Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Bell–CHSH Inequality and the Absence of Global Value Assignment in the Intrinsic Observability Framework

Atsushi Okamoto

Published Jun 19, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Bell–CHSH inequalities are commonly interpreted as demonstrating the incompatibility between quantum mechanics and local hidden-variable theories based on pre-existing measurement outcomes. In standard derivations of the CHSH inequality, however, it is implicitly assumed that all possible measurement settings can be assigned simultaneous values within a single global hidden-variable structure. In this paper, we reconsider the Bell–CHSH framework from the viewpoint of the Intrinsic Observability Framework (IOF). We argue that the central issue is not the experimental violation of the inequality itself, but the applicability of the global value assignment assumed in its derivation. In particular, the simultaneous definition of outcomes associated with incompatible measurement settings presupposes a common operational structure shared across all observational configurations. Within IOF, observable outcomes are not treated as globally pre-existing values independent of observational accessibility and decomposition structure. Instead, measurement outcomes are associated with operationally accessible configurations determined through observable–hidden relations. From this perspective, the global assignment required for the CHSH derivation is not operationally justified. We further show that this viewpoint remains fully consistent with the standard quantum-mechanical correlations observed in Bell-type experiments. The present analysis suggests that the Bell–CHSH inequality may be interpreted not as a direct contradiction between quantum mechanics and locality itself, but rather as a limitation of globally defined pre-existing value assignments across incompatible observational configurations.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.20758881

Related papers

On the Valid Scope of Bell Inequalities for Testing Quantum Hidden Variables — Analysis Based on Continuum Measure and Relativistic Simultaneity

Qian(千) Chen(陈)

Bell inequalities have long served as the standard criterion to verify local hidden variable theories. Experimental violations of these inequalities are commonly interpreted as fundamental quantum nonlocality at the microscopic scale. This paper proves rigorously that Bell inequalities hold only under three prerequisites: countable discrete variables, countably additive probability measures, and classical absolute simultaneity. The state space of entangled quantum systems forms an uncountable infinite continuum. By the property of Vitali non-measurable sets in measure theory, the integral deduction of the CHSH inequality collapses naturally over continuous state spaces. Furthermore, special relativity excludes universal global time synchronization, so the absolute time embedded in Bell’s theory is an artificial assumption inconsistent with physical reality. Inspired by the framework dependence of probability revealed in Bertrand’s paradox, we demonstrate that the excess correlation observed in experiments is an apparent effect caused by the mismatch between classical measurement frameworks and the intrinsic continuum property of quantum systems, rather than evidence against local hidden variables. Statistical correlation between entangled particles originates from their shared evolutionary sequence defined at pair generation, with no superluminal interaction, fully complying with relativistic causality. This paper does not explore the ultimate origin of entanglement, but treats it as a given primitive physical law. Two falsifiable predictions are proposed to distinguish the continuum model from standard quantum mechanics. The conclusion is that hidden variable theories have never been falsified by experiments; they only need to be extended from discrete forms to continuum models compatible with relativity.

•Jul 14, 2026•0 citations

Breakdown of Bell Factorization from Non-Injective Effective Descriptions

Jérôme Beau

Violations of Bell inequalities are commonly interpreted as evidence for nonlocal influences or as constraints on realist descriptions. We show that the failure of Bell-type factorizability arises naturally when observable outcomes are obtained through a non-injective mapping from an underlying configuration space. In this setting, the standard factorization assumption can be viewed as an implicit requirement that observable variables admit a jointly factorizable completion at the underlying level. We demonstrate that this requirement need not hold when the mapping from underlying configurations to observables is many-to-one. The resulting breakdown of probabilistic factorization does not rely on superluminal dynamics or hidden causal influences, but follows from information loss under projection. Observable outcomes correspond to equivalence classes of underlying configurations, preventing the assignment of independent local variables. We illustrate this mechanism with an explicit toy model producing Bell–CHSH violations while preserving operational no-signalling and statistical independence of measurement settings. The model is not intended to reproduce quantum correlations quantitatively, and may exceed the Tsirelson bound; its role is to isolate the structural origin of the violation. This analysis does not contradict Bell’s theorem, but identifies a class of effective descriptions for which its factorizability assumption does not apply. The framework preserves locality at the underlying level, introduces no additional hidden-variable dynamics, and does not modify quantum mechanics. It clarifies how classical factorization is recovered in regimes where the effective mapping becomes approximately injective. In the operator language of quantum theory, the same mechanism admits a natural reformulation in terms of reduction to an effective observable subalgebra by a noncommutative conditional expectation.

Quantum Reports•May 2, 2026•1 citation

Entangled Photons and the Structure of Observable Values in the IOF

Atsushi Okamoto

Entangled photon experiments occupy a central position in discussions of quantum foundations because they exhibit strong nonclassical correlations while simultaneously challenging intuitive notions of observable reality and locality. In conventional interpretations, these correlations are often discussed in terms of hidden polarization values, nonlocal influences, or globally predefined observable properties across multiple measurement settings. However, the conceptual status of observable values themselves remains unclear. In the present work, we reconsider entangled photon measurements within the Intrinsic Observability Framework (IOF). In particular, we examine the role of polarization measurement angles not merely as passive readout directions, but as operational observational configurations that participate in the establishment of observable values. From this viewpoint, observable values associated with different polarization settings are not automatically interpreted as simultaneously defined global properties independent of measurement configuration. The analysis suggests that entangled photon correlations do not necessarily require globally simultaneous observable values across all possible polarization angles. Instead, observable values are understood as operationally established within specific observational configurations. This viewpoint preserves the experimentally verified quantum correlations while avoiding the assumption of universally predefined simultaneous observable properties. Furthermore, the present work proposes that quantum correlations may be interpreted not as directly transmitted observable information, but rather as relational structures that function as informational resources for subsequent information formation. In this sense, entanglement correlations are understood not as completed observable information itself, but as pre-observable relational information structures from which observable information may be operationally established under appropriate accessibility conditions. The present analysis provides an operational reinterpretation of entangled photon correlations within the IOF and suggests a structural distinction between correlation resources and observable information in quantum systems.

•Jun 27, 2026•0 citations

Non-local setting and outcome information for violation of Bell's inequality

Marcin Pawłowski, Johannes Kofler, Tomasz Paterek +2 more

Bell's theorem is a no-go theorem stating that quantum mechanics cannot be reproduced by a physical theory based on realism, freedom to choose experimental settings and two locality conditions: setting (SI) and outcome (OI) independence. We provide a novel analysis of what it takes to violate Bell's inequality within the framework in which both realism and freedom of choice are assumed, by showing that it is impossible to model a violation without having information in one laboratory about both the setting and the outcome at the distant one. While it is possible that outcome information can be revealed from shared hidden variables, the assumed experimenter's freedom to choose the settings ensures that the setting information must be non-locally transferred even when the SI condition is obeyed. The amount of transmitted information about the setting that is sufficient to violate the CHSH inequality up to its quantum mechanical maximum is 0.736 bits.

arXiv:0903.5042•New Journal of Physics•Aug 25, 2010•32 citations

A violation of the Tsirelson bound in the pre-quantum theory of trace dynamics

Rabsan Galib Ahmed, Singh, Tejinder P.

The term Bell's theorem refers to a set of closely related results which imply that quantum mechanics is incompatible with local hidden variable theories. Bell's inequality is the statement that if measurements are performed independently on two space-like separated particles of an entangled pair, the assumption that outcomes depend on hidden variables implies an upper bound on the correlations between the outcomes. Quantum mechanics predicts correlations which violate this upper bound. The CHSH inequality is a specific Bell inequality in which classical correlation (i.e. if local hidden variables exist) can take the maximum value of 2. Quantum mechanics violates this bound, allowing for a higher bound on the correlation, which can take the maximum value $2\sqrt{2}$, known as the Tsirelson bound. Popescu and Rohrlich showed that the assumption of relativistic causality allows for an even higher bound on the CHSH correlation, this value being 4. Why is the bound coming from causality higher than the Tsirelson bound? Are there relativistic causal dynamical theories which violate the Tsirelson bound? In the present paper we answer this question in the affirmative. We show that the pre-quantum theory of trace dynamics, from which quantum theory is emergent as a thermodynamic approximation, permits the CHSH correlation to take values higher than $2\sqrt{2}$. We interpret our findings to suggest that quantum theory is approximate, and emergent from the more general theory of trace dynamics.

arXiv:2208.02209•Aug 3, 2022•15 citations

Crouching Symmetry, Hidden Structure: A Geometric Reinterpretation of Bell's Inequality

Kacheong R. Yeung, Lex Yeung

Bell’s inequality relies on a structural feature of the standard Bell-local model: the potential outcomes for all relevant measurement settings are jointly represented on a single hidden-variable space. This joint representation is not enforced by locality alone, and its status becomes nontrivial once the physical realization of measurement events and their associated symmetry structures are taken into account. We develop a symmetry-sensitive framework in which each measurement event is associated with an event-dependent symmetry action on the hidden-variable space. Within this framework, symmetry-compatible joint representability requires that these actions be compatible with a single equivariant hidden-variable model. We show that, for the symmetry structures considered here, no such common realization exists. Consequently, the standard jointly represented CHSH construction cannot be carried out within this symmetry-restricted class. The obstruction is algebraic rather than causal: spacelike separation rules out direct causal influence between the measurement events, but does not ensure compatibility of their symmetry actions. The analysis brings into view a representational structure beneath the standard Bell construction: joint representability is not only a probabilistic requirement, but also a question of symmetry compatibility. This perspective clarifies the assumptions underlying Bell’s theorem and highlights the role of symmetry in determining which hidden-variable models are physically realizable. This is version 1.0 of the manuscript.

•Aug 13, 2026•0 citations
Bell–CHSH inequalities are commonly interpreted as demonstrating the incompatibility between quantum mechanics and local hidden-variable theories based on pre-existing measurement outcomes. In standard derivations of the CHSH inequality, however, it is implicitly assumed that all possible measurement settings can be assigned simultaneous values within a single global hidden-variable structure. In this paper, we reconsider the Bell–CHSH framework from the viewpoint of the Intrinsic Observability Framework (IOF). We argue that the central issue is not the experimental violation of the inequality itself, but the applicability of the global value assignment assumed in its derivation. In particular, the simultaneous definition of outcomes associated with incompatible measurement settings presupposes a common operational structure shared across all observational configurations. Within IOF, observable outcomes are not treated as globally pre-existing values independent of observational accessibility and decomposition structure. Instead, measurement outcomes are associated with operationally accessible configurations determined through observable–hidden relations. From this perspective, the global assignment required for the CHSH derivation is not operationally justified. We further show that this viewpoint remains fully consistent with the standard quantum-mechanical correlations observed in Bell-type experiments. The present analysis suggests that the Bell–CHSH inequality may be interpreted not as a direct contradiction between quantum mechanics and locality itself, but rather as a limitation of globally defined pre-existing value assignments across incompatible observational configurations.
Bell inequalities have long served as the standard criterion to verify local hidden variable theories. Experimental violations of these inequalities are commonly interpreted as fundamental quantum nonlocality at the microscopic scale. This paper proves rigorously that Bell inequalities hold only under three prerequisites: countable discrete variables, countably additive probability measures, and classical absolute simultaneity. The state space of entangled quantum systems forms an uncountable infinite continuum. By the property of Vitali non-measurable sets in measure theory, the integral deduction of the CHSH inequality collapses naturally over continuous state spaces. Furthermore, special relativity excludes universal global time synchronization, so the absolute time embedded in Bell’s theory is an artificial assumption inconsistent with physical reality. Inspired by the framework dependence of probability revealed in Bertrand’s paradox, we demonstrate that the excess correlation observed in experiments is an apparent effect caused by the mismatch between classical measurement frameworks and the intrinsic continuum property of quantum systems, rather than evidence against local hidden variables. Statistical correlation between entangled particles originates from their shared evolutionary sequence defined at pair generation, with no superluminal interaction, fully complying with relativistic causality. This paper does not explore the ultimate origin of entanglement, but treats it as a given primitive physical law. Two falsifiable predictions are proposed to distinguish the continuum model from standard quantum mechanics. The conclusion is that hidden variable theories have never been falsified by experiments; they only need to be extended from discrete forms to continuum models compatible with relativity.
Violations of Bell inequalities are commonly interpreted as evidence for nonlocal influences or as constraints on realist descriptions. We show that the failure of Bell-type factorizability arises naturally when observable outcomes are obtained through a non-injective mapping from an underlying configuration space. In this setting, the standard factorization assumption can be viewed as an implicit requirement that observable variables admit a jointly factorizable completion at the underlying level. We demonstrate that this requirement need not hold when the mapping from underlying configurations to observables is many-to-one. The resulting breakdown of probabilistic factorization does not rely on superluminal dynamics or hidden causal influences, but follows from information loss under projection. Observable outcomes correspond to equivalence classes of underlying configurations, preventing the assignment of independent local variables. We illustrate this mechanism with an explicit toy model producing Bell–CHSH violations while preserving operational no-signalling and statistical independence of measurement settings. The model is not intended to reproduce quantum correlations quantitatively, and may exceed the Tsirelson bound; its role is to isolate the structural origin of the violation. This analysis does not contradict Bell’s theorem, but identifies a class of effective descriptions for which its factorizability assumption does not apply. The framework preserves locality at the underlying level, introduces no additional hidden-variable dynamics, and does not modify quantum mechanics. It clarifies how classical factorization is recovered in regimes where the effective mapping becomes approximately injective. In the operator language of quantum theory, the same mechanism admits a natural reformulation in terms of reduction to an effective observable subalgebra by a noncommutative conditional expectation.
Entangled photon experiments occupy a central position in discussions of quantum foundations because they exhibit strong nonclassical correlations while simultaneously challenging intuitive notions of observable reality and locality. In conventional interpretations, these correlations are often discussed in terms of hidden polarization values, nonlocal influences, or globally predefined observable properties across multiple measurement settings. However, the conceptual status of observable values themselves remains unclear. In the present work, we reconsider entangled photon measurements within the Intrinsic Observability Framework (IOF). In particular, we examine the role of polarization measurement angles not merely as passive readout directions, but as operational observational configurations that participate in the establishment of observable values. From this viewpoint, observable values associated with different polarization settings are not automatically interpreted as simultaneously defined global properties independent of measurement configuration. The analysis suggests that entangled photon correlations do not necessarily require globally simultaneous observable values across all possible polarization angles. Instead, observable values are understood as operationally established within specific observational configurations. This viewpoint preserves the experimentally verified quantum correlations while avoiding the assumption of universally predefined simultaneous observable properties. Furthermore, the present work proposes that quantum correlations may be interpreted not as directly transmitted observable information, but rather as relational structures that function as informational resources for subsequent information formation. In this sense, entanglement correlations are understood not as completed observable information itself, but as pre-observable relational information structures from which observable information may be operationally established under appropriate accessibility conditions. The present analysis provides an operational reinterpretation of entangled photon correlations within the IOF and suggests a structural distinction between correlation resources and observable information in quantum systems.
Bell's theorem is a no-go theorem stating that quantum mechanics cannot be reproduced by a physical theory based on realism, freedom to choose experimental settings and two locality conditions: setting (SI) and outcome (OI) independence. We provide a novel analysis of what it takes to violate Bell's inequality within the framework in which both realism and freedom of choice are assumed, by showing that it is impossible to model a violation without having information in one laboratory about both the setting and the outcome at the distant one. While it is possible that outcome information can be revealed from shared hidden variables, the assumed experimenter's freedom to choose the settings ensures that the setting information must be non-locally transferred even when the SI condition is obeyed. The amount of transmitted information about the setting that is sufficient to violate the CHSH inequality up to its quantum mechanical maximum is 0.736 bits.
The term Bell's theorem refers to a set of closely related results which imply that quantum mechanics is incompatible with local hidden variable theories. Bell's inequality is the statement that if measurements are performed independently on two space-like separated particles of an entangled pair, the assumption that outcomes depend on hidden variables implies an upper bound on the correlations between the outcomes. Quantum mechanics predicts correlations which violate this upper bound. The CHSH inequality is a specific Bell inequality in which classical correlation (i.e. if local hidden variables exist) can take the maximum value of 2. Quantum mechanics violates this bound, allowing for a higher bound on the correlation, which can take the maximum value 222\sqrt{2}22​, known as the Tsirelson bound. Popescu and Rohrlich showed that the assumption of relativistic causality allows for an even higher bound on the CHSH correlation, this value being 4. Why is the bound coming from causality higher than the Tsirelson bound? Are there relativistic causal dynamical theories which violate the Tsirelson bound? In the present paper we answer this question in the affirmative. We show that the pre-quantum theory of trace dynamics, from which quantum theory is emergent as a thermodynamic approximation, permits the CHSH correlation to take values higher than 222\sqrt{2}22​. We interpret our findings to suggest that quantum theory is approximate, and emergent from the more general theory of trace dynamics.
Bell’s inequality relies on a structural feature of the standard Bell-local model: the potential outcomes for all relevant measurement settings are jointly represented on a single hidden-variable space. This joint representation is not enforced by locality alone, and its status becomes nontrivial once the physical realization of measurement events and their associated symmetry structures are taken into account. We develop a symmetry-sensitive framework in which each measurement event is associated with an event-dependent symmetry action on the hidden-variable space. Within this framework, symmetry-compatible joint representability requires that these actions be compatible with a single equivariant hidden-variable model. We show that, for the symmetry structures considered here, no such common realization exists. Consequently, the standard jointly represented CHSH construction cannot be carried out within this symmetry-restricted class. The obstruction is algebraic rather than causal: spacelike separation rules out direct causal influence between the measurement events, but does not ensure compatibility of their symmetry actions. The analysis brings into view a representational structure beneath the standard Bell construction: joint representability is not only a probabilistic requirement, but also a question of symmetry compatibility. This perspective clarifies the assumptions underlying Bell’s theorem and highlights the role of symmetry in determining which hidden-variable models are physically realizable. This is version 1.0 of the manuscript.