arXiv:2610.39059
Fate of Quantum Magic
Liuke Lyu, Erik S. Sørensen, William Witczak-Krempa
Abstract
Magic, a quantum resource distinct from entanglement, measures departure from states stabilized by products of Pauli operators. Such stabilizer states can be maximally entangled yet admit efficient classical description: quantum advantage requires magic. We develop a powerful framework to evaluate the degree of magic in generic many-body states. We use it to study the fate of magic under thermal and dynamical evolution. In the transverse field Ising model, we find a thermal sudden death of magic that saturates with system size, and occurs after the death of entanglement. We reach similar conclusions in generic spin chains, and in the Kitaev quantum spin liquid on the honeycomb lattice, where the threshold shows an intricate dependence on subregion shape. We then study how magic equilibrates after a quantum quench. In quenches of generic spin chains, the magic of a subregion typically dies before entanglement, contrary to thermal trajectories. An explanation is given in terms of the geometry of non-magical states. As a third type of trajectory, we examine the fate of magic with separation with an appropriate notion of non-local magic and establish a sudden death. Finally, we show how to experimentally witness a volume law of frame-robust magic in quantum materials by using neutron scattering.
AI Summary
The paper studies when mixed-state magic disappears under heating, post-quench evolution, and spatial separation, and how bulk measurements can certify extensive magic. Magic is quantified by Bures distance to the stabilizer polytope, a faithful monotone under stabilizer-preserving channels. A GPU-accelerated Stabilizer-Orbit Frank–Wolfe algorithm (SOFA) produces upper bounds on this distance for mixed states up to 12 qubits. Separate stabilizer decompositions and exhaustive witnesses certify membership and nonmembership for smaller blocks. For the critical infinite transverse-field Ising chain, block-size extrapolation gives a magic-death temperature $T_c/J=2.6395$, with a rigorous lower bound $T_c/J>2.61$. The extrapolated entanglement threshold is $T/J=1.7093$, assuming PPT and separability thresholds continue to coincide beyond the tested sizes. Entanglement-first thermal death also occurs in Kitaev-model subregions and 42/50 sampled generic chains. Conversely, magic dies first in 36/40 and 24/25 resolved random-quench samples; an integrable Ising quench retains late-time magic. Sampled stabilizer-boundary geometry motivates, but does not prove, this typical ordering. The paper defines genuine bipartite magic through nonpreparability from shared stabilizers and arbitrary party-local channels, and numerically finds death with separation before entanglement. It also proves a local-to-global certificate: homogeneous correlations satisfying $m^2+|C_{xx}|>1$ imply frame-robust convex-roof stabilizer-nullity density $n_{\rm fr}\geq2(m^2+|C_{xx}|-1)$. Magnetometry and neutron-scattering observables can access this preparation-cost bound. Limitations include increasingly costly optimization near thresholds, finite-size extrapolations, unresolved quenches, and witness failure not implying absence of magic. No experimental measurement is reported.
Central claim may not hold: The quoted infinite-chain magic-death temperature 2.6395 is inferred by finite-block extrapolation, whereas the supplied near-threshold certificates establish only a thermodynamic lower bound greater than 2.61. The thermodynamic comparison with entanglement death relies on an extrapolated PPT threshold and an unproved identification of that threshold with full separability. Positive SOFA distances do not certify magic because they are upper bounds, leaving the larger-block magic thresholds without the independent certification supplied through seven qubits.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 15+10 pages, 6+3 figures