We present a unified analysis of Bell and Leggett-type inequality violations for the maximally polarization-entangled Bell states |Ψ±⟩ and |Φ±⟩ within a single measurement framework on the Poincaré sphere. Using the symmetry-independent Leggett inequality together with a common correlation model and a Jones-matrix description of polarization analysis, we evaluate the Leggett parameterL3(φ) and the CHSH parameterSCHSHfor all four Bell states, showing thatL3(φ) is identical across the Bell basis. The same Leggett-constrained 2×6 setting family supports two inequivalent CHSH combinations: a coplanar one that saturates the Tsirelson bound, |SCHSH| = 2.828 atφ= 90° and observable down to a visibilityV≈ 0.707, and a genuinely noncoplanar cross-triplet one reaching |SCHSH| = 2.236 at φ = 53°, observable down toV≈ 0.894; in both cases the violation magnitude is identical across the Bell basis, with opposite signs for the |Ψ±⟩ and |Φ±⟩ families. Both inequalities are violated at a common angle forφV> 0.943 atφ≈ 39°, so that the predicted correlations are incompatible with locally causal hidden-variable models and with the restricted class of Leggett-type nonlocal realistic models considered here. The framework is directly compatible with standard polarization-entanglement experiments and suitable for implementation in fiber-based and free-space quantum communication systems.
We present a unified analysis of Bell and Leggett-type inequality violations for the maximally polarization-entangled Bell states |Ψ±⟩ and |Φ±⟩ within a single measurement framework on the Poincaré sphere. Using the symmetry-independent Leggett inequality together with a common correlation model and a Jones-matrix description of polarization analysis, we evaluate the Leggett parameterL3(φ) and the CHSH parameterSCHSHfor all four Bell states, showing thatL3(φ) is identical across the Bell basis. The same Leggett-constrained 2×6 setting family supports two inequivalent CHSH combinations: a coplanar one that saturates the Tsirelson bound, |SCHSH| = 2.828 atφ= 90° and observable down to a visibilityV≈ 0.707, and a genuinely noncoplanar cross-triplet one reaching |SCHSH| = 2.236 at φ = 53°, observable down toV≈ 0.894; in both cases the violation magnitude is identical across the Bell basis, with opposite signs for the |Ψ±⟩ and |Φ±⟩ families. Both inequalities are violated at a common angle forφV> 0.943 atφ≈ 39°, so that the predicted correlations are incompatible with locally causal hidden-variable models and with the restricted class of Leggett-type nonlocal realistic models considered here. The framework is directly compatible with standard polarization-entanglement experiments and suitable for implementation in fiber-based and free-space quantum communication systems.
Leggett inequality states that nonlocal hidden-variable models might still be incompatible with the predictions of quantum physics. However, its theoretical and experimental demonstration is only in the scenario of 2-dimensional maximally entangled systems. An open question remains as to whether the Leggett inequality can be violated by nonmaximally entangled states. Here, we answer this question both in theory and experiment. Specifically, from the point of view of geometry, we theoretically map the problem of maximizing the correlation measure in the Leggett inequality to maximizing the sum of an ellipse’s diameter and semi-diameter axes, accordingly, demonstrating that the violation of the Leggett inequality requires a more robust entanglement than that of Bell’s theory. Experimentally, by leveraging the controllable photonic orbital angular momentum entanglement, we demonstrate the violation of Leggett-type inequalities by more than 8.7 and 4.5 standard deviations under concurrence C = 0.95 and 0.9, respectively. Our observations indicate that, the requirement for quantum correlation should be increased to exclude a particular class of non-local hidden variable theories that abide by Leggett’s model, providing insights into the boundaries of quantum correlation and the limitations imposed by non-local hidden variables.
Bell–CHSH inequalities are commonly interpreted as demonstrating the incompatibility between quantum mechanics and local hidden-variable theories based on pre-existing measurement outcomes. In standard derivations of the CHSH inequality, however, it is implicitly assumed that all possible measurement settings can be assigned simultaneous values within a single global hidden-variable structure. In this paper, we reconsider the Bell–CHSH framework from the viewpoint of the Intrinsic Observability Framework (IOF). We argue that the central issue is not the experimental violation of the inequality itself, but the applicability of the global value assignment assumed in its derivation. In particular, the simultaneous definition of outcomes associated with incompatible measurement settings presupposes a common operational structure shared across all observational configurations. Within IOF, observable outcomes are not treated as globally pre-existing values independent of observational accessibility and decomposition structure. Instead, measurement outcomes are associated with operationally accessible configurations determined through observable–hidden relations. From this perspective, the global assignment required for the CHSH derivation is not operationally justified. We further show that this viewpoint remains fully consistent with the standard quantum-mechanical correlations observed in Bell-type experiments. The present analysis suggests that the Bell–CHSH inequality may be interpreted not as a direct contradiction between quantum mechanics and locality itself, but rather as a limitation of globally defined pre-existing value assignments across incompatible observational configurations.
We describe an experimental test of local realistic and nonlocal realistic theories using polarization-entangled two-photon singlet states created using a fiber-based polarization Sagnac interferometer. We show a violation of Bell's inequality in the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt form by 15 standard deviations, thus excluding local hidden-variable theories, and a violation of a Leggett-type nonlocal hidden-variable inequality by more than three standard deviations, thus excluding a class of nonlocal hidden-variable theories.
The Bell inequality is thought to be a common constraint shared by all models of local hidden variables that aim to describe the entangled states of two qubits. Since the inequality is violated by the quantum mechanical description of these states, it purportedly allows distinguishing in an experimentally testable way the predictions of quantum mechanics from those of models of local hidden variables and, ultimately, ruling the latter out. In this paper, we show, however, that the models of local hidden variables constrained by the Bell inequality all share a subtle, though crucial, feature that is not required by fundamental physical principles and, hence, it might not be fulfilled in the actual experimental setup that tests the inequality. Indeed, the disputed feature neither can be properly implemented within the standard framework of quantum mechanics and it is even at odds with the fundamental principle of relativity. Namely, the proof of the inequality requires the existence of a preferred absolute frame of reference (supposedly provided by the lab) with respect to which the hidden properties of the entangled particles and the orientations of each one of the measurement devices that test them can be independently defined through a long sequence of realizations of the experiment. We notice, however, that while the relative orientation between the two measurement devices is a properly defined physical magnitude in every single realization of the experiment, their global rigid orientation with respect to a lab frame is a spurious gauge degree of freedom. Following this observation, we were able to explicitly build a model of local hidden variables that does not share the disputed feature and, hence, it is able to reproduce the predictions of quantum mechanics for the entangled states of two qubits.
Linearly polarized projections are the tacit means for performing Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) Bell-inequality tests using polarization-entangled photon pairs. The inequality is valid for all states on the Poincaré-Bloch sphere, but few laboratory studies have investigated violations with the full sphere. In this article, we explore the experimental verifications of the predicted violations of the CHSH inequality with Bell and non-Bell states with same and different linear and elliptically polarized basis states for each photon. We find that Bell states violate CHSH when using the same basis for both photons, regardless of their ellipticity, whereas they show no violations for photon projections in different bases. We found non-Bell maximally-entangled states for which the converse is true.
We derive the Bell–CHSH inequality as a conditional theorem inside Charlton Geometry (CG), rather than as an independent axiom about “local realism”. The key CG primitive is non-invertibility, η(ω) = η(−ω), which forces an observational quotient and produces irrecoverable “lost state” carried by polarity and intrinsic phase. In a bipartite experiment, Bell’s bound is recovered exactly when one adds an additional factorization condition asserting that outcomes depend only on local settings and a local lift choice, i.e. that the lost-state fiber decomposes into independent local fibers. Within CG, the natural geometric coupling of two regions through shared lift and holonomy generically violates that factorization while preserving operational no-signaling, so the Bell inequality becomes a theorem about a restricted subclass of quotients rather than a universal constraint. Using the Born brick as an upstream theorem that fixes the unique binary law cos2(θ/2) on the spin-lifted setting space, we recover the standard singlet correlation E(a, b) = −a °§ b and the Tsirelson bound 2√2 as the sharp CG-compatible CHSH maximum. In this framing, Bell violation is not an ontic miracle but the expected signature of a globally shared, non-invertible geometric substate whose reversal cannot be represented