Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1002.3005 · Progress of Theoretical Physics

Position Uncertainty in the Heisenberg Uncertainty Relation

Satoshi Kosugi

Published Mar 1, 2010• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Position measurements are examined under the assumption that object position and probe position just after the measurement are expressed as a linear combination of positions and just before the measurement. The Heisenberg uncertainty relation between the position uncertainty and momentum disturbance holds when the measurement error ε(xt) for the object position is adopted as the position uncertainty. However, the uncertainty in the measurement result obtained for is the standard deviation of the measurement result, and not the measurement error ε(x0). This difference is due to the reduction of a wave packet. The validity of the linearity assumption is examined in detail.

DOI
10.1143/ptp.123.431

Related papers

Quantum Measurements, Instruments, and Uncertainty Principle

Masanao Ozawa

The Heisenberg uncertainty relation for measurement noise and disturbance states that any position measurement with noise ε brings the momentum disturbance not less than hbar⁄2ε. However, this relation holds only for restricted class of measurements. Here, we discuss universally valid uncertainty relations for measurement noise and disturbance, which hold for all the possible quantum measurements.

Interdisciplinary Information Sciences•Jan 1, 2004•1 citation

Uncertainty in the Results of Position Measurement in the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle

Seiji Kosugi

Heisenbergの不確定性原理において,位置の測定値の不確定性として何を用いるべきかについて考察した.測定対象の位置としては,測定前の位置x0と測定後の位置xtの2つが考えられる.位置xtの測定値(xt)expの不確定性はこの測定値の測定誤差ε(xt)である.しかし位置x0の測定値(x0)expの不確定性は測定誤差ε(x0)ではなく,測定値(x0)expの標準偏差σ((x0)exp)である.位置の測定値の不確定性としてε(xt)またはσ((x0)exp)を用いた場合には,Heisenbergの不確定性関係は成立している.2つの位置情報の不確定性ε(xt)とσ((x0)exp)の非対称性を引き起こしているのは波束の収縮である.

•Feb 25, 2011•0 citations

Position measuring interactions and the Heisenberg uncertainty principle

Masanao Ozawa

A prevailing formulation of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle is re-examined that measuring position with noise $\\epsilon$ brings the momentum disturbance no less than $\\hbar/2\\epsilon$. With rigorous formulations of noise and disturbance, a model of a measuring interaction demonstrates that this formulation of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle is by no means universally valid. An experimental realization of the model is also suggested.

•Jun 30, 2001•37 citations

Proof of Heisenberg's error-disturbance principle

Seiji Kosugi

In Heisenberg's error-disturbance relation for electron position measurement, the measurement error must be the one that determines the uncertainty in the electron position just after the measurement. It is the resolution $ε(x_t)$ i.e., the measurement error of the post-measurement observable $\hat{x}_t$, not the precision $ε(x_0)$ i.e., that of the pre-measurement observable $\hat{x}_0$ that determines the uncertainty of the observable $\hat{x}_t$. Therefore, Heisenberg's relation must be interpreted as one between the resolution $ε(x_t)$ and the disturbance $η(y_0)$. The magnitude of the disturbance $η(y_0)$ is independent of the definition of the measurement value of the observable $\hat{x}_t$. Heisenberg's error-disturbance relation is proven to hold true in general, when the measurement value of $\hat{x}_t$ is defined in order to minimize the resolution $ε(x_t)$.

arXiv:1504.03779•Apr 15, 2015•2 citations

Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle

S. Rajasekar, R. Velusamy

One of the most striking deviations of quantum mechanics from classical mechanics is that any measurement of a microscopic system involves the interaction with the measuring instruments. The interaction cannot be neglected and in fact leads to uncontrollable disturbance on the system. In 1927, Werner Karl Heisenberg in his celebrated paper established the quantitative expression for unavoidable momentum disturbance caused by any position measurement. The crucial word here is simultaneously. The uncertainty relation gives the lower bound on the product of the uncertainties of two pairs of variables. But it says nothing about the accuracy with which individual observables can be measured. The physical meaning of energy-time uncertainty is different from that of x-px uncertainty. Position and momentum are observables to which Hermitian operators are assigned and which are measured at a particular time. An important implication of the uncertainty principle is that quantum systems do follow classical trajectories which conflict with our everyday experience.

CRC Press eBooks•Sep 29, 2022•1 citation

Universally valid reformulation of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle on noise and disturbance in measurement

Masanao Ozawa

The Heisenberg uncertainty principle states that the product of the noise in a position measurement and the momentum disturbance caused by that measurement should be no less than the limit set by Planck's constant $\ensuremath{\Elzxh}/2$ as demonstrated by Heisenberg's thought experiment using a \ensuremath{\gamma}-ray microscope. Here it is shown that this common assumption is not universally true: a universally valid trade-off relation between the noise and the disturbance has an additional correlation term, which is redundant when the intervention brought by the measurement is independent of the measured object, but which allows the noise-disturbance product much below Planck's constant when the intervention is dependent. A model of measuring interaction with dependent intervention shows that Heisenberg's lower bound for the noise-disturbance product is violated even by a nearly nondisturbing precise position measurement. An experimental implementation is also proposed to realize the above model in the context of optical quadrature measurement with currently available linear optical devices.

arXiv:quant-ph/0207121•Physical Review A•Apr 11, 2003•440 citations
Position measurements are examined under the assumption that object position and probe position just after the measurement are expressed as a linear combination of positions and just before the measurement. The Heisenberg uncertainty relation between the position uncertainty and momentum disturbance holds when the measurement error ε(xt) for the object position is adopted as the position uncertainty. However, the uncertainty in the measurement result obtained for is the standard deviation of the measurement result, and not the measurement error ε(x0). This difference is due to the reduction of a wave packet. The validity of the linearity assumption is examined in detail.
Heisenbergの不確定性原理において,位置の測定値の不確定性として何を用いるべきかについて考察した.測定対象の位置としては,測定前の位置x0と測定後の位置xtの2つが考えられる.位置xtの測定値(xt)expの不確定性はこの測定値の測定誤差ε(xt)である.しかし位置x0の測定値(x0)expの不確定性は測定誤差ε(x0)ではなく,測定値(x0)expの標準偏差σ((x0)exp)である.位置の測定値の不確定性としてε(xt)またはσ((x0)exp)を用いた場合には,Heisenbergの不確定性関係は成立している.2つの位置情報の不確定性ε(xt)とσ((x0)exp)の非対称性を引き起こしているのは波束の収縮である.
A prevailing formulation of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle is re-examined that measuring position with noise epsilon\\epsilonepsilon brings the momentum disturbance no less than hbar/2epsilon\\hbar/2\\epsilonhbar/2epsilon. With rigorous formulations of noise and disturbance, a model of a measuring interaction demonstrates that this formulation of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle is by no means universally valid. An experimental realization of the model is also suggested.
In Heisenberg's error-disturbance relation for electron position measurement, the measurement error must be the one that determines the uncertainty in the electron position just after the measurement. It is the resolution ε(xt)ε(x_t)ε(xt​) i.e., the measurement error of the post-measurement observable x^t\hat{x}_tx^t​, not the precision ε(x0)ε(x_0)ε(x0​) i.e., that of the pre-measurement observable x^0\hat{x}_0x^0​ that determines the uncertainty of the observable x^t\hat{x}_tx^t​. Therefore, Heisenberg's relation must be interpreted as one between the resolution ε(xt)ε(x_t)ε(xt​) and the disturbance η(y0)η(y_0)η(y0​). The magnitude of the disturbance η(y0)η(y_0)η(y0​) is independent of the definition of the measurement value of the observable x^t\hat{x}_tx^t​. Heisenberg's error-disturbance relation is proven to hold true in general, when the measurement value of x^t\hat{x}_tx^t​ is defined in order to minimize the resolution ε(xt)ε(x_t)ε(xt​).
One of the most striking deviations of quantum mechanics from classical mechanics is that any measurement of a microscopic system involves the interaction with the measuring instruments. The interaction cannot be neglected and in fact leads to uncontrollable disturbance on the system. In 1927, Werner Karl Heisenberg in his celebrated paper established the quantitative expression for unavoidable momentum disturbance caused by any position measurement. The crucial word here is simultaneously. The uncertainty relation gives the lower bound on the product of the uncertainties of two pairs of variables. But it says nothing about the accuracy with which individual observables can be measured. The physical meaning of energy-time uncertainty is different from that of x-px uncertainty. Position and momentum are observables to which Hermitian operators are assigned and which are measured at a particular time. An important implication of the uncertainty principle is that quantum systems do follow classical trajectories which conflict with our everyday experience.
The Heisenberg uncertainty principle states that the product of the noise in a position measurement and the momentum disturbance caused by that measurement should be no less than the limit set by Planck's constant $\ensuremath{\Elzxh}/2$ as demonstrated by Heisenberg's thought experiment using a \ensuremath{\gamma}-ray microscope. Here it is shown that this common assumption is not universally true: a universally valid trade-off relation between the noise and the disturbance has an additional correlation term, which is redundant when the intervention brought by the measurement is independent of the measured object, but which allows the noise-disturbance product much below Planck's constant when the intervention is dependent. A model of measuring interaction with dependent intervention shows that Heisenberg's lower bound for the noise-disturbance product is violated even by a nearly nondisturbing precise position measurement. An experimental implementation is also proposed to realize the above model in the context of optical quadrature measurement with currently available linear optical devices.