Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Pre-registration: are successive single-electron hits in a double-slit build-up statistically independent?

Romans Sereda

Published Nov 4, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Analysis plan fixed before any raw data are seen. Question: are successive single-electron hits in a double-slit build-up (Bach et al. 2013, NJP 15, 033018, if the authors share the raw data) statistically independent in time and place? Primary statistic: Fano factor of hit counts in 0.2-30 s windows; secondary: spatial clustering, lag correlations of positions, day/night split. Controls for source drift, detector artefacts and a shuffle test; decision rules stated in advance. A speculative 'threshold detachment' picture predicts excess clustering near the noise correlation time; standard quantum mechanics with a Poisson source predicts F = 1. This is a test plan, not a claim. Toy-model code attached (h234_threshold_release.py).

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.23947075

Related papers

Can the impact point of a single electron be predictedfrom its launch point? Deterministic guidance,wave-source geometryand constraints from existing experiments

Modhar Mohammed Torki Msliki, Fawaz Modhar Maliki

We ask whether the impact point of an individual electron in an interference experimentcan be predicted from its launch point, and what precision this would require. Particlesare described deterministically, guided by the ux of the wave as in the de BroglieBohmformulation, and wave sources are placed according to the base table of a directional-productmodel, xk,n = s ck + Cn with eight levels c = (0, 1, 1.5, 2.5, 3, 4, 5.5, 6). A simulation of thecontrolled electron double-slit experiment of Bach et al., with the electron wavelength writtenas the directional product (pc)2 = K(K + 2mec2), reproduces the interference pattern fromdeterministic, non-crossing paths (correlation 0.98), but shows that launch points spreadover one slit (54 nm) reach six fringes: predicting the fringe of a single electron requires itsposition in the slit plane to be known to about 5 nm. Propagating this requirement back toa nanotip source with the measured eective radius of 0.550.80 nm gives a required launchprecision of 0.48 pm for source-to-object distances of 0.11 mm at 600 eV, far below atomicdimensions. A review of single-electron experiments shows that sources already localise theemission point to below 1 nm without destroying coherence, and that single electrons fromsuch sources still arrive at dierent fringes; no experiment records the in-wave launch positionthat a deterministic prediction would need. A repeat-launch simulation shows why: xing thelaunch position by a measurement of 5 nm (1 nm) precision spreads the impacts over 4.3 (22)fringes and lowers the correlation with the interference pattern from 0.996 to 0.46 (−0.05).Within pilot-wave theory an individual prediction is therefore possible only for an ensembleout of quantum equilibrium, and the proposed test is a test of quantum non-equilibrium.We identify which existing data (per-pulse emission times and arrival positions) can testtiming-based prediction rules, and summarise a pre-registration protocol for a decisive test,in which the prediction rule is to be xed before any data are taken.

•Oct 1, 2026•0 citations

Can Quantum Interference Arise from the Dynamics of Time? A Matter-Free Local Time-Rate Field Study

Mitsuhiro Kobayashi

Can two-path quantum-interference phenomenology be understood as a property of a local time-rate field before an individual result is fixed? We investigate this question in a matter-free effective dynamical branch of the Enchan framework. A real local time-rate field, initialized with field and velocity data, propagates through two apertures and produces a non-additive, oscillatory screen-energy-flux pattern without primitive particles, a primitive wavefunction, Born weights, or a collapse operation. Its normalized cross term is 0.533636, 0.529264, and 0.526779 on three successively refined grids. A linear-response control retains the effect, identifying a broader coherent-field mechanism. We then evolve a coupled field/path-tag model in which the passing field writes opposite tag orientations near the two slits. Across a frozen five-strength sweep, the independently measured route-tag overlap and unresolved interference decrease together; their Pearson correlations are 0.996786 and 0.998675 on two numerical levels. The screen is computed from the evolved fields without multiplying a reference fringe by a tag-overlap factor. The additional tag channel and slit-local antisymmetric coupling are explicit minimal model assumptions, not a unique derivation from the canonical scalar ontology. The physical comparisons are route removal, path tagging with both routes open, and localized screen recording. A half-amplitude control reduces flux to 24.64% while retaining the normalized cross term. A third calculation reuses the exact Q0 field and defines a nonnegative screen event measure from the accumulated positive forward energy flux, J_+(y) = integral max(F_E,x, 0) dt. One localized screen coordinate is drawn per independent preparation from the normalized $J_+$ distribution. In a fixed 600-event realization, the binned hit histogram has Pearson correlation 0.9553 and total-variation distance 0.0949 relative to the binned event measure. This finite-sample agreement is a consistency check of the explicit forward-flux readout, not an independent validation and not a derivation of the Born rule. Interference, path-tagging, and one-hit event realization are therefore supported at their separately stated model levels, while microscopic detector selection and experimental confirmation of the proposed ontology are outside the scope of this study. The release includes the manuscript PDF, a standalone reproducibility ZIP with manuscript sources, frozen numerical solvers and inputs, lightweight results and figures, an English reproduction manual, LICENSE, and SHA-256 checksums. The manuscript is dated 18 September 2026. No private repository, external dataset, or GPU is required. Enchan Research & Verification License v1.0. Copyright (c) 2026 Mitsuhiro Kobayashi. All rights reserved.

•Sep 19, 2026•1 citation

Pre-registration: a calibrated test of the independence premise of fault tolerance on public QEC syndrome data (premise meter, frozen protocol)

Aarush Das Bansiwal

Version 2: pre-registration addendum for Phase D Outcome of the registered gate (G0) The G0 gate failed for every dataset, window family and null. No twin built from independent error mechanisms with circuit-local supports reproduces the bulk of the window-count distributions in the public data from Google Willow, Google Sycamore or Rigetti. For larger codes the twin cannot even be simulated. As the protocol requires, hypotheses H1–H3 are therefore not tested. This version adds pre-registration addendum 1. It fixes the analyses run instead, before either touches the test halves: • Model-free certificate (T3), on the test halves. It covers every registered configuration that has a circuit (the Google archives and Rigetti D6e). Windows are whole-patch windows of 1 and of 5 rounds, separated by one unused round, and the disjointness of their fault-location sets is checked from each circuit. Each stratum (archive, code family, code distance, window family) gets a premise curve ε_lo(k) on the grid k = c·j, j = 1–16, with Bonferroni correction at family-wise α = 0.05.• Threshold values for the certificate. ε* = 7.4 × 10⁻⁴ (Fowler, PRL 109, 180502, 2012) is the primary value; 2.73 × 10⁻⁵ (Aliferis, Gottesman and Preskill, QIC 6, 97, 2006) is a sensitivity check. Certificates against ε* are computed for surface-code strata only. Repetition-code, colour-code and stability strata get premise curves only.• Bursts. The primary analysis uses all windows; a secondary one excludes the windows flagged by the frozen burst classifier. B1/B2 event rates are reported descriptively.• Cat-qubit case study (exploratory). The model-based premise meter is applied to the AWS cat-qubit (D4) distance-3 configurations whose twin was simulable in G0. It reports R(k) intervals and k_cert, with the H1 reading (consistent if R_hi ≤ 3 for all k ≤ k_cert). It is labelled exploratory because D4's own G0 verdict is a fail. Status of the data when version 2 was created G0, which uses only the bulk bins, has run on the test halves. Its stored histograms include tail bins, but no tail statistic has been computed or examined. Both new analyses were dry-run on fit halves as pipeline checks. One choice was made after that dry run, and it is recorded in the addendum: ε* certificates were limited to surface-code strata, and strata were split by code family. The dry run had shown repetition-code and stability strata crossing ε* at k = c, i.e. at their base error rate, where Fowler's surface-code theorem does not apply. The model-based certification horizon is not computed, because it needs a twin tail. Files added in version 2 • phaseD_addendum.json: the machine-readable addendum. SHA-256: a458bcb40aa474d94a882a563a38a1a152d7bfb4404df9299f99fb020ab78834• ADDENDUM.md: the readable version of the addendum.• qpremise_code_phaseD_ade59b0.zip: the code that will run. The addendum's code_sha256 (794122ae1557c009664127e1c2e6b109781d5a71efcc566bc637b991c0403ab6) can be recomputed from it as the SHA-256 over the files matching qpremise/**/*.py, phaseD/scripts/*.py and phaseC/scripts/run_g0.py, taken in path order: each file's relative path, then its bytes with LF line endings.• SHA256SUMS_addendum.txt: checksums of the three files above. The version 1 files are unchanged. The original registration text follows. ──────────────────────────── Version 1 registration (2026-10-01) What this registers The analysis protocol of the premise meter. It tests whether public quantum-error-correction syndrome data agree with an independent-noise "twin" fitted to the same data. It also measures how far each dataset can certify the local-stochastic premise of the threshold theorem. Every analysis choice is fixed in frozen_protocol.json:• configuration eligibility, and the pre-registered subset in g0_selection.json;• the interleaved fit/test split;• the window families;• twin construction: candidate mechanisms from each circuit, an exact parity-moment fit, and a signed quasi-probability simulation with local weights;• the G0 gate decision rule;• the burst classifiers B1 and B2 with their validation targets;• the excess-tail-ratio interval and the certification-horizon conditions;• the model-free certificate's window rule. qpremise_code_at_freeze_79dbf14.zip holds the analysis code at the freeze. The protocol's code_sha256 can be recomputed from it: the SHA-256 over every qpremise/**/*.py file in path order, each file's relative path followed by its bytes with LF line endings. Hypotheses analysed after this registration (on test halves only) H1. After removing windows flagged by the frozen burst classifier, the excess tail ratio R(k) = P_obs(K ≥ k) / P_twin(K ≥ k) has an upper 95% confidence bound ≤ 3 for all k ≤ k_cert. Failure: a lower bound > 3 that replicates on the held-out half. H2. Including burst windows, R(k) > 10 for k ≥ k_b in at least one dataset, and a burst-mixture model fitted to the flagged windows predicts the published repetition-code error floor within a factor of 10. H3. The empirical horizon (power ≥ 0.8 at α = 0.05 against a factor-5 excess) agrees with the exact binomial computation within ±1. At least one dataset certifies k ≥ 10 in whole-patch windows. These are evaluated only on (dataset, window family) pairs that pass the G0 gate under both the stationary (N1) and drift-aware (N5) twins. The model-free certificate (T3) does not depend on the twin. Its threshold ε* is fixed before any certificate is computed. Timing and what had been seen Frozen 2026-10-01 17:31 IST (git commit 79dbf14). Before the freeze, only fit halves had been analysed. The G0 gate (bulk of the window-count distributions only; decision rule frozen) began on the test halves minutes after the freeze. When this record was created, no tail statistic (R(k), H1–H3, burst rates, certificates) had been computed from the test halves, and their tail bins had not been examined. The planned cloud-hardware contrast experiment (H4, H5) is not part of this registration and will be registered separately before any hardware run. Full details are in PREREGISTRATION.md. Protocol SHA-256: 5f7458cfdbe0e203fd9e2bf5d579703509c8374bae53096c37f8f1530540707a

•Oct 1, 2026•0 citations

Statistics of simultaneous macroscopic detection of electrons at both slits of a double-slit experiment

Satish Ramakrishna

Abstract In the standard double-slit experiment, the interaction between the electron and a detector at either of the slits is supposed to be local. However, one never notices a situation where the electron is detected at both slits simultaneously in the frame of the observer. This is usually explained by the statement that there is only one electron that is being located and it obviously cannot actually be located in two places at the same time in the observer's frame of reference. However, this is a global constraint, which is hard to understand when the interaction between the electron and a measurement device at a particular slit is completely local - how would the measuring device realize that there was only one electron that was to be detected? It would be useful to deduce this from purely local interactions at each slit, even with detectors at each slit, without having to adduce assumptions about long-range correlations between (potentially) space-like separated events. In this paper, we start with a Hamiltonian that was studied in a previous paper on the measurement problem, with a local interaction between the electron and a detector - here we assume that there is a detector at each slit. We study this problem numerically and also make a theoretical argument that the detection problem is exactly the same as that of the problem of equilibration of a macroscopic number of coupled harmonic oscillators. At each detector, as the measurement happens, the amplitude for each of the states of the measuring apparata relaxes to an equilibrium configuration akin to the equilibration of a thermodynamic system. The problem of the detection of the electron at each slit is then mapped to the motion of a random walker in a line with reflecting barriers at both ends, where the ends are separated by a macroscopic number of steps. This connection to a well-studied mathematical problem has a well-understood consequence - two (or a finite number of) random walkers in this space will be expected to be separated by a macroscopic number of steps. Hence, only one of the detectors will see a macroscopic number of its detection degrees of freedom affected - ergo, only one of the detectors, selected completely at random, will "see" the electron. For a large, macroscopic, though finite-sized measurement device, there will be a vanishingly small chance of detecting the electron simultaneously at both slits. Indeed, in the limit of an infinitely massive detector, we will never detect the electron at two places at the same time. This problem also illustrates further that the systematic application of Schrödinger's equation along with a local interaction Hamiltonian that effectively represents the measurement process helps solve some curious issues in the quantum measurement problem.

•Oct 12, 2022•0 citations

Pre-registration: Symmetry-Dependent Quantum Birthmark on ibm_kingston

Amit Brahmbhatt

Note: description expanded on 2026-10-14 for readability. It adds no new predictions or criteria. The frozen pre-registration is the attached PDF, unchanged since publication. Status: the experiment was run on 2026-10-14, after this record was published. Results, including every pre-registered test, will be reported in a separate record linked here. In plain language Theory says a quantum system never completely forgets where it started, even when its dynamics are chaotic. This leftover memory is called a quantum birthmark (Graf et al., Phys. Rev. X, 2026). Theory also says the birthmark should be larger when the system's rules run the same forwards and backwards in time (time-reversal symmetry) than when that symmetry is broken. This record pre-registers a test of that prediction on IBM's ibm_kingston quantum processor. We built two nearly identical sets of 4-qubit circuits. One set has time-reversal symmetry and the other does not. Both use exactly the same gates, so they experience the same hardware noise. We measure how often each circuit returns to its starting state, compared with the 1-in-16 chance level, and predict that the symmetric set shows about 1.67× more memory than the broken set. All predictions, pass/fail criteria, circuits and analysis code were deposited here before any quantum hardware was used. What is tested, and what is not Tested: whether the return probability stays above the ergodic baseline 1/16 at depths 8–23, and whether that excess is larger for the time-reversal-symmetric class by the ratio exact numerics predict for these fixed instances. Not tested: the withdrawn temporal-memory claims of 10.5281/zenodo.20470129. The birthmark is closed-system coherent memory, which measurement and reset erase, so no outcome here bears on those claims. Not tested: the universal random-matrix value 1.889. At this size (N = 16) the circuit family itself gives about 1.66, so a finite-size difference is expected. Not a quantum-advantage claim: a 16-dimensional system is exactly simulable. This is a hardware-validation experiment. Design Hardware: ibm_kingston, physical qubits 108–109–118–129 as an open chain, selected by a no-QPU calibration audit (included as v6_backend_audit.zip). Circuits: a kicked-Ising Floquet period Kx(a/2) → D(h1) → Kx(b) → D(h2) → Kx(a/2), with D(h) = exp(−iΣhiZi)·exp(−iπ/4 ΣZiZj), at exactly 6 CZ per period. COE (symmetric): h1 = h2. TRSB (broken): h1 = h + d, h2 = h − d. The classes differ only in virtual-Z angles. Instances: 16 seeded COE/TRSB pairs (seed 20261013), run at every depth from 8 to 23 (48–138 CZ). Observable: P(t) = |⟨0000|Ft|0000⟩|². The primary statistic is the readout-mitigated excess ratio R = ECOE / ETRSB, where E is the mean of P(t) − 1/16. A noise fidelity common to both classes cancels in R. Controls: 32 deep circuits (depths 60–63) as a decoherence-floor check. 8 state-preparation monitors. 16 readout-calibration circuits. Run: one SamplerV2 job of 568 circuits at 256 shots each, with dynamical decoupling and twirling off and the execution order shuffled. Predictions Quantity COE TRSB R Excess over 1/16, depths 8–23 (noiseless, primary) 0.0896 0.0537 1.667 Same instances, infinite-time limit 0.0952 0.0634 1.502 Circuit family, 10,000 random draws — — 1.661 Random-matrix reference, N = 16 — — 1.889 Under four simulated noise models (nominal, pessimistic, and each with coherent errors), the mitigated R stays between 1.64 and 1.77. The shot-noise standard deviation of R at 256 shots is 0.070–0.125. Pre-registered decision criteria Test Pass condition H1 (primary): symmetry dependence 99% CI lower bound of R > 1.0 H2 (primary): quantitative agreement 99% CI of R intersects 1.54–1.87 and is at most 1.0 wide S1: birthmark above decohered floor Window excess minus depth 60–63 excess, 99% CI lower bound > 0, for both classes S2: matched fidelity between classes 0.85 ≤ FCOE/FTRSB ≤ 1.15 S3: instance-level agreement Pearson r ≥ 0.80 against exact predictions S4 (flag only): state prep and drift Monitors ≥ 0.95, drift ≤ 0.045 Overall verdict: CONFIRMED if H1, H2 and S2 all pass; PARTIAL if H1 passes but H2 or S2 fails; NOT CONFIRMED if H1 fails. Every test is reported whatever the outcome. Uncertainty comes from a 10,000-sample parametric multinomial bootstrap over every circuit's counts, with instances held fixed. Amendment 1 (v1.1.0, made before any data) Amendment 1 changed two things relative to v1.0.0 (10.5281/zenodo.23355804): Shots: reduced from 1024 to 256 per circuit for QPU budget, cutting estimated execution from about 152 s to about 38 s. H2: changed from "point estimate in 1.54–1.87" to the CI rule above, because at 256 shots the point rule would falsely fail 20–25% of the time under the pessimistic models. A CI-width cap of 1.0 keeps H2 informative. Circuits, instances and predictions are unchanged. The trade-off is that H2 is now a weaker test. Provenance Every reported number is derived by script from raw counts: Source and transpiled circuits are saved as QPY. Before submission, every transpiled circuit is mapped back to 4 qubits and its unitary checked against the exact model to < 10−8. The analysis reads its decision bands only from predictions.json and its data only from the raw results file. Submission is gated on the DOI of this record. Files: The PDF is the authoritative pre-registration. predictions.json holds every predicted number and decision band. birthmark_prereg_v1.1.0.zip contains the circuit builder, verification, submission and frozen analysis scripts, plus simulated-data self-tests. v6_backend_audit.zip is the pre-submission calibration audit. Known limitations Small system size (N = 16), so the random-matrix value is not expected. The prediction is specific to depths 8–23 and to these 16 fixed instances. The noise models exclude leakage, TLS fluctuations and crosstalk from outside the chain. T1 relaxation biases P(0000) upward, which pulls R toward 1 (conservative). One backend, one path, one job: no replication. Data: CC BY 4.0. Code: MIT. Principal investigator: Amit Brahmbhatt, Quantum-Clarity LLC.

•Oct 14, 2026•0 citations

Detection statistics in a double-double-slit experiment

MohammadJavad Kazemi, Vahid Hosseinzadeh

In this paper, we analyze the statistics of detection data in a general double-double-slit experiment. The two particles are detected at random times which are not equal in general and because we do not have any constraint on the distances of left and right screens from their slits and the ratio they can be detected in completely different timescales. As the detection of the first particle leads to collapse of the wave function, there is no a straightforward and agreed-upon method to study this problem in the orthodox formalism which lacks a clear prediction of these random events and therefore the quantum state afterward. This is not the case in the Bohmian framework which we implement in this paper, and we can predict the system up to the end of experiment. The main result is the joint distribution of detection data including the arrival time and position of the particles on left and right screens. As one of the main consequences, we see that although the joint spatial distribution can be affected by a change to the relative location of screens, the marginals on each side remain intact, compatible with signal locality. At the end, we see how this result is very sensitive to quantum equilibrium conditions.

arXiv:2208.01325•Physical Review A•Jan 31, 2023•11 citations
Analysis plan fixed before any raw data are seen. Question: are successive single-electron hits in a double-slit build-up (Bach et al. 2013, NJP 15, 033018, if the authors share the raw data) statistically independent in time and place? Primary statistic: Fano factor of hit counts in 0.2-30 s windows; secondary: spatial clustering, lag correlations of positions, day/night split. Controls for source drift, detector artefacts and a shuffle test; decision rules stated in advance. A speculative 'threshold detachment' picture predicts excess clustering near the noise correlation time; standard quantum mechanics with a Poisson source predicts F = 1. This is a test plan, not a claim. Toy-model code attached (h234_threshold_release.py).
We ask whether the impact point of an individual electron in an interference experimentcan be predicted from its launch point, and what precision this would require. Particlesare described deterministically, guided by the ux of the wave as in the de BroglieBohmformulation, and wave sources are placed according to the base table of a directional-productmodel, xk,n = s ck + Cn with eight levels c = (0, 1, 1.5, 2.5, 3, 4, 5.5, 6). A simulation of thecontrolled electron double-slit experiment of Bach et al., with the electron wavelength writtenas the directional product (pc)2 = K(K + 2mec2), reproduces the interference pattern fromdeterministic, non-crossing paths (correlation 0.98), but shows that launch points spreadover one slit (54 nm) reach six fringes: predicting the fringe of a single electron requires itsposition in the slit plane to be known to about 5 nm. Propagating this requirement back toa nanotip source with the measured eective radius of 0.550.80 nm gives a required launchprecision of 0.48 pm for source-to-object distances of 0.11 mm at 600 eV, far below atomicdimensions. A review of single-electron experiments shows that sources already localise theemission point to below 1 nm without destroying coherence, and that single electrons fromsuch sources still arrive at dierent fringes; no experiment records the in-wave launch positionthat a deterministic prediction would need. A repeat-launch simulation shows why: xing thelaunch position by a measurement of 5 nm (1 nm) precision spreads the impacts over 4.3 (22)fringes and lowers the correlation with the interference pattern from 0.996 to 0.46 (−0.05).Within pilot-wave theory an individual prediction is therefore possible only for an ensembleout of quantum equilibrium, and the proposed test is a test of quantum non-equilibrium.We identify which existing data (per-pulse emission times and arrival positions) can testtiming-based prediction rules, and summarise a pre-registration protocol for a decisive test,in which the prediction rule is to be xed before any data are taken.
Can two-path quantum-interference phenomenology be understood as a property of a local time-rate field before an individual result is fixed? We investigate this question in a matter-free effective dynamical branch of the Enchan framework. A real local time-rate field, initialized with field and velocity data, propagates through two apertures and produces a non-additive, oscillatory screen-energy-flux pattern without primitive particles, a primitive wavefunction, Born weights, or a collapse operation. Its normalized cross term is 0.533636, 0.529264, and 0.526779 on three successively refined grids. A linear-response control retains the effect, identifying a broader coherent-field mechanism. We then evolve a coupled field/path-tag model in which the passing field writes opposite tag orientations near the two slits. Across a frozen five-strength sweep, the independently measured route-tag overlap and unresolved interference decrease together; their Pearson correlations are 0.996786 and 0.998675 on two numerical levels. The screen is computed from the evolved fields without multiplying a reference fringe by a tag-overlap factor. The additional tag channel and slit-local antisymmetric coupling are explicit minimal model assumptions, not a unique derivation from the canonical scalar ontology. The physical comparisons are route removal, path tagging with both routes open, and localized screen recording. A half-amplitude control reduces flux to 24.64% while retaining the normalized cross term. A third calculation reuses the exact Q0 field and defines a nonnegative screen event measure from the accumulated positive forward energy flux, J_+(y) = integral max(F_E,x, 0) dt. One localized screen coordinate is drawn per independent preparation from the normalized J+J_+J+​ distribution. In a fixed 600-event realization, the binned hit histogram has Pearson correlation 0.9553 and total-variation distance 0.0949 relative to the binned event measure. This finite-sample agreement is a consistency check of the explicit forward-flux readout, not an independent validation and not a derivation of the Born rule. Interference, path-tagging, and one-hit event realization are therefore supported at their separately stated model levels, while microscopic detector selection and experimental confirmation of the proposed ontology are outside the scope of this study. The release includes the manuscript PDF, a standalone reproducibility ZIP with manuscript sources, frozen numerical solvers and inputs, lightweight results and figures, an English reproduction manual, LICENSE, and SHA-256 checksums. The manuscript is dated 18 September 2026. No private repository, external dataset, or GPU is required. Enchan Research & Verification License v1.0. Copyright (c) 2026 Mitsuhiro Kobayashi. All rights reserved.
Version 2: pre-registration addendum for Phase D Outcome of the registered gate (G0) The G0 gate failed for every dataset, window family and null. No twin built from independent error mechanisms with circuit-local supports reproduces the bulk of the window-count distributions in the public data from Google Willow, Google Sycamore or Rigetti. For larger codes the twin cannot even be simulated. As the protocol requires, hypotheses H1–H3 are therefore not tested. This version adds pre-registration addendum 1. It fixes the analyses run instead, before either touches the test halves: • Model-free certificate (T3), on the test halves. It covers every registered configuration that has a circuit (the Google archives and Rigetti D6e). Windows are whole-patch windows of 1 and of 5 rounds, separated by one unused round, and the disjointness of their fault-location sets is checked from each circuit. Each stratum (archive, code family, code distance, window family) gets a premise curve ε_lo(k) on the grid k = c·j, j = 1–16, with Bonferroni correction at family-wise α = 0.05.• Threshold values for the certificate. ε* = 7.4 × 10⁻⁴ (Fowler, PRL 109, 180502, 2012) is the primary value; 2.73 × 10⁻⁵ (Aliferis, Gottesman and Preskill, QIC 6, 97, 2006) is a sensitivity check. Certificates against ε* are computed for surface-code strata only. Repetition-code, colour-code and stability strata get premise curves only.• Bursts. The primary analysis uses all windows; a secondary one excludes the windows flagged by the frozen burst classifier. B1/B2 event rates are reported descriptively.• Cat-qubit case study (exploratory). The model-based premise meter is applied to the AWS cat-qubit (D4) distance-3 configurations whose twin was simulable in G0. It reports R(k) intervals and k_cert, with the H1 reading (consistent if R_hi ≤ 3 for all k ≤ k_cert). It is labelled exploratory because D4's own G0 verdict is a fail. Status of the data when version 2 was created G0, which uses only the bulk bins, has run on the test halves. Its stored histograms include tail bins, but no tail statistic has been computed or examined. Both new analyses were dry-run on fit halves as pipeline checks. One choice was made after that dry run, and it is recorded in the addendum: ε* certificates were limited to surface-code strata, and strata were split by code family. The dry run had shown repetition-code and stability strata crossing ε* at k = c, i.e. at their base error rate, where Fowler's surface-code theorem does not apply. The model-based certification horizon is not computed, because it needs a twin tail. Files added in version 2 • phaseD_addendum.json: the machine-readable addendum. SHA-256: a458bcb40aa474d94a882a563a38a1a152d7bfb4404df9299f99fb020ab78834• ADDENDUM.md: the readable version of the addendum.• qpremise_code_phaseD_ade59b0.zip: the code that will run. The addendum's code_sha256 (794122ae1557c009664127e1c2e6b109781d5a71efcc566bc637b991c0403ab6) can be recomputed from it as the SHA-256 over the files matching qpremise/**/*.py, phaseD/scripts/*.py and phaseC/scripts/run_g0.py, taken in path order: each file's relative path, then its bytes with LF line endings.• SHA256SUMS_addendum.txt: checksums of the three files above. The version 1 files are unchanged. The original registration text follows. ──────────────────────────── Version 1 registration (2026-10-01) What this registers The analysis protocol of the premise meter. It tests whether public quantum-error-correction syndrome data agree with an independent-noise "twin" fitted to the same data. It also measures how far each dataset can certify the local-stochastic premise of the threshold theorem. Every analysis choice is fixed in frozen_protocol.json:• configuration eligibility, and the pre-registered subset in g0_selection.json;• the interleaved fit/test split;• the window families;• twin construction: candidate mechanisms from each circuit, an exact parity-moment fit, and a signed quasi-probability simulation with local weights;• the G0 gate decision rule;• the burst classifiers B1 and B2 with their validation targets;• the excess-tail-ratio interval and the certification-horizon conditions;• the model-free certificate's window rule. qpremise_code_at_freeze_79dbf14.zip holds the analysis code at the freeze. The protocol's code_sha256 can be recomputed from it: the SHA-256 over every qpremise/**/*.py file in path order, each file's relative path followed by its bytes with LF line endings. Hypotheses analysed after this registration (on test halves only) H1. After removing windows flagged by the frozen burst classifier, the excess tail ratio R(k) = P_obs(K ≥ k) / P_twin(K ≥ k) has an upper 95% confidence bound ≤ 3 for all k ≤ k_cert. Failure: a lower bound > 3 that replicates on the held-out half. H2. Including burst windows, R(k) > 10 for k ≥ k_b in at least one dataset, and a burst-mixture model fitted to the flagged windows predicts the published repetition-code error floor within a factor of 10. H3. The empirical horizon (power ≥ 0.8 at α = 0.05 against a factor-5 excess) agrees with the exact binomial computation within ±1. At least one dataset certifies k ≥ 10 in whole-patch windows. These are evaluated only on (dataset, window family) pairs that pass the G0 gate under both the stationary (N1) and drift-aware (N5) twins. The model-free certificate (T3) does not depend on the twin. Its threshold ε* is fixed before any certificate is computed. Timing and what had been seen Frozen 2026-10-01 17:31 IST (git commit 79dbf14). Before the freeze, only fit halves had been analysed. The G0 gate (bulk of the window-count distributions only; decision rule frozen) began on the test halves minutes after the freeze. When this record was created, no tail statistic (R(k), H1–H3, burst rates, certificates) had been computed from the test halves, and their tail bins had not been examined. The planned cloud-hardware contrast experiment (H4, H5) is not part of this registration and will be registered separately before any hardware run. Full details are in PREREGISTRATION.md. Protocol SHA-256: 5f7458cfdbe0e203fd9e2bf5d579703509c8374bae53096c37f8f1530540707a
Abstract In the standard double-slit experiment, the interaction between the electron and a detector at either of the slits is supposed to be local. However, one never notices a situation where the electron is detected at both slits simultaneously in the frame of the observer. This is usually explained by the statement that there is only one electron that is being located and it obviously cannot actually be located in two places at the same time in the observer's frame of reference. However, this is a global constraint, which is hard to understand when the interaction between the electron and a measurement device at a particular slit is completely local - how would the measuring device realize that there was only one electron that was to be detected? It would be useful to deduce this from purely local interactions at each slit, even with detectors at each slit, without having to adduce assumptions about long-range correlations between (potentially) space-like separated events. In this paper, we start with a Hamiltonian that was studied in a previous paper on the measurement problem, with a local interaction between the electron and a detector - here we assume that there is a detector at each slit. We study this problem numerically and also make a theoretical argument that the detection problem is exactly the same as that of the problem of equilibration of a macroscopic number of coupled harmonic oscillators. At each detector, as the measurement happens, the amplitude for each of the states of the measuring apparata relaxes to an equilibrium configuration akin to the equilibration of a thermodynamic system. The problem of the detection of the electron at each slit is then mapped to the motion of a random walker in a line with reflecting barriers at both ends, where the ends are separated by a macroscopic number of steps. This connection to a well-studied mathematical problem has a well-understood consequence - two (or a finite number of) random walkers in this space will be expected to be separated by a macroscopic number of steps. Hence, only one of the detectors will see a macroscopic number of its detection degrees of freedom affected - ergo, only one of the detectors, selected completely at random, will "see" the electron. For a large, macroscopic, though finite-sized measurement device, there will be a vanishingly small chance of detecting the electron simultaneously at both slits. Indeed, in the limit of an infinitely massive detector, we will never detect the electron at two places at the same time. This problem also illustrates further that the systematic application of Schrödinger's equation along with a local interaction Hamiltonian that effectively represents the measurement process helps solve some curious issues in the quantum measurement problem.
Note: description expanded on 2026-10-14 for readability. It adds no new predictions or criteria. The frozen pre-registration is the attached PDF, unchanged since publication. Status: the experiment was run on 2026-10-14, after this record was published. Results, including every pre-registered test, will be reported in a separate record linked here. In plain language Theory says a quantum system never completely forgets where it started, even when its dynamics are chaotic. This leftover memory is called a quantum birthmark (Graf et al., Phys. Rev. X, 2026). Theory also says the birthmark should be larger when the system's rules run the same forwards and backwards in time (time-reversal symmetry) than when that symmetry is broken. This record pre-registers a test of that prediction on IBM's ibm_kingston quantum processor. We built two nearly identical sets of 4-qubit circuits. One set has time-reversal symmetry and the other does not. Both use exactly the same gates, so they experience the same hardware noise. We measure how often each circuit returns to its starting state, compared with the 1-in-16 chance level, and predict that the symmetric set shows about 1.67× more memory than the broken set. All predictions, pass/fail criteria, circuits and analysis code were deposited here before any quantum hardware was used. What is tested, and what is not Tested: whether the return probability stays above the ergodic baseline 1/16 at depths 8–23, and whether that excess is larger for the time-reversal-symmetric class by the ratio exact numerics predict for these fixed instances. Not tested: the withdrawn temporal-memory claims of 10.5281/zenodo.20470129. The birthmark is closed-system coherent memory, which measurement and reset erase, so no outcome here bears on those claims. Not tested: the universal random-matrix value 1.889. At this size (N = 16) the circuit family itself gives about 1.66, so a finite-size difference is expected. Not a quantum-advantage claim: a 16-dimensional system is exactly simulable. This is a hardware-validation experiment. Design Hardware: ibm_kingston, physical qubits 108–109–118–129 as an open chain, selected by a no-QPU calibration audit (included as v6_backend_audit.zip). Circuits: a kicked-Ising Floquet period Kx(a/2) → D(h1) → Kx(b) → D(h2) → Kx(a/2), with D(h) = exp(−iΣhiZi)·exp(−iπ/4 ΣZiZj), at exactly 6 CZ per period. COE (symmetric): h1 = h2. TRSB (broken): h1 = h + d, h2 = h − d. The classes differ only in virtual-Z angles. Instances: 16 seeded COE/TRSB pairs (seed 20261013), run at every depth from 8 to 23 (48–138 CZ). Observable: P(t) = |⟨0000|Ft|0000⟩|². The primary statistic is the readout-mitigated excess ratio R = ECOE / ETRSB, where E is the mean of P(t) − 1/16. A noise fidelity common to both classes cancels in R. Controls: 32 deep circuits (depths 60–63) as a decoherence-floor check. 8 state-preparation monitors. 16 readout-calibration circuits. Run: one SamplerV2 job of 568 circuits at 256 shots each, with dynamical decoupling and twirling off and the execution order shuffled. Predictions Quantity COE TRSB R Excess over 1/16, depths 8–23 (noiseless, primary) 0.0896 0.0537 1.667 Same instances, infinite-time limit 0.0952 0.0634 1.502 Circuit family, 10,000 random draws — — 1.661 Random-matrix reference, N = 16 — — 1.889 Under four simulated noise models (nominal, pessimistic, and each with coherent errors), the mitigated R stays between 1.64 and 1.77. The shot-noise standard deviation of R at 256 shots is 0.070–0.125. Pre-registered decision criteria Test Pass condition H1 (primary): symmetry dependence 99% CI lower bound of R > 1.0 H2 (primary): quantitative agreement 99% CI of R intersects 1.54–1.87 and is at most 1.0 wide S1: birthmark above decohered floor Window excess minus depth 60–63 excess, 99% CI lower bound > 0, for both classes S2: matched fidelity between classes 0.85 ≤ FCOE/FTRSB ≤ 1.15 S3: instance-level agreement Pearson r ≥ 0.80 against exact predictions S4 (flag only): state prep and drift Monitors ≥ 0.95, drift ≤ 0.045 Overall verdict: CONFIRMED if H1, H2 and S2 all pass; PARTIAL if H1 passes but H2 or S2 fails; NOT CONFIRMED if H1 fails. Every test is reported whatever the outcome. Uncertainty comes from a 10,000-sample parametric multinomial bootstrap over every circuit's counts, with instances held fixed. Amendment 1 (v1.1.0, made before any data) Amendment 1 changed two things relative to v1.0.0 (10.5281/zenodo.23355804): Shots: reduced from 1024 to 256 per circuit for QPU budget, cutting estimated execution from about 152 s to about 38 s. H2: changed from "point estimate in 1.54–1.87" to the CI rule above, because at 256 shots the point rule would falsely fail 20–25% of the time under the pessimistic models. A CI-width cap of 1.0 keeps H2 informative. Circuits, instances and predictions are unchanged. The trade-off is that H2 is now a weaker test. Provenance Every reported number is derived by script from raw counts: Source and transpiled circuits are saved as QPY. Before submission, every transpiled circuit is mapped back to 4 qubits and its unitary checked against the exact model to < 10−8. The analysis reads its decision bands only from predictions.json and its data only from the raw results file. Submission is gated on the DOI of this record. Files: The PDF is the authoritative pre-registration. predictions.json holds every predicted number and decision band. birthmark_prereg_v1.1.0.zip contains the circuit builder, verification, submission and frozen analysis scripts, plus simulated-data self-tests. v6_backend_audit.zip is the pre-submission calibration audit. Known limitations Small system size (N = 16), so the random-matrix value is not expected. The prediction is specific to depths 8–23 and to these 16 fixed instances. The noise models exclude leakage, TLS fluctuations and crosstalk from outside the chain. T1 relaxation biases P(0000) upward, which pulls R toward 1 (conservative). One backend, one path, one job: no replication. Data: CC BY 4.0. Code: MIT. Principal investigator: Amit Brahmbhatt, Quantum-Clarity LLC.
In this paper, we analyze the statistics of detection data in a general double-double-slit experiment. The two particles are detected at random times which are not equal in general and because we do not have any constraint on the distances of left and right screens from their slits and the ratio they can be detected in completely different timescales. As the detection of the first particle leads to collapse of the wave function, there is no a straightforward and agreed-upon method to study this problem in the orthodox formalism which lacks a clear prediction of these random events and therefore the quantum state afterward. This is not the case in the Bohmian framework which we implement in this paper, and we can predict the system up to the end of experiment. The main result is the joint distribution of detection data including the arrival time and position of the particles on left and right screens. As one of the main consequences, we see that although the joint spatial distribution can be affected by a change to the relative location of screens, the marginals on each side remain intact, compatible with signal locality. At the end, we see how this result is very sensitive to quantum equilibrium conditions.