Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Universal death of magic precedes universal death of entanglement in Pauli Gibbs states

Dylan Z. Liu Liu

Published Feb 7, 2025• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Above some temperature every thermal state of a Hamiltonian family is separable, and above another every thermal state is a mixture of stabilizer states, which carry no magic. Putterman, Zlokapa and Cotler conjectured that the second temperature is the lower one, so that heating removes magic from a whole family before entanglement. We prove this ordering for Pauli Hamiltonians of bounded interaction degree or bounded neighbourhood strength, the two families whose separability threshold is known exactly. A Clifford reduction shows that a Gibbs state is a stabilizer mixture whenever that of a canonical all-anticommuting Hamiltonian on the anticommutation graph of its terms is, with equivalence for independent terms, so commuting overlaps drop out of the guarantee. A cluster expansion exploiting anticommutation then shows that every Gibbs state is a stabilizer mixture for βΛ ≤ 0.2183, strictly beyond the sharp separability constant 1/(2e) ≈ 0.1839, and an exactly solvable graph caps the constant at 0.6232. A single Hamiltonian can still order its own transitions the other way. Because the guarantee counts only anticommuting neighbours, it certifies magic-free Gibbs states of the transverse-field Ising, Heisenberg, Kitaev and perturbed toric-code models at temperatures 1.1 to 5.6 times lower than those at which separability is guaranteed.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.23376931

Related papers

Sharp universal death of entanglement threshold for Pauli Hamiltonians

Bobak T. Kiani

We determine the exact universal high-temperature separability threshold for Pauli Hamiltonians of bounded degree $Δ\ge2$. If every coefficient in the Hamiltonian has magnitude at most one and each term has overlapping support with at most $Δ$ other terms, the Gibbs state is a mixture of product Pauli eigenstates whenever \[ β\le z_Δ:= \operatorname{arctanh}\left[\max_{0\le x \le 1}x\left(\frac{1-x}{1+x}\right)^{Δ-1} \right]. \] For every $β>z_Δ$, a finite commuting Hamiltonian with maximum overlap degree at most $Δ$ has an entangled Gibbs state. At any fixed $β<z_Δ$ strictly below the threshold, a classical polynomial-time algorithm produces samples from a distribution over product Pauli eigenstates approximating the Gibbs state in trace distance.

quant-pharXiv:2609.30149•Sep 25, 2026•1 citation

When quantum thermal states look classical

Harald Putterman, Alexander Zlokapa, Jordan Cotler

At high temperature, quantum Gibbs states retain several classical features of the maximally mixed state: the absence of entanglement, the absence of magic, analyticity of the partition function, correlation decay, and algorithmic tractability. We prove new and sharp bounds showing that these features persist down to finite temperatures independent of system size, but fail at distinct inverse-temperature scales, forming a hierarchy of classical-to-quantum transitions. Our results hold for long-range Pauli interactions with bounded strength at every site. Despite such all-to-all interactions, we show that the death of entanglement occurs at constant temperature, resolving an open question of Rouze, Franca and Alhambra (STOC'25). We give a polynomial-time classical algorithm that prepares Gibbs states up to the death of entanglement transition. Notably, this is asymptotically colder than temperatures at which quantum Gibbs samplers are known to mix quickly, as well as the original separability temperature of Bakshi et al. (FOCS'24), which we improve to be tight up to constants. At asymptotically even colder temperatures, we show that the Gibbs state remains in the thermodynamic infinite-temperature phase. We give polynomial-time classical algorithms for estimating thermal expectations up to the phase transition (despite both entanglement and magic), and as a corollary resolve a correlation decay conjecture of Harrow, Mehraban and Soleimanifar (STOC'20).

quant-pharXiv:2607.28536•Jul 31, 2026•12 citations

Fate of Quantum Magic

Liuke Lyu, Erik S. Sørensen, William Witczak-Krempa

Magic, a quantum resource distinct from entanglement, measures departure from states stabilized by products of Pauli operators. Such stabilizer states can be maximally entangled yet admit efficient classical description: quantum advantage requires magic. We develop a powerful framework to evaluate the degree of magic in generic many-body states. We use it to study the fate of magic under thermal and dynamical evolution. In the transverse field Ising model, we find a thermal sudden death of magic that saturates with system size, and occurs after the death of entanglement. We reach similar conclusions in generic spin chains, and in the Kitaev quantum spin liquid on the honeycomb lattice, where the threshold shows an intricate dependence on subregion shape. We then study how magic equilibrates after a quantum quench. In quenches of generic spin chains, the magic of a subregion typically dies before entanglement, contrary to thermal trajectories. An explanation is given in terms of the geometry of non-magical states. As a third type of trajectory, we examine the fate of magic with separation with an appropriate notion of non-local magic and establish a sudden death. Finally, we show how to experimentally witness a volume law of frame-robust magic in quantum materials by using neutron scattering.

quant-pharXiv:2610.39059•Oct 30, 2026•1 citation

Sharp universal death of entanglement threshold for Pauli Hamiltonians — E8 Intelligence Research

Andrew Stewart Caldin

We determine the exact universal high-temperature separability threshold for Pauli Hamiltonians of bounded degree $Δ\ge2$. If every coefficient in the Hamiltonian has magnitude at most one and each term has overlapping support with at most $Δ$ other terms, the Gibbs state is a mixture of product Pauli eigenstates whenever \[ β\le z_Δ:= \operatorname{arctanh}\left[\max_{0\le x \le 1}x\left(\frac{1-x}{1+x}\right)^{Δ-1} \right]. \] For every $β>z_Δ$, a finite commuting Hamiltonian with maximum overlap degree at most $Δ$ has an entangled Gibbs state. At any fixed $β Author: Andrew Stewart Caldin, Independent Researcher, UK. Part of the E8 Intelligence Research series. Platform: e8intelligence.com

•Nov 13, 2026•0 citations

One-dimensional quantum Gibbs states in constant circuit depth

Saúl Pilatowsky-Cameo, Georgios Styliaris, Ainesh Bakshi +1 more

We prove that the Gibbs state of any spin chain can be exactly decomposed into a mixture of product states over contiguous blocks of qubits with bounded length, at any constant temperature. As a consequence, any such Gibbs state can be prepared by local unitary circuits of constant depth, with efficient classical preprocessing. We place strong limits on the spatial structure of thermal entanglement: both the entanglement depth and entanglement width (measures of multiparticle entanglement) are bounded by constants, while the localizable entanglement (the bipartite entanglement that can be generated with the aid of local measurements and classical communication) vanishes exactly beyond a constant threshold distance. Our result also has implications for quantum thermalization: for any translation-invariant spin-chain Hamiltonian with nondegenerate spectral gaps, typical low-complexity pure states drawn from a maximally entropic ensemble at any constant effective temperature become locally indistinguishable from the Gibbs state upon unitary evolution. Additionally, we obtain an analogous decomposition for fermionic systems: the Gibbs state of any 1D local fermionic Hamiltonian is exactly a mixture of constant-depth local fermionic circuits acting on Gaussian states.

quant-pharXiv:2609.35973•Sep 30, 2026•4 citations

Magic Without Entanglement: Exact Revivals and Their Fisher Information Origin

Rishabh Jha, Karun Gadge

Magic and entanglement are independent quantum resources, yet their exact relation in many-body dynamics has remained elusive. We uncover two structural principles. First, at any stabilizer state, the curvature of the second stabilizer Rényi entropy under an arbitrary Hermitian generator equals the quantum Fisher information up to a fixed normalization, creating a bidirectional bridge between computational and metrological resources. Second, for commuting Ising evolution on any forest graph, a Clifford pruning circuit yields the full stabilizer-Rényi family at arbitrary size and in any spatial embedding, thereby furnishing a graph-theoretic construction of families with finite magic density and vanishing entanglement density in the thermodynamic limit. We solve two paradigmatic one-dimensional realizations central to quantum simulation -- an Ising quench and a kicked Floquet chain -- exactly for arbitrary system size and directly in the thermodynamic limit, revealing finite magic density with vanishing entanglement density, distinct magic and entanglement revival periods, and Clifford points with zero magic but finite bipartite entanglement. The same tangent geometry fixes initial growth, perturbative revival lifting, and stability of thermodynamic magic minima. Large-scale Pauli-basis matrix-product-state calculations verify all predictions, and the tangent bridge yields a concrete protocol for detecting magic through established quantum-Fisher-information measurements.

quant-pharXiv:2607.14222•Jul 17, 2026•3 citations
Above some temperature every thermal state of a Hamiltonian family is separable, and above another every thermal state is a mixture of stabilizer states, which carry no magic. Putterman, Zlokapa and Cotler conjectured that the second temperature is the lower one, so that heating removes magic from a whole family before entanglement. We prove this ordering for Pauli Hamiltonians of bounded interaction degree or bounded neighbourhood strength, the two families whose separability threshold is known exactly. A Clifford reduction shows that a Gibbs state is a stabilizer mixture whenever that of a canonical all-anticommuting Hamiltonian on the anticommutation graph of its terms is, with equivalence for independent terms, so commuting overlaps drop out of the guarantee. A cluster expansion exploiting anticommutation then shows that every Gibbs state is a stabilizer mixture for βΛ ≤ 0.2183, strictly beyond the sharp separability constant 1/(2e) ≈ 0.1839, and an exactly solvable graph caps the constant at 0.6232. A single Hamiltonian can still order its own transitions the other way. Because the guarantee counts only anticommuting neighbours, it certifies magic-free Gibbs states of the transverse-field Ising, Heisenberg, Kitaev and perturbed toric-code models at temperatures 1.1 to 5.6 times lower than those at which separability is guaranteed.
We determine the exact universal high-temperature separability threshold for Pauli Hamiltonians of bounded degree Δ≥2Δ\ge2Δ≥2. If every coefficient in the Hamiltonian has magnitude at most one and each term has overlapping support with at most ΔΔΔ other terms, the Gibbs state is a mixture of product Pauli eigenstates whenever β≤zΔ:=arctanh⁡[max⁡0≤x≤1x(1−x1+x)Δ−1]. β\le z_Δ:= \operatorname{arctanh}\left[\max_{0\le x \le 1}x\left(\frac{1-x}{1+x}\right)^{Δ-1} \right]. β≤zΔ​:=arctanh[max0≤x≤1​x(1+x1−x​)Δ−1]. For every β>zΔβ>z_Δβ>zΔ​, a finite commuting Hamiltonian with maximum overlap degree at most ΔΔΔ has an entangled Gibbs state. At any fixed β<zΔβ<z_Δβ<zΔ​ strictly below the threshold, a classical polynomial-time algorithm produces samples from a distribution over product Pauli eigenstates approximating the Gibbs state in trace distance.
At high temperature, quantum Gibbs states retain several classical features of the maximally mixed state: the absence of entanglement, the absence of magic, analyticity of the partition function, correlation decay, and algorithmic tractability. We prove new and sharp bounds showing that these features persist down to finite temperatures independent of system size, but fail at distinct inverse-temperature scales, forming a hierarchy of classical-to-quantum transitions. Our results hold for long-range Pauli interactions with bounded strength at every site. Despite such all-to-all interactions, we show that the death of entanglement occurs at constant temperature, resolving an open question of Rouze, Franca and Alhambra (STOC'25). We give a polynomial-time classical algorithm that prepares Gibbs states up to the death of entanglement transition. Notably, this is asymptotically colder than temperatures at which quantum Gibbs samplers are known to mix quickly, as well as the original separability temperature of Bakshi et al. (FOCS'24), which we improve to be tight up to constants. At asymptotically even colder temperatures, we show that the Gibbs state remains in the thermodynamic infinite-temperature phase. We give polynomial-time classical algorithms for estimating thermal expectations up to the phase transition (despite both entanglement and magic), and as a corollary resolve a correlation decay conjecture of Harrow, Mehraban and Soleimanifar (STOC'20).
Magic, a quantum resource distinct from entanglement, measures departure from states stabilized by products of Pauli operators. Such stabilizer states can be maximally entangled yet admit efficient classical description: quantum advantage requires magic. We develop a powerful framework to evaluate the degree of magic in generic many-body states. We use it to study the fate of magic under thermal and dynamical evolution. In the transverse field Ising model, we find a thermal sudden death of magic that saturates with system size, and occurs after the death of entanglement. We reach similar conclusions in generic spin chains, and in the Kitaev quantum spin liquid on the honeycomb lattice, where the threshold shows an intricate dependence on subregion shape. We then study how magic equilibrates after a quantum quench. In quenches of generic spin chains, the magic of a subregion typically dies before entanglement, contrary to thermal trajectories. An explanation is given in terms of the geometry of non-magical states. As a third type of trajectory, we examine the fate of magic with separation with an appropriate notion of non-local magic and establish a sudden death. Finally, we show how to experimentally witness a volume law of frame-robust magic in quantum materials by using neutron scattering.
We determine the exact universal high-temperature separability threshold for Pauli Hamiltonians of bounded degree Δ≥2Δ\ge2Δ≥2. If every coefficient in the Hamiltonian has magnitude at most one and each term has overlapping support with at most ΔΔΔ other terms, the Gibbs state is a mixture of product Pauli eigenstates whenever β≤zΔ:=arctanh⁡[max⁡0≤x≤1x(1−x1+x)Δ−1]. β\le z_Δ:= \operatorname{arctanh}\left[\max_{0\le x \le 1}x\left(\frac{1-x}{1+x}\right)^{Δ-1} \right]. β≤zΔ​:=arctanh[max0≤x≤1​x(1+x1−x​)Δ−1]. For every β>zΔβ>z_Δβ>zΔ​, a finite commuting Hamiltonian with maximum overlap degree at most ΔΔΔ has an entangled Gibbs state. At any fixed $β Author: Andrew Stewart Caldin, Independent Researcher, UK. Part of the E8 Intelligence Research series. Platform: e8intelligence.com
We prove that the Gibbs state of any spin chain can be exactly decomposed into a mixture of product states over contiguous blocks of qubits with bounded length, at any constant temperature. As a consequence, any such Gibbs state can be prepared by local unitary circuits of constant depth, with efficient classical preprocessing. We place strong limits on the spatial structure of thermal entanglement: both the entanglement depth and entanglement width (measures of multiparticle entanglement) are bounded by constants, while the localizable entanglement (the bipartite entanglement that can be generated with the aid of local measurements and classical communication) vanishes exactly beyond a constant threshold distance. Our result also has implications for quantum thermalization: for any translation-invariant spin-chain Hamiltonian with nondegenerate spectral gaps, typical low-complexity pure states drawn from a maximally entropic ensemble at any constant effective temperature become locally indistinguishable from the Gibbs state upon unitary evolution. Additionally, we obtain an analogous decomposition for fermionic systems: the Gibbs state of any 1D local fermionic Hamiltonian is exactly a mixture of constant-depth local fermionic circuits acting on Gaussian states.
Magic and entanglement are independent quantum resources, yet their exact relation in many-body dynamics has remained elusive. We uncover two structural principles. First, at any stabilizer state, the curvature of the second stabilizer Rényi entropy under an arbitrary Hermitian generator equals the quantum Fisher information up to a fixed normalization, creating a bidirectional bridge between computational and metrological resources. Second, for commuting Ising evolution on any forest graph, a Clifford pruning circuit yields the full stabilizer-Rényi family at arbitrary size and in any spatial embedding, thereby furnishing a graph-theoretic construction of families with finite magic density and vanishing entanglement density in the thermodynamic limit. We solve two paradigmatic one-dimensional realizations central to quantum simulation -- an Ising quench and a kicked Floquet chain -- exactly for arbitrary system size and directly in the thermodynamic limit, revealing finite magic density with vanishing entanglement density, distinct magic and entanglement revival periods, and Clifford points with zero magic but finite bipartite entanglement. The same tangent geometry fixes initial growth, perturbative revival lifting, and stability of thermodynamic magic minima. Large-scale Pauli-basis matrix-product-state calculations verify all predictions, and the tangent bridge yields a concrete protocol for detecting magic through established quantum-Fisher-information measurements.