Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

European Microwave Conference (EuMC)

Interlaboratory Study of Cryogenic On-Wafer S-Parameter Measurements of CPW Microwave Devices

Lewis Manning, Daniel Stokes, Andrin Bagus, Fabian Thome, Felix Heinz, Francesco Fortunato, Helena Rodilla, Jan Stake, Nick Ridler, Xiaobang Shang

Published Oct 1, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Cryogenic microwave on-wafer measurements underpin the development and validation of planar circuits used in quantum computing systems. This paper reports an interlaboratory comparison of cryogenic on-wafer S-parameter measurements performed on three coplanar waveguide (CPW) devices: a transmission line, a Beatty line, and a weakly coupled resonator. Measurements were carried out by three laboratories of the same devices on the same wafer over the frequency range 100 MHz to 14 GHz at indicated chuck temperatures below 6 K. The measured results and corresponding standard deviations are compared and discussed. The study provides useful insights into the reproducibility of cryogenic on-wafer S-parameter measurements and may serve as a reference for other laboratories developing similar capabilities.

DOI
10.23919/eumc69230.2026.11748208

Related papers

On-Wafer Penetration Depth Measurements of Superconducting Films

Michael E. Cyberey, Robert M. Weikle, Arthur W. Lichtenberger

An on-wafer measurement technique allowing measurement of a superconducting film's penetration depth without post device-fabrication separation of the chips has been investigated. Coplanar waveguide (CPW) probes and a CPW to microstrip transition are utilized, allowing the use of commercially available LakeShore® CPX-1.5K cryogenic CPW probing station capable of microwave measurements to 50 GHz. The use of CPW probes allows for rapid prototyping and is nondestructive to the device wafers, and hence compatible with many device fabrication technologies. Measurement techniques utilizing resonant microwave circuits have been reported (1),(2), but require mounting to custom-made test fixtures and are not performed on-wafer, but instead on individual diced devices. However, such a dicing requirement is incompatible with our ultra-thin Si, Au beam-lead chip architecture (3). In addition to a traditional resonant circuit measurement technique, a technique that uses on-wafer calibration standards is discussed. The on-wafer calibration eliminates possible effects introduced by the testing setup and potentially offers additional advantages such as a size reduction and a direct measurement of RF loss. The designs and results for both measurement techniques are reported for NbTiN films.

•Mar 1, 2010•1 citation

Cryogenic On-Chip In Situ S -Parameter Calibration Using Superconducting Coplanar Waveguides

Jeremy N. Thomas, Johannes Paul Hoffmann, Nathan E. Flowers-Jacobs +5 more

This article presents a new multiimpedance-state line (MISL) in situ scattering parameter (S-parameter) calibration technique using on-chip superconducting transmission lines at 4 K that enables cryogenic calibration in a fixed signal path without the need for cryogenic switches or a cryogenic probe station. The method uses coplanar waveguide (CPW) models based on various impedance states of niobium (Nb), which has zero dc resistance below 9 K and a monotonically increasing resistance from 10 K to room temperature. The different impedance states are accessed by heating the 4 K stage of a cryostat and injecting up to 245 mA of current into the line. Using these states, we solve for the unknowns in an eight-term error model through a least-squares analysis. We first validate the MISL calibration technique by comparing it with short-open-load-reciprocal (SOLR) calibrated measurements in a cryogenic probe station, finding transmission agreement within 0.2 dB and uncertainty overlap for nearly all frequencies up to 26.5 GHz. We then apply the method to calibrate Nb CPWs with and without embedded Josephson junctions (JJs), using a fixed wire bonded connection, and without the use of cryogenic switches or movable probes. Strong agreement with the CPW models is demonstrated, with uncertainty overlap and differences below 0.1 dB up to 4.6 GHz without JJs and up to 2.4 GHz with JJs; resonances cause interruptions beyond these frequencies.

IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques•Jul 16, 2025•2 citations

Broadband Coaxial S-Parameter Measurements for Cryogenic Quantum Technologies

Sang-Hee Shin, Manoj Stanley, James Skinner +2 more

Development of RF and microwave metrology capabilities at cryogenic temperatures is critical for the development of high-performance microwave devices to facilitate commercialization of cryogenic quantum technologies. This article presents a broadband microwave S-parameter calibration scheme suitable for cryogenic environments operating at temperatures down to tens of milli-kelvin (mK). The technique is based on a weighted multi-line thru-reflect-line (TRL) calibration approach and is demonstrated using coaxial air line calibration standards. One-and two-port microwave devices commonly used in cryogenic quantum computing applications, a cryogenic 50$~\Omega$matched load and a cryogenic 6 dB attenuator, were measured. The measured results at mK temperatures indicate that when combined with calibration standards of appropriate electrical length, the weighted multi-line TRL calibration scheme allows broadband frequency coverage compared to conventional TRL calibration schemes utilizing a single line standard. The mechanical and electrical properties of the line standards at mK temperatures were investigated and discussed. These findings establish the feasibility of utilizing multiple off-the-shelf coaxial air lines to enhance the frequency range of calibrations at mK temperatures.

IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques•Oct 17, 2023•20 citations

Characterization of NB and TiN superconducting CPW lines with thru-line calibration method

Wei-Tao Lv, Jie Hu, Jing-Pin Yang +2 more

Microwave kinetic inductance detectors (MKIDs) are playing an increasingly role in THz astronomy. Superconducting coplanar waveguide (CPW) lines are commonly adopted in MKIDs for the resonators as well as the readout through line. It is therefore of particular interest to characterize the transmission properities of superconducting CPW lines at low temperatures. A cryogenic through-line method based on two cryogenic RF switches is proposed to characterize Nb and TiN superconducting CPW lines. On-chip calibration has been successfully carried out. Detailed results and analysis will be presented.

Infrared, Millimeter-Wave, and Terahertz Technologies•Nov 9, 2018•0 citations

Exploring Materials for RF Transmission Lines in Cryogenic Systems

Daniel Lau, Vignesh Shanmugam Bhaskar, Yong Chyn Ng +3 more

Superconducting systems operating in cryogenic environments represent a rapidly evolving domain with diverse applications spanning from quantum computing to medical diagnostics. To optimize and enhance the performance of such systems, a comprehensive understanding of material properties and their responses under cryogenic conditions is imperative. This work investigates the RF and DC electrical performance of passive structures, specifically transmission lines, at both room and cryogenic temperatures. S-parameter measurements were conducted on Coplanar Waveguides (CPWs) transmission lines, which are crucial for interaction with qubit chips and the resonators to read out the qubit states. Additionally, DC electrical testing is performed on the CPWs to analyse the resistance across the signal and ground metal lines. A series of test structures using different substrates and metal lines are fabricated for s-parameter testing at both room and cryogenic temperatures. This paper presents the impact of the superconducting environment on material RF loss and resistance.

IEEE Electronics Packaging Technology Conference (EPTC)•Dec 3, 2024•0 citations

Broadband RF Characterization and Modeling of Superconducting Coplanar Waveguides

Corentin Beilvert, Norman Vivien, Candice Thomas +4 more

We present the RF characterization of 2-µm-wide superconducting coplanar waveguides made of 100-nm-thick niobium (Nb) or niobium nitride (NbN) films fabricated on 200 mm silicon wafers. Measurements of the two-ports S-parameters up to 25 GHz in a 4.7K–14 K temperature range with an added direct current up to 115 mA were done using a cryogenic probe station. With proper RF calibration and de-embedding procedure, both temperature and dc current dependence of the RF superconducting properties are analyzed. We report a kinetic inductance of 0.15 pH/$\square$, a critical current density of 50 MA/cm$^{2}$, and a critical temperature of 8.9 K for Nb as well as 4.27 pH/$\square$, 3 MA/cm$^{2}$, and 13.8 K for NbN. A telegraphist transmission line model taking into account the BCS theory has been developed and the comparison with the measurements is discussed.

IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity•Dec 13, 2024•0 citations
Cryogenic microwave on-wafer measurements underpin the development and validation of planar circuits used in quantum computing systems. This paper reports an interlaboratory comparison of cryogenic on-wafer S-parameter measurements performed on three coplanar waveguide (CPW) devices: a transmission line, a Beatty line, and a weakly coupled resonator. Measurements were carried out by three laboratories of the same devices on the same wafer over the frequency range 100 MHz to 14 GHz at indicated chuck temperatures below 6 K. The measured results and corresponding standard deviations are compared and discussed. The study provides useful insights into the reproducibility of cryogenic on-wafer S-parameter measurements and may serve as a reference for other laboratories developing similar capabilities.
An on-wafer measurement technique allowing measurement of a superconducting film's penetration depth without post device-fabrication separation of the chips has been investigated. Coplanar waveguide (CPW) probes and a CPW to microstrip transition are utilized, allowing the use of commercially available LakeShore® CPX-1.5K cryogenic CPW probing station capable of microwave measurements to 50 GHz. The use of CPW probes allows for rapid prototyping and is nondestructive to the device wafers, and hence compatible with many device fabrication technologies. Measurement techniques utilizing resonant microwave circuits have been reported (1),(2), but require mounting to custom-made test fixtures and are not performed on-wafer, but instead on individual diced devices. However, such a dicing requirement is incompatible with our ultra-thin Si, Au beam-lead chip architecture (3). In addition to a traditional resonant circuit measurement technique, a technique that uses on-wafer calibration standards is discussed. The on-wafer calibration eliminates possible effects introduced by the testing setup and potentially offers additional advantages such as a size reduction and a direct measurement of RF loss. The designs and results for both measurement techniques are reported for NbTiN films.
This article presents a new multiimpedance-state line (MISL) in situ scattering parameter (S-parameter) calibration technique using on-chip superconducting transmission lines at 4 K that enables cryogenic calibration in a fixed signal path without the need for cryogenic switches or a cryogenic probe station. The method uses coplanar waveguide (CPW) models based on various impedance states of niobium (Nb), which has zero dc resistance below 9 K and a monotonically increasing resistance from 10 K to room temperature. The different impedance states are accessed by heating the 4 K stage of a cryostat and injecting up to 245 mA of current into the line. Using these states, we solve for the unknowns in an eight-term error model through a least-squares analysis. We first validate the MISL calibration technique by comparing it with short-open-load-reciprocal (SOLR) calibrated measurements in a cryogenic probe station, finding transmission agreement within 0.2 dB and uncertainty overlap for nearly all frequencies up to 26.5 GHz. We then apply the method to calibrate Nb CPWs with and without embedded Josephson junctions (JJs), using a fixed wire bonded connection, and without the use of cryogenic switches or movable probes. Strong agreement with the CPW models is demonstrated, with uncertainty overlap and differences below 0.1 dB up to 4.6 GHz without JJs and up to 2.4 GHz with JJs; resonances cause interruptions beyond these frequencies.
Development of RF and microwave metrology capabilities at cryogenic temperatures is critical for the development of high-performance microwave devices to facilitate commercialization of cryogenic quantum technologies. This article presents a broadband microwave S-parameter calibration scheme suitable for cryogenic environments operating at temperatures down to tens of milli-kelvin (mK). The technique is based on a weighted multi-line thru-reflect-line (TRL) calibration approach and is demonstrated using coaxial air line calibration standards. One-and two-port microwave devices commonly used in cryogenic quantum computing applications, a cryogenic 50 Ω~\Omega Ωmatched load and a cryogenic 6 dB attenuator, were measured. The measured results at mK temperatures indicate that when combined with calibration standards of appropriate electrical length, the weighted multi-line TRL calibration scheme allows broadband frequency coverage compared to conventional TRL calibration schemes utilizing a single line standard. The mechanical and electrical properties of the line standards at mK temperatures were investigated and discussed. These findings establish the feasibility of utilizing multiple off-the-shelf coaxial air lines to enhance the frequency range of calibrations at mK temperatures.
Microwave kinetic inductance detectors (MKIDs) are playing an increasingly role in THz astronomy. Superconducting coplanar waveguide (CPW) lines are commonly adopted in MKIDs for the resonators as well as the readout through line. It is therefore of particular interest to characterize the transmission properities of superconducting CPW lines at low temperatures. A cryogenic through-line method based on two cryogenic RF switches is proposed to characterize Nb and TiN superconducting CPW lines. On-chip calibration has been successfully carried out. Detailed results and analysis will be presented.
Superconducting systems operating in cryogenic environments represent a rapidly evolving domain with diverse applications spanning from quantum computing to medical diagnostics. To optimize and enhance the performance of such systems, a comprehensive understanding of material properties and their responses under cryogenic conditions is imperative. This work investigates the RF and DC electrical performance of passive structures, specifically transmission lines, at both room and cryogenic temperatures. S-parameter measurements were conducted on Coplanar Waveguides (CPWs) transmission lines, which are crucial for interaction with qubit chips and the resonators to read out the qubit states. Additionally, DC electrical testing is performed on the CPWs to analyse the resistance across the signal and ground metal lines. A series of test structures using different substrates and metal lines are fabricated for s-parameter testing at both room and cryogenic temperatures. This paper presents the impact of the superconducting environment on material RF loss and resistance.
We present the RF characterization of 2-µm-wide superconducting coplanar waveguides made of 100-nm-thick niobium (Nb) or niobium nitride (NbN) films fabricated on 200 mm silicon wafers. Measurements of the two-ports S-parameters up to 25 GHz in a 4.7K–14 K temperature range with an added direct current up to 115 mA were done using a cryogenic probe station. With proper RF calibration and de-embedding procedure, both temperature and dc current dependence of the RF superconducting properties are analyzed. We report a kinetic inductance of 0.15 pH/□\square□, a critical current density of 50 MA/cm2^{2}2, and a critical temperature of 8.9 K for Nb as well as 4.27 pH/□\square□, 3 MA/cm2^{2}2, and 13.8 K for NbN. A telegraphist transmission line model taking into account the BCS theory has been developed and the comparison with the measurements is discussed.