Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2106.00523 · Quantum

Flow of time during energy measurements and the resulting time-energy uncertainty relations

Ismael L. Paiva, Augusto César Lobo, Eliahu Cohen

Published Apr 7, 2022• 17 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Uncertainty relations play a crucial role in quantum mechanics. Well-defined methods exist for the derivation of such uncertainties for pairs of observables. Other approaches also allow the formulation of time-energy uncertainty relations, even though time is not an operator in standard quantum mechanics. However, in these cases, different approaches are associated with different meanings and interpretations for these relations. The one of interest here revolves around the idea of whether quantum mechanics inherently imposes a fundamental minimum duration for energy measurements with a certain precision. In our study, we investigate within the Page and Wootters timeless framework how energy measurements modify the relative "flow of time'' between internal and external clocks. This provides a unified framework for discussing the subject, allowing us to recover previous results and derive new ones. In particular, we show that the duration of an energy measurement carried out by an external system cannot be performed arbitrarily fast from the perspective of the internal clock. Moreover, we show that during any energy measurement the evolution given by the internal clock is non-unitary.

DOI
10.22331/q-2022-04-07-683

Related papers

Time-energy uncertainty relation for quantum events

Matteo Fadel, Lorenzo Maccone

Textbook quantum mechanics treats time as a classical parameter and not as a quantum observable with an associated Hermitian operator. For this reason, to make sense of usual time-energy uncertainty relations such as $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}t\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}E\ensuremath{\gtrsim}\ensuremath{\hbar}$, the term $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}t$ must be interpreted as a time interval and not as a time measurement uncertainty due to quantum noise. However, quantum clocks allow for a measurement of the ``time at which an event happens'' by conditioning the system's evolution on an additional quantum degree of freedom. Within this framework we derive here two uncertainty relations that relate the uncertainty in the quantum measurement of the time at which a quantum event happens on a system to its energy uncertainty.

arXiv:2108.13974•Physical Review A•Nov 24, 2021•11 citations

Measurement of the total energy of an isolated system by an internal observer

Serge Massar, Sandu Popescu

We consider the situation in which an observer internal to an isolated system wants to measure the total energy of the isolated system (this includes his own energy, that of the measuring device and clocks used, etc.). We show that he can do this in an arbitrarily short time, as measured by his own clock. This measurement is not subjected to a time-energy uncertainty relation. The properties of such measurements are discussed in detail with particular emphasis on the relation between the duration of the measurement as measured by internal clocks versus external clocks.

arXiv:quant-ph/0412079•Physical Review A•Apr 20, 2005•3 citations

Duration Is Not Background Time: A Conceptual Reassessment of Energy–Time Uncertainty Relations

Behruz Ebrahimi

Relations known as energy–time uncertainty relations constrain different temporal quantities. Within the framework of quantum mechanics with classical background time, this paper offers a criterion for identifying what these constraints apply to. By distinguishing the common-state condition from the simultaneity of measurement operations, and the spread of a system’s position from background space, it argues that the constraint imposed by each relation must be attributed to the quantity and physical referent defined in it. An examination of characteristic durations, waiting-duration distributions, clock readings and resolution, and information measures shows that the meaning of the temporal factor must be determined from the definition and validity conditions of the particular relation. The temporal character of duration, its expression in time coordinates, and its measurement by a clock do not, by themselves, imply the indeterminacy of background time itself; this distinction holds even with an ideal measurement reference. The spread of duration, the precision of its estimation, and the duration of the measurement procedure are also distinct quantities. Accordingly, the designation ‘energy–duration’ is proposed, with the type of duration or its associated measure explicitly specified. This reinterpretation preserves the mathematical structure and differing validity conditions of the relations without treating them all as inequalities between two statistical spreads. Inferring the indeterminacy of background time requires an independent premise about that background itself and does not follow from these inequalities.

•Nov 3, 2026•0 citations

Time in Quantum Measurements

M. Hossein Partovi, R. Blankenbecler

Our formalism for describing quantum measurements is generalized to the multitime case and used to derive rigorous time-energy uncertainty relations. For a free particle, we find that $T\ensuremath{\delta}H\ensuremath{\ge}\frac{1}{2}$, where $\ensuremath{\delta}H$ is the dispersion in energy and $T$ is the measurement duration as given by an external clock of arbitrarily high accuracy. Moreover, any system used as a clock obeys $\ensuremath{\delta}t\ensuremath{\delta}H\ensuremath{\ge}\frac{1}{2}$, where $\ensuremath{\delta}t$ is the dispersion in the values of time as measured by the system.

Physical Review Letters•Dec 8, 1986•21 citations

Quantum clock frames: Uncertainty relations, non-Hermitian dynamics and nonlocality in time

Eliahu Cohen

Abstract Dynamical evolution can be reconstructed within stationary, closed quantum systems by employing the Page-Wootters “timeless approach”. When conditioning upon the state of a “clock” subsystem, the rest of the system regains its time dependence. This mechanism, involving entanglement between the above subsystems has gained much attention during the last few years. After a brief introduction to the topic we will elaborate on a few recent results: The derivation of new time-energy uncertainty relations, emergence of non-Hermitian dynamics when utilizing non-inertial quantum clocks and dynamical nonlocality in quantum time.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jun 1, 2023•1 citation

Entropic Energy-Time Uncertainty Relation

Patrick J. Coles, Vishal Katariya, Seth Lloyd +2 more

Energy-time uncertainty plays an important role in quantum foundations and technologies, and it was even discussed by the founders of quantum mechanics. However, standard approaches (e.g., Robertson's uncertainty relation) do not apply to energy-time uncertainty because, in general, there is no Hermitian operator associated with time. Following previous approaches, we quantify time uncertainty by how well one can read off the time from a quantum clock. We then use entropy to quantify the information-theoretic distinguishability of the various time states of the clock. Our main result is an entropic energy-time uncertainty relation for general time-independent Hamiltonians, stated for both the discrete-time and continuous-time cases. Our uncertainty relation is strong, in the sense that it allows for a quantum memory to help reduce the uncertainty, and this formulation leads us to reinterpret it as a bound on the relative entropy of asymmetry. Because of the operational relevance of entropy, we anticipate that our uncertainty relation will have information-processing applications.

arXiv:1805.07772•Physical Review Letters•Mar 12, 2019•40 citations
Uncertainty relations play a crucial role in quantum mechanics. Well-defined methods exist for the derivation of such uncertainties for pairs of observables. Other approaches also allow the formulation of time-energy uncertainty relations, even though time is not an operator in standard quantum mechanics. However, in these cases, different approaches are associated with different meanings and interpretations for these relations. The one of interest here revolves around the idea of whether quantum mechanics inherently imposes a fundamental minimum duration for energy measurements with a certain precision. In our study, we investigate within the Page and Wootters timeless framework how energy measurements modify the relative "flow of time'' between internal and external clocks. This provides a unified framework for discussing the subject, allowing us to recover previous results and derive new ones. In particular, we show that the duration of an energy measurement carried out by an external system cannot be performed arbitrarily fast from the perspective of the internal clock. Moreover, we show that during any energy measurement the evolution given by the internal clock is non-unitary.
Textbook quantum mechanics treats time as a classical parameter and not as a quantum observable with an associated Hermitian operator. For this reason, to make sense of usual time-energy uncertainty relations such as $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}t\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}E\ensuremath{\gtrsim}\ensuremath{\hbar}$, the term $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}t$ must be interpreted as a time interval and not as a time measurement uncertainty due to quantum noise. However, quantum clocks allow for a measurement of the ``time at which an event happens'' by conditioning the system's evolution on an additional quantum degree of freedom. Within this framework we derive here two uncertainty relations that relate the uncertainty in the quantum measurement of the time at which a quantum event happens on a system to its energy uncertainty.
We consider the situation in which an observer internal to an isolated system wants to measure the total energy of the isolated system (this includes his own energy, that of the measuring device and clocks used, etc.). We show that he can do this in an arbitrarily short time, as measured by his own clock. This measurement is not subjected to a time-energy uncertainty relation. The properties of such measurements are discussed in detail with particular emphasis on the relation between the duration of the measurement as measured by internal clocks versus external clocks.
Relations known as energy–time uncertainty relations constrain different temporal quantities. Within the framework of quantum mechanics with classical background time, this paper offers a criterion for identifying what these constraints apply to. By distinguishing the common-state condition from the simultaneity of measurement operations, and the spread of a system’s position from background space, it argues that the constraint imposed by each relation must be attributed to the quantity and physical referent defined in it. An examination of characteristic durations, waiting-duration distributions, clock readings and resolution, and information measures shows that the meaning of the temporal factor must be determined from the definition and validity conditions of the particular relation. The temporal character of duration, its expression in time coordinates, and its measurement by a clock do not, by themselves, imply the indeterminacy of background time itself; this distinction holds even with an ideal measurement reference. The spread of duration, the precision of its estimation, and the duration of the measurement procedure are also distinct quantities. Accordingly, the designation ‘energy–duration’ is proposed, with the type of duration or its associated measure explicitly specified. This reinterpretation preserves the mathematical structure and differing validity conditions of the relations without treating them all as inequalities between two statistical spreads. Inferring the indeterminacy of background time requires an independent premise about that background itself and does not follow from these inequalities.
Our formalism for describing quantum measurements is generalized to the multitime case and used to derive rigorous time-energy uncertainty relations. For a free particle, we find that $T\ensuremath{\delta}H\ensuremath{\ge}\frac{1}{2}$, where $\ensuremath{\delta}H$ is the dispersion in energy and TTT is the measurement duration as given by an external clock of arbitrarily high accuracy. Moreover, any system used as a clock obeys $\ensuremath{\delta}t\ensuremath{\delta}H\ensuremath{\ge}\frac{1}{2}$, where $\ensuremath{\delta}t$ is the dispersion in the values of time as measured by the system.
Abstract Dynamical evolution can be reconstructed within stationary, closed quantum systems by employing the Page-Wootters “timeless approach”. When conditioning upon the state of a “clock” subsystem, the rest of the system regains its time dependence. This mechanism, involving entanglement between the above subsystems has gained much attention during the last few years. After a brief introduction to the topic we will elaborate on a few recent results: The derivation of new time-energy uncertainty relations, emergence of non-Hermitian dynamics when utilizing non-inertial quantum clocks and dynamical nonlocality in quantum time.
Energy-time uncertainty plays an important role in quantum foundations and technologies, and it was even discussed by the founders of quantum mechanics. However, standard approaches (e.g., Robertson's uncertainty relation) do not apply to energy-time uncertainty because, in general, there is no Hermitian operator associated with time. Following previous approaches, we quantify time uncertainty by how well one can read off the time from a quantum clock. We then use entropy to quantify the information-theoretic distinguishability of the various time states of the clock. Our main result is an entropic energy-time uncertainty relation for general time-independent Hamiltonians, stated for both the discrete-time and continuous-time cases. Our uncertainty relation is strong, in the sense that it allows for a quantum memory to help reduce the uncertainty, and this formulation leads us to reinterpret it as a bound on the relative entropy of asymmetry. Because of the operational relevance of entropy, we anticipate that our uncertainty relation will have information-processing applications.