Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Condensate Replaced by a Number: Bogoliubov's Substitution and Its Self-Priced Error Bar

William Alexander Aldred

Published Nov 6, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In 1947 Nikolai Bogoliubov founded the microscopic theory of superfluidity on a single operation: the zero-momentum mode's operators a_0, a_0^\dagger are replaced by the c-number \sqrt{N_0}, particle-number conservation is broken by hand, the Hamiltonian becomes quadratic, and its diagonalization returns the phonon spectrum E(k) = \sqrt{\epsilon_k^2 + 2gn\epsilon_k} on which superfluidity's microscopic basis stands. The paper's own warrant for the replacement is a size argument — the commutator 1 is small compared with a_0, a_0^* themselves — and a size argument is a regime statement, not a derivation. This paper evaluates the substitution with the theory's own arithmetic on declared inputs: the same diagonalization returns a quantum depletion of 1.682088 percent of the gas outside the condensate at the mildest declared coupling, 4.757664 percent at the central inputs, and 13.456707 percent at the strongest — the substitution's self-evaluated error bar, printed by its own computation — while the c-number discards the condensate mode's number fluctuations (relative spread 0.003333 at the declared central size) and commutator (1/N_0 = 0.000111) by decree, and the discarded third- and fourth-order terms return at the relative scale \sqrt{\gamma} = 0.031623. The spectrum, the sound speed, and superfluidity's basis are the 1947 paper's derivations and stand entire. What is counted here is the derivation status of the step they stand on: 1 c-number substitution carrying the discarded terms it makes necessary, 0 derivations in 1947 of the substitution. Census headline, unchanged: NOT SOLVED / PARTIAL · producing-count 0.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.24014352

Related papers

Bogoliubov theory for a many-boson system

Gary S. Grest, A. K. Rajagopal

Presently there are two distinct classes of microscopic theories which describe a system of many identical spinless bosons. One is the Bogoliubov theory, which places special emphasis on the occupation of the zero-momentum state and as such depends explicitly on the number of particles in this state, ${N}_{0}$. The other depends on density fluctuations to describe the fluid. In this work, we derive a modified version of the Bogoliubov theory which results in a number-conserving Hamiltonian with no explicit dependence on ${N}_{0}$. The ground- and first-excited-state energies evaluated through second order in $\frac{1}{{N}^{\frac{1}{2}}}$ are equivalent to the results of a variational-perturbative procedure based on the method of correlated basis functions in the uniform limit.

Physical review. B, Solid state•Dec 1, 1975•2 citations

Nonequivalence of N -fixed and μ -fixed formalisms adopting a0†=a0=N012 for condensed Bose systems

J.C. Lee

The idea of replacing the condensate operators by the $c$ number ${N}_{0}^{\frac{1}{2}}$ in treating condensed Bose systems is known as Bogoliubov prescription (BP). Once BP is adopted, there are two ways to proceed. The first is the popular method of Hugenholtz and Pines, which we call $\ensuremath{\mu}$-fixed formalism. The second may be found in the well-known works of Foldy and Brueckner on a dense charged boson gas. Unlike the $\ensuremath{\mu}$-fixed formalism, the latter method does not require the introduction of the chemical potential, and thus it is called the $N$-fixed formalism. We argue that BP is rigorous in the $\ensuremath{\mu}$-fixed formalism but is not in the $N$-fixed one. BP in the $N$-fixed one gives correct results for terms of leading orders (Foldy and Brueckner took just these terms) but incorrect results for terms of higher orders.

Physical review. B, Solid state•Nov 1, 1975•0 citations

Statistical Mechanics of a Nonideal Boson Gas: Pair Hamiltonian Model

Marshall Luban

This work is concerned with a microscopic model of a nonideal boson gas. The Hamiltonian is treated in a rigorous manner free of all approximations and, in particular, the Bogoliubov approximation of replacing the zero-momentum single-particle creation and destruction operators by a $c$ number is entirely avoided. Utilizing a method due to Wentzel, the Hamiltonian is replaced by one involving products of two second quantized operators which, in general, can be diagonalized. This replacement is shown to be rigorously valid in the infinite volume limit for all temperatures despite the avoidance of the Bogoliubov approximation. It is found that the assumption of a positive-definite quasiparticle excitation spectrum $\ensuremath{\epsilon}(\mathrm{k})$ becomes untenable for temperatures $T$ less than a critical value ${T}_{c}$, if the interparticle potential is described by a certain kernel which possesses positive eigenvalues only, corresponding to a sufficiently repulsive interparticle force. Assuming that $\ensuremath{\epsilon}(\mathrm{k})=0$ only for k=0, it is found that for $T<{T}_{c}$ the system undergoes an Einstein condensation into the k=0 single-particle state, and the integral equations characterizing the system are precisely the same as would be obtained if the Bogoliubov approximation were made, proving within the framework of this model the strict validity of this approximation procedure. The well-known criterion for an Einstein condensation $v(0)>0$, where $v(\mathrm{k})$ is the Fourier transform of the interparticle potential, is shown to be a weaker statement of our eigenvalue criterion. Further, in agreement with Girardeau and Arnowitt, it is found that an energy gap separates $\ensuremath{\epsilon}(0)$ and $\ensuremath{\epsilon}(\mathrm{k})$ for $k>0$. An approximation method is developed for solving the integral equations which describe those systems which undergo an Einstein condensation, and it is shown that this method can be justified if $|T\ensuremath{-}{T}_{c}|\ensuremath{\lesssim}\frac{{T}_{c}}{10}$, and in cases of short-range repulsive interparticle forces and systems for which $\ensuremath{\rho}v(0)$ possesses a certain prescribed upper bound, $\ensuremath{\rho}$ being the number of particles per unit volume. The transition temperature is found to be lower than the corresponding quantity for the ideal boson gas of the same density. A detailed discussion of the thermal properties of the system in the vicinity of ${T}_{c}$ is also given. In an Appendix a general type of smeared Einstein condensation is assumed, and it is found that for systems in which this property occurs $\ensuremath{\epsilon}(\mathrm{k})$ is linear for small $k$. This ansatz is shown to be tenable only if $v(0)<0$. Finally, by assuming an appropriate pseudopotential representation of a hard repulsive core and by including a weak, longranged attractive force between particles, $\ensuremath{\epsilon}(\mathrm{k})$ shows a nonmonotonic behavior of the same qualitative type as observed in liquid ${\mathrm{He}}^{4}$.

Physical Review•Oct 15, 1962•93 citations

Superfluidity without a Bose condensate

S. I. Shevchenko

We have developed a microscopic theory of superfluidity in a two-dimensional, slightly nonideal Bose gas. The theory is rooted in the fact that a number of bosons are concentrated in the small momentum region at low temperatures when the interaction is weak, in spite of the fact that there is no Bose condensate in the two-dimensional case when T≠0. This fact lets us reduce the description of the system from one employing creation ak+ and annihilation ak operators for bosons to one based on combinations of these operators ρk and φk(ρk = S−1Σqaq+aq+k, φk· = −(i/ns) Σ(kq/k2 + l)aq+aq+k, where n is the boson density, and S is the area of the system). The description in terms of ρk and φk is simple because the hamiltonian is quadratic with respect to ρk and φk. The operators ρk and φk can also be used to express the occupation number Nk = ak+ak and current operators. We find the elementary excitation spectrum (which is identical to the Bogolyubov spectrum) and the momentum distribution of the bosons. We calculate the normal density due to thermal oscillations in the Bose gas and to interactions with impurity centers in the substrate.

Soviet Journal of Low Temperature Physics•Oct 1, 1983•1 citation

Re-Examining Bogoliubov's Theory of an Interacting Bose Gas

A. M. Ettouhami

As is well-known, in the conventional formulation of Bogoliubov's theory of an interacting Bose gas, the Hamiltonian is written as a decoupled sum of contributions from different momenta of the form . Then, each of the single-mode Hamiltonians is diagonalized separately, and the resulting ground state wavefunction of the total Hamiltonian is written as a simple product of the ground state wavefunctions of each of the single-mode Hamiltonians . While this way of diagonalizing the total Hamiltonian may seem to be valid from the perspective of the standard, number non-conserving Bogoliubov's method, where the k = 0 state is removed from the Hilbert space and hence the individual Hilbert spaces where the Hamiltonians {} are diagonalized are disjoint from one another, we argue that from a number-conserving perspective this diagonalization method may not be adequate since the true Hilbert spaces where the Hamiltonians {} should be diagonalized all have the k = 0 state in common, and hence the ground state wavefunction of the total Hamiltonian may not be written as a simple product of the ground state wavefunctions of the 's. In this paper, we give a thorough review of Bogoliubov's method, and discuss a variational and number-conserving formulation of this theory in which the k = 0 state is restored to the Hilbert space of the interacting gas, and where, instead of diagonalizing the Hamiltonians separately, we diagonalize the total Hamiltonian . When this is done, we find that the ground state energy is lowered below the Bogoliubov result, and the depletion of bosons is significantly reduced with respect to the one obtained in the number non-conserving treatment. We also find that the spectrum of the usual αk excitations of Bogoliubov's method changes from a gapless one, as predicted by the standard, number non-conserving formulation of this theory, to one which exhibits a finite gap in the k → 0 limit. We discuss the presence of a gap in the spectrum of the αk's in light of Goldstone's theorem, and show that there is no contradiction with the latter.

arXiv:cond-mat/0703498•Progress of Theoretical Physics•Mar 1, 2012•16 citations

Justification of c -Number Substitutions in Bosonic Hamiltonians

Élliott H. Lieb, Robert Seiringer, Jakob Yngvason

The validity of substituting a c-number z for the k=0 mode operator a(0) is established rigorously in full generality, thereby verifying one aspect of Bogoliubov's 1947 theory. This substitution not only yields the correct value of thermodynamic quantities such as the pressure or ground state energy, but also the value of |z|(2) that maximizes the partition function equals the true amount of condensation in the presence of a gauge-symmetry-breaking term. This point had previously been elusive.

arXiv:math-ph/0412023•Physical Review Letters•Mar 2, 2005•85 citations
In 1947 Nikolai Bogoliubov founded the microscopic theory of superfluidity on a single operation: the zero-momentum mode's operators a_0, a_0^\dagger are replaced by the c-number \sqrt{N_0}, particle-number conservation is broken by hand, the Hamiltonian becomes quadratic, and its diagonalization returns the phonon spectrum E(k) = \sqrt{\epsilon_k^2 + 2gn\epsilon_k} on which superfluidity's microscopic basis stands. The paper's own warrant for the replacement is a size argument — the commutator 1 is small compared with a_0, a_0^* themselves — and a size argument is a regime statement, not a derivation. This paper evaluates the substitution with the theory's own arithmetic on declared inputs: the same diagonalization returns a quantum depletion of 1.682088 percent of the gas outside the condensate at the mildest declared coupling, 4.757664 percent at the central inputs, and 13.456707 percent at the strongest — the substitution's self-evaluated error bar, printed by its own computation — while the c-number discards the condensate mode's number fluctuations (relative spread 0.003333 at the declared central size) and commutator (1/N_0 = 0.000111) by decree, and the discarded third- and fourth-order terms return at the relative scale \sqrt{\gamma} = 0.031623. The spectrum, the sound speed, and superfluidity's basis are the 1947 paper's derivations and stand entire. What is counted here is the derivation status of the step they stand on: 1 c-number substitution carrying the discarded terms it makes necessary, 0 derivations in 1947 of the substitution. Census headline, unchanged: NOT SOLVED / PARTIAL · producing-count 0.
Presently there are two distinct classes of microscopic theories which describe a system of many identical spinless bosons. One is the Bogoliubov theory, which places special emphasis on the occupation of the zero-momentum state and as such depends explicitly on the number of particles in this state, N0{N}_{0}N0​. The other depends on density fluctuations to describe the fluid. In this work, we derive a modified version of the Bogoliubov theory which results in a number-conserving Hamiltonian with no explicit dependence on N0{N}_{0}N0​. The ground- and first-excited-state energies evaluated through second order in 1N12\frac{1}{{N}^{\frac{1}{2}}}N21​1​ are equivalent to the results of a variational-perturbative procedure based on the method of correlated basis functions in the uniform limit.
The idea of replacing the condensate operators by the ccc number N012{N}_{0}^{\frac{1}{2}}N021​​ in treating condensed Bose systems is known as Bogoliubov prescription (BP). Once BP is adopted, there are two ways to proceed. The first is the popular method of Hugenholtz and Pines, which we call $\ensuremath{\mu}$-fixed formalism. The second may be found in the well-known works of Foldy and Brueckner on a dense charged boson gas. Unlike the $\ensuremath{\mu}$-fixed formalism, the latter method does not require the introduction of the chemical potential, and thus it is called the NNN-fixed formalism. We argue that BP is rigorous in the $\ensuremath{\mu}$-fixed formalism but is not in the NNN-fixed one. BP in the NNN-fixed one gives correct results for terms of leading orders (Foldy and Brueckner took just these terms) but incorrect results for terms of higher orders.
This work is concerned with a microscopic model of a nonideal boson gas. The Hamiltonian is treated in a rigorous manner free of all approximations and, in particular, the Bogoliubov approximation of replacing the zero-momentum single-particle creation and destruction operators by a ccc number is entirely avoided. Utilizing a method due to Wentzel, the Hamiltonian is replaced by one involving products of two second quantized operators which, in general, can be diagonalized. This replacement is shown to be rigorously valid in the infinite volume limit for all temperatures despite the avoidance of the Bogoliubov approximation. It is found that the assumption of a positive-definite quasiparticle excitation spectrum $\ensuremath{\epsilon}(\mathrm{k})$ becomes untenable for temperatures TTT less than a critical value Tc{T}_{c}Tc​, if the interparticle potential is described by a certain kernel which possesses positive eigenvalues only, corresponding to a sufficiently repulsive interparticle force. Assuming that $\ensuremath{\epsilon}(\mathrm{k})=0$ only for k=0, it is found that for T<TcT<{T}_{c}T<Tc​ the system undergoes an Einstein condensation into the k=0 single-particle state, and the integral equations characterizing the system are precisely the same as would be obtained if the Bogoliubov approximation were made, proving within the framework of this model the strict validity of this approximation procedure. The well-known criterion for an Einstein condensation v(0)>0v(0)>0v(0)>0, where v(k)v(\mathrm{k})v(k) is the Fourier transform of the interparticle potential, is shown to be a weaker statement of our eigenvalue criterion. Further, in agreement with Girardeau and Arnowitt, it is found that an energy gap separates $\ensuremath{\epsilon}(0)$ and $\ensuremath{\epsilon}(\mathrm{k})$ for k>0k>0k>0. An approximation method is developed for solving the integral equations which describe those systems which undergo an Einstein condensation, and it is shown that this method can be justified if $|T\ensuremath{-}{T}_{c}|\ensuremath{\lesssim}\frac{{T}_{c}}{10}$, and in cases of short-range repulsive interparticle forces and systems for which $\ensuremath{\rho}v(0)$ possesses a certain prescribed upper bound, $\ensuremath{\rho}$ being the number of particles per unit volume. The transition temperature is found to be lower than the corresponding quantity for the ideal boson gas of the same density. A detailed discussion of the thermal properties of the system in the vicinity of Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ is also given. In an Appendix a general type of smeared Einstein condensation is assumed, and it is found that for systems in which this property occurs $\ensuremath{\epsilon}(\mathrm{k})$ is linear for small kkk. This ansatz is shown to be tenable only if v(0)<0v(0)<0v(0)<0. Finally, by assuming an appropriate pseudopotential representation of a hard repulsive core and by including a weak, longranged attractive force between particles, $\ensuremath{\epsilon}(\mathrm{k})$ shows a nonmonotonic behavior of the same qualitative type as observed in liquid He4{\mathrm{He}}^{4}He4.
We have developed a microscopic theory of superfluidity in a two-dimensional, slightly nonideal Bose gas. The theory is rooted in the fact that a number of bosons are concentrated in the small momentum region at low temperatures when the interaction is weak, in spite of the fact that there is no Bose condensate in the two-dimensional case when T≠0. This fact lets us reduce the description of the system from one employing creation ak+ and annihilation ak operators for bosons to one based on combinations of these operators ρk and φk(ρk = S−1Σqaq+aq+k, φk· = −(i/ns) Σ(kq/k2 + l)aq+aq+k, where n is the boson density, and S is the area of the system). The description in terms of ρk and φk is simple because the hamiltonian is quadratic with respect to ρk and φk. The operators ρk and φk can also be used to express the occupation number Nk = ak+ak and current operators. We find the elementary excitation spectrum (which is identical to the Bogolyubov spectrum) and the momentum distribution of the bosons. We calculate the normal density due to thermal oscillations in the Bose gas and to interactions with impurity centers in the substrate.
As is well-known, in the conventional formulation of Bogoliubov's theory of an interacting Bose gas, the Hamiltonian is written as a decoupled sum of contributions from different momenta of the form . Then, each of the single-mode Hamiltonians is diagonalized separately, and the resulting ground state wavefunction of the total Hamiltonian is written as a simple product of the ground state wavefunctions of each of the single-mode Hamiltonians . While this way of diagonalizing the total Hamiltonian may seem to be valid from the perspective of the standard, number non-conserving Bogoliubov's method, where the k = 0 state is removed from the Hilbert space and hence the individual Hilbert spaces where the Hamiltonians {} are diagonalized are disjoint from one another, we argue that from a number-conserving perspective this diagonalization method may not be adequate since the true Hilbert spaces where the Hamiltonians {} should be diagonalized all have the k = 0 state in common, and hence the ground state wavefunction of the total Hamiltonian may not be written as a simple product of the ground state wavefunctions of the 's. In this paper, we give a thorough review of Bogoliubov's method, and discuss a variational and number-conserving formulation of this theory in which the k = 0 state is restored to the Hilbert space of the interacting gas, and where, instead of diagonalizing the Hamiltonians separately, we diagonalize the total Hamiltonian . When this is done, we find that the ground state energy is lowered below the Bogoliubov result, and the depletion of bosons is significantly reduced with respect to the one obtained in the number non-conserving treatment. We also find that the spectrum of the usual αk excitations of Bogoliubov's method changes from a gapless one, as predicted by the standard, number non-conserving formulation of this theory, to one which exhibits a finite gap in the k → 0 limit. We discuss the presence of a gap in the spectrum of the αk's in light of Goldstone's theorem, and show that there is no contradiction with the latter.
The validity of substituting a c-number z for the k=0 mode operator a(0) is established rigorously in full generality, thereby verifying one aspect of Bogoliubov's 1947 theory. This substitution not only yields the correct value of thermodynamic quantities such as the pressure or ground state energy, but also the value of |z|(2) that maximizes the partition function equals the true amount of condensation in the presence of a gauge-symmetry-breaking term. This point had previously been elusive.