Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Peay's Helium Immersion: Completing the Structure of the Equation Physics Calls Unsolvable

Dwayne Peay

Published Oct 27, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The time-independent Schrödinger equation for the helium atom has stood for a century as the canonical example of a quantum problem with no exact solution: the electron–electron repulsion term 1/r12 couples the coordinates inseparably, and the field's settled practice is approximation (Hartree–Fock, configuration interaction, density functional theory). This paper reports a completed result obtained by a different route. Rather than approximating the equation as posed, the problem was immersed in a complete relational framework (the Source Codex of Mathematics, Peay), whose structure diagnoses what a formulation is missing. The immersion identified a single structural defect: the standard formulation poses the atom as two independent electrons plus an orphaned interaction term, while the pair-distance r12 is never admitted as a structural coordinate of the wavefunction. Completing the structure — admitting u = r12 as a member of the wavefunction — collapses the problem. A variational Monte Carlo computation with a single admitted structural term yields a ground-state energy of -2.8908 ± 0.0007 Hartree, beyond the Hartree-Fock limit (-2.86168) that bounds all separable methods; extending along the same admitted coordinate reaches -2.9024 against the experimental value -2.90372.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.23745844

Related papers

Peay's Helium Immersion: Completing the Structure of the Equation Physics Calls Unsolvable

Dwayne Peay

The time-independent Schrödinger equation for the helium atom has stood for a century as the canonical example of a quantum problem with no exact solution: the electron–electron repulsion term 1/r12 couples the coordinates inseparably, and the field's settled practice is approximation (Hartree–Fock, configuration interaction, density functional theory). This paper reports a completed result obtained by a different route. Rather than approximating the equation as posed, the problem was immersed in a complete relational framework (the Source Codex of Mathematics, Peay), whose structure diagnoses what a formulation is missing. The immersion identified a single structural defect: the standard formulation poses the atom as two independent electrons plus an orphaned interaction term, while the pair-distance r12 is never admitted as a structural coordinate of the wavefunction. Completing the structure — admitting u = r12 as a member of the wavefunction — collapses the problem. A variational Monte Carlo computation with a single admitted structural term yields a ground-state energy of -2.8908 ± 0.0007 Hartree, beyond the Hartree-Fock limit (-2.86168) that bounds all separable methods; extending along the same admitted coordinate reaches -2.9024 against the experimental value -2.90372. This paper also stands published in the SourceTech community on Zenodo: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23745845 — Community: https://zenodo.org/communities/sourcetech — The Source Codex of Mathematics (the Book): https://jalejaproducts3.gumroad.com/l/cglqnv — Speaking and correspondence: dwayne@sourcetecei.com

•Oct 29, 2026•0 citations

Helium Atom Excitations by the GW and Bethe-Salpeter Many-Body Formalism

Jing Li, Markus Holzmann, Ivan Duchemin +2 more

The helium atom is the simplest many-body electronic system provided by nature. The exact solution to the Schrödinger equation is known for helium ground and excited states, and it represents a benchmark for any many-body methodology. Here, we check the ab initio many-body GW approximation and the Bethe-Salpeter equation (BSE) against the exact solution for helium. Starting from the Hartree-Fock method, we show that the GW and the BSE yield impressively accurate results on excitation energies and oscillator strength, systematically improving the time-dependent Hartree-Fock method. These findings suggest that the accuracy of the BSE and GW approximations is not significantly limited by self-interaction and self-screening problems even in this few electron limit. We further discuss our results in comparison to those obtained by time-dependent density-functional theory.

arXiv:1611.07456•Physical Review Letters•Apr 17, 2017•29 citations

Comparing many-body approaches against the helium atom exact solution

Jing Li, N. D. Drummond, Peter Schuck +1 more

Over time, many different theories and approaches have been developed to tackle the many-body problem in quantum chemistry, condensed-matter physics, and nuclear physics. Here we use the helium atom, a real system rather than a model, and we use the exact solution of its Schrödinger equation as a benchmark for comparison between methods. We present new results beyond the random-phase approximation (RPA) from a renormalized RPA (r-RPA) in the framework of the self-consistent RPA (SCRPA) originally developed in nuclear physics, and compare them with various other approaches like configuration interaction (CI), quantum Monte Carlo (QMC), time-dependent density-functional theory (TDDFT), and the Bethe-Salpeter equation on top of the \boldsymbol{GW} 𝐆 𝐖 approximation. Most of the calculations are consistently done on the same footing, e.g. using the same basis set, in an effort for a most faithful comparison between methods.

arXiv:1801.09977•SciPost Physics•Apr 1, 2019•30 citations

On the Energy of a “Two-Dimensional” Two-Electron Atom

В. В. Скобелев

With the use of the known solution of the Schrödinger equation for an electron in the nucleus field in the polar coordinates, the energy of a “two-dimensional” two-electron atom in the ground state, as well as its single ionization energy, has been calculated both in perturbation theory and with an almost century-old method of variation of the parameter Z in a trial wavefunction of the ground state. Since such two-dimensional atoms, e.g., helium atoms, can in principle be implemented in experiments by “freezing” of one degree of freedom in the phase of Bose–Einstein condensate, the conclusions made in this work can be tested. Fundamental features of the calculation of the energy of “one-dimensional” two-electron atoms and the formation of their Bose–Einstein condensate have also been discussed. The results obtained in this work coincide in a number of particular cases with the results obtained in a previous work, where some results were absent.

Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics•Dec 1, 2017•9 citations

Wrong Potential Energy Term in Schrödinger’s Equation for Hydrogen Atom

Gurcharn Singh Sandhu

Even after nine decades of successful run of the Quantum Mechanics (QM), different viewpoints on foundational problems of Quantum Physics are still being actively debated. That is because mathematical logic of QM often defies the physical intuition which constitutes the main spirit of Physics. De Broglie’s hypothesis of matter waves implied that the dynamic characteristics of a micro particle in motion, can be ascribed to the wave characteristics of the wavelet accompanying the particle. The Schrödinger equation models the matter-wave interactions through wavefunction ψ and effectively serves as the foundation of QM. Even though mathematical structure of the Schrödinger equation is sound and elegant, here we show a conceptual mistake in the development of this equation wherein the physical situation has not been correctly modeled in the equation. The Coulomb potential energy of the proton electron pair in Hydrogen atom is essentially the negative interaction energy between their superposed electrostatic fields which is inversely proportional to their instantaneous separation distance. Assuming the proton to be relatively fixed at the origin of an appropriate coordinate system, the potential energy of the orbiting electron will be a function of instantaneous position coordinates of the electron. This has not been properly modeled in the Schrödinger equation. The resulting errors in the solution have been quantitatively demonstrated in this paper. We have stressed the necessity of incorporating a specific correction in the potential energy term of the Schrödinger equation, after which it may facilitate the adoption of Bohmian QM.

Journal of Modern Physics•Jan 1, 2018•4 citations

Proposed definitions of the correlation energy density from a Hartree-Fock starting point: The two-electron Moshinsky model atom as an exactly solvable model

Norman Henry March, A. Cabo, Francisco H. Claro +1 more

In both molecular physics and condensed matter theory, deeper understanding of the correlation energy density ${ϵ}_{c}(\mathbf{r})$ remains a high priority. By adopting L\"owdin's definition of correlation energy as the difference between the exact and the Hartree-Fock values, here we propose two alternative routes to define this. One of these involves both exact and Hartree-Fock (HF) wave functions, while the second requires a coupling constant integration. As an exact analytical example of the first route, we treat the two-electron model atom of Moshinsky, for which both confinement potential and interactions are harmonic. Though the correlation energy density ${ϵ}_{c}(\mathbf{r})$ is known analytically, we also investigate numerically its relation to the exact ground-state density in this example.

arXiv:0803.2594•Physical Review A•Apr 4, 2008•16 citations
The time-independent Schrödinger equation for the helium atom has stood for a century as the canonical example of a quantum problem with no exact solution: the electron–electron repulsion term 1/r12 couples the coordinates inseparably, and the field's settled practice is approximation (Hartree–Fock, configuration interaction, density functional theory). This paper reports a completed result obtained by a different route. Rather than approximating the equation as posed, the problem was immersed in a complete relational framework (the Source Codex of Mathematics, Peay), whose structure diagnoses what a formulation is missing. The immersion identified a single structural defect: the standard formulation poses the atom as two independent electrons plus an orphaned interaction term, while the pair-distance r12 is never admitted as a structural coordinate of the wavefunction. Completing the structure — admitting u = r12 as a member of the wavefunction — collapses the problem. A variational Monte Carlo computation with a single admitted structural term yields a ground-state energy of -2.8908 ± 0.0007 Hartree, beyond the Hartree-Fock limit (-2.86168) that bounds all separable methods; extending along the same admitted coordinate reaches -2.9024 against the experimental value -2.90372.
The time-independent Schrödinger equation for the helium atom has stood for a century as the canonical example of a quantum problem with no exact solution: the electron–electron repulsion term 1/r12 couples the coordinates inseparably, and the field's settled practice is approximation (Hartree–Fock, configuration interaction, density functional theory). This paper reports a completed result obtained by a different route. Rather than approximating the equation as posed, the problem was immersed in a complete relational framework (the Source Codex of Mathematics, Peay), whose structure diagnoses what a formulation is missing. The immersion identified a single structural defect: the standard formulation poses the atom as two independent electrons plus an orphaned interaction term, while the pair-distance r12 is never admitted as a structural coordinate of the wavefunction. Completing the structure — admitting u = r12 as a member of the wavefunction — collapses the problem. A variational Monte Carlo computation with a single admitted structural term yields a ground-state energy of -2.8908 ± 0.0007 Hartree, beyond the Hartree-Fock limit (-2.86168) that bounds all separable methods; extending along the same admitted coordinate reaches -2.9024 against the experimental value -2.90372. This paper also stands published in the SourceTech community on Zenodo: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23745845 — Community: https://zenodo.org/communities/sourcetech — The Source Codex of Mathematics (the Book): https://jalejaproducts3.gumroad.com/l/cglqnv — Speaking and correspondence: dwayne@sourcetecei.com
The helium atom is the simplest many-body electronic system provided by nature. The exact solution to the Schrödinger equation is known for helium ground and excited states, and it represents a benchmark for any many-body methodology. Here, we check the ab initio many-body GW approximation and the Bethe-Salpeter equation (BSE) against the exact solution for helium. Starting from the Hartree-Fock method, we show that the GW and the BSE yield impressively accurate results on excitation energies and oscillator strength, systematically improving the time-dependent Hartree-Fock method. These findings suggest that the accuracy of the BSE and GW approximations is not significantly limited by self-interaction and self-screening problems even in this few electron limit. We further discuss our results in comparison to those obtained by time-dependent density-functional theory.
Over time, many different theories and approaches have been developed to tackle the many-body problem in quantum chemistry, condensed-matter physics, and nuclear physics. Here we use the helium atom, a real system rather than a model, and we use the exact solution of its Schrödinger equation as a benchmark for comparison between methods. We present new results beyond the random-phase approximation (RPA) from a renormalized RPA (r-RPA) in the framework of the self-consistent RPA (SCRPA) originally developed in nuclear physics, and compare them with various other approaches like configuration interaction (CI), quantum Monte Carlo (QMC), time-dependent density-functional theory (TDDFT), and the Bethe-Salpeter equation on top of the \boldsymbol{GW} 𝐆 𝐖 approximation. Most of the calculations are consistently done on the same footing, e.g. using the same basis set, in an effort for a most faithful comparison between methods.
With the use of the known solution of the Schrödinger equation for an electron in the nucleus field in the polar coordinates, the energy of a “two-dimensional” two-electron atom in the ground state, as well as its single ionization energy, has been calculated both in perturbation theory and with an almost century-old method of variation of the parameter Z in a trial wavefunction of the ground state. Since such two-dimensional atoms, e.g., helium atoms, can in principle be implemented in experiments by “freezing” of one degree of freedom in the phase of Bose–Einstein condensate, the conclusions made in this work can be tested. Fundamental features of the calculation of the energy of “one-dimensional” two-electron atoms and the formation of their Bose–Einstein condensate have also been discussed. The results obtained in this work coincide in a number of particular cases with the results obtained in a previous work, where some results were absent.
Even after nine decades of successful run of the Quantum Mechanics (QM), different viewpoints on foundational problems of Quantum Physics are still being actively debated. That is because mathematical logic of QM often defies the physical intuition which constitutes the main spirit of Physics. De Broglie’s hypothesis of matter waves implied that the dynamic characteristics of a micro particle in motion, can be ascribed to the wave characteristics of the wavelet accompanying the particle. The Schrödinger equation models the matter-wave interactions through wavefunction ψ and effectively serves as the foundation of QM. Even though mathematical structure of the Schrödinger equation is sound and elegant, here we show a conceptual mistake in the development of this equation wherein the physical situation has not been correctly modeled in the equation. The Coulomb potential energy of the proton electron pair in Hydrogen atom is essentially the negative interaction energy between their superposed electrostatic fields which is inversely proportional to their instantaneous separation distance. Assuming the proton to be relatively fixed at the origin of an appropriate coordinate system, the potential energy of the orbiting electron will be a function of instantaneous position coordinates of the electron. This has not been properly modeled in the Schrödinger equation. The resulting errors in the solution have been quantitatively demonstrated in this paper. We have stressed the necessity of incorporating a specific correction in the potential energy term of the Schrödinger equation, after which it may facilitate the adoption of Bohmian QM.
In both molecular physics and condensed matter theory, deeper understanding of the correlation energy density ϵc(r){ϵ}_{c}(\mathbf{r})ϵc​(r) remains a high priority. By adopting L\"owdin's definition of correlation energy as the difference between the exact and the Hartree-Fock values, here we propose two alternative routes to define this. One of these involves both exact and Hartree-Fock (HF) wave functions, while the second requires a coupling constant integration. As an exact analytical example of the first route, we treat the two-electron model atom of Moshinsky, for which both confinement potential and interactions are harmonic. Though the correlation energy density ϵc(r){ϵ}_{c}(\mathbf{r})ϵc​(r) is known analytically, we also investigate numerically its relation to the exact ground-state density in this example.