The most famous integral in quantum mechanics integrates against a measure that does not exist. Feynman's 1948 space-time formulation writes the amplitude for a particle to travel between two points as a sum over all paths, made concrete by cutting time into N slices and multiplying one factor of 1/A into every slice, with A = (2πiħε/m)^{1/2} for slice width ε. No measure on the space of paths is constructed in the paper — the sliced product is the definition — and the one concrete constant in the construction, A, is fixed by demanding that the construction reproduce the free-particle propagator it was built to reproduce. This paper evaluates that joint, and only that joint. The count is one assumed object with zero derivations. The normalization diverges as the slicing refines: at N = 100 slices the prefactor already stands at log₁₀|(1/A)^N| = +60.09, and at N = 1000 at +1100.91, a divergence cancelled only by oscillation, in a limit no measure controls. Cameron proved in 1960 that the missing object cannot be supplied: a countably additive complex measure of this form would carry infinite total variation. The measure exists in exactly one place — imaginary time, where the phase is absent and Wiener's construction gives a probability measure of total mass exactly 1. The formalism's truth is not graded here; a century of use confirms it as an instrument. What is evaluated is the derivation deficit at its load-bearing joint: a postulate that works is still a postulate. Grade: ONE ASSUMED OBJECT, ZERO DERIVATIONS — PRICED, STILL TURNING. This paper stands outside my work on the vacuum catastrophe; it draws nothing from that work and repairs nothing in it, and it touches no claim of that program — quantum gravity stands not solved in my books, and nothing here moves it.
The most famous integral in quantum mechanics integrates against a measure that does not exist. Feynman's 1948 space-time formulation writes the amplitude for a particle to travel between two points as a sum over all paths, made concrete by cutting time into N slices and multiplying one factor of 1/A into every slice, with A = (2πiħε/m)^{1/2} for slice width ε. No measure on the space of paths is constructed in the paper — the sliced product is the definition — and the one concrete constant in the construction, A, is fixed by demanding that the construction reproduce the free-particle propagator it was built to reproduce. This paper evaluates that joint, and only that joint. The count is one assumed object with zero derivations. The normalization diverges as the slicing refines: at N = 100 slices the prefactor already stands at log₁₀|(1/A)^N| = +60.09, and at N = 1000 at +1100.91, a divergence cancelled only by oscillation, in a limit no measure controls. Cameron proved in 1960 that the missing object cannot be supplied: a countably additive complex measure of this form would carry infinite total variation. The measure exists in exactly one place — imaginary time, where the phase is absent and Wiener's construction gives a probability measure of total mass exactly 1. The formalism's truth is not graded here; a century of use confirms it as an instrument. What is evaluated is the derivation deficit at its load-bearing joint: a postulate that works is still a postulate. Grade: ONE ASSUMED OBJECT, ZERO DERIVATIONS — PRICED, STILL TURNING. This paper stands outside my work on the vacuum catastrophe; it draws nothing from that work and repairs nothing in it, and it touches no claim of that program — quantum gravity stands not solved in my books, and nothing here moves it.
In 1948, Richard Feynman published the first paper on his new approach to non-relativistic quantum mechanics. Before Feynman's work there were two mathematical formulations of quantum mechanics. Schrödinger's formulation was based on PDE (the Schrödinger equation) and states representation by wave functions, so it was in the framework of analysis and differential equations. The other formulation was Heisenberg's matrix algebra. Initially, they were thought to be competing. The proponents of one claimed that the other was “ wrong. ” Within a couple of years, John von Neumann had proved that they are equivalent.\nAlthough Feynman's theory was not fundamentally new, it nonetheless offered an entirely fresh and different perspective: via a precise formulation of Bohr's correspondence principle, it made quantum mechanics similar to classical mechanics in a precise sense. In addition, Feynman's approach made it possible to explain physical experiments, and, via diagrams, link them directly to computations. What resulted was a very powerful device for computing energies and scattering amplitudes - the famous Feynman's diagrams.\nIn his formulation, Feynman aimed at representing the solution to the non-relativistic Schrödinger equation in the form of an “ average ” over histories or paths of a particle. This solution is commonly known as the Feynman path integral. It plays an important role in the theory but appears as a postulate based on intuition coming from physics rather than a justified mathematical object. This is why Feynman's vision has caught the attention of many mathematicians as well as physicists.\nThe papers of Gelfand, Cameron, and Nelson are among the first, and more substantial, attempts to supply Feynman's theory with a rigorous mathematical foundation. These attempts were followed by many others, but unfortunately all of them were not quite satisfactory. The difficulty comes from a need to define a measure on an infinite-dimensional space of continuous functions that represent all possible paths of a particle. This Feynman's measure has to produce an integral with the properties requested by Feynman. In particular, the expression for the Feynman measure has to involve the non-absolutely integrable Fresnel integrands. The non-absolute integrability of the Fresnel integrands makes the measure fail to be positive and to have the countably additive property. Thus, a well-defined measure in the case of the Feynman path integral does not exist.\nExtensive research has been done on the methods of relating the Feynman path integral to the integral with respect to the Wiener measure. The method of analytic continuation in mass defines the Feynman path integral as a certain limit of the Wiener integrals. Unfortunately, this method can be used as definition for only almost all values of the mass parameter in the Schrödinger equation. For physicists, this is not a satisfactory result and needs to be improved.\nIn this work we examine those questions which originally led to the Feynman path integral. By now we know that Feynman's “ dream ” cannot be realized as a positive and countably additive measure on the path-space. Here, we offer a new way out by modifying Feynman's question, and thereby achieving a solution to the Schrödinger equation via a different kind of averages in the path-space.\nWe give our version of the question that Feynman “ should have asked ” in order to realize the elusive path integral. In our formulation, we get a Feynman path integral as a limit of linear functionals, as opposed to the more familiar inductive limits of positive measures, traditionally used for constructing the Wiener measure, and related Gaussian families. We adapt here an approach pioneered by Patrick Muldowney. In it, Muldowney suggested a Henstock integration technique in order to deal with the non-absolute integrability of the kind of Fresnel integrals which we need in our solution to Feynman's question. By applying Henstock's theory to Fresnel integrals, we construct a complex-valued “ probability distribution functions ” on the path-space. Then we use this “ probability ” distribution function to define the Feynman path integral as an inductive limit. This establishes a mathematically rigorous Feynman limit, and at the same time, preserves Feynman's intuitive idea in resulting functional. In addition, our definition, and our solution, do not place any restrictions on any of the parameters in the Schrödinger equation, and have a potential to offer useful computational experiments, and other theoretical insights.
The application of infinite dimensional integration techniques of oscillatory type to the mathematical definition of Feynman path integrals is described.Recent applications to the dynamics of quantum open systems, in particular to the quantum theory of continuous measurement, are also presented. \S 1. IntroductionFeynman integration techniques are widely used (often at an heuristic level) in many areas of theoretical physics, such as quantum field theory, nonrelativistic quantum me- chanics, statistical mechanics, see e.g.[22,25,28,29,34,36,46,50]. The origins of these ideas can be found the 40s[23] , when R. Feynman, inspired by a suggestion by Dirac [19], proposed an alternative formulation of time evolution in quantum mechanics.Feynman's original aim was a variational Lagrangian formulation of quantum theory, reintroducing the concept of trajectory, which had been banned by the "traditional'' formulation of quantum mechanics [49].According to Feynman, the wave function ψ of a non relativistic quantum particle, namely the solution of the Schr\"odinger equation(where ℏ is the reduced Planck constant, m>0 is the mass of the particle and F=−∇V is an external force) should be given by a "sum over all possible histories i.e. by a heuristic integral over the space of all possible paths γ (in the configuration space of the system) with finite energy and fixed end point of the form:
We are concerned with rigorously defined, by time slicing approximation method, Feynman path integral ∫Ωx,yF(γ)eiνS(γ)D(γ) of a functional F(γ), cf. [13]. Here Ωx,y is the set of paths γ(t) in Rd starting from a point y∈ Rd at time 0 and arriving at x∈ Rd at time T, S(γ) is the action of γ and ν=2πh−1, with Planck's constant h. Assuming that p(γ) is a vector field on the path space with suitable property, we prove the following integration by parts formula for Feynman path integrals: $ \int_{\Omega_{x,y}}DF(\gamma)[p(\gamma)]e^{i\nu S(\gamma)} {\cal D}(\gamma) $ $ = -\int_{\Omega_{x,y}} F(\gamma) {\rm Div}\, p(\gamma) e^{i\nu S(\gamma)} {\cal D}(\gamma) -i\nu \int_{\Omega_{x,y}} F(\gamma)DS(\gamma)[p(\gamma)]e^{i\nu S(\gamma)}{\cal D}(\gamma). $ (1) Here DF(γ)[p(γ)] and DS(γ)[p(γ)] are differentials of F(γ) and S(γ) evaluated in the direction of p(γ), respectively, and Divp(γ) is divergence of vector field p(γ). This formula is an analogy to Elworthy's integration by parts formula for Wiener integrals, cf. [1]. As an application, we prove a semiclassical asymptotic formula of the Feynman path integrals which gives us a sharp information in the case F(γ∗)=0. Here γ∗ is the stationary point of the phase S(γ).
The Feynman path integral is an essential part of our mathematical description of fundamental nature at small scales. However, what it seems to say about the world is very much at odds with our classical intuitions, and exactly why nature requires us to describe her in this way is currently unknown. We will describe here a possibility according to which the path integral may be the spacetime manifestation of objects existing in a lower-dimensional analog of spacetime until they give rise to the emergence of spacetime objects under a process that is currently labeled a ‘Quantum Measurement’. This idea is based on a mathematical distinction which at present does not appear to be widely appreciated.
Two of my census papers price, thirty years apart, the same logical move: an exact theory resting on an object that is asserted to exist, or a property asserted to be certified, without the object being given or the certification being derived. CC-128 priced Kohn and Sham's 1965 equations: the interacting system mapped onto a fictitious non-interacting one under an assumed representability, and everything the mapping does not compute swept into one object, the exchange–correlation functional E_xc[n] — named, not given, with no explicit form for arbitrary density in 1965 or derived since, and the open face sized by a declared later parametrisation at 0.164462 of the local exchange–correlation energy per electron at r_s = 2, rising to 0.334172 at r_s = 20. CC-126 priced Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen's 1935 argument: a criterion of reality that certifies an element of reality wherever a value can be predicted with certainty without disturbance, riding on a separation premise — two premises, both spent as definitions, whose conjunction an exhaustive enumeration prices exactly, forcing |S| ≤ 2 against the singlet's returned 2.828427, an excess of 0.828427, or 41.421356 per cent of the bound. This paper states the joint claim the two parents make together and prices it with their own exhibits: across the two addresses, four load-bearing postulated objects — one representability, one functional, one criterion, one separation — stand against zero derivations, and in each case the theory built on the object is exact or valid exactly where the object is granted, so that the object's standing, not the machinery downstream of it, is the whole question. My bench reproduces both parents' exhibits digit for digit — the sixteen-assignment enumeration returning 8 assignments at S = +2 and 8 at S = −2, the singlet sweep returning 2.449490 at 15 and 75 degrees, 2.732051 at 30 and 60, and 2.828427 at 45, and the exchange–correlation table returning the open-face fractions 0.115165 at r_s = 1 through 0.334172 at r_s = 20, growing by a factor of 2.031910 across the declared grid — and then counts, jointly: 4 postulated objects, 0 derivations, 2 exact theories, and 1 shared structure, the existence claim spent where a construction was needed. Grade for this joint entry, printed at full size: REASON FOUND / STILL TURNING — PREMISE-ONLY, explicitly not a kill and not a falsification of either parent paper. The program headline stands unmoved: vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED / PARTIAL, producing-count 0.
The Feynman path integral is an essential part of our mathematical description of fundamental nature at small scales. However, what it seems to say about the world is very much at odds with our classical intu-itions, and exactly why nature requires us to describe her in this way is currently unknown. We will describe here a possibility according to which the path integral may be the spacetime manifestation of objects existing in a lower-dimensional analog of spacetime until they give rise to the emergence of spacetime objects under a process that is currently labeled a ‘Quantum Measure-ment’. This idea is based on a mathematical distinction which at present does not appear to be widely appreci-ated.