Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:cond-mat/0703498 · Progress of Theoretical Physics

Re-Examining Bogoliubov's Theory of an Interacting Bose Gas

A. M. Ettouhami

Published Mar 1, 2012• 16 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

As is well-known, in the conventional formulation of Bogoliubov's theory of an interacting Bose gas, the Hamiltonian is written as a decoupled sum of contributions from different momenta of the form . Then, each of the single-mode Hamiltonians is diagonalized separately, and the resulting ground state wavefunction of the total Hamiltonian is written as a simple product of the ground state wavefunctions of each of the single-mode Hamiltonians . While this way of diagonalizing the total Hamiltonian may seem to be valid from the perspective of the standard, number non-conserving Bogoliubov's method, where the k = 0 state is removed from the Hilbert space and hence the individual Hilbert spaces where the Hamiltonians {} are diagonalized are disjoint from one another, we argue that from a number-conserving perspective this diagonalization method may not be adequate since the true Hilbert spaces where the Hamiltonians {} should be diagonalized all have the k = 0 state in common, and hence the ground state wavefunction of the total Hamiltonian may not be written as a simple product of the ground state wavefunctions of the 's. In this paper, we give a thorough review of Bogoliubov's method, and discuss a variational and number-conserving formulation of this theory in which the k = 0 state is restored to the Hilbert space of the interacting gas, and where, instead of diagonalizing the Hamiltonians separately, we diagonalize the total Hamiltonian . When this is done, we find that the ground state energy is lowered below the Bogoliubov result, and the depletion of bosons is significantly reduced with respect to the one obtained in the number non-conserving treatment. We also find that the spectrum of the usual αk excitations of Bogoliubov's method changes from a gapless one, as predicted by the standard, number non-conserving formulation of this theory, to one which exhibits a finite gap in the k → 0 limit. We discuss the presence of a gap in the spectrum of the αk's in light of Goldstone's theorem, and show that there is no contradiction with the latter.

DOI
10.1143/ptp.127.453

Related papers

Nature of the Bogoliubov ground state of a weakly interacting Bose gas

A. M. Ettouhami

As is well-known, in Bogoliubov's theory of an interacting Bose gas the ground state of the Hamiltonian $\hat{H}=\sum_{\bf k\neq 0}\hat{H}_{\bf k}$ is found by diagonalizing each of the Hamiltonians $\hat{H}_{\bf k}$ corresponding to a given momentum mode ${\bf k}$ independently of the Hamiltonians $\hat{H}_{\bf k'(\neq k)}$ of the remaining modes. We argue that this way of diagonalizing $\hat{H}$ may not be adequate, since the Hilbert spaces where the single-mode Hamiltonians $\hat{H}_{\bf k}$ are diagonalized are not disjoint, but have the ${\bf k}=0$ in common. A number-conserving generalization of Bogoliubov's method is presented where the total Hamiltonian $\hat{H}$ is diagonalized directly. When this is done, the spectrum of excitations changes from a gapless one, as predicted by Bogoliubov's method, to one which has a finite gap in the $k\to 0$ limit.

arXiv:cond-mat/0702058•Feb 5, 2007•0 citations

Re-examining the Statistical Mechanics of an Interacting Bose Gas

A. M. Ettouhami

We re-examine the way in which Bogoliubov's theory of a dilute Bose gas at $T=0$ has been extended to describe the statistical mechanics of interacting bosons at finite temperature. We show explicitly that the field-theoretic calculation of the grand partition function in this formulation amounts to a canonical trace over the eigenfunctions of the Bogoliubov Hamiltonian at fixed total number of bosons $N$, and that the additional trace over $N$ that is required in the grand-canonical formalism is never carried out. This implies that what usually passes as the grand-canonical treatment of the Bogoliubov Hamiltonian is not quite grand-canonical, and is in fact a canonical one. We also show that the discontinuity in the condensate density predicted by previous formulations of this theory as the temperature $T$ goes past the critical transition temperature $T_c$ is a direct consequence of an inappropriate generalization of the Bogoliubov prescription to finite temperatures, and that this discontinuity disappears when this prescription is either used as a zero temperature approximation or avoided altogether. Armed with the above findings, we reformulate the statistical mechanics of interacting bosons in the canonical ensemble and derive the thermodynamics of the system. We then show how the canonical treatment can be used to setup a truly grand-canonical description of the statistical mechanics of a weakly interacting Bose gas where the average number of bosons in the system varies with temperature, unlike existing formulations where the total number of bosons $N$ is taken to be a constant that does not depend on $T$. Consequences on the physics of interacting bosons are briefly discussed.

arXiv:1702.00899•Feb 3, 2017•0 citations

N-particle Bogoliubov vacuum state

J. Dziarmaga, Krzysztof Sacha

We consider the Bogoliubov vacuum state in the number-conserving Bogoliubov theory proposed by Castin and Dum [Phys. Rev. A 57 , 3008 (1998)]. We show that, in the particle representation, the vacuum can be written in a simple diagonal form. The vacuum state can describe the stationary N -particle ground state of a condensate in a trap, but it can also represent a dynamical state when, for example, a Bose-Einstein condensate initially prepared in the stationary ground state is subject to a time-dependent perturbation. In both cases the diagonal form of the Bogoliubov vacuum can be obtained by basically diagonalizing the reduced single-particle density matrix of the vacuum. We compare N -body states obtained within the Bogoliubov theory with the exact ground states in a 3-site Bose-Hubbard model. In this example, the Bogoliubov theory fails to accurately describe the stationary ground state in the limit when N → ∞ but a small fraction of depleted particles is kept constant.

arXiv:cond-mat/0511580•Laser Physics•Jun 28, 2006•0 citations

Re-examining the quadratic approximation in theory of a weakly interacting Bose gas with condensate: the role of nonlocal interaction potentials

M. S. Bulakhov, A. S. Peletminskii, S V Peletminskii +2 more

Abstract We derive and analyze the coupled equations of quadratic approximation of the Bogoliubov model for a weakly interacting Bose gas. The first equation determines the condensate density as a variational parameter and ensures the minimum of the grand thermodynamic potential. The second one provides a relation between the total number of particles and chemical potential. Their consistent theoretical analysis is performed for a number of model interaction potentials including contact (local) and nonlocal interactions, where the latter provide nontrivial dependencies in momentum space. We demonstrate that the derived equations have no solutions for the local potential, although they formally reproduce the well-known results of the Bogoliubov approach. At the same time, it is shown that these equations have the solutions for physically relevant nonlocal potentials. We show that in the regimes close to experimental realizations with ultracold atoms, the contribution of the terms originating from the quadratic part of the truncated Hamiltonian to the chemical potential can be of the same order of magnitude as from its c -number part. Due to this fact, in particular, the spectrum of single-particle excitations in the quadratic approximation acquires a gap. The issue of the gap is also discussed.

arXiv:1804.10398•Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Sep 11, 2018•8 citations

The relation between the Gross–Pitaevskii and Bogoliubov descriptions of a dilute Bose gas

A. J. Leggett

I formulate a 'pseudo-paradox' in the theory of a dilute Bose gas with repulsive interactions: the standard expression for the ground state energy within the Gross–Pitaevskii (GP) approximation is lower than that in the Bogoliubov approximation, and hence, by the standard variational argument, the former should prima facie be a better approximation than the latter to the true ground state—a conclusion which is of course opposite to the established wisdom concerning this problem. It is shown that the pseudo-paradox is (unsurprisingly) resolved by a correct transcription of the two-body scattering theory to the many-body case; however, contrary to what appears to be a widespread belief, the resolution has nothing to do with any spurious ultraviolet divergences which result from the replacement of the true interatomic potential by a delta-function pseudopotential. Rather, it relates to an infrared divergence which has the consequence that (a) the most obvious form of the GP 'approximation' actually does not correspond to any well-defined ansatz for the many-body wavefunction, and (b) that the 'best shot' at such a wavefunction always produces an energy which exceeds, or at best equals, that calculated in the Bogoliubov approximation. In fact, the necessity of the latter may be seen as a consequence of the need to reduce the Fock term in the energy, which is absent in the two-particle problem but dominant in the many-body case; it does this by increasing the density correlations, at distances less than or approximately equal to the correlation length , above the value extrapolated from the two-body case. As a by-product I devise an alternative formulation of the Bogoliubov approximation which does not require the explicit replacement of the true interatomic potential by a delta-function pseudopotential.

New Journal of Physics•Jul 31, 2003•29 citations

Particle-number-conserving Bogoliubov method which demonstrates the validity of the time-dependent Gross-Pitaevskii equation for a highly condensed Bose gas

Crispin W. Gardiner

The Bogoliubov method for the excitation spectrum of a Bose-condensed gas is generalized to apply to a gas with an exact large number $N$ of particles. This generalization yields a description of the Schr\"odinger picture field operators as the product of an annihilation operator $A$ for the total number of particles and the sum of a ``condensate wave function'' $\ensuremath{\xi}(\mathbf{x})$ and a phonon field operator $\ensuremath{\chi}(\mathbf{x})$ in the form $\ensuremath{\psi}(\mathbf{x})\ensuremath{\approx}A{\ensuremath{\xi}(\mathbf{x})+\ensuremath{\chi}(\mathbf{x})/\sqrt{N}}$ when the field operator acts on the $N$ particle subspace. It is then possible to expand the Hamiltonian in decreasing powers of $\sqrt{N}$, and thus obtain solutions for eigenvalues and eigenstates as an asymptotic expansion of the same kind. It is also possible to compute all matrix elements of field operators between states of different $N$. The excitation spectrum can be obtained by essentially the same method as Bogoliubov only if $\ensuremath{\xi}(\mathbf{x})$ is a solution of the time-independent Gross-Pitaevskii equation for $N$ particles and any chemical potential $\ensuremath{\mu}$, which yields a valid and stable solution of the Gross-Pitaevskii equation. The treatment within a subspace of fixed $N$ is identical in form to that usually used, but the interpretation of the operators is slightly different. A time-dependent generalization is then made, yielding an asymptotic expansion in decreasing powers of $\sqrt{N}$ for the equations of motion. In this expansion the condensate wave function has the time-dependent form $\ensuremath{\xi}(\mathbf{x},t)$, and the condition for the validity of the expansion is that $\ensuremath{\xi}(\mathbf{x},t)$ satisfies the time-dependent Gross-Pitaevskii equation $\ensuremath{\partial}\ensuremath{\xi}/\ensuremath{\partial}t=\ensuremath{-}({\ensuremath{\Elzxh}}^{2}/2m){\ensuremath{\nabla}}^{2}\ensuremath{\xi}+V\ensuremath{\xi}+Nu|\ensuremath{\xi}{|}^{2}\ensuremath{\xi}$. The physics is then described in a kind of interaction picture, called the condensate picture, in which the phonon operator can be expressed as $\ensuremath{\chi}(\mathbf{x},t)={\ensuremath{\sum}}_{k}{\ensuremath{\xi}}_{k}(\mathbf{x},t){\ensuremath{\alpha}}_{k},$ where the operators ${\ensuremath{\alpha}}_{k}$ are time-independent annihilation operators, and the state vector has a time evolution described by a Schr\"odinger equation in which the Hamiltonian is a time-dependent quadratic form in the phonon creation and annihilation operators, whose coefficients are explicitly determined in terms of the time-dependent condensate wave function $\ensuremath{\xi}(\mathbf{x},t)$.

arXiv:quant-ph/9703005•Physical Review A•Aug 1, 1997•256 citations
As is well-known, in the conventional formulation of Bogoliubov's theory of an interacting Bose gas, the Hamiltonian is written as a decoupled sum of contributions from different momenta of the form . Then, each of the single-mode Hamiltonians is diagonalized separately, and the resulting ground state wavefunction of the total Hamiltonian is written as a simple product of the ground state wavefunctions of each of the single-mode Hamiltonians . While this way of diagonalizing the total Hamiltonian may seem to be valid from the perspective of the standard, number non-conserving Bogoliubov's method, where the k = 0 state is removed from the Hilbert space and hence the individual Hilbert spaces where the Hamiltonians {} are diagonalized are disjoint from one another, we argue that from a number-conserving perspective this diagonalization method may not be adequate since the true Hilbert spaces where the Hamiltonians {} should be diagonalized all have the k = 0 state in common, and hence the ground state wavefunction of the total Hamiltonian may not be written as a simple product of the ground state wavefunctions of the 's. In this paper, we give a thorough review of Bogoliubov's method, and discuss a variational and number-conserving formulation of this theory in which the k = 0 state is restored to the Hilbert space of the interacting gas, and where, instead of diagonalizing the Hamiltonians separately, we diagonalize the total Hamiltonian . When this is done, we find that the ground state energy is lowered below the Bogoliubov result, and the depletion of bosons is significantly reduced with respect to the one obtained in the number non-conserving treatment. We also find that the spectrum of the usual αk excitations of Bogoliubov's method changes from a gapless one, as predicted by the standard, number non-conserving formulation of this theory, to one which exhibits a finite gap in the k → 0 limit. We discuss the presence of a gap in the spectrum of the αk's in light of Goldstone's theorem, and show that there is no contradiction with the latter.
As is well-known, in Bogoliubov's theory of an interacting Bose gas the ground state of the Hamiltonian H^=∑k≠0H^k\hat{H}=\sum_{\bf k\neq 0}\hat{H}_{\bf k}H^=∑k=0​H^k​ is found by diagonalizing each of the Hamiltonians H^k\hat{H}_{\bf k}H^k​ corresponding to a given momentum mode k{\bf k}k independently of the Hamiltonians H^k′(≠k)\hat{H}_{\bf k'(\neq k)}H^k′(=k)​ of the remaining modes. We argue that this way of diagonalizing H^\hat{H}H^ may not be adequate, since the Hilbert spaces where the single-mode Hamiltonians H^k\hat{H}_{\bf k}H^k​ are diagonalized are not disjoint, but have the k=0{\bf k}=0k=0 in common. A number-conserving generalization of Bogoliubov's method is presented where the total Hamiltonian H^\hat{H}H^ is diagonalized directly. When this is done, the spectrum of excitations changes from a gapless one, as predicted by Bogoliubov's method, to one which has a finite gap in the k→0k\to 0k→0 limit.
We re-examine the way in which Bogoliubov's theory of a dilute Bose gas at T=0T=0T=0 has been extended to describe the statistical mechanics of interacting bosons at finite temperature. We show explicitly that the field-theoretic calculation of the grand partition function in this formulation amounts to a canonical trace over the eigenfunctions of the Bogoliubov Hamiltonian at fixed total number of bosons NNN, and that the additional trace over NNN that is required in the grand-canonical formalism is never carried out. This implies that what usually passes as the grand-canonical treatment of the Bogoliubov Hamiltonian is not quite grand-canonical, and is in fact a canonical one. We also show that the discontinuity in the condensate density predicted by previous formulations of this theory as the temperature TTT goes past the critical transition temperature TcT_cTc​ is a direct consequence of an inappropriate generalization of the Bogoliubov prescription to finite temperatures, and that this discontinuity disappears when this prescription is either used as a zero temperature approximation or avoided altogether. Armed with the above findings, we reformulate the statistical mechanics of interacting bosons in the canonical ensemble and derive the thermodynamics of the system. We then show how the canonical treatment can be used to setup a truly grand-canonical description of the statistical mechanics of a weakly interacting Bose gas where the average number of bosons in the system varies with temperature, unlike existing formulations where the total number of bosons NNN is taken to be a constant that does not depend on TTT. Consequences on the physics of interacting bosons are briefly discussed.
We consider the Bogoliubov vacuum state in the number-conserving Bogoliubov theory proposed by Castin and Dum [Phys. Rev. A 57 , 3008 (1998)]. We show that, in the particle representation, the vacuum can be written in a simple diagonal form. The vacuum state can describe the stationary N -particle ground state of a condensate in a trap, but it can also represent a dynamical state when, for example, a Bose-Einstein condensate initially prepared in the stationary ground state is subject to a time-dependent perturbation. In both cases the diagonal form of the Bogoliubov vacuum can be obtained by basically diagonalizing the reduced single-particle density matrix of the vacuum. We compare N -body states obtained within the Bogoliubov theory with the exact ground states in a 3-site Bose-Hubbard model. In this example, the Bogoliubov theory fails to accurately describe the stationary ground state in the limit when N → ∞ but a small fraction of depleted particles is kept constant.
Abstract We derive and analyze the coupled equations of quadratic approximation of the Bogoliubov model for a weakly interacting Bose gas. The first equation determines the condensate density as a variational parameter and ensures the minimum of the grand thermodynamic potential. The second one provides a relation between the total number of particles and chemical potential. Their consistent theoretical analysis is performed for a number of model interaction potentials including contact (local) and nonlocal interactions, where the latter provide nontrivial dependencies in momentum space. We demonstrate that the derived equations have no solutions for the local potential, although they formally reproduce the well-known results of the Bogoliubov approach. At the same time, it is shown that these equations have the solutions for physically relevant nonlocal potentials. We show that in the regimes close to experimental realizations with ultracold atoms, the contribution of the terms originating from the quadratic part of the truncated Hamiltonian to the chemical potential can be of the same order of magnitude as from its c -number part. Due to this fact, in particular, the spectrum of single-particle excitations in the quadratic approximation acquires a gap. The issue of the gap is also discussed.
I formulate a 'pseudo-paradox' in the theory of a dilute Bose gas with repulsive interactions: the standard expression for the ground state energy within the Gross–Pitaevskii (GP) approximation is lower than that in the Bogoliubov approximation, and hence, by the standard variational argument, the former should prima facie be a better approximation than the latter to the true ground state—a conclusion which is of course opposite to the established wisdom concerning this problem. It is shown that the pseudo-paradox is (unsurprisingly) resolved by a correct transcription of the two-body scattering theory to the many-body case; however, contrary to what appears to be a widespread belief, the resolution has nothing to do with any spurious ultraviolet divergences which result from the replacement of the true interatomic potential by a delta-function pseudopotential. Rather, it relates to an infrared divergence which has the consequence that (a) the most obvious form of the GP 'approximation' actually does not correspond to any well-defined ansatz for the many-body wavefunction, and (b) that the 'best shot' at such a wavefunction always produces an energy which exceeds, or at best equals, that calculated in the Bogoliubov approximation. In fact, the necessity of the latter may be seen as a consequence of the need to reduce the Fock term in the energy, which is absent in the two-particle problem but dominant in the many-body case; it does this by increasing the density correlations, at distances less than or approximately equal to the correlation length , above the value extrapolated from the two-body case. As a by-product I devise an alternative formulation of the Bogoliubov approximation which does not require the explicit replacement of the true interatomic potential by a delta-function pseudopotential.
The Bogoliubov method for the excitation spectrum of a Bose-condensed gas is generalized to apply to a gas with an exact large number NNN of particles. This generalization yields a description of the Schr\"odinger picture field operators as the product of an annihilation operator AAA for the total number of particles and the sum of a ``condensate wave function'' $\ensuremath{\xi}(\mathbf{x})$ and a phonon field operator $\ensuremath{\chi}(\mathbf{x})$ in the form $\ensuremath{\psi}(\mathbf{x})\ensuremath{\approx}A{\ensuremath{\xi}(\mathbf{x})+\ensuremath{\chi}(\mathbf{x})/\sqrt{N}}$ when the field operator acts on the NNN particle subspace. It is then possible to expand the Hamiltonian in decreasing powers of N\sqrt{N}N​, and thus obtain solutions for eigenvalues and eigenstates as an asymptotic expansion of the same kind. It is also possible to compute all matrix elements of field operators between states of different NNN. The excitation spectrum can be obtained by essentially the same method as Bogoliubov only if $\ensuremath{\xi}(\mathbf{x})$ is a solution of the time-independent Gross-Pitaevskii equation for NNN particles and any chemical potential $\ensuremath{\mu}$, which yields a valid and stable solution of the Gross-Pitaevskii equation. The treatment within a subspace of fixed NNN is identical in form to that usually used, but the interpretation of the operators is slightly different. A time-dependent generalization is then made, yielding an asymptotic expansion in decreasing powers of N\sqrt{N}N​ for the equations of motion. In this expansion the condensate wave function has the time-dependent form $\ensuremath{\xi}(\mathbf{x},t)$, and the condition for the validity of the expansion is that $\ensuremath{\xi}(\mathbf{x},t)$ satisfies the time-dependent Gross-Pitaevskii equation $\ensuremath{\partial}\ensuremath{\xi}/\ensuremath{\partial}t=\ensuremath{-}({\ensuremath{\Elzxh}}^{2}/2m){\ensuremath{\nabla}}^{2}\ensuremath{\xi}+V\ensuremath{\xi}+Nu|\ensuremath{\xi}{|}^{2}\ensuremath{\xi}$. The physics is then described in a kind of interaction picture, called the condensate picture, in which the phonon operator can be expressed as $\ensuremath{\chi}(\mathbf{x},t)={\ensuremath{\sum}}_{k}{\ensuremath{\xi}}_{k}(\mathbf{x},t){\ensuremath{\alpha}}_{k},$ where the operators ${\ensuremath{\alpha}}_{k}$ are time-independent annihilation operators, and the state vector has a time evolution described by a Schr\"odinger equation in which the Hamiltonian is a time-dependent quadratic form in the phonon creation and annihilation operators, whose coefficients are explicitly determined in terms of the time-dependent condensate wave function $\ensuremath{\xi}(\mathbf{x},t)$.