Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Duration Is Not Background Time: A Conceptual Reassessment of Energy–Time Uncertainty Relations

Behruz Ebrahimi

Published Nov 3, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Relations known as energy–time uncertainty relations constrain different temporal quantities. Within the framework of quantum mechanics with classical background time, this paper offers a criterion for identifying what these constraints apply to. By distinguishing the common-state condition from the simultaneity of measurement operations, and the spread of a system’s position from background space, it argues that the constraint imposed by each relation must be attributed to the quantity and physical referent defined in it. An examination of characteristic durations, waiting-duration distributions, clock readings and resolution, and information measures shows that the meaning of the temporal factor must be determined from the definition and validity conditions of the particular relation. The temporal character of duration, its expression in time coordinates, and its measurement by a clock do not, by themselves, imply the indeterminacy of background time itself; this distinction holds even with an ideal measurement reference. The spread of duration, the precision of its estimation, and the duration of the measurement procedure are also distinct quantities. Accordingly, the designation ‘energy–duration’ is proposed, with the type of duration or its associated measure explicitly specified. This reinterpretation preserves the mathematical structure and differing validity conditions of the relations without treating them all as inequalities between two statistical spreads. Inferring the indeterminacy of background time requires an independent premise about that background itself and does not follow from these inequalities.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.23907725

Related papers

Flow of time during energy measurements and the resulting time-energy uncertainty relations

Ismael L. Paiva, Augusto César Lobo, Eliahu Cohen

Uncertainty relations play a crucial role in quantum mechanics. Well-defined methods exist for the derivation of such uncertainties for pairs of observables. Other approaches also allow the formulation of time-energy uncertainty relations, even though time is not an operator in standard quantum mechanics. However, in these cases, different approaches are associated with different meanings and interpretations for these relations. The one of interest here revolves around the idea of whether quantum mechanics inherently imposes a fundamental minimum duration for energy measurements with a certain precision. In our study, we investigate within the Page and Wootters timeless framework how energy measurements modify the relative "flow of time'' between internal and external clocks. This provides a unified framework for discussing the subject, allowing us to recover previous results and derive new ones. In particular, we show that the duration of an energy measurement carried out by an external system cannot be performed arbitrarily fast from the perspective of the internal clock. Moreover, we show that during any energy measurement the evolution given by the internal clock is non-unitary.

arXiv:2106.00523•Quantum•Apr 7, 2022•17 citations

Harmonic Time Theory and the Uncertainty Principle: Resolving the Paradox

Parsons, LJ

Harmonic Time Theory proposes that physical time is generated not as a linear sequence of equal increments, but as a harmonic structure composed of multiplicative, ratio-based intervals. In this framework, temporal intervals contract asymptotically toward zero without ever reaching it, establishing a strictly positive minimal temporal interval inherent to the structure of time itself. This paper demonstrates that such a harmonic temporal architecture provides a natural and previously unexplored foundation for the Heisenberg energy–time uncertainty relation, ΔE·Δt ≥ ħ⁄2. We show that the temporal quantity appearing in the uncertainty relation corresponds to real harmonic time (Tᵣ), rather than linear, clock-measured time (Tₗ). Because harmonic time possesses an asymptotic lower bound, ΔTᵣ cannot be made arbitrarily small, thereby enforcing a non-zero uncertainty limit independent of measurement precision or experimental design. Under this interpretation, quantum uncertainty arises as a structural consequence of harmonic temporal scaling rather than as an irreducible probabilistic principle. The framework resolves the conceptual tension between the energy–time uncertainty relation and the asymptotic behaviour of early-universe temporal compression, eliminates the need for singular temporal origins, and preserves consistency with established quantum formalism. The theory further implies epoch-dependent behaviour of temporal uncertainty, with consequences for quantum fluctuations, vacuum energy, early-universe dynamics, and cosmological time measurement. Harmonic Time Theory therefore provides a unified conceptual bridge between quantum mechanics and cosmological time structure while remaining empirically testable and mathematically consistent.

•Dec 6, 2025•3 citations

Temporal Symmetry of Quantum Uncertainty: A Reinterpretation of the Heisenberg Principle

Justin L Dickinson

The Heisenberg uncertainty principle is conventionally interpreted as a constraint on the precision of future measurement outcomes. We argue that this temporal asymmetry is not justified by the underlying mathematics of quantum mechanics, which is fundamentally time-symmetric. We propose that uncertainty applies equally in both temporal directions: the past has no greater ontological determinacy than the future. Between collapse events, prior states were no more determined than future states are now. Only the present moment of collapse constitutes anything approaching a definite physical state, and that moment is immediately receding into a past that was never fully determined before collapse occurred. We formalize this interpretation through a timesymmetric reading of the existing uncertainty relations and discuss its implications for the ontological status of the past, the measurement problem, and the foundations of physical determinism.

•Feb 25, 2026•0 citations

Time in the Quantum Theory and the Uncertainty Relation for Time and Energy

Yakir Aharonov, David Böhm

Because time does not appear in Schr\"odinger's equation as an operator but only as a parameter, the time-energy uncertainty relation must be formulated in a special way. This problem has in fact been studied by many authors and we give a summary of their treatments. We then criticize the main conclusion of these treatments; viz., that in a measurement of energy carried out in a time interval, $\ensuremath{\Delta}t$, there must be a minimum uncertainty in the transfer of energy to the observed system, given by $\ensuremath{\Delta}({E}^{\ensuremath{'}}\ensuremath{-}E)>~\frac{h}{\ensuremath{\Delta}t}$. We show that this conclusion is erroneous in two respects. First, it is not consistent with the general principles of the quantum theory, which require that all uncertainty relations be expressible in terms of the mathematical formalism, i.e., by means of operators, wave functions, etc. Secondly, the examples of measurement processes that were used to derive the above uncertainty relation are not general enough. We then develop a systematic presentation of our own point of view, with regard to the role of time in the quantum theory, and give a concrete example of a measurement process not satisfying the above uncertainty relation.

Physical Review•Jun 1, 1961•476 citations

The Misplaced Condition of Simultaneity in the Position–Momentum Uncertainty Relation

Behruz Ebrahimi

Introducing measurement simultaneity into the formulation of the position–momentum spread relation attributes a condition to it that it does not contain and misdirects its interpretation. Likewise, when one quantity is measured while information about the other is available, ‘simultaneous measurement of two quantities’ adds an operation that is not performed. Drawing on the established distinction between state spreads and joint-measurement inaccuracy, this article shows that simultaneous interactions, simultaneous access to data, and attribution of two quantities to the same stage are distinct conditions; conflating them changes the subject of the claim. A rereading of Heisenberg and Robertson and an examination of a scenario involving prior information clarify why having two records available at once does not guarantee that both can validly be attributed to the same situation. The resulting reconstruction makes the interpretation explicit: the relation constrains the product of two spreads in a common state; sharing a state is not equivalent to simultaneous readouts. Nor does a constraint concerning one state imply a prohibition on access to information about different stages. The reconstruction specifies the physical referent of each attribution, the source of information, and the meaning of accuracy, and establishes that simultaneous measurement is not a condition of the relation. It thereby prevents an unwarranted transformation of a claim about a state into one about measurement simultaneity, as well as the addition of a second measurement operation to a scenario involving a single active measurement.

•Oct 31, 2026•1 citation

The Explanatory Context of Energy-Time Uncertainty Relation

Zhao Da

There are many controversies on energy—time uncertainty relation. Because of the confused role time plays in quantum mechanics, the references and meanings of energy—time uncertainty relation are different in different explanatory contexts. But what do time and energy really mean? What is the philosophical foundation of this relationship? The article bases on the three different meanings of time in quantum mechanics, discusses the references and meanings of energy—time uncertainty relation in various contexts, and aims to clarify the confusion on the references and the meanings of the uncertainty relation between energy and time.

Ziran bianzhengfa tongxun•Jan 1, 2007•0 citations
Relations known as energy–time uncertainty relations constrain different temporal quantities. Within the framework of quantum mechanics with classical background time, this paper offers a criterion for identifying what these constraints apply to. By distinguishing the common-state condition from the simultaneity of measurement operations, and the spread of a system’s position from background space, it argues that the constraint imposed by each relation must be attributed to the quantity and physical referent defined in it. An examination of characteristic durations, waiting-duration distributions, clock readings and resolution, and information measures shows that the meaning of the temporal factor must be determined from the definition and validity conditions of the particular relation. The temporal character of duration, its expression in time coordinates, and its measurement by a clock do not, by themselves, imply the indeterminacy of background time itself; this distinction holds even with an ideal measurement reference. The spread of duration, the precision of its estimation, and the duration of the measurement procedure are also distinct quantities. Accordingly, the designation ‘energy–duration’ is proposed, with the type of duration or its associated measure explicitly specified. This reinterpretation preserves the mathematical structure and differing validity conditions of the relations without treating them all as inequalities between two statistical spreads. Inferring the indeterminacy of background time requires an independent premise about that background itself and does not follow from these inequalities.
Uncertainty relations play a crucial role in quantum mechanics. Well-defined methods exist for the derivation of such uncertainties for pairs of observables. Other approaches also allow the formulation of time-energy uncertainty relations, even though time is not an operator in standard quantum mechanics. However, in these cases, different approaches are associated with different meanings and interpretations for these relations. The one of interest here revolves around the idea of whether quantum mechanics inherently imposes a fundamental minimum duration for energy measurements with a certain precision. In our study, we investigate within the Page and Wootters timeless framework how energy measurements modify the relative "flow of time'' between internal and external clocks. This provides a unified framework for discussing the subject, allowing us to recover previous results and derive new ones. In particular, we show that the duration of an energy measurement carried out by an external system cannot be performed arbitrarily fast from the perspective of the internal clock. Moreover, we show that during any energy measurement the evolution given by the internal clock is non-unitary.
Harmonic Time Theory proposes that physical time is generated not as a linear sequence of equal increments, but as a harmonic structure composed of multiplicative, ratio-based intervals. In this framework, temporal intervals contract asymptotically toward zero without ever reaching it, establishing a strictly positive minimal temporal interval inherent to the structure of time itself. This paper demonstrates that such a harmonic temporal architecture provides a natural and previously unexplored foundation for the Heisenberg energy–time uncertainty relation, ΔE·Δt ≥ ħ⁄2. We show that the temporal quantity appearing in the uncertainty relation corresponds to real harmonic time (Tᵣ), rather than linear, clock-measured time (Tₗ). Because harmonic time possesses an asymptotic lower bound, ΔTᵣ cannot be made arbitrarily small, thereby enforcing a non-zero uncertainty limit independent of measurement precision or experimental design. Under this interpretation, quantum uncertainty arises as a structural consequence of harmonic temporal scaling rather than as an irreducible probabilistic principle. The framework resolves the conceptual tension between the energy–time uncertainty relation and the asymptotic behaviour of early-universe temporal compression, eliminates the need for singular temporal origins, and preserves consistency with established quantum formalism. The theory further implies epoch-dependent behaviour of temporal uncertainty, with consequences for quantum fluctuations, vacuum energy, early-universe dynamics, and cosmological time measurement. Harmonic Time Theory therefore provides a unified conceptual bridge between quantum mechanics and cosmological time structure while remaining empirically testable and mathematically consistent.
The Heisenberg uncertainty principle is conventionally interpreted as a constraint on the precision of future measurement outcomes. We argue that this temporal asymmetry is not justified by the underlying mathematics of quantum mechanics, which is fundamentally time-symmetric. We propose that uncertainty applies equally in both temporal directions: the past has no greater ontological determinacy than the future. Between collapse events, prior states were no more determined than future states are now. Only the present moment of collapse constitutes anything approaching a definite physical state, and that moment is immediately receding into a past that was never fully determined before collapse occurred. We formalize this interpretation through a timesymmetric reading of the existing uncertainty relations and discuss its implications for the ontological status of the past, the measurement problem, and the foundations of physical determinism.
Because time does not appear in Schr\"odinger's equation as an operator but only as a parameter, the time-energy uncertainty relation must be formulated in a special way. This problem has in fact been studied by many authors and we give a summary of their treatments. We then criticize the main conclusion of these treatments; viz., that in a measurement of energy carried out in a time interval, $\ensuremath{\Delta}t$, there must be a minimum uncertainty in the transfer of energy to the observed system, given by $\ensuremath{\Delta}({E}^{\ensuremath{'}}\ensuremath{-}E)>~\frac{h}{\ensuremath{\Delta}t}$. We show that this conclusion is erroneous in two respects. First, it is not consistent with the general principles of the quantum theory, which require that all uncertainty relations be expressible in terms of the mathematical formalism, i.e., by means of operators, wave functions, etc. Secondly, the examples of measurement processes that were used to derive the above uncertainty relation are not general enough. We then develop a systematic presentation of our own point of view, with regard to the role of time in the quantum theory, and give a concrete example of a measurement process not satisfying the above uncertainty relation.
Introducing measurement simultaneity into the formulation of the position–momentum spread relation attributes a condition to it that it does not contain and misdirects its interpretation. Likewise, when one quantity is measured while information about the other is available, ‘simultaneous measurement of two quantities’ adds an operation that is not performed. Drawing on the established distinction between state spreads and joint-measurement inaccuracy, this article shows that simultaneous interactions, simultaneous access to data, and attribution of two quantities to the same stage are distinct conditions; conflating them changes the subject of the claim. A rereading of Heisenberg and Robertson and an examination of a scenario involving prior information clarify why having two records available at once does not guarantee that both can validly be attributed to the same situation. The resulting reconstruction makes the interpretation explicit: the relation constrains the product of two spreads in a common state; sharing a state is not equivalent to simultaneous readouts. Nor does a constraint concerning one state imply a prohibition on access to information about different stages. The reconstruction specifies the physical referent of each attribution, the source of information, and the meaning of accuracy, and establishes that simultaneous measurement is not a condition of the relation. It thereby prevents an unwarranted transformation of a claim about a state into one about measurement simultaneity, as well as the addition of a second measurement operation to a scenario involving a single active measurement.
There are many controversies on energy—time uncertainty relation. Because of the confused role time plays in quantum mechanics, the references and meanings of energy—time uncertainty relation are different in different explanatory contexts. But what do time and energy really mean? What is the philosophical foundation of this relationship? The article bases on the three different meanings of time in quantum mechanics, discusses the references and meanings of energy—time uncertainty relation in various contexts, and aims to clarify the confusion on the references and the meanings of the uncertainty relation between energy and time.