Characterising NISQ Gate-Level Noise in Hybrid Quantum-Classical Neural Networks for Tabular Clinical Data: An Empirical Investigation Across Diabetes and Cardiac Benchmarks
J Maria Shanthi, M Subburaj, V Krishnamoorthy, Venkat Ramana, S Anithakumar
Hybrid quantum classical neural networks (HQNNs) combine with the variational quantum circuits with traditional pipelines, yet the behaviour possed under real NISQ gate level noise on tabular electronic health record (EHR) data is mostly unexamined.Most of the published hybrid quantum classical healthcare studies depend on ideal simulators, while those introducing noise evaluate only image based benchmarks. The work aims to fill the gap through a reproducible experiment across two open licence clinical cohorts which are the PIMA Indians Diabetes benchmark $(\mathbf{n}=\mathbf{7 6 8}, \mathbf{C C 0})$ and the Cleveland Heart Disease repository $(\mathbf{n}=\mathbf{3 0 3}, \mathbf{C C}$ BY 4.0). The proposed Five architectures operate under identical training conditions. A conventional multi layer perceptron, a noiseless HQNN, and three noise exposed variants are subjected to depolarizing, bitflip and compound quantum channels at injection probability p=0.05.Each noise type undergoes reevaluation at eight discrete probability levels spanning where $\mathbf{p}=\mathbf{0. 0 0}$ to $\mathbf{p}=\mathbf{0. 2 0}$, producing 48 independently trained models for each dataset. A previously undocumented quantum noise regularisation (QNR) effect appears a bit flip injection increases cardiac diagnostic accuracy by 8.34 percent when compared to the noiseless baseline (81.67% vs 73.33%), resembling dropout-based regularisation on small datasets. Within the diabetes cohort, the noise exposed variants have the highest AUC ROC of 81.00%.Every architecture maintains parity with the classical reference at noise magnitudes consistent with contemporary NISQ hardware p less than 0.02, supporting near-term clinical applicability.
Hybrid quantum classical neural networks (HQNNs) combine with the variational quantum circuits with traditional pipelines, yet the behaviour possed under real NISQ gate level noise on tabular electronic health record (EHR) data is mostly unexamined.Most of the published hybrid quantum classical healthcare studies depend on ideal simulators, while those introducing noise evaluate only image based benchmarks. The work aims to fill the gap through a reproducible experiment across two open licence clinical cohorts which are the PIMA Indians Diabetes benchmark (n=768,CC0) and the Cleveland Heart Disease repository (n=303,CC BY 4.0). The proposed Five architectures operate under identical training conditions. A conventional multi layer perceptron, a noiseless HQNN, and three noise exposed variants are subjected to depolarizing, bitflip and compound quantum channels at injection probability p=0.05.Each noise type undergoes reevaluation at eight discrete probability levels spanning where p=0.00 to p=0.20, producing 48 independently trained models for each dataset. A previously undocumented quantum noise regularisation (QNR) effect appears a bit flip injection increases cardiac diagnostic accuracy by 8.34 percent when compared to the noiseless baseline (81.67% vs 73.33%), resembling dropout-based regularisation on small datasets. Within the diabetes cohort, the noise exposed variants have the highest AUC ROC of 81.00%.Every architecture maintains parity with the classical reference at noise magnitudes consistent with contemporary NISQ hardware p less than 0.02, supporting near-term clinical applicability.
Hybrid Quantum Neural Networks (HQNNs) offer promising potential of quantum computing while retaining the flexibility of classical deep learning. However, the limitations of Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) devices introduce significant challenges in achieving ideal performance due to noise interference, such as decoherence, gate errors, and readout errors. This paper presents an extensive comparative analysis of two HQNN algorithms, Quantum Convolutional Neural Network (QCNN) and Quanvolutional Neural Network (QuanNN), assessing their noise resilience across diverse image classification tasks. We systematically inject noise into variational quantum circuits using five quantum noise channels: Phase Flip, Bit Flip, Phase Damping, Amplitude Damping, and Depolarizing Noise. By varying noise probabilities from 0.1 to 1.0, we evaluate the correlation between noise robustness and model behavior across different noise levels.Our findings demonstrate that different noise types and levels significantly influence HQNN performance. The QuanNN shows robust performance across most noise channels for low noise levels (0.1 - 0.4), but succumbs to diverse effects of depolarizing and amplitude damping noise at probabilities between (0.5 - 1.0). However, the QuanNN exhibits robustness to bit flip noise at high probabilities (0.9 - 1.0). On the other hand, the QCNN tends to benefit from the noise injection by outperforming noise-free models for bit flip, phase flip, and phase damping at high noise probabilities. However, for other noise types, the QCNN shows gradual performance degradation as noise increases. These insights aim to guide future research in error mitigation strategies to enhance HQNN models in the NISQ era.
This study presents a noise-aware evaluation framework for hybrid quantum–classical machine learning models applied to medical binary classification. Using three healthcare datasets—Pima Indians Diabetes, Heart Disease, and Breast Cancer Wisconsin—the performance of a Variational Quantum Classifier (VQC) was analyzed under multiple depolarizing noise levels (0.00–0.10). Classical baselines, Logistic Regression (LR) and Support Vector Machine (SVM), were implemented for comparison. The research investigates the impact of noise on predictive accuracy, F1-score, and training time, highlighting the computational overhead of hybrid quantum–classical models. Zero Noise Extrapolation (ZNE), using linear and Richardson methods, was applied to mitigate noise effects, revealing that while ZNE improves performance under certain conditions, extrapolation instability can occur. Transpiler optimization also contributed to improved VQC stability by reducing circuit complexity. Results show that classical models consistently outperformed the VQC in accuracy, stability, and training efficiency. VQC exhibited fluctuating performance under noise, requiring significantly higher training time, and increasing SPSA iterations did not always yield stable accuracy improvements. These findings underscore the challenges of noise robustness, optimization instability, and computational cost in the NISQ era, and suggest directions for future work, including alternative optimizers, adaptive ansatz design, advanced error mitigation, and real hardware benchmarking. This research provides a systematic benchmarking framework for evaluating training time versus noise-level trade-offs, contributing to the development of more reliable quantum machine learning models for medical applications. Keywords: Quantum Machine Learning, Variational Quantum Classifier, Depolarizing Noise, Zero Noise Extrapolation, Medical Classification, Hybrid Quantum–Classical Models, Training Time Analysis
uantum computing offers the potential to solve selected computational problems more efficiently than classical systems by leveraging quantum mechanical principles such as superposition and entanglement. However, current quantum devices operate in the noisy intermediatescale quantum (NISQ) regime, where limited coherence times, gate errors, measurement instability, and hardware variability significantly constrain practical performance. As a result, many quantum machine learning architectures that appear promising under idealized simulation conditions experience substantial degradation when executed under realistic noisy environments. This thesis investigates the problem of robustness in hybrid quantum neural network (HQNN) systems operating under realistic NISQ conditions. Rather than focusing primarily on quantum expressivity or claims of quantum advantage, the work examines whether practical hybrid quantum learning can maintain stable optimization and reliable inference in the presence of stochastic perturbations. A robustness-engineering framework is developed that integrates learned-readout decoding, multi-observable quantum feature extraction, architecture-level optimization, stability-aware training, and noise-augmented learning within a unified hybrid quantum-classical pipeline. To evaluate the framework, a comprehensive benchmarking methodology is developed across multiple datasets, architectures, perturbation environments, software frameworks, and hardware platforms. The experiments compare classical machine learning models, quantum kernel methods, and several HQNN architectures, including quanvolutional neural networks, quantum convolutional neural networks, and quantum transfer learning systems. Performance is evaluated under both noiseless and noisy conditions using standardized metrics, cross-noise validation, architecture-level comparisons, and real IBM Quantum hardware execution. The results demonstrate that baseline HQNN systems are highly sensitive to optimization instability, parity-based information loss, measurement variability, and perturbation accumulation. The experiments further reveal that robustness, rather than representational expressivity alone, is the dominant factor limiting practical hybrid quantum learning under realistic NISQ conditions. Through successive robustness-engineering stages, noisy performance improves from approximately 0.37 to 0.50 in baseline architectures to approximately 0.97 under several benchmark environments while maintaining substantially improved stability and reduced degradation under perturbation. These findings establish robustness as a central design objective for practical quantum machine learning. The thesis demonstrates that reliable hybrid quantum learning emerges through coordinated interaction between quantum feature generation, adaptive classical inference, stability-aware optimization, and hardware-aware architecture design. More broadly, the results suggest that hybrid quantum-AI systems are most effective when viewed as integrated quantum-classical computational frameworks in which quantum circuits function as probabilistic feature generators operating within larger robustness-oriented learning pipelines.
In current noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices, hybrid quantum neural networks (HQNNs) offer a promising solution, combining the strengths of classical machine learning with quantum computing capabilities. However, the performance of these networks can be significantly affected by the quantum noise inherent in NISQ devices. In this paper, we conduct an extensive comparative analysis of various HQNN algorithms, namely Quantum Convolution Neural Network (QCNN), Quanvolutional Neural Network (QuanNN), and Quantum Transfer Learning (QTL), for image classification tasks. We evaluate the performance of each algorithm across quantum circuits with different entangling structures, variations in layer count, and optimal placement in the architecture. Subsequently, we select the highest-performing architectures and assess their robustness against noise influence by introducing quantum gate noise through Phase Flip, Bit Flip, Phase Damping, Amplitude Damping, and the Depolarization Channel. Our results reveal that the top-performing models exhibit varying resilience to different noise channels. However, in most scenarios, the QuanNN demonstrates greater robustness across various quantum noise channels, consistently outperforming other models. This highlights the importance of tailoring model selection to specific noise environments in NISQ devices.
This study presents a reproducible evaluation framework for hybrid quantum-classical neural networks (HQCNNs) in healthcare classification, rather than a new architecture. We assess a four-qubit HQCNN combining a compact classical encoder, a two-layer parameterized quantum circuit (PQC), and a classical readout (441 trainable parameters) against carefully tuned classical baselines on the Wisconsin Diagnostic Breast Cancer (WDBC) dataset under identical five-fold cross-validation. The work is framed as a single-dataset proof-of-concept: the contribution is a documented, shared-fold evaluation protocol with a parameter-matched classical control and a quantified epistemic-informativeness analysis, not a demonstration of general quantum advantage. The HQCNN reached 96.49±1.96% accuracy and 99.44±0.60% ROC-AUC. A parameter-matched classical multilayer perceptron (441 parameters) reached 95.08±1.81% accuracy; the HQCNN’s +1.41 percentage-point edge at equal capacity was not statistically significant (paired t, p=0.056). Across five shared folds, no HQCNN-versus-classical accuracy difference survived Holm–Bonferroni correction (all adjusted p≥0.625), so we report the HQCNN as competitive with, not superior to, strong tuned classical baselines. A multi-split depth ablation showed that circuit depth L∈{1,2,3} had no statistically detectable effect on accuracy (L=2 vs. L=3: Wilcoxon p=1.00); we therefore adopt two variational layers as a practical default rather than an optimum. Under a low-noise simulator (depolarising and amplitude-damping channels, p=0.01), accuracy was 96.49%, indicating robustness only at modest uniform error rates; realistic hardware noise is higher. We additionally apply Bayesian surprise as an epistemic-informativeness heuristic—not a formal generative model—to rank which findings are most worth building on. The framework offers a reproducible, documented evaluation procedure that can support cumulative comparison of hybrid quantum-classical models in healthcare.
Medical image classification is a critical component of modern healthcare; however, accurate diagnosis remains challenging due to limited annotated datasets, class imbalance, and the high dimensionality of medical imaging data. To address these challenges, a hybrid quantum-classical neural network (HQCNN) is proposed, integrating classical deep learning with variational quantum learning for medical image classification. The proposed architecture combines a five-layer convolutional neural network (CNN) for hierarchical feature extraction with a lightweight 4-qubit variational quantum circuit (VQC) incorporating quantum state encoding, superposition and entanglement mechanisms, and a quantum attention-Fourier (QAF) module. This hybrid design aims to improve nonlinear feature representation and quantum parameter efficiency while maintaining a shallow quantum circuit suitable for noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ)-era constraints. Experimental evaluation on six MedMNIST benchmark datasets demonstrated competitive performance across both binary and multi-class classification tasks. HQCNN achieved 98.88% accuracy on the binary subset of PathMNIST (classes 0 vs. 1), 97.61% accuracy on the multi-class OrganAMNIST dataset, and 86.29% accuracy on BreastMNIST. Comparative experiments and statistical analyses demonstrated consistent improvements over the controlled BHQNN baseline, while component-wise ablation studies showed that the QAF module, superposition and entanglement mechanisms, and expressive parameterized rotations contributed to classification performance in a complementary and dataset-dependent manner. Moreover, HQCNN reduced the number of trainable quantum parameters by approximately 55.6% compared with the baseline hybrid quantum neural network (BHQNN). Noise-aware simulations further showed that the model retained relatively stable predictive performance under moderate depolarizing noise, supporting further evaluation under near-term quantum computing conditions. Overall, the results demonstrate that HQCNN provides a parameter-efficient hybrid quantum-classical framework for medical image classification and offers a promising foundation for further investigation of quantum-enhanced medical image analysis.