Even after nine decades of successful run of the Quantum Mechanics (QM), different viewpoints on foundational problems of Quantum Physics are still being actively debated. That is because mathematical logic of QM often defies the physical intuition which constitutes the main spirit of Physics. De Broglie’s hypothesis of matter waves implied that the dynamic characteristics of a micro particle in motion, can be ascribed to the wave characteristics of the wavelet accompanying the particle. The Schrödinger equation models the matter-wave interactions through wavefunction ψ and effectively serves as the foundation of QM. Even though mathematical structure of the Schrödinger equation is sound and elegant, here we show a conceptual mistake in the development of this equation wherein the physical situation has not been correctly modeled in the equation. The Coulomb potential energy of the proton electron pair in Hydrogen atom is essentially the negative interaction energy between their superposed electrostatic fields which is inversely proportional to their instantaneous separation distance. Assuming the proton to be relatively fixed at the origin of an appropriate coordinate system, the potential energy of the orbiting electron will be a function of instantaneous position coordinates of the electron. This has not been properly modeled in the Schrödinger equation. The resulting errors in the solution have been quantitatively demonstrated in this paper. We have stressed the necessity of incorporating a specific correction in the potential energy term of the Schrödinger equation, after which it may facilitate the adoption of Bohmian QM.
Even after nine decades of successful run of the Quantum Mechanics (QM), different viewpoints on foundational problems of Quantum Physics are still being actively debated. That is because mathematical logic of QM often defies the physical intuition which constitutes the main spirit of Physics. De Broglie’s hypothesis of matter waves implied that the dynamic characteristics of a micro particle in motion, can be ascribed to the wave characteristics of the wavelet accompanying the particle. The Schrödinger equation models the matter-wave interactions through wavefunction ψ and effectively serves as the foundation of QM. Even though mathematical structure of the Schrödinger equation is sound and elegant, here we show a conceptual mistake in the development of this equation wherein the physical situation has not been correctly modeled in the equation. The Coulomb potential energy of the proton electron pair in Hydrogen atom is essentially the negative interaction energy between their superposed electrostatic fields which is inversely proportional to their instantaneous separation distance. Assuming the proton to be relatively fixed at the origin of an appropriate coordinate system, the potential energy of the orbiting electron will be a function of instantaneous position coordinates of the electron. This has not been properly modeled in the Schrödinger equation. The resulting errors in the solution have been quantitatively demonstrated in this paper. We have stressed the necessity of incorporating a specific correction in the potential energy term of the Schrödinger equation, after which it may facilitate the adoption of Bohmian QM.
The Schrodinger equation has been considered to be a postulate of quantum physics, but it is also perceived and derived heuristically as the quantum equivalent of the classical energy relation. We indicate that the Schrodinger equation cannot be a physical postulate, and we show that the heuristic derivations wrongly consider that the particle kinetic energy is proportional to the square of the momentum operator acting on the wavefunction. The correct term is proportional to the square of the momentum. Analyzing particle interactions, we realize that particles have multiple virtual motions and that each motion is accompanied by a wave that has constant amplitude. Accordingly, we define the wavefunction as the superposition of the virtual waves of the particle. As a result, quantum mechanics becomes a local and global theory, while in the traditional formulation it is a local theory. In several interaction settings we can tell what particle motions arise and explain the outcomes in simple and tangible terms. Most importantly, the mathematical foundation of quantum mechanics becomes clear and justified, and we derive the Schrodinger, Dirac, etc. equations as the conditions the wavefunction must satisfy at each space-time point in order to fulfill the respective total energy equation.
Employing reciprocity considerations, de Broglie conjectured in 1923 that because electromagnetic radiation exhibits some particle behavior, matter particles should exhibit some wave behavior. Schrödinger undertook a step to specifically express de Broglie's particle wave equation. Observation of Schrödinger equations suggests the definition of various differential operators on the Ψ functions space. The hydrogen atom consists of a single proton of positive charge and a single electron of negative charge, orbiting around the proton. All atoms and ions having a single orbiting electron are considered “hydrogen-like”. To find out the selection rules one needs to study the wave functions characteristics of the electron states, as well as the photon characteristics. For deductive brevity of addressing the selection rules issue, several teaching texts argue that they all stem from parity properties of the Y ℓm (θ, φ) function.
The validity of the de Broglie formula λ=h⁄p for matter waves has been confirmed by numerous experiments such as Davisson-Germer and G. P. Thomson experiments. But there is a big problem here. If λ=h⁄p is valid for matter waves, we must be able to obtain it for these waves using the mathematical calculations. But as you will see here, according to de Broglie's hypothesis, which considers matter wave energy is E=hf, this work is impossible; and so, we must change the matter wave energy equation to extract λ=h⁄p. The change in the equation of energy causes two important changes in the Schrodinger’s wave equation. These two changes bring us to a new wave equation. In the fourth part of the article, you will see that we need a new atomic model for the hydrogen atom due to some problems. The new model leads us to new results and findings. In this Article, we show what the cause of the quantization of the orbits in the Bohr atomic model is.
The validity of the de Broglie formula λ=h⁄p for matter waves has been confirmed by numerous experiments such as Davisson-Germer and G. P. Thomson experiments. But there is a major problem here. If λ=h⁄p is valid for matter waves, we must be able to obtain it for these waves using mathematical calculations. But as you will see here, according to de Broglie's hypothesis, which considers matter wave energy equal to E=hf, this work is impossible; and so, we must change the matter wave energy equation to obtain λ=h⁄p. The change in the equation of energy causes two important changes in Schrodinger’s wave equation. These two changes bring us to a new wave equation. In the fourth part of the article you will see that, for explanation of the reason for the quantization of the orbits in Bohr's atomic model, we need a new atomic model for the Hydrogen atom. The new model leads us to new results and findings. In this article, we show what the cause of the quantization of the orbits in the Bohr atomic model is.
The validity of the de Broglie formula λ=h⁄p for matter waves has been confirmed by numerous experiments such as Davisson-Germer and G. P. Thomson experiments. But there is a major problem here. If λ=h⁄p is valid for matter waves, we must be able to obtain it for these waves using mathematical calculations. But as you will see here, according to de Broglie's hypothesis, which considers matter wave energy equal to E=hf, this work is impossible; and so, we must change the matter wave energy equation to obtain λ=h⁄p. The change in the equation of energy causes two important changes in Schrodinger’s wave equation. These two changes bring us to a new wave equation. In the fourth part of the article you will see that, for explanation of the reason for the quantization of the orbits in Bohr's atomic model, we need a new atomic model for the Hydrogen atom. The new model leads us to new results and findings. In this article, we show what the cause of the quantization of the orbits in the Bohr atomic model is.
The hydrogen atom is the simplest atom, which is a system of two particles, namely, a proton and an electron. In this system, a single electron moves in the field of a nucleus of unit positive charge. This system is bound by electrostatic force of attraction. In other words, we can say that the electron of the hydrogen atom revolves around the nucleus in the field of the force of the nucleus. Since hydrogen is the simplest atom, it formsthe basis for the theoretical treatment of more complex atomic systems. The Schrödinger equation for hydrogen atom can be solved in closed form. When the next atom in the order of increasing complexity is considered, for example, Helium, which consists of two electrons moving in the field of the nucleus with charge two, the Schrödinger equation can no longer be solved in closed form. For the solution of such systems, the approximate methods are employed to get the wave function. The hydrogen atom (simple solution of Schrödinger equation) As already stated that the hydrogen atom is one electron system with a charge ‘−e’ rotating around a central proton (p) with charge ‘+e’ . The potential energy of the system is expressed as Putting the value of V in the Schrödinger equation, we have To solve the Schrödinger equation for hydrogen atom, let us consider where, r is the distance of electron from the nucleus. Differentiating Eq. (8.3) with respect to x , we shall get Differentiating the above equation again with respect to x , we obtain Putting the value of or r 2 ψ in Eq. (8.2), we shall get The simplest solution of Eq. (8.5) may be given by Differentiating this equation with respect to r twice, we shall get Putting these values in Eq. (8.5), we have Since Eq. (8.8) is true for any value of r , the sum of the first two terms, which is independent of r and the third term involving r should be separately zero because the equation should also be satisfied when r → ∞, We can equate Eqs (8.9) and (8.10) and shall get This is the value of energy of hydrogen atom. It is clear that E is negative, which indicates that the electron is bound.