The Marzlin-Sanders Paradox : In light of Kato's proof of the adiabatic theorem
Hannes Tedsjö Unneberg
Abstract
The adiabatic theorem was an unshaken pillar of quantum mechanics until Marzlin and Sanders shook it. They created a system where the adiabatic approximation is inappropriate despite satisfying the traditional adiabatic condition, a seemingly paradoxical situation. This thesis conducts a literature review, examines the renowned two-level Marzlin-Sanders system by means of the Hilbert-Schmidt norm and Fubini-Study metric, and lastly interrogates the general Marzlin-Sanders system in the spirit of Kato’s proof of the adiabatic theorem. The results show, unexpectedly, that there is no notion of adiabatic evolution in the system; in fact, the circular construction deprive it of its adiabatic evolution and the adiabatic condition ceases to be a condition. In conclusion, it does not make sense to make an adiabatic approximation for this system and the adiabatic theorem, with its condition and approximation, can proceed unshaken.