Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

時間対称量子力学における実在と遡及因果 : 見ていないときに何が起こっているのか

Yutaka Shinba

Published Jun 1, 2013• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

When we don't see it, what is its value of observable?" Bohr recommended that don't think about such a meaningless question.Nevertheless, about half century later, the conception for reality in quantum mechanics is restarted to argue seriously.Many interpretations and experiments have been proposed.Recently, in connection with execution on the experiment about the Hardy's Paradox, Aharonov's so called Time Symmetric Quantum Mechanics is paid attention.We discuss the conception of reality and backward causation, appearing Aharonov's interpretation, from among many paradoxical aspects of that interpretation.

Related papers

Understanding Time and Causality is the Key to Understanding Quantum Mechanics

W. R. Wharton

A new interpretation of quantum mechanics, similar to the Copenhagen interpretation, is developed from time-symmetry arguments and commonly held principles concerning time and causality. These principles, which are grounded in ideas outside of quantum mechanics, suggest that the strange features and paradoxes of quantum mechanics come from backward causation, in which future events can change the past. Using these principles this paper gives a better understanding of (and reasons for) stationary states, tunneling, wave-particle duality, the measurement problem with the collapse of the state vector, Hardy's paradox, non-locality, and the EPR paradox. These are only a few of the interpretational successes, and the model will be contrasted to other popular and/or recent interpretations. Unfortunately, this model is metaphysical, without any predictive power.

arXiv:quant-ph/0310131•Oct 21, 2003•1 citation

Introduction

David Wallace

The basic thesis of this book is that there is no quantum measurement problem. I do not mean by this that the apparent paradoxes of quantum mechanics arise because we fail to recognize ‘that quantum theory does not describe physical reality’ (Fuchs and Peres 2000a). Quantum theory describes reality just fine, like any other scientific theory worth taking seriously: describing (and explaining) reality is what the scientific enterprise is about. Nor do I mean that we have found solutions to the problem, ways to modify or supplement quantum mechanics so that the paradoxes are removed. I don’t actually think that we have found any very satisfactory solutions in this sense (at least not in the relativistic domain) but that isn’t my theme: even if we did have these modifications, they would be ways of changing from quantum physics, which supposedly does have a measurement problem, to some other theory, which supposedly doesn’t.

Oxford University Press eBooks•May 24, 2012•4 citations

Physics and mathematical reality: comments on Aharonov et al, arXiv:1902.08798

Suresh Chandra Tiwari

Do we have two kinds of reality: physical and mathematical? What is the role of mathematics in physics? These fundamental questions have intrigued original and brilliant minds since ancient times. A recent article (Aharonov, Cohen and Oaknin, arXiv:1902.08798) offers a viewpoint on the use of abstract mathematics in quantum theory. They argue that, in some cases, it may result into a paradox focusing on an example in quantum mechanics regarding Aharonov-Bergmann-Lebowitz (ABL) rule. In this comment we discuss three issues: theory reduction and approximation, origin of a paradox, and the reality of time. It is pointed out that paradoxes appear even in mathematics; we explain them as the results of the acceptance of pure logical artifacts. In physics too, the impact of the so called quantum and relativity revolutions, have led to the emergence of counter-intuitive and mysterious notion of the physical reality. The most fundamental change has been on rejecting the reality of time. A radically new perspective that physics is the language of mathematics is suggested. The mathematical reality of the natural numbers manifests in the form of physical time.

arXiv:1906.05537•Jun 13, 2019•1 citation

Quantum mechanics and reality

Bryce Seligman DeWitt

Despite its enormous practical success, quantum theory is so contrary to intuition that, even after 45 years, the experts themselves still do not all agree what to make of it. The area of disagreement centers primarily around the problem of describing observations. Formally, the result of a measurement is a superposition of vectors, each representing the quantity being observed as having one of its possible values. The question that has to be answered is how this superposition can be reconciled with the fact that in practice we only observe one value. How is the measuring instrument prodded into making up its mind which value it has observed?

Physics Today•Sep 1, 1970•706 citations

Quantum Mechanics and Reality

Bryce Seligman DeWitt

Despite its enormous practical success, quantum theory is so contrary to intuition that, even after 45 years, the experts themselves still do not all agree what to make of it. The area of disagreement centers primarily around the problem of describing observations. Formally, the result of a measurement is a superposition of vectors, each representing the quantity being observed as having one of its possible values. The question that has to be answered is how this superposition can be reconciled with the fact that in practice we only observe one value. How is the measuring instrument prodded into making up its mind which value it has observed?

Princeton University Press eBooks•Apr 24, 2015•28 citations

The double-slit quantum eraser experiments and Hardy's paradox in the quantum linguistic interpretation

Shiro Ishikawa

Recently we proposed the linguistic interpretation of quantum mechanics (called quantum and classical measurement theory), which was characterized as a kind of metaphysical and linguistic turn of the Copenhagen interpretation. This turn from physics to language does not only extend quantum theory to classical systems but also yield the quantum mechanical world view (i.e., quantum philosophy or quantum language). The purpose of this paper is to formulate the double-slit experiment, the quantum eraser experiment, Wheeler's delayed choice experiment, Hardy's paradox and the three boxes paradox (the weak value associated with a weak measurement due to Aharonov, et al.) in the linguistic interpretation of quantum mechanics. Through these arguments, we assert that the linguistic interpretation is just the final version of so called Copenhagen interpretation. And therefore, we conclude that the Copenhagen interpretation does not belong to physics (i.e., the realistic world view) but the linguistic world view.

arXiv:1407.5143•Jul 19, 2014•1 citation
When we don't see it, what is its value of observable?" Bohr recommended that don't think about such a meaningless question.Nevertheless, about half century later, the conception for reality in quantum mechanics is restarted to argue seriously.Many interpretations and experiments have been proposed.Recently, in connection with execution on the experiment about the Hardy's Paradox, Aharonov's so called Time Symmetric Quantum Mechanics is paid attention.We discuss the conception of reality and backward causation, appearing Aharonov's interpretation, from among many paradoxical aspects of that interpretation.
A new interpretation of quantum mechanics, similar to the Copenhagen interpretation, is developed from time-symmetry arguments and commonly held principles concerning time and causality. These principles, which are grounded in ideas outside of quantum mechanics, suggest that the strange features and paradoxes of quantum mechanics come from backward causation, in which future events can change the past. Using these principles this paper gives a better understanding of (and reasons for) stationary states, tunneling, wave-particle duality, the measurement problem with the collapse of the state vector, Hardy's paradox, non-locality, and the EPR paradox. These are only a few of the interpretational successes, and the model will be contrasted to other popular and/or recent interpretations. Unfortunately, this model is metaphysical, without any predictive power.
The basic thesis of this book is that there is no quantum measurement problem. I do not mean by this that the apparent paradoxes of quantum mechanics arise because we fail to recognize ‘that quantum theory does not describe physical reality’ (Fuchs and Peres 2000a). Quantum theory describes reality just fine, like any other scientific theory worth taking seriously: describing (and explaining) reality is what the scientific enterprise is about. Nor do I mean that we have found solutions to the problem, ways to modify or supplement quantum mechanics so that the paradoxes are removed. I don’t actually think that we have found any very satisfactory solutions in this sense (at least not in the relativistic domain) but that isn’t my theme: even if we did have these modifications, they would be ways of changing from quantum physics, which supposedly does have a measurement problem, to some other theory, which supposedly doesn’t.
Do we have two kinds of reality: physical and mathematical? What is the role of mathematics in physics? These fundamental questions have intrigued original and brilliant minds since ancient times. A recent article (Aharonov, Cohen and Oaknin, arXiv:1902.08798) offers a viewpoint on the use of abstract mathematics in quantum theory. They argue that, in some cases, it may result into a paradox focusing on an example in quantum mechanics regarding Aharonov-Bergmann-Lebowitz (ABL) rule. In this comment we discuss three issues: theory reduction and approximation, origin of a paradox, and the reality of time. It is pointed out that paradoxes appear even in mathematics; we explain them as the results of the acceptance of pure logical artifacts. In physics too, the impact of the so called quantum and relativity revolutions, have led to the emergence of counter-intuitive and mysterious notion of the physical reality. The most fundamental change has been on rejecting the reality of time. A radically new perspective that physics is the language of mathematics is suggested. The mathematical reality of the natural numbers manifests in the form of physical time.
Despite its enormous practical success, quantum theory is so contrary to intuition that, even after 45 years, the experts themselves still do not all agree what to make of it. The area of disagreement centers primarily around the problem of describing observations. Formally, the result of a measurement is a superposition of vectors, each representing the quantity being observed as having one of its possible values. The question that has to be answered is how this superposition can be reconciled with the fact that in practice we only observe one value. How is the measuring instrument prodded into making up its mind which value it has observed?
Despite its enormous practical success, quantum theory is so contrary to intuition that, even after 45 years, the experts themselves still do not all agree what to make of it. The area of disagreement centers primarily around the problem of describing observations. Formally, the result of a measurement is a superposition of vectors, each representing the quantity being observed as having one of its possible values. The question that has to be answered is how this superposition can be reconciled with the fact that in practice we only observe one value. How is the measuring instrument prodded into making up its mind which value it has observed?
Recently we proposed the linguistic interpretation of quantum mechanics (called quantum and classical measurement theory), which was characterized as a kind of metaphysical and linguistic turn of the Copenhagen interpretation. This turn from physics to language does not only extend quantum theory to classical systems but also yield the quantum mechanical world view (i.e., quantum philosophy or quantum language). The purpose of this paper is to formulate the double-slit experiment, the quantum eraser experiment, Wheeler's delayed choice experiment, Hardy's paradox and the three boxes paradox (the weak value associated with a weak measurement due to Aharonov, et al.) in the linguistic interpretation of quantum mechanics. Through these arguments, we assert that the linguistic interpretation is just the final version of so called Copenhagen interpretation. And therefore, we conclude that the Copenhagen interpretation does not belong to physics (i.e., the realistic world view) but the linguistic world view.