Nelson.

arXiv:quant-ph/0105054•May 11, 2001•38 citations

非対称量子ラビ模型の固有値に関する研究

アルマンド シッド

The quantum Rabi model is a model in quantum optics used to describe the interaction between a two-level atom and a single-level photon field.This model, described in 1963 by Jaynes and Cummings, is the fully quantized version of the original semi-classical model proposed in 1936 by Rabi.In previous years, the study of the properties of Hamiltonian of the quantum Rabi model and its energy levels (eigenvalues of the Hamiltonian) has been relegated mainly for two reasons.The first one was the belief that the quantum Rabi model was not an exactly solvable model, that is, that its energy levels could not be described analytically.The second reason is that in the parameter regime achievable at the time in experiments and applications, the quantum Rabi model could be approximated successfully by the Jaynes-Cummings model, a simpler model which is known to be exactly solvable.Both situations changed in recent years.In 2011, Daniel Braak proved the exact-solvability of the quantum Rabi model by constructing analytical solutions and defining a transcendental function, the G-function, whose zeros determine all the spectrum (with the exception of a (possible finite) set of exceptional eigenvalues).This pioneering technique has since then been successfully applied to show the exact-solvability of several models in quantum optics.On the other hand, due to the advances in experimental physics, starting from the first decade of this century, experiments have been steadily reaching parameter regimes where the Jaynes-Cummings model becomes unsuitable for approximation and in 2014, the experiments by Maissen et al reached regimes where it is imperative to consider the full Hamiltonian of the quantum Rabi model.Adding to this, recently there has also been proposals for applications of the quantum Rabi model in quantum information theory and quantum computing.For these reasons, there has been a large amount of research done in theoretical and experimental physics, and, more recently, mathematics on the subject of the quantum Rabi model, its generalizations and applications.In this thesis, we study the asymmetric quantum Rabi model, one of the generalizations of the quantum Rabi model.In this generalization, an additional non-trivial interaction term is introduced in the Hamiltonian, breaking the Z 2Z-symmetry of the quantum Rabi Hamiltonian.The presence of this symmetry in the quantum Rabi model explains the presence of crossings in the energy levels (degeneracies in the spectrum), so a priori there was no reason to expect degeneracies in the spectrum of the asymmetric version.In this work, we show that when the coefficient of the symmetry-breaking term is halfinteger, degeneracies appear in the spectrum of the asymmetric quantum Rabi model.This is done by studying the properties of the constraint polynomials, polynomials appearing in certain conditions that the parameters of the model must satisfy in order to have certain eigenvalues, called Juddian eigenvalues.The spectrum of the asymmetric quantum Rabi model is divided into different sets, an infinite set of regular eigenvalues, the zeros of the G-function and the exceptional eigenvalues, not captured as zeros of the G-function.The exceptional spectrum is further classified into Juddian and non-Juddian, according to the type of solution in the Segal-Bargmann space realization.These solutions are also described in terms of the sl 2 picture of the Hamiltonian in terms of irreducible representations of sl 2 .The case for Juddian and regular eigenvalues was already known, and in this thesis we complete the picture for the non-Juddian eigenvalues.Another main result of this work is to characterize the degeneracies of the asymmetric quantum Rabi model in terms of the types of eigenvalues and the parameters.Furthermore, by carefully studying the poles of the G-function, we define a new G-function whose zeros give the full spectrum of the asymmetric quantum Rabi model.Finally, we present a study on continued fractions expansions of integer powers of the Napier constant e with a nice representation and good convergence properties.This study is a byproduct of the study of certain orthogonal polynomial families related to the constraint polynomials of the AQRM.

•Jun 28, 2018•0 citations

On the spectrum of a class of quantum models

Alexander Moroz

The spectrum of any quantum model whose eigenvalue equation reduces to a three-term recurrence, such as a displaced harmonic oscillator, the Jaynes-Cummings model, the Rabi model, and a generalized Rabi model, can be determined as zeros of a corresponding transcendental function F ( x ). The latter can be analytically determined as an infinite series defined solely in terms of the recurrence coefficients.

arXiv:1209.3265•Europhysics Letters (EPL)•Dec 1, 2012•36 citations

Low-temperature spectrum of correlation lengths of the XXZ chain in the antiferromagnetic massive regime*

Maxime Dugave, Frank Göhmann, Karol Kajetan Kozlowski +1 more

Abstract We consider the spectrum of correlation lengths of the spin− XXZ chain in the antiferromagnetic massive regime. These are given as ratios of eigenvalues of the quantum transfer matrix of the model. The eigenvalues are determined by integrals over certain auxiliary functions and by their zeros. The auxiliary functions satisfy nonlinear integral equations. We analyse these nonlinear integral equations in the low-temperature limit. In this limit we can determine the auxiliary functions and the expressions for the eigenvalues as functions of a finite number of parameters which satisfy finite sets of algebraic equations, the so-called higher-level Bethe ansatz equations. The behaviour of these equations, if we send the temperature T to zero, is different for zero and non-zero magnetic field h . If h is zero the situation is much like in the case of the usual transfer matrix. Non-trivial higher-level Bethe ansatz equations remain which determine certain complex excitation parameters as functions of hole parameters which are free on a line segment in the complex plane. If h is non-zero, on the other hand, a remarkable restructuring occurs, and all parameters which enter the description of the quantum transfer matrix eigenvalues can be interpreted entirely in terms of particles and holes which are freely located on two curves when T goes to zero.

arXiv:1504.07923•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Jul 28, 2015•29 citations

A one-dimensional statistical mechanics model with exact transfer integral solution

Gary Mathew Wysin

A simple one-dimensional model with scalar variables −1≤sn≤+1, coupled according to a Hamiltonian, H=−J∑n‖sn−sn+1‖, is presented. This Ising-like model is an interesting example of a graduate-level statistical mechanics problem where the eigenfunctions and eigenvalues of an integral operator, the transfer integral, can be determined exactly. This can be contrasted with the determination of eigenfunctions and eigenvalues of differential operators, such as the quantum mechanical finite-depth square well. In this problem transcendental equations leading to the eigenvalues and eigenfunctions are also obtained. The largest eigenvalue is identified and the free energy is determined. The thermodynamic properties depend on the sign of J, unlike classical Ising or Heisenberg models.

American Journal of Physics•Aug 1, 1993•0 citations

Common quantum mechanics and statistical mechanics results

Douglas Natelson

A review of perturbation theory Most quantum mechanics problems are not solvable in closed form with analytical techniques. To extend our repertoire beyond just particle-in-a-box, a number of approximation techniques have been developed. A large class of these fall under the heading of “perturbation theory”, in which we consider our system to obey Hamiltonian H that may be written as H = H 0 + λ H 1 + λ 2 H 2 + … , (A.1) where H 0 is an exactly solvable Hamiltonian, λ is a small parameter, and the other terms may therefore be taken as small corrections. These notes are a quick review of how to deal with systems that obey such Hamiltonians. We'll be using Dirac notation and the Schrödinger formalism, in which the states are time-dependent. We begin with time-independent perturbation theory, and will then move on to consider time-dependent problems. For now, we'll only deal with single-particle problems, too. Time-independent We're going to use the time-independent Schrödinger equation, and look for the energy eigenvalues and eigenstates of H . First, suppose that our unperturbed problem, H 0 |ψ 0 〉 = E 0 |ψ 0 〉 (A.2) may be solved exactly, giving an energy eigenvalue spectrum E 0 j with corresponding eigenstates |ψ 0 j 〉. Remember, because H 0 is a Hermitian operator, its eigenvalues are real, and its eigenvectors |ψ 0 j 〉 form a complete set. The strategy we're going to take is straightforward. We're going to assume that our perturbative corrections to the Hamiltonian, λ H 1 + λ 2 H 2 + … , lead to corresponding perturbative corrections to the eigenvalues and eigenstates. That is, E j = E 0 j + λ E 1 j + λ 2 E 2 j + … , |ψ j 〉 = |ψ 0 j 〉 + λ|ψ 1 j 〉 + λ 2 |ψ 2 j 〉 + ….

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jun 18, 2015•0 citations
Abstract There are several concepts of what constitutes the analytical solution of a quantum model, as opposed to the mere “numerically exact” one. This applies even if one considers only the determination of the discrete spectrum of the corresponding Hamiltonian, setting aside such important questions as the asymptotic dynamics for long times. In the simplest case, the spectrum can be given in closed form, the eigenvalues Ej,j=0,…,N≤∞E_{j}, j=0,\ldots ,N\le \infty Ej​,j=0,…,N≤∞ E j , j = 0 , … , N ≤ ∞ read Ej=f(j,{pk})E_{j} =f(j,\{p_{k}\})Ej​=f(j,{pk​}) E j = f ( j , { p k } ) , where f is a known function of the label j∈N0j\in \mathbb {N}_{0}j∈N0​ j ∈ N 0 and the {pk}\{p_k\}{pk​} { p k } are a set of numbers parameterizing the Hamilton operator. This kind of solution exists only in cases where the classical limit of the model is Liouville-integrable. Some quantum-mechanical many-body systems allow the determination of the spectrum in terms of auxiliary parameters [{kj},{nl}][\{k_j\},\{n_l\}][{kj​},{nl​}] [ { k j } , { n l } ] as E({nl})=f({kj({nl})})E(\{n_l\}) = f(\{k_{j}(\{n_{l}\})\})E({nl​})=f({kj​({nl​})}) E ( { n l } ) = f ( { k j ( { n l } ) } ) where the {kj({nl})}\{k_{j}(\{n_{l}\})\}{kj​({nl​})} { k j ( { n l } ) } satisfy a coupled set of transcendental equations, following from a certain ansatz for the eigenfunctions. These systems (integrable in the sense of Yang-Baxter (Eckle 2019)) may have a Hilbert space dimension growing exponentially with the system size L, i.e., N∼eLN\sim e^{L}N∼eL N ∼ e L . The simple enumeration of the energies with the label j is replaced by the multi-index {nl}\{n_{l}\}{nl​} { n l } . Although no priori knowledge about the spectrum is available, its statistical properties can be computed exactly (Berry and Tabor 1977). Other integrable and also non-integrable models exist where N depends polynomially on L and the energies EjE_jEj​ E j are the zeroes of an analytically computable transcendental function, the so-called G-function G(E,{pk})G(E,\{p_k\})G(E,{pk​}) G ( E ,
We study the quantum-mechanical interpretation of models with non-Hermitian Hamiltonians and real spectra. We set up a general framework for the analysis of such systems in terms of Hermitian Hamiltonians defined in the usual Hilbert space L2(−∞,∞)L_2(-\infty,\infty)L2​(−∞,∞). Special emphasis is put on the correct definition of the algebra of physical observables. Within this scheme we consider various examples, including the model recently introduced by Cannata et al. and the model of Hatano and Nelson.
The quantum Rabi model is a model in quantum optics used to describe the interaction between a two-level atom and a single-level photon field.This model, described in 1963 by Jaynes and Cummings, is the fully quantized version of the original semi-classical model proposed in 1936 by Rabi.In previous years, the study of the properties of Hamiltonian of the quantum Rabi model and its energy levels (eigenvalues of the Hamiltonian) has been relegated mainly for two reasons.The first one was the belief that the quantum Rabi model was not an exactly solvable model, that is, that its energy levels could not be described analytically.The second reason is that in the parameter regime achievable at the time in experiments and applications, the quantum Rabi model could be approximated successfully by the Jaynes-Cummings model, a simpler model which is known to be exactly solvable.Both situations changed in recent years.In 2011, Daniel Braak proved the exact-solvability of the quantum Rabi model by constructing analytical solutions and defining a transcendental function, the G-function, whose zeros determine all the spectrum (with the exception of a (possible finite) set of exceptional eigenvalues).This pioneering technique has since then been successfully applied to show the exact-solvability of several models in quantum optics.On the other hand, due to the advances in experimental physics, starting from the first decade of this century, experiments have been steadily reaching parameter regimes where the Jaynes-Cummings model becomes unsuitable for approximation and in 2014, the experiments by Maissen et al reached regimes where it is imperative to consider the full Hamiltonian of the quantum Rabi model.Adding to this, recently there has also been proposals for applications of the quantum Rabi model in quantum information theory and quantum computing.For these reasons, there has been a large amount of research done in theoretical and experimental physics, and, more recently, mathematics on the subject of the quantum Rabi model, its generalizations and applications.In this thesis, we study the asymmetric quantum Rabi model, one of the generalizations of the quantum Rabi model.In this generalization, an additional non-trivial interaction term is introduced in the Hamiltonian, breaking the Z 2Z-symmetry of the quantum Rabi Hamiltonian.The presence of this symmetry in the quantum Rabi model explains the presence of crossings in the energy levels (degeneracies in the spectrum), so a priori there was no reason to expect degeneracies in the spectrum of the asymmetric version.In this work, we show that when the coefficient of the symmetry-breaking term is halfinteger, degeneracies appear in the spectrum of the asymmetric quantum Rabi model.This is done by studying the properties of the constraint polynomials, polynomials appearing in certain conditions that the parameters of the model must satisfy in order to have certain eigenvalues, called Juddian eigenvalues.The spectrum of the asymmetric quantum Rabi model is divided into different sets, an infinite set of regular eigenvalues, the zeros of the G-function and the exceptional eigenvalues, not captured as zeros of the G-function.The exceptional spectrum is further classified into Juddian and non-Juddian, according to the type of solution in the Segal-Bargmann space realization.These solutions are also described in terms of the sl 2 picture of the Hamiltonian in terms of irreducible representations of sl 2 .The case for Juddian and regular eigenvalues was already known, and in this thesis we complete the picture for the non-Juddian eigenvalues.Another main result of this work is to characterize the degeneracies of the asymmetric quantum Rabi model in terms of the types of eigenvalues and the parameters.Furthermore, by carefully studying the poles of the G-function, we define a new G-function whose zeros give the full spectrum of the asymmetric quantum Rabi model.Finally, we present a study on continued fractions expansions of integer powers of the Napier constant e with a nice representation and good convergence properties.This study is a byproduct of the study of certain orthogonal polynomial families related to the constraint polynomials of the AQRM.
Abstract We consider the spectrum of correlation lengths of the spin− XXZ chain in the antiferromagnetic massive regime. These are given as ratios of eigenvalues of the quantum transfer matrix of the model. The eigenvalues are determined by integrals over certain auxiliary functions and by their zeros. The auxiliary functions satisfy nonlinear integral equations. We analyse these nonlinear integral equations in the low-temperature limit. In this limit we can determine the auxiliary functions and the expressions for the eigenvalues as functions of a finite number of parameters which satisfy finite sets of algebraic equations, the so-called higher-level Bethe ansatz equations. The behaviour of these equations, if we send the temperature T to zero, is different for zero and non-zero magnetic field h . If h is zero the situation is much like in the case of the usual transfer matrix. Non-trivial higher-level Bethe ansatz equations remain which determine certain complex excitation parameters as functions of hole parameters which are free on a line segment in the complex plane. If h is non-zero, on the other hand, a remarkable restructuring occurs, and all parameters which enter the description of the quantum transfer matrix eigenvalues can be interpreted entirely in terms of particles and holes which are freely located on two curves when T goes to zero.
A simple one-dimensional model with scalar variables −1≤sn≤+1, coupled according to a Hamiltonian, H=−J∑n‖sn−sn+1‖, is presented. This Ising-like model is an interesting example of a graduate-level statistical mechanics problem where the eigenfunctions and eigenvalues of an integral operator, the transfer integral, can be determined exactly. This can be contrasted with the determination of eigenfunctions and eigenvalues of differential operators, such as the quantum mechanical finite-depth square well. In this problem transcendental equations leading to the eigenvalues and eigenfunctions are also obtained. The largest eigenvalue is identified and the free energy is determined. The thermodynamic properties depend on the sign of J, unlike classical Ising or Heisenberg models.
A review of perturbation theory Most quantum mechanics problems are not solvable in closed form with analytical techniques. To extend our repertoire beyond just particle-in-a-box, a number of approximation techniques have been developed. A large class of these fall under the heading of “perturbation theory”, in which we consider our system to obey Hamiltonian H that may be written as H = H 0 + λ H 1 + λ 2 H 2 + … , (A.1) where H 0 is an exactly solvable Hamiltonian, λ is a small parameter, and the other terms may therefore be taken as small corrections. These notes are a quick review of how to deal with systems that obey such Hamiltonians. We'll be using Dirac notation and the Schrödinger formalism, in which the states are time-dependent. We begin with time-independent perturbation theory, and will then move on to consider time-dependent problems. For now, we'll only deal with single-particle problems, too. Time-independent We're going to use the time-independent Schrödinger equation, and look for the energy eigenvalues and eigenstates of H . First, suppose that our unperturbed problem, H 0 |ψ 0 〉 = E 0 |ψ 0 〉 (A.2) may be solved exactly, giving an energy eigenvalue spectrum E 0 j with corresponding eigenstates |ψ 0 j 〉. Remember, because H 0 is a Hermitian operator, its eigenvalues are real, and its eigenvectors |ψ 0 j 〉 form a complete set. The strategy we're going to take is straightforward. We're going to assume that our perturbative corrections to the Hamiltonian, λ H 1 + λ 2 H 2 + … , lead to corresponding perturbative corrections to the eigenvalues and eigenstates. That is, E j = E 0 j + λ E 1 j + λ 2 E 2 j + … , |ψ j 〉 = |ψ 0 j 〉 + λ|ψ 1 j 〉 + λ 2 |ψ 2 j 〉 + ….