Can the impact point of a single electron be predictedfrom its launch point? Deterministic guidance,wave-source geometryand constraints from existing experiments
Modhar Mohammed Torki Msliki, Fawaz Modhar Maliki
Abstract
We ask whether the impact point of an individual electron in an interference experimentcan be predicted from its launch point, and what precision this would require. Particlesare described deterministically, guided by the ux of the wave as in the de BroglieBohmformulation, and wave sources are placed according to the base table of a directional-productmodel, xk,n = s ck + Cn with eight levels c = (0, 1, 1.5, 2.5, 3, 4, 5.5, 6). A simulation of thecontrolled electron double-slit experiment of Bach et al., with the electron wavelength writtenas the directional product (pc)2 = K(K + 2mec2), reproduces the interference pattern fromdeterministic, non-crossing paths (correlation 0.98), but shows that launch points spreadover one slit (54 nm) reach six fringes: predicting the fringe of a single electron requires itsposition in the slit plane to be known to about 5 nm. Propagating this requirement back toa nanotip source with the measured eective radius of 0.550.80 nm gives a required launchprecision of 0.48 pm for source-to-object distances of 0.11 mm at 600 eV, far below atomicdimensions. A review of single-electron experiments shows that sources already localise theemission point to below 1 nm without destroying coherence, and that single electrons fromsuch sources still arrive at dierent fringes; no experiment records the in-wave launch positionthat a deterministic prediction would need. A repeat-launch simulation shows why: xing thelaunch position by a measurement of 5 nm (1 nm) precision spreads the impacts over 4.3 (22)fringes and lowers the correlation with the interference pattern from 0.996 to 0.46 (−0.05).Within pilot-wave theory an individual prediction is therefore possible only for an ensembleout of quantum equilibrium, and the proposed test is a test of quantum non-equilibrium.We identify which existing data (per-pulse emission times and arrival positions) can testtiming-based prediction rules, and summarise a pre-registration protocol for a decisive test,in which the prediction rule is to be xed before any data are taken.