Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Adiabatic theorem independent of the quantum representations: Resolution of the Marzlin-Sanders inconsistency

Hsiang Shun Chou

Published Sep 12, 2022• 3 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We construct the adiabatic theorem independent of the quantum representations. The quantum-representation-independent geometrical phase, adiabatic condition, and fidelity of the adiabatic approximation are derived. As an example, we apply the quantum-representation-independent adiabatic theorem to provide a thorough resolution of the Marzlin-Sanders inconsistency. We show that the Marzlin-Sanders inconsistency results from the wrong identification of the time-dependent Hamiltonian as the instantaneous energy operator and the quantum representation dependence of the Marzlin-Sanders transformation.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.106.032210

Related papers

Quantum adiabatic theorem in light of the Marzlin-Sanders inconsistency

Juan Ortigoso

A consensus that questions the perfunctory use of the quantum adiabatic theorem has emerged since Marzlin and Sanders [Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 160408 (2004)] showed the existence of an inconsistency in the applicability of the theorem. Further analysis proved that the inconsistency may arise from the existence of resonant terms in the Hamiltonian, but recent work indicates that the debate about the full extent of the problem remains open. Here, we first show that key premises required in the standard demonstration of the theorem do not hold for a dual Hamiltonian involved in the Marzlin-Sanders inconsistency. Also, we show that two simple conditions can identify systems for which the adiabatic approximation fails, in spite of satisfying traditional quantitative conditions that were believed to guarantee its validity. Finally, we prove that the inconsistency only arises for Hamiltonians that contain resonant terms whose amplitudes go asymptotically to zero.

arXiv:1111.5195•Physical Review A•Sep 26, 2012•22 citations

Inconsistencies of the Adiabatic Theorem and the Berry Phase

Arun Kumar Pati, A. K. Rajagopal

The adiabatic theorem states that if we prepare a quantum system in one of the instantaneous eigenstates then the quantum number is an adiabatic invariant and the state at a later time is equivalent to the instantaneous eigenstate at that time apart from phase factors. Recently, Marzlin and Sanders have pointed out that this could lead to apparent violation of unitarity. We resolve the Marzlin-Sanders inconsistency within the quantum adiabatic theorem. Yet, our resolution points to another inconsistency, namely, that the cyclic as well as non-cyclic adiabatic Berry phases may vanish under strict adiabatic condition. We resolve this inconsistency and develop an unitary operator decomposition method to argue for the validity of the adiabatic approximation.

arXiv:quant-ph/0405129•May 21, 2004•24 citations

Is the Adiabatic Approximation Inconsistent?

Solomon Duki, Harsh Mathur, Onuttom Narayan

Marzlin and Sanders \cite{marzlin} have shown rigorously that the adiabatic approximation can be very inaccurate when applied to a Hamiltonian $H(t)$ that generates the evolution $U^{\dagger} (t)$ even if it gives an excellent approximation to the evolution $U(t)$ generated by a dual Hamiltonian $h(t)$. We show that this is not inconsistent with the adiabatic theorem and find that in general even if $h(t)$ satisfies the conditions of the adiabatic theorem, $H(t)$ will likely violate those conditions.

arXiv:quant-ph/0510131•Oct 17, 2005•12 citations

Review of inconsistency of quantum adiabatic theorem

Yong Tao

In this paper, we note that there are two different types of inconsistencies of quantum adiabatic theorem in work of K. P. Marzlin and B. C. Sanders [Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 160408, 2004], MS inconsistency and MS counterexample. Nevertheless, these two types are often confused as one by many authors. We shall point out that the inconsistencies of quantum adiabatic theorem raised by the relevant references just can be classified as these two types.

arXiv:1010.1321•Oct 7, 2010•0 citations

Sufficient Condition for Validity of Quantum Adiabatic Theorem

Yong Tao

In this paper, we attempt to give a sufficient condition of guaranteeing the validity of the proof of the quantum adiabatic theorem. The new sufficient condition can clearly remove the inconsistency and the counterexample of the quantum adiabatic theorem pointed out by Marzlin and Sanders [Phys. Rev. Lett. 93 (2004) 160408].

arXiv:1010.1326•Communications in Theoretical Physics•Mar 1, 2012•5 citations

The Marzlin-Sanders Paradox : In light of Kato's proof of the adiabatic theorem

Hannes Tedsjö Unneberg

The adiabatic theorem was an unshaken pillar of quantum mechanics until Marzlin and Sanders shook it. They created a system where the adiabatic approximation is inappropriate despite satisfying the traditional adiabatic condition, a seemingly paradoxical situation. This thesis conducts a literature review, examines the renowned two-level Marzlin-Sanders system by means of the Hilbert-Schmidt norm and Fubini-Study metric, and lastly interrogates the general Marzlin-Sanders system in the spirit of Kato’s proof of the adiabatic theorem. The results show, unexpectedly, that there is no notion of adiabatic evolution in the system; in fact, the circular construction deprive it of its adiabatic evolution and the adiabatic condition ceases to be a condition. In conclusion, it does not make sense to make an adiabatic approximation for this system and the adiabatic theorem, with its condition and approximation, can proceed unshaken.

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations
We construct the adiabatic theorem independent of the quantum representations. The quantum-representation-independent geometrical phase, adiabatic condition, and fidelity of the adiabatic approximation are derived. As an example, we apply the quantum-representation-independent adiabatic theorem to provide a thorough resolution of the Marzlin-Sanders inconsistency. We show that the Marzlin-Sanders inconsistency results from the wrong identification of the time-dependent Hamiltonian as the instantaneous energy operator and the quantum representation dependence of the Marzlin-Sanders transformation.
A consensus that questions the perfunctory use of the quantum adiabatic theorem has emerged since Marzlin and Sanders [Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 160408 (2004)] showed the existence of an inconsistency in the applicability of the theorem. Further analysis proved that the inconsistency may arise from the existence of resonant terms in the Hamiltonian, but recent work indicates that the debate about the full extent of the problem remains open. Here, we first show that key premises required in the standard demonstration of the theorem do not hold for a dual Hamiltonian involved in the Marzlin-Sanders inconsistency. Also, we show that two simple conditions can identify systems for which the adiabatic approximation fails, in spite of satisfying traditional quantitative conditions that were believed to guarantee its validity. Finally, we prove that the inconsistency only arises for Hamiltonians that contain resonant terms whose amplitudes go asymptotically to zero.
The adiabatic theorem states that if we prepare a quantum system in one of the instantaneous eigenstates then the quantum number is an adiabatic invariant and the state at a later time is equivalent to the instantaneous eigenstate at that time apart from phase factors. Recently, Marzlin and Sanders have pointed out that this could lead to apparent violation of unitarity. We resolve the Marzlin-Sanders inconsistency within the quantum adiabatic theorem. Yet, our resolution points to another inconsistency, namely, that the cyclic as well as non-cyclic adiabatic Berry phases may vanish under strict adiabatic condition. We resolve this inconsistency and develop an unitary operator decomposition method to argue for the validity of the adiabatic approximation.
Marzlin and Sanders \cite{marzlin} have shown rigorously that the adiabatic approximation can be very inaccurate when applied to a Hamiltonian H(t)H(t)H(t) that generates the evolution U†(t)U^{\dagger} (t)U†(t) even if it gives an excellent approximation to the evolution U(t)U(t)U(t) generated by a dual Hamiltonian h(t)h(t)h(t). We show that this is not inconsistent with the adiabatic theorem and find that in general even if h(t)h(t)h(t) satisfies the conditions of the adiabatic theorem, H(t)H(t)H(t) will likely violate those conditions.
The adiabatic theorem was an unshaken pillar of quantum mechanics until Marzlin and Sanders shook it. They created a system where the adiabatic approximation is inappropriate despite satisfying the traditional adiabatic condition, a seemingly paradoxical situation. This thesis conducts a literature review, examines the renowned two-level Marzlin-Sanders system by means of the Hilbert-Schmidt norm and Fubini-Study metric, and lastly interrogates the general Marzlin-Sanders system in the spirit of Kato’s proof of the adiabatic theorem. The results show, unexpectedly, that there is no notion of adiabatic evolution in the system; in fact, the circular construction deprive it of its adiabatic evolution and the adiabatic condition ceases to be a condition. In conclusion, it does not make sense to make an adiabatic approximation for this system and the adiabatic theorem, with its condition and approximation, can proceed unshaken.