Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Path integration with non-positive distributions and applications to the Schrödinger equation

Ekaterina S. Nathanson

Published Jul 1, 2014• 7 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In 1948, Richard Feynman published the first paper on his new approach to non-relativistic quantum mechanics. Before Feynman's work there were two mathematical formulations of quantum mechanics. Schrödinger's formulation was based on PDE (the Schrödinger equation) and states representation by wave functions, so it was in the framework of analysis and differential equations. The other formulation was Heisenberg's matrix algebra. Initially, they were thought to be competing. The proponents of one claimed that the other was “ wrong. ” Within a couple of years, John von Neumann had proved that they are equivalent.\nAlthough Feynman's theory was not fundamentally new, it nonetheless offered an entirely fresh and different perspective: via a precise formulation of Bohr's correspondence principle, it made quantum mechanics similar to classical mechanics in a precise sense. In addition, Feynman's approach made it possible to explain physical experiments, and, via diagrams, link them directly to computations. What resulted was a very powerful device for computing energies and scattering amplitudes - the famous Feynman's diagrams.\nIn his formulation, Feynman aimed at representing the solution to the non-relativistic Schrödinger equation in the form of an “ average ” over histories or paths of a particle. This solution is commonly known as the Feynman path integral. It plays an important role in the theory but appears as a postulate based on intuition coming from physics rather than a justified mathematical object. This is why Feynman's vision has caught the attention of many mathematicians as well as physicists.\nThe papers of Gelfand, Cameron, and Nelson are among the first, and more substantial, attempts to supply Feynman's theory with a rigorous mathematical foundation. These attempts were followed by many others, but unfortunately all of them were not quite satisfactory. The difficulty comes from a need to define a measure on an infinite-dimensional space of continuous functions that represent all possible paths of a particle. This Feynman's measure has to produce an integral with the properties requested by Feynman. In particular, the expression for the Feynman measure has to involve the non-absolutely integrable Fresnel integrands. The non-absolute integrability of the Fresnel integrands makes the measure fail to be positive and to have the countably additive property. Thus, a well-defined measure in the case of the Feynman path integral does not exist.\nExtensive research has been done on the methods of relating the Feynman path integral to the integral with respect to the Wiener measure. The method of analytic continuation in mass defines the Feynman path integral as a certain limit of the Wiener integrals. Unfortunately, this method can be used as definition for only almost all values of the mass parameter in the Schrödinger equation. For physicists, this is not a satisfactory result and needs to be improved.\nIn this work we examine those questions which originally led to the Feynman path integral. By now we know that Feynman's “ dream ” cannot be realized as a positive and countably additive measure on the path-space. Here, we offer a new way out by modifying Feynman's question, and thereby achieving a solution to the Schrödinger equation via a different kind of averages in the path-space.\nWe give our version of the question that Feynman “ should have asked ” in order to realize the elusive path integral. In our formulation, we get a Feynman path integral as a limit of linear functionals, as opposed to the more familiar inductive limits of positive measures, traditionally used for constructing the Wiener measure, and related Gaussian families. We adapt here an approach pioneered by Patrick Muldowney. In it, Muldowney suggested a Henstock integration technique in order to deal with the non-absolute integrability of the kind of Fresnel integrals which we need in our solution to Feynman's question. By applying Henstock's theory to Fresnel integrals, we construct a complex-valued “ probability distribution functions ” on the path-space. Then we use this “ probability ” distribution function to define the Feynman path integral as an inductive limit. This establishes a mathematically rigorous Feynman limit, and at the same time, preserves Feynman's intuitive idea in resulting functional. In addition, our definition, and our solution, do not place any restrictions on any of the parameters in the Schrödinger equation, and have a potential to offer useful computational experiments, and other theoretical insights.

DOI
10.17077/etd.k483ok3i

Related papers

The Schrödinger Equation, Path Integration and Applications

Everaldo Mello Bonotto, Felipe Federson, Marcia Cristina Anderson Braz Federson

The Schrödinger equation is fundamental in quantum mechanics as it makes it possible to determine the wave function from energies and to use this function in the mean calculation of variables, for example, as the most likely position of a group of one or more massive particles. In this paper, we present a survey on some theories involving the Schrödinger equation and the Feynman path integral. We also consider a Feynman–Kac-type formula, as introduced by Patrick Muldowney, with the Henstock integral in the description of the expectation of random walks of a particle. It is well known that the non-absolute integral defined by R. Henstock “fixes” the defects of the Feynman integral. Possible applications where the potential in the Schrödinger equation can be highly oscillating, discontinuous or delayed are mentioned in the end of the paper.

COSMOS•Mar 1, 2021•1 citation

Feynman's Path Integrals and Henstock's Non-Absolute Integration

Patrick Muldowney

R. Feynman formulated quantum mechanics in terms of integrals over spaces of paths (Feynman path integrals). But the absolute value of Feynman's integrand is not integrable. And his integrand does not generate a measure. So Lebesgue integration theory could not be used by Feynman. To establish the equivalence of his theory with the traditional formulation of quantum mechanics, Feynman gave an argument that his path integral satisfies Schrödinger's equation. This paper gives a proof of this part of Feynman's theory. To justify Feynman's and other investigators' use of the language and concepts of integration and probability theory, and to justify taking limits under the integral sign in Feynman's integral, we use R. Henstock's approach to non-absolute integration, which does not require the measure concept, and for which the absolute value of the integrand need not be integrable.

Journal of Applied Analysis•Jan 1, 2000•20 citations

Path Integral Formulation of Quantum Mechanics

Pranawa C. Deshmukh

We choose to examine a phenomenon which is impossible, absolutely impossible, to explain in any classical way, and which has in it the heart of quantum mechanics. In reality, it contains the only mystery. —Richard P. Feynman In this chapter we show that a reformulation of quantum mechanics, namely Feynman's path integral approach, is equivalent to the earlier ones, due to Schrödinger and Heisenberg. We shall introduce and apply it in this chapter to interpret the Aharonov–Bohm effect, which is considered to be a “quantum wonder.” It underscores the importance of electromagnetic potentials. We shall find that in addition to the dynamical phase introduced in Chapter 1, another angle, namely the geometric phase (Pancharatnam–Berry phase), is an important physical property of the wavefunction whose consequences are measurable. 2.1 Propagator: Propagation of a Quantum of Knowledge Notwithstanding the equivalence of wave mechanics and matrix mechanics, Schrödinger and Heisenberg did not appreciate each other's methodologies [1]. In 1926, Schrödinger said: “ I knew of [Heisenberg’s] theory, of course, but I felt discouraged, not to say repelled, by the methods of transcendental algebra, which appeared difficult to me, and by the lack of visualizability. ” Heisenberg's dislike for Schrödinger's wave mechanics was equally intense. In the same year, in a letter to Pauli, he wrote “ The more I think about the physical portion of Schrödinger's theory, the more repulsive I find it…. What Schrödinger writes about the visualizability of his theory ‘is probably not quite right,’ in other words it's crap .” In the mean time, Paul A. M. Dirac, who had made path-breaking contributions [2] in that eventful year (1926) to the formulation of quantum mechanics, had drawn a penetrating analogy [3] between classical and quantum mechanics. Dirac's remark drew the attention of Richard P. Feynman, who used it to build the path integral approach to quantum mechanics based on the variational principle. Feynman was introduced to the principle of extremum action [4] rather early, while in high school. He reveals in his book [5] that “ my Physics teacher … Mr. Bader … told me something … absolutely fascinating…. Every time the subject comes up, I work on it … the principle of least (rather, ‘extremum’) action. ”

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Sep 14, 2023•0 citations

Feynman path integrals for quantum open systems (Introductory Workshop on Path Integrals and Pseudo-Differential Operators : RIMS共同研究報告集)

Sonia Mazzucchi

The application of infinite dimensional integration techniques of oscillatory type to the mathematical definition of Feynman path integrals is described.Recent applications to the dynamics of quantum open systems, in particular to the quantum theory of continuous measurement, are also presented. \S 1. IntroductionFeynman integration techniques are widely used (often at an heuristic level) in many areas of theoretical physics, such as quantum field theory, nonrelativistic quantum me- chanics, statistical mechanics, see e.g.[22,25,28,29,34,36,46,50]. The origins of these ideas can be found the $40s[23]$ , when R. Feynman, inspired by a suggestion by Dirac [19], proposed an alternative formulation of time evolution in quantum mechanics.Feynman's original aim was a variational Lagrangian formulation of quantum theory, reintroducing the concept of trajectory, which had been banned by the "traditional'' formulation of quantum mechanics [49].According to Feynman, the wave function $\psi$ of a non relativistic quantum particle, namely the solution of the Schr\"odinger equation(where $\hslash$ is the reduced Planck constant, $m>0$ is the mass of the particle and $F=-\nabla V$ is an external force) should be given by a "sum over all possible histories i.e. by a heuristic integral over the space of all possible paths $\gamma$ (in the configuration space of the system) with finite energy and fixed end point of the form:

数理解析研究所講究録•Jul 1, 2015•0 citations

The Feynman integral path a Henstock integral: a survey and open problems

R. Gaitán, María Guadalupe Morales

The Feynman path integral is defined over the space $\mathbb{R}^T$ of all possible paths; it has been a powerful tool to develop Quantum Mechanics. The absolute value of Feynman's integrand is not integrable, then Lebesgue integration theory could not be used by Feynman. However, it exists formally as a Henstock integral (which does not require the measure concept) and is a suitable alternative to the ordinary integrals that normally appear in path integrals. Feynman proved the equivalence of his theory with the traditional formulation of Quantum Mechanics, since his path integral satisfies Schrödinger's equation. On the other hand, Feynman's path integral is related to the diagrams of Feynman. For the application of this integral in Feynman's diagrams it is necessary to exchange the integral $\int_{\mathbb{R}^T}$ and the series. We discuss the impossibility to exchange the integral and the sum, considering integral of Henstock and the version of Dominated Convergence Theorem. Even it has not been proved through the several mathematical formalisms that have been used.

arXiv:2002.12691•Feb 28, 2020•0 citations

Feynman's path to Schrödinger (and various other things)

Bernat Frangi, López, Héctor

Feynman's path integral formulation arose from his attempt to incorporate the Lagrangian framework into quantum mechanics, offering what he regarded as a more fundamental perspective than the Hamiltonian approach, particularly in the context of quantum electrodynamics. Inspired by an analogy proposed by P. A. M. Dirac, Feynman showed that Schrödinger's equation could be recovered by promoting this analogy to an equality, up to a constant factor. This insight laid the foundation for the path integral formalism. In this article, we first outline the historical development of dynamical frameworks in physics and then trace Feynman's reasoning as he constructed his formulation, beginning with the double-slit experiment and its interpretation. We subsequently derive the Schrödinger equation from the path integral and demonstrate the conservation of probability. These final sections aim to provide students with a clear link between this elegant yet less commonly presented approach and the more standard methods typically taught in undergraduate courses.

arXiv:2509.17108•Sep 21, 2025•0 citations
In 1948, Richard Feynman published the first paper on his new approach to non-relativistic quantum mechanics. Before Feynman's work there were two mathematical formulations of quantum mechanics. Schrödinger's formulation was based on PDE (the Schrödinger equation) and states representation by wave functions, so it was in the framework of analysis and differential equations. The other formulation was Heisenberg's matrix algebra. Initially, they were thought to be competing. The proponents of one claimed that the other was “ wrong. ” Within a couple of years, John von Neumann had proved that they are equivalent.\nAlthough Feynman's theory was not fundamentally new, it nonetheless offered an entirely fresh and different perspective: via a precise formulation of Bohr's correspondence principle, it made quantum mechanics similar to classical mechanics in a precise sense. In addition, Feynman's approach made it possible to explain physical experiments, and, via diagrams, link them directly to computations. What resulted was a very powerful device for computing energies and scattering amplitudes - the famous Feynman's diagrams.\nIn his formulation, Feynman aimed at representing the solution to the non-relativistic Schrödinger equation in the form of an “ average ” over histories or paths of a particle. This solution is commonly known as the Feynman path integral. It plays an important role in the theory but appears as a postulate based on intuition coming from physics rather than a justified mathematical object. This is why Feynman's vision has caught the attention of many mathematicians as well as physicists.\nThe papers of Gelfand, Cameron, and Nelson are among the first, and more substantial, attempts to supply Feynman's theory with a rigorous mathematical foundation. These attempts were followed by many others, but unfortunately all of them were not quite satisfactory. The difficulty comes from a need to define a measure on an infinite-dimensional space of continuous functions that represent all possible paths of a particle. This Feynman's measure has to produce an integral with the properties requested by Feynman. In particular, the expression for the Feynman measure has to involve the non-absolutely integrable Fresnel integrands. The non-absolute integrability of the Fresnel integrands makes the measure fail to be positive and to have the countably additive property. Thus, a well-defined measure in the case of the Feynman path integral does not exist.\nExtensive research has been done on the methods of relating the Feynman path integral to the integral with respect to the Wiener measure. The method of analytic continuation in mass defines the Feynman path integral as a certain limit of the Wiener integrals. Unfortunately, this method can be used as definition for only almost all values of the mass parameter in the Schrödinger equation. For physicists, this is not a satisfactory result and needs to be improved.\nIn this work we examine those questions which originally led to the Feynman path integral. By now we know that Feynman's “ dream ” cannot be realized as a positive and countably additive measure on the path-space. Here, we offer a new way out by modifying Feynman's question, and thereby achieving a solution to the Schrödinger equation via a different kind of averages in the path-space.\nWe give our version of the question that Feynman “ should have asked ” in order to realize the elusive path integral. In our formulation, we get a Feynman path integral as a limit of linear functionals, as opposed to the more familiar inductive limits of positive measures, traditionally used for constructing the Wiener measure, and related Gaussian families. We adapt here an approach pioneered by Patrick Muldowney. In it, Muldowney suggested a Henstock integration technique in order to deal with the non-absolute integrability of the kind of Fresnel integrals which we need in our solution to Feynman's question. By applying Henstock's theory to Fresnel integrals, we construct a complex-valued “ probability distribution functions ” on the path-space. Then we use this “ probability ” distribution function to define the Feynman path integral as an inductive limit. This establishes a mathematically rigorous Feynman limit, and at the same time, preserves Feynman's intuitive idea in resulting functional. In addition, our definition, and our solution, do not place any restrictions on any of the parameters in the Schrödinger equation, and have a potential to offer useful computational experiments, and other theoretical insights.
The Schrödinger equation is fundamental in quantum mechanics as it makes it possible to determine the wave function from energies and to use this function in the mean calculation of variables, for example, as the most likely position of a group of one or more massive particles. In this paper, we present a survey on some theories involving the Schrödinger equation and the Feynman path integral. We also consider a Feynman–Kac-type formula, as introduced by Patrick Muldowney, with the Henstock integral in the description of the expectation of random walks of a particle. It is well known that the non-absolute integral defined by R. Henstock “fixes” the defects of the Feynman integral. Possible applications where the potential in the Schrödinger equation can be highly oscillating, discontinuous or delayed are mentioned in the end of the paper.
R. Feynman formulated quantum mechanics in terms of integrals over spaces of paths (Feynman path integrals). But the absolute value of Feynman's integrand is not integrable. And his integrand does not generate a measure. So Lebesgue integration theory could not be used by Feynman. To establish the equivalence of his theory with the traditional formulation of quantum mechanics, Feynman gave an argument that his path integral satisfies Schrödinger's equation. This paper gives a proof of this part of Feynman's theory. To justify Feynman's and other investigators' use of the language and concepts of integration and probability theory, and to justify taking limits under the integral sign in Feynman's integral, we use R. Henstock's approach to non-absolute integration, which does not require the measure concept, and for which the absolute value of the integrand need not be integrable.
We choose to examine a phenomenon which is impossible, absolutely impossible, to explain in any classical way, and which has in it the heart of quantum mechanics. In reality, it contains the only mystery. —Richard P. Feynman In this chapter we show that a reformulation of quantum mechanics, namely Feynman's path integral approach, is equivalent to the earlier ones, due to Schrödinger and Heisenberg. We shall introduce and apply it in this chapter to interpret the Aharonov–Bohm effect, which is considered to be a “quantum wonder.” It underscores the importance of electromagnetic potentials. We shall find that in addition to the dynamical phase introduced in Chapter 1, another angle, namely the geometric phase (Pancharatnam–Berry phase), is an important physical property of the wavefunction whose consequences are measurable. 2.1 Propagator: Propagation of a Quantum of Knowledge Notwithstanding the equivalence of wave mechanics and matrix mechanics, Schrödinger and Heisenberg did not appreciate each other's methodologies [1]. In 1926, Schrödinger said: “ I knew of [Heisenberg’s] theory, of course, but I felt discouraged, not to say repelled, by the methods of transcendental algebra, which appeared difficult to me, and by the lack of visualizability. ” Heisenberg's dislike for Schrödinger's wave mechanics was equally intense. In the same year, in a letter to Pauli, he wrote “ The more I think about the physical portion of Schrödinger's theory, the more repulsive I find it…. What Schrödinger writes about the visualizability of his theory ‘is probably not quite right,’ in other words it's crap .” In the mean time, Paul A. M. Dirac, who had made path-breaking contributions [2] in that eventful year (1926) to the formulation of quantum mechanics, had drawn a penetrating analogy [3] between classical and quantum mechanics. Dirac's remark drew the attention of Richard P. Feynman, who used it to build the path integral approach to quantum mechanics based on the variational principle. Feynman was introduced to the principle of extremum action [4] rather early, while in high school. He reveals in his book [5] that “ my Physics teacher … Mr. Bader … told me something … absolutely fascinating…. Every time the subject comes up, I work on it … the principle of least (rather, ‘extremum’) action. ”
The application of infinite dimensional integration techniques of oscillatory type to the mathematical definition of Feynman path integrals is described.Recent applications to the dynamics of quantum open systems, in particular to the quantum theory of continuous measurement, are also presented. \S 1. IntroductionFeynman integration techniques are widely used (often at an heuristic level) in many areas of theoretical physics, such as quantum field theory, nonrelativistic quantum me- chanics, statistical mechanics, see e.g.[22,25,28,29,34,36,46,50]. The origins of these ideas can be found the 40s[23]40s[23]40s[23] , when R. Feynman, inspired by a suggestion by Dirac [19], proposed an alternative formulation of time evolution in quantum mechanics.Feynman's original aim was a variational Lagrangian formulation of quantum theory, reintroducing the concept of trajectory, which had been banned by the "traditional'' formulation of quantum mechanics [49].According to Feynman, the wave function ψ\psiψ of a non relativistic quantum particle, namely the solution of the Schr\"odinger equation(where ℏ\hslashℏ is the reduced Planck constant, m>0m>0m>0 is the mass of the particle and F=−∇VF=-\nabla VF=−∇V is an external force) should be given by a "sum over all possible histories i.e. by a heuristic integral over the space of all possible paths γ\gammaγ (in the configuration space of the system) with finite energy and fixed end point of the form:
The Feynman path integral is defined over the space RT\mathbb{R}^TRT of all possible paths; it has been a powerful tool to develop Quantum Mechanics. The absolute value of Feynman's integrand is not integrable, then Lebesgue integration theory could not be used by Feynman. However, it exists formally as a Henstock integral (which does not require the measure concept) and is a suitable alternative to the ordinary integrals that normally appear in path integrals. Feynman proved the equivalence of his theory with the traditional formulation of Quantum Mechanics, since his path integral satisfies Schrödinger's equation. On the other hand, Feynman's path integral is related to the diagrams of Feynman. For the application of this integral in Feynman's diagrams it is necessary to exchange the integral ∫RT\int_{\mathbb{R}^T}∫RT​ and the series. We discuss the impossibility to exchange the integral and the sum, considering integral of Henstock and the version of Dominated Convergence Theorem. Even it has not been proved through the several mathematical formalisms that have been used.
Feynman's path integral formulation arose from his attempt to incorporate the Lagrangian framework into quantum mechanics, offering what he regarded as a more fundamental perspective than the Hamiltonian approach, particularly in the context of quantum electrodynamics. Inspired by an analogy proposed by P. A. M. Dirac, Feynman showed that Schrödinger's equation could be recovered by promoting this analogy to an equality, up to a constant factor. This insight laid the foundation for the path integral formalism. In this article, we first outline the historical development of dynamical frameworks in physics and then trace Feynman's reasoning as he constructed his formulation, beginning with the double-slit experiment and its interpretation. We subsequently derive the Schrödinger equation from the path integral and demonstrate the conservation of probability. These final sections aim to provide students with a clear link between this elegant yet less commonly presented approach and the more standard methods typically taught in undergraduate courses.