Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Uncertainty in the Results of Position Measurement in the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle

Seiji Kosugi

Published Feb 25, 2011• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

Heisenbergの不確定性原理において,位置の測定値の不確定性として何を用いるべきかについて考察した.測定対象の位置としては,測定前の位置x0と測定後の位置xtの2つが考えられる.位置xtの測定値(xt)expの不確定性はこの測定値の測定誤差ε(xt)である.しかし位置x0の測定値(x0)expの不確定性は測定誤差ε(x0)ではなく,測定値(x0)expの標準偏差σ((x0)exp)である.位置の測定値の不確定性としてε(xt)またはσ((x0)exp)を用いた場合には,Heisenbergの不確定性関係は成立している.2つの位置情報の不確定性ε(xt)とσ((x0)exp)の非対称性を引き起こしているのは波束の収縮である.

Related papers

Position Uncertainty in the Heisenberg Uncertainty Relation

Satoshi Kosugi

Position measurements are examined under the assumption that object position and probe position just after the measurement are expressed as a linear combination of positions and just before the measurement. The Heisenberg uncertainty relation between the position uncertainty and momentum disturbance holds when the measurement error ε(xt) for the object position is adopted as the position uncertainty. However, the uncertainty in the measurement result obtained for is the standard deviation of the measurement result, and not the measurement error ε(x0). This difference is due to the reduction of a wave packet. The validity of the linearity assumption is examined in detail.

arXiv:1002.3005•Progress of Theoretical Physics•Mar 1, 2010•1 citation

Position-Measurement Errors in the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle

誠司 小杉, Seiji Kosugi

測定過程に関連したHeisenbergの不確定性原理に対する小澤の批判を考察し,小澤が定義した測定値が正しくないために,小澤の理論にはいくつかの不合理な点が存在することを指摘した.本論文で明らかにした正しい測定値を用いれば,これらの問題は生じない.EPRがおこなった粒子2の位置測定の結果から粒子1の位置測定をおこなう間接測定の場合には,Heisenbergの不確定性関係を一般化した小澤の不等式は成立していない.

•Feb 25, 2009•0 citations

Probability as Translation, Not a Property of Nature: The Born Rule and the Deterministic Core of the Schrödinger Equation

T.O.

This paper relocates the Schrödinger equation, the Born probability rule, and the definiteness of experience from a single undifferentiated account into two layers: a deterministic structural layer (Tier-2) and a translation layer (Tier-3), the layer of commutative, analytic, classical description. No part of the mathematical content of wave mechanics is changed; what changes is only the layer to which each statement belongs.The main result is the following. The probabilistic reading of the Born rule presupposes three Tier-3 choices: (P1) realising the state as a complex-valued state functional; (P2) restricting that functional to a commutative subalgebra and constructing a measure from the spectral theorem; and (P3) adopting a rule that reads the measure as a distribution of measurement outcomes. Each choice adds structure that Tier-2 does not determine, so the passage from Tier-2 is a non-invertible translation and the probabilistic reading is representation-dependent. Probability is therefore not a primitive property of nature. The evolution of the state, by contrast, is the generator equation of a strongly continuous unitary group; it is smooth and deterministic, and its statement is independent of P1–P3. Within physics (Tier-3), the paper also assigns complementary roles to the two original mechanics: matrix mechanics, the non-commutative algebra of observables, is the theoretical pillar, and wave mechanics is the implementation that makes concrete models tractable. For finitely many degrees of freedom they are unitarily equivalent, so the asymmetry between them lies in tractability and not in content. The paper does not deny the validity or the empirical adequacy of the Born rule. It does not resolve the meaning of probability, does not derive the selection of an individual outcome, does not derive the post-measurement update rule, and does not claim to derive the Born rule from Tier-2. Its aim is an account that Schrödinger himself could accept: smooth deterministic evolution, with probability placed outside the dynamics. This paper follows the author's three papers on the uncertainty principle (https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23073559, https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23128791, https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23130407) and applies the same structural analysis to the Born rule and the Schrödinger equation. Appendix A of the paper contains five self-contained Python 3 verification scripts (NumPy only); Code 1, which exhibits a pair of representations sharing one wave function, is reproduced below. import math import numpy as np hbar, m, sigma0 = 1.0, 1.0, 1.0 k = hbar / (2.0 * m * sigma0**2) # d(tau)/dt, tau = k t def psi(x, t): """Exact free Gaussian packet psi_0 ~ exp(-x^2/(4 sigma0^2)).""" tau = k * t c = 1.0 + 1j * tau return (2*np.pi*sigma0**2)**-0.25 * c**-0.5 * np.exp(-x**2 / (4*sigma0**2*c)) def psi_x_over_psi(x, t): return -x / (2.0 * sigma0**2 * (1.0 + 1j * k * t)) def velocity(x, t): # guidance equation v = (hbar/m) Im(psi_x/psi) return (hbar / m) * np.imag(psi_x_over_psi(x, t)) def trajectories(x0, T, steps=2000): # deterministic RK4 x, dt = x0.copy(), T / steps for i in range(steps): t = i * dt k1 = velocity(x, t); k2 = velocity(x + 0.5*dt*k1, t + 0.5*dt) k3 = velocity(x + 0.5*dt*k2, t + 0.5*dt); k4 = velocity(x + dt*k3, t + dt) x = x + dt * (k1 + 2*k2 + 2*k3 + k4) / 6.0 return x # (a) psi solves the free Schroedinger equation (finite-difference residual) x = np.linspace(-8, 8, 4001); h, dt, t0 = x[1]-x[0], 1e-4, 1.3 dpsi_dt = (psi(x, t0+dt) - psi(x, t0-dt)) / (2*dt) lap = (psi(x[2:], t0) - 2*psi(x[1:-1], t0) + psi(x[:-2], t0)) / h**2 res = np.max(np.abs(1j*hbar*dpsi_dt[1:-1] + hbar**2/(2*m)*lap)) print("Schroedinger residual :", f"{res:.2e}") assert res < 1e-5 # (b) trajectories are deterministic functions of x0; they match the closed form rng = np.random.default_rng(12345) x0 = rng.normal(0.0, sigma0, 200000) # the ONLY random input: initial positions T = 3.0 xT = trajectories(x0, T) closed = x0 * math.sqrt(1.0 + (k*T)**2) err = np.max(np.abs(xT - closed)) print("max |RK4 - closed form| :", f"{err:.2e}") assert err < 1e-8 assert np.array_equal(xT, trajectories(x0, T)) # same x0 -> same x(T), bit for bit # (c) equivariance: ignorance measure |psi_0|^2 at t=0 is carried to |psi_T|^2 sigT = sigma0 * math.sqrt(1.0 + (k*T)**2) print("std of positions at T / sigma(T) :", f"{xT.std():.4f} / {sigT:.4f}") assert abs(xT.std()/sigT - 1.0) < 5e-3 s = np.sort(xT) cdf = np.array([0.5*(1.0 + math.erf(v/(sigT*math.sqrt(2.0)))) for v in s]) ks = np.max(np.abs(cdf - (np.arange(1, s.size+1)/s.size))) print("KS distance to |psi(x,T)|^2 :", f"{ks:.4f}") assert ks < 3.0 / math.sqrt(s.size) # approx. 99.9 percent level print("PASS")

•Oct 6, 2026•0 citations

Uncertainty relation from parameter estimation of the position of an electron in a uniform magnetic field

Shin Funada

1960年代頃から量子推定理論に基づいて分散を求めた結果と量子力学における不確定性関係との比較をした研究がなされてきた。その結果、量子推定理論に基づく結果が Heisenberg-Robertson の不確定性関係と同様な関係を与えることが知られていた。一方、渡辺らはd次元のフルパラメータモデルについて量子推定理論が Heisenberg-Robertson の不確定性関係とは異なる結果を与えることを示した。 本研究では, 一様磁場中にある一つの電子という物理的に意味のある具体的なモデルを設定した。量子推定理論により一様磁場中にある電子の位置座標(x,y)における x と y の分散の下界を求め, 不確定性関係について論じた。渡辺らの先行研究は有限次元におけるものであり本質的に無限次元となるモデルについて調べているところが本研究と先行研究の違いである。 一様磁場中にある電子の位置に関する不確定性関係を量子推定理論に基づいて求めるにあたり本研究では, 推定に使うユニタリー変換として正準運動量と力学的運動量を生成子とした場合の二つを用いて量子推定を行った。前者をモデル1, 後者をモデル2と呼ぶ。モデル1, モデル2ともに量子推定理論を用いると Heisenberg-Robertson の不確定性関係(Δx)(Δy)≧0 よりタイトな下界が得られることが示せた。 モデル1では熱状態(混合状態)を基準状態とした時, Gaussian Shift モデルと同等になることがわかった。従って RLD クラメール・ラオ不等式が与える下界が SLD のものよりタイトな下界となり, また RLD の与える下界は達成可能であることもわかった。基底状態(純粋状態)を基準状態としてとった場合は, 正準運動量の x, y 成分が非可換なことを反映し, SLD フィッシャー情報行列に量子的な効果が見られた。 一方のモデル2で熱状態(混合状態)を基準状態とした時Δx,Δyのとりうる領域は RLD,SLD の与える下界, Z 行列の与える上界の組み合わせで表される複雑な構造になることがわかった。さらにその下界の形は電子の角運動量に依存して変わるという興味深い結果が得られた。基底状態(純粋状態)を基準状態とした場合は, 力学的運動量の x, y 成分が可換なことを反映し, SLD フィッシャー情報行列に準古典的な効果が見られた。

•Mar 25, 2019•0 citations

Classical and quantum spreading of position probability

John E. G. Farina

If Δxt is the standard deviation of the position probability distribution at time t of a particle moving freely in one dimension, and Δv is the standard deviation of its velocity distribution, it is shown for a suitable choice of time origin that (Δxt)2 = (Δx0)2 + (Δv)2t2 whether the particle is moving classically or quantum mechanically. The quantum-mechanical proof is shown to exactly parallel that in the classical case. In the classical case, the correlation coefficient between the velocity and position distributions is shown to tend to −1 as t → −∞, to increase steadily with time, and to become +1 as t → +∞. A quantum-mechanical analog of this result is also proved.

American Journal of Physics•Dec 1, 1977•7 citations

Experimental test of the Heisenberg uncertainty relation for position and momentum

Winfrid Görlich, Ingo Hoffmann, Thomas Schürmann

•Dec 27, 2008•0 citations
Heisenbergの不確定性原理において,位置の測定値の不確定性として何を用いるべきかについて考察した.測定対象の位置としては,測定前の位置x0と測定後の位置xtの2つが考えられる.位置xtの測定値(xt)expの不確定性はこの測定値の測定誤差ε(xt)である.しかし位置x0の測定値(x0)expの不確定性は測定誤差ε(x0)ではなく,測定値(x0)expの標準偏差σ((x0)exp)である.位置の測定値の不確定性としてε(xt)またはσ((x0)exp)を用いた場合には,Heisenbergの不確定性関係は成立している.2つの位置情報の不確定性ε(xt)とσ((x0)exp)の非対称性を引き起こしているのは波束の収縮である.
Position measurements are examined under the assumption that object position and probe position just after the measurement are expressed as a linear combination of positions and just before the measurement. The Heisenberg uncertainty relation between the position uncertainty and momentum disturbance holds when the measurement error ε(xt) for the object position is adopted as the position uncertainty. However, the uncertainty in the measurement result obtained for is the standard deviation of the measurement result, and not the measurement error ε(x0). This difference is due to the reduction of a wave packet. The validity of the linearity assumption is examined in detail.
測定過程に関連したHeisenbergの不確定性原理に対する小澤の批判を考察し,小澤が定義した測定値が正しくないために,小澤の理論にはいくつかの不合理な点が存在することを指摘した.本論文で明らかにした正しい測定値を用いれば,これらの問題は生じない.EPRがおこなった粒子2の位置測定の結果から粒子1の位置測定をおこなう間接測定の場合には,Heisenbergの不確定性関係を一般化した小澤の不等式は成立していない.
This paper relocates the Schrödinger equation, the Born probability rule, and the definiteness of experience from a single undifferentiated account into two layers: a deterministic structural layer (Tier-2) and a translation layer (Tier-3), the layer of commutative, analytic, classical description. No part of the mathematical content of wave mechanics is changed; what changes is only the layer to which each statement belongs.The main result is the following. The probabilistic reading of the Born rule presupposes three Tier-3 choices: (P1) realising the state as a complex-valued state functional; (P2) restricting that functional to a commutative subalgebra and constructing a measure from the spectral theorem; and (P3) adopting a rule that reads the measure as a distribution of measurement outcomes. Each choice adds structure that Tier-2 does not determine, so the passage from Tier-2 is a non-invertible translation and the probabilistic reading is representation-dependent. Probability is therefore not a primitive property of nature. The evolution of the state, by contrast, is the generator equation of a strongly continuous unitary group; it is smooth and deterministic, and its statement is independent of P1–P3. Within physics (Tier-3), the paper also assigns complementary roles to the two original mechanics: matrix mechanics, the non-commutative algebra of observables, is the theoretical pillar, and wave mechanics is the implementation that makes concrete models tractable. For finitely many degrees of freedom they are unitarily equivalent, so the asymmetry between them lies in tractability and not in content. The paper does not deny the validity or the empirical adequacy of the Born rule. It does not resolve the meaning of probability, does not derive the selection of an individual outcome, does not derive the post-measurement update rule, and does not claim to derive the Born rule from Tier-2. Its aim is an account that Schrödinger himself could accept: smooth deterministic evolution, with probability placed outside the dynamics. This paper follows the author's three papers on the uncertainty principle (https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23073559, https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23128791, https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23130407) and applies the same structural analysis to the Born rule and the Schrödinger equation. Appendix A of the paper contains five self-contained Python 3 verification scripts (NumPy only); Code 1, which exhibits a pair of representations sharing one wave function, is reproduced below. import math import numpy as np hbar, m, sigma0 = 1.0, 1.0, 1.0 k = hbar / (2.0 * m * sigma0**2) # d(tau)/dt, tau = k t def psi(x, t): """Exact free Gaussian packet psi_0 ~ exp(-x^2/(4 sigma0^2)).""" tau = k * t c = 1.0 + 1j * tau return (2*np.pi*sigma0**2)**-0.25 * c**-0.5 * np.exp(-x**2 / (4*sigma0**2*c)) def psi_x_over_psi(x, t): return -x / (2.0 * sigma0**2 * (1.0 + 1j * k * t)) def velocity(x, t): # guidance equation v = (hbar/m) Im(psi_x/psi) return (hbar / m) * np.imag(psi_x_over_psi(x, t)) def trajectories(x0, T, steps=2000): # deterministic RK4 x, dt = x0.copy(), T / steps for i in range(steps): t = i * dt k1 = velocity(x, t); k2 = velocity(x + 0.5*dt*k1, t + 0.5*dt) k3 = velocity(x + 0.5*dt*k2, t + 0.5*dt); k4 = velocity(x + dt*k3, t + dt) x = x + dt * (k1 + 2*k2 + 2*k3 + k4) / 6.0 return x # (a) psi solves the free Schroedinger equation (finite-difference residual) x = np.linspace(-8, 8, 4001); h, dt, t0 = x[1]-x[0], 1e-4, 1.3 dpsi_dt = (psi(x, t0+dt) - psi(x, t0-dt)) / (2*dt) lap = (psi(x[2:], t0) - 2*psi(x[1:-1], t0) + psi(x[:-2], t0)) / h**2 res = np.max(np.abs(1j*hbar*dpsi_dt[1:-1] + hbar**2/(2*m)*lap)) print("Schroedinger residual :", f"{res:.2e}") assert res < 1e-5 # (b) trajectories are deterministic functions of x0; they match the closed form rng = np.random.default_rng(12345) x0 = rng.normal(0.0, sigma0, 200000) # the ONLY random input: initial positions T = 3.0 xT = trajectories(x0, T) closed = x0 * math.sqrt(1.0 + (k*T)**2) err = np.max(np.abs(xT - closed)) print("max |RK4 - closed form| :", f"{err:.2e}") assert err < 1e-8 assert np.array_equal(xT, trajectories(x0, T)) # same x0 -> same x(T), bit for bit # (c) equivariance: ignorance measure |psi_0|^2 at t=0 is carried to |psi_T|^2 sigT = sigma0 * math.sqrt(1.0 + (k*T)**2) print("std of positions at T / sigma(T) :", f"{xT.std():.4f} / {sigT:.4f}") assert abs(xT.std()/sigT - 1.0) < 5e-3 s = np.sort(xT) cdf = np.array([0.5*(1.0 + math.erf(v/(sigT*math.sqrt(2.0)))) for v in s]) ks = np.max(np.abs(cdf - (np.arange(1, s.size+1)/s.size))) print("KS distance to |psi(x,T)|^2 :", f"{ks:.4f}") assert ks < 3.0 / math.sqrt(s.size) # approx. 99.9 percent level print("PASS")
1960年代頃から量子推定理論に基づいて分散を求めた結果と量子力学における不確定性関係との比較をした研究がなされてきた。その結果、量子推定理論に基づく結果が Heisenberg-Robertson の不確定性関係と同様な関係を与えることが知られていた。一方、渡辺らはd次元のフルパラメータモデルについて量子推定理論が Heisenberg-Robertson の不確定性関係とは異なる結果を与えることを示した。 本研究では, 一様磁場中にある一つの電子という物理的に意味のある具体的なモデルを設定した。量子推定理論により一様磁場中にある電子の位置座標(x,y)における x と y の分散の下界を求め, 不確定性関係について論じた。渡辺らの先行研究は有限次元におけるものであり本質的に無限次元となるモデルについて調べているところが本研究と先行研究の違いである。 一様磁場中にある電子の位置に関する不確定性関係を量子推定理論に基づいて求めるにあたり本研究では, 推定に使うユニタリー変換として正準運動量と力学的運動量を生成子とした場合の二つを用いて量子推定を行った。前者をモデル1, 後者をモデル2と呼ぶ。モデル1, モデル2ともに量子推定理論を用いると Heisenberg-Robertson の不確定性関係(Δx)(Δy)≧0 よりタイトな下界が得られることが示せた。 モデル1では熱状態(混合状態)を基準状態とした時, Gaussian Shift モデルと同等になることがわかった。従って RLD クラメール・ラオ不等式が与える下界が SLD のものよりタイトな下界となり, また RLD の与える下界は達成可能であることもわかった。基底状態(純粋状態)を基準状態としてとった場合は, 正準運動量の x, y 成分が非可換なことを反映し, SLD フィッシャー情報行列に量子的な効果が見られた。 一方のモデル2で熱状態(混合状態)を基準状態とした時Δx,Δyのとりうる領域は RLD,SLD の与える下界, Z 行列の与える上界の組み合わせで表される複雑な構造になることがわかった。さらにその下界の形は電子の角運動量に依存して変わるという興味深い結果が得られた。基底状態(純粋状態)を基準状態とした場合は, 力学的運動量の x, y 成分が可換なことを反映し, SLD フィッシャー情報行列に準古典的な効果が見られた。
If Δxt is the standard deviation of the position probability distribution at time t of a particle moving freely in one dimension, and Δv is the standard deviation of its velocity distribution, it is shown for a suitable choice of time origin that (Δxt)2 = (Δx0)2 + (Δv)2t2 whether the particle is moving classically or quantum mechanically. The quantum-mechanical proof is shown to exactly parallel that in the classical case. In the classical case, the correlation coefficient between the velocity and position distributions is shown to tend to −1 as t → −∞, to increase steadily with time, and to become +1 as t → +∞. A quantum-mechanical analog of this result is also proved.