Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

A Measured Lorentzian Cone in Non-Hermitian Quantum Geometry

Jeromie Beasley

Published Aug 20, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The Ledger Outlives the Metric: Wall Species, the Reciprocity Obstruction, and a Measured Crossing Behind an Operator-Side Reading of Entropic Gravity We identify the operator-side object that licenses two recent programmes deriving gravity from relative entropy, and we measure where that license expires and what survives its expiration. For a family of projectors Π(θ), a metric–curvature inequality holds if and only if a quadratic form Q built from the round-trip transition amplitudes is positive semidefinite — guaranteed when Π is self-adjoint, and losing that guarantee, not the inequality itself, otherwise. We prove this is one of three distinct wall species of differing codimension, with a licence locus 4 det g ≥ Ω² nested strictly inside the metric-definiteness locus det g ≥ 0. We identify a reciprocity obstruction: for B-symmetric generators under B-symmetric probes, the round-trip form is forced to a perfect square, and det g vanishes identically at every parameter value and every degree of non-Hermiticity — not approximately, not on a measure-zero set. Measured on a hyperboloidal Pöschl–Teller generator, the gauge-invariant witness W sits at the instrument floor (≤1.1×10⁻⁷) across 28 operating points, seven orders of magnitude below a non-reciprocal control. Breaking reciprocity lifts W linearly in the perturbation, log-log slope 1.000 against a pre-registered prediction of 1.00 ± 0.15. The paper's central measurement crosses the metric wall directly. On a six-dimensional generator with a tunable dial, det g changes sign at κ* = 0.627127751476while the contour eigenvalue count and the regularised trace-log log-determinant — the ledger — hold at 4.4×10⁻¹⁶ and 6.7×10⁻¹⁶ respectively, identically on both sides of the wall and at it. The metric fails; the ledger does not notice. We extend the record layer to two further checkpoints, each posed with its bar stated before the measurement. The ledger's response kernel on a gapless three-dimensional lattice generator extrapolates to 4πrG(r) → 1.001, the Newtonian potential, with its Hessian the inverse-square law; gapping the same generator gives a Yukawa kernel with the predicted mass. The trace-log of a region scales as an area with a logarithmic correction at the gapless point (Widom form, fit to 0.2–1.1%) while its count scales as the volume, splitting the record's two halves across the two plateaus classically expected of an entropy and a charge. A companion result, proved independently in normalised Hamming space, shows why this robustness cannot be accidental: a regularised trace-log that is Lipschitz in a metric forgiving local surgery is thereby disqualified from marking any wall in that metric — the same property, read from two sides, as both the survival and the metric's failure. Twenty-two further theorems and measured results are established, including a positive semidefinite reading of the metric as a symmetrised pairing of two families (self-adjointness recovering the Gram structure exactly), an eta-invariant argument placing the surviving quantity inside established Atiyah–Patodi–Singer index theory, and a clock exponent — 1 for semidefinite generators, 1/2 for indefinite ones — matching the two known horizon lapse laws structurally rather than by fit. The junction with entropic gravity is stated at the grade it has earned. What is proved is that a relative entropy and the operator ledger are both built from a trace of a matrix logarithm, that neither requires a definite pairing, and that both remain finite exactly where a Gram determinant changes sign — which is, at the level the mathematics supports, why the recent horizon-entropy programmes' substitution of an entropy for a metric works where it does. No horizon is derived here, and no claim is made that any of the generators tested is a spacetime. That identification is stated as a reading, graded accordingly, and left as the paper's open problem. 63 pages, 8 figures, 22 theorems/propositions, 30 numerically gated results with captured scripts and output, complete reproduction package included.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.22023237

Related papers

The Offset Belongs to the Boundary: the trace split of the entanglement Hamiltonian, a measured Clausius region, and an offset with no bulk

Jeromie Beasley

For a region of a free-fermion ground state the entanglement Hamiltonian K_A = log[(1 - C_A) C_A^-1] splits into a part proportional to the identity and a trace-free remainder. The identity part shifts every level rigidly, so every observable built from level differences is blind to it. This paper is about that part. It is not a bulk quantity. The block carries one ladder per entangling cut, the trace is the difference of the two cut-phase charges, and on the exactly dimerised chain with a single cut carrying the whole charge it has the closed form 2 artanh(v / sqrt(v^2 + t^2)), derived in one line and measured to 10^-11. In exact arithmetic the trace is a definite number: zero to thirty-three digits when the two cut phases agree, and 0.786153199019314523 when they do not. The apparent divergence reported in earlier work was double-precision truncation of a finite sum, and is retired here. Along the two lines through the Rice-Mele plane where the half-line entanglement Hamiltonian is known in closed form, it is proportional to the Bisognano-Wichmann deformation T = (1/2){X, H} with no additive constant, and the ladder spacing and phase are fixed by the literature. Between those lines the commuting operator survives, measured at 10^-13 against controls that fail at 1.5 and 29, but the proportionality does not: the level map acquires an intercept b that is zero to 3 x 10^-9 on both lines and of order 10^-1 in the interior, and is identical whether the region has one entangling cut or two. That intercept is the measured failure of exact Bisognano-Wichmann proportionality. At first order in the staggering v the intercept is derived rather than fitted. The symbol's determinant is det(z - P) = z(z - 1) independently of momentum, so the factorisation is canonical everywhere; its logarithm is affine in an involution R = H/E with R^2 = I; the abelian Szego-type boundary functional is identically even in v and therefore cannot carry an odd intercept; and the first-order piece follows from the chiral zero mode of the dimerised chain, whose amplitudes are (-r)^j C(2j,j) 4^-j in closed form. The result is b/v = 2(E' - K')/(1 - r^2) + K', K' = K(1 - r^2), E' = E(1 - r^2), r = t1/t2, whose expansion in the modulus u is, in exact rationals, h(u)/(pi/8) = 1 - (5/8) u^2 - (9/64) u^4 - (65/1024) u^6 - (595/16384) u^8 - ... So pi/8, -5/8 and -9/64 are consequences rather than recognitions, and the natural elliptic candidate [9E - K]/16 - pi/8 is excluded by 7.7 percent on the first coefficient it does not get to choose. The closed form agrees with direct measurement extrapolated to v -> 0 by two to three orders better than the fitted series it replaces; a previously reported u^6 coefficient of -0.0648 is corrected here to -65/1024 and identified as truncation. The trace-free half is treated in parallel. A Clausius relation with a single temperature holds exactly when that half is proportional to the region's own Hamiltonian. At a ground state it never is, and the measured temperature is zero, which is correct rather than a failure. In a thermal state the same instrument returns 1/beta to five significant figures, and the boundary of the region where it does so collapses onto two dimensionless ratios. Two further results are included. The offset vanishes when the two cuts sit at the same phase in the unit cell, without requiring chirality, time reversal, inversion or cleanliness, and a mirror-symmetrised disordered chain gives a larger offset than its unsymmetrised control, which rules reflection out as the mechanism. And in two dimensions the offset is exactly additive along the boundary for a transverse coupling proportional to the identity in sublattice space, for a reason short enough to state, with a derived crossing past which additivity fails and a sigma_z coupling that breaks it smoothly. Every claim carries one of four grades: [T] proven here, [V] computationally verified with stated controls and a stated failure mode, [C] imported from the cited literature, [H] interpretation. The two exact lines, the commuting deformation, the boundary-locality of the entanglement spectrum, and the first law of entanglement entropy are not this work's and are used as given. Sixteen retired claims, including two withdrawn from earlier versions of this manuscript, are listed with the measurement that killed each. Files in this deposit: the_offset_belongs_to_the_boundary_v8_submission.pdf — 35 pages, gate output verbatim, script listings supplied separately. the_offset_belongs_to_the_boundary_v8_complete.pdf — 59 pages, identical body with all scripts printed inline. offset_v8_scripts.zip — 23 files. Every number quoted in the paper is printed by one of them; the two gate files reproduce their stored output byte for byte. KEYWORDS entanglement Hamiltonian; entanglement spectrum; modular Hamiltonian; Bisognano-Wichmann; Rice-Mele model; SSH model; free fermions; boundary charge; cut-phase charge; corner transfer matrix; Toeplitz operators; Wiener-Hopf factorisation; Szego-Widom asymptotics; algebraic Heun operator; complete elliptic integrals; entanglement first law; area law; Landau-Widom counting function ADDITIONAL NOTES Supersedes earlier versions of this manuscript. Two claims present in versions 1 to 3 are withdrawn and recorded in the kill list: that the incommensurate offset has no value, and that the offset is one quantum. Both were double-precision truncation of a finite sum. The u^6 coefficient of the shape function reported in the companion results ledger is likewise superseded by the derived value. Computational verification, gating and drafting assistance by an AI collaborator (Claude, Anthropic). Every gate is independently re-runnable from the ancillary scripts.

•Aug 31, 2026•0 citations

Opened matter · the boundary census The Weight Between and the Exit Line

Jeromie Beasley

When a system of electrons is cut into a region and the rest, its correlation matrix has a cross block, X_A = C_AB C_BA: the weight between the two sides of the cut. This paper proves what that weight can and cannot say, and then studies where opened (non-Hermitian) matter leaves the disk of its occupation chart. The weight between. X_A is positive and never larger than 1/4. Both sides of the cut see the same positive spectrum. It is stable under small changes, with a certified count. It sits below the local defect C_A − C_A², and for a pure Gaussian (Slater) state, where C is an orthogonal projector, the two are equal. Four times its trace bounds the Gaussian mutual information across the cut from below, with a sharp constant, and there is no upper constant without a spectral margin. Exact examples show that a one-body record does not in general determine correlations outside the quasi-free class. The signed boundary offset τ = log det(I − C_A)/det C_A moves no faster than τ̇² ≤ 4gS, and two preparations with the same census, offset, cross weight and coupling saturate this bound in opposite directions. The exit line. On the PT-symmetric Su–Schrieffer–Heeger chain, the band-averaged Petermann factor equals 2 exactly on the line E(0)E(π) = u², equivalently (w² − v²)² = 2u²(w² + v²). Exits predicted from that line before the run match the measured census exits of finite blocks to about 5e-8 in these runs. A linearly weighted operator, T = ½{X + ½, H}, commutes entrywise with the half-chain correlation block; the proof uses only H(k)² = E(k)²I, so it holds without Hermiticity. At 200 sampled gapped parameter points, its tested low-index edge eigenvectors exhibit an equally spaced entanglement ladder ε_j = jΔ + iθ, with a spacing Δ = 2πK′/K taken from a Hermitian band hidden inside the opened one and a shared phase θ given by an elliptic (Abel) formula. For this proposed ladder, the paper proves that it crosses the rim of the disk all at once, and that its phase reaches a quarter turn exactly on the Petermann line, in both directions. The dimer limit is proved exactly. Plain finite blocks give a census rotation equal to the same phase to within 7e-7. An analytic derivation of the ladder for the coupled chain remains open, and the paper states it as open. Related numerical work on the same model (Rottoli, Fossati and Calabrese, 2024) is cited and compared. Every claim carries a grade (proved, Lean-checked algebraic subclaim, verified numerically, known result, or open), and every number comes from a script included in the archive, with the reference-run environment recorded. Files: the paper (PDF); a web edition (HTML) with an interactive view of the proposed ladder model; and a zip holding the LaTeX source, the Python scripts and their outputs, the figure, the Lean proofs, and a README mapping each Lean grade to its theorem. Prepared with AI assistance (Claude, Anthropic; and OpenAI tools for parts of the formal development); the ideas and research direction are the author's.

•Nov 5, 2026•0 citations

Metric Structure from the Parity-Entanglement Bound, with Gravitational Correspondences

Ram Kirpitch

The Parity-Entanglement Bound (PEB) fixes the clock-system mutual information of a ℤ₂ constrained bipartite pure state at exactly two bits. We show that this invariant functions as the zero point of a metric geometry built from information. Six results are given. (i) The deviation Π = 1 - 1/2 I is the unique local-unitary (LU) invariant of the minimal state (pure, ℤ₂, bipartite); relaxing each hypothesis adds a definite number of further axes, which we count numerically (mixedness +1, ℤn+(n-2), tripartite +2; a continuous gauge group opens a continuous axis), (ii) The correlation quantity d = -ln κ is non-negative, symmetric, and vanishes in the coincidence limit; in the gapped regime, at separations above a floor r*(m), it obeys the triangle inequality and is a metric. (iii) The validity window is mapped: the floor r*(m) grows with the gap and the window closes entirely once the correlation length falls below the lattice scale (m ≥ 1.7 in 1D, ≥ 2 in 2D, lattice units); in the opposite, gapless limit the inequality survives with growing slack (0 violations atm m = 0.02) and an asymptotic argument establishes it analytically in the logarithmic regime. Non-Gaussianity per se does not damage the inequality: on a φ⁴ chain the observed violations are reproduced quantitatively by a free field of matched effective gap. (iv) Local noise acts on d as an exactly additive per-region dilation, d → d + δA + δB with δ ≥ 0; pure dephasing leaves d exactly invariant, and local noise can only increase the triangle slack, so the metric is noise-robust by construction. (v) The PEB value equals a combinatorial crossing number of stabiliser generators, hence is independent of system size, clock size, and clock position; it is formally analogous to a topological entanglement entropy. (vi) Following the Dirac-equation construction [6], the two-dimensionality dim ℋC = 2 underlies a distance/time split. The construction is verified by exact and Monte-Carlo simulation (geodesic locking 60/60 across five seeds; zero triangle violations above the floor in more than 1.6 × 10⁴ triples spanning gapped, near-critical, interacting, and noisy regimes) and, as a proof of concept, by a state-preparation study on quantum hardware (IBM FEZ). Formal correspondences to gravitational behaviour geodesic bending in a non-uniform gap and a volume-to-area transition in the crossing count are recorded in Sec. no gravitational derivation is claimed. Statements are labelled [P] proved, [K] known-with-citation, [N] numerical, or [0] open.

•Jul 5, 2026•0 citations

Entanglement Equilibrium on a Solvable Gaussian Network: The Contact Term Identified, Geometry Recovered from Entanglement Data, Causal Structure Bounded, and Equilibrium Explained

T. Weinmann

Jacobson's entanglement-equilibrium argument derives the Einstein equation from (i) an area law with finite Newton constant, (ii) a first law for the matter modular Hamiltonian, and (iii) stationarity of the vacuum entropy of small geodesic balls at fixed volume. We test these ingredients on a solvable family of network states: a pair sector whose entanglement encodes a Riemannian metric, combined with the Gaussian ground state of a scalar field on the same weighted graph, for which entropies and modular Hamiltonians of arbitrary regions are computed exactly. Every assumption is isolated as a hypothesis and classified as proved, derived, computed, or imposed by construction. (1) Derivation (conditional). The wave-packet quadratic form of the exact massless modular Hamiltonian of a ball, computed by Longo and Morsella, is identical to the bulk form K_bulk = 2π ∫ κ T_00^(min) + (2π ξ_c n / ℓ) ∫ φ^2 exhibited by the lattice data; the contact-term coefficient χ = 2π ξ_c and the response R = 1 + ξ_c n(n+2)/(ωℓ/c)^2 are identified, not fitted. The step from the continuum identity to the lattice is a modular-convergence statement (Conjecture C1) which we do not prove: a proved proposition on the non-analyticity of the entropy function at the band edge, together with a heuristic accumulation argument, shows why the spectral convergence of the matter sector does not imply it. The lattice data support C1: q_∞ = 1.02 ± 0.02 in n = 2 (up to 1.09 in n = 3 at the accessible radii ℓ ≤ 8). (2) Geometry (recovered, not emergent). The metric is imposed on the pair sector by construction; what is tested is the inverse map. An identifiability lemma shows the entropic distance matrix determines the manifold up to isometry; on S^2 the blind pipeline recovers the dimension (c_2 = 3.13 ≈ π), detects curvature through the negative tail of the MDS spectrum, and measures the curvature radius to 4%. (3) Causal structure (bounded, then computed). For the oscillator sector we prove a field-commutator cone bound with explicit constants, valid on arbitrary point sets, with cone velocity v_φ = 3.05 = 3.1 c_lat; the exact field commutator shows the physical front propagates at c_lat, with Lorentz violation controlled by β = γ(6,m)/16γ(4,m) = 0.384 as (kξ)^2. (4) Equilibrium. The equilibrium postulate is proved equivalent to the reconstructed metric having constant scalar curvature (Einstein only in n = 2); passivity supplies an exact constrained second-variation identity: at fixed geometry and fixed modular energy the vacuum is a local maximum of the generalised entropy along every constrained matter direction. The entropic flow whose fixed points are the equilibrium geometries is defined, not derived; in n = 2 it coincides with the normalised Ricci flow, whose convergence is Hamilton's theorem. (5) Spectral convergence (leading order, black box). For deterministic quasi-uniform sequences on curved manifolds the form-consistency step is proved explicitly, and eigenvalue convergence is obtained only conditionally by citing the graph discretisation of the Laplace–Beltrami operator as a black box. The curvature renormalisation of the speed of sound, c_eff^2 = c^2(1 - R_s γ(n+4,m)ξ^2 / 6n γ(n+2,m)), is verified on S^2 to 1%. For non-uniform random point sets the raw operator converges to a drift operator, and a blind density correction computed from entropic ball counts repairs it, recovering the manifold spectrum to within 0.2–2.3% plus a counting bias of order 1 / N̄_(r_b). All numbers are generated by the programs distributed with this work.

•Nov 8, 2026•0 citations

Optimal Transport Gravity: SDW Equations and Axiomatics: Operational OTq Density-Matrix Dynamics with Einstein-Locked Geometry

Gwenolé Bocquet

Overview: This paper develops the state-to-geometry interface of the OT–GKSL architecture for open quantum sources. Its starting point is a familiar low-energy tension: classical general relativity couples spacetime geometry to matter through the Einstein equations, whereas quantum matter may be open, coherent, correlated, preparation dependent, or subject to measurement and environmental records. Semiclassical gravity and stochastic-gravity approaches have long made clear that the relation between quantum sources and classical geometry is not conceptually trivial (Page & Geilker, 1981; Kuo & Ford, 1993; Hu & Verdaguer, 2008). The OT–GKSL architecture addresses this problem by not assuming classical spacetime as part of the native quantum state description. Instead, it separates a persistent quantum/open-state domain from later classical descendants. At the native level, states belong to a faithful finite-dimensional working stratum, ρ ∈ D°(H_eff), and evolve under a declared GKSL dynamics, dρξ/dξ = L*(ρξ). The completely positive Markovian structure follows the standard theory of Gorini, Kossakowski & Sudarshan (1976) and Lindblad (1976). On a faithful reversible detailed-balance component, the dissipative generator admits the noncommutative optimal-transport gradient representation developed in the quantum Markov setting by Carlen & Maas (2017): L*_db(ρ) = - grad_gOT D(ρ || π). Here g_OT is a positive state-space metric and D(ρ || π) = Tr[ρ(log ρ - log π)] is the relative entropy to a faithful stationary state π. The detailed-balance entropy production is σ_db(ρ) = ||grad_gOT D(ρ || π)||²_gOT ≥ 0. This identity concerns the detailed-balance dissipative component, not automatically the complete GKSL trajectory. If L* = L_coh + L_db + L*_rem, then the full relative-entropy balance retains the coherent and remainder contributions separately. The native evolution parameter ξ, the accumulated entropic ordering variable t_ent, and physical readout time t_ro are therefore distinct: ξ ≠ t_ent ≠ t_ro. A physical clock requires a stabilized and calibrated clock record. Its identification with the temporal sector of the Lorentzian spacetime readout requires the additional clock–coframe and proper-time compatibility conditions of the certified spacetime branch. From records to geometric readout: Classical geometry is not identified directly with the native OT geometry. The architecture first constructs physical records. Protocol-complete certified records determine event identity, while a separate geometric coarse-graining determines which event distinctions are used for localization. A 2 rank-D family then supplies local geometric coordinates. On the observed spacetime branch, D = 4. native states → certified physical records → event classes → geometric coarse-graining → rank-D coordinate records → horizontal readout sector → section and soldering →Lorentzian coframe → classical metricThe important distinction is complete event-record content ≠ rank-D coordinate content.Additional records may encode matter properties, preparation data, measurement outcomes, orientation, gauge information, clock information, or internal structure without becoming additional spacetime dimensions. On a regular geometric patch, the coordinate map defines a vertical sector and its OT-orthogonalhorizontal complement, V = ker DΠ_coord, H = V^(⊥ gOT). A local section selects native representatives and a calibrated soldering map transfers the readablehorizontal data to the physical frame bundle. The physical coframe e^a then defines g_ro = η_ab e^a ⊗ e^b, with η_ab = diag(-1,+1,+1,+1)on the observed Lorentzian branch. The positive metric g_OT and the Lorentzian metric g_ro are therefore different mathematical objects with different domains and physical roles. Lorentzian signature is not obtained by changing the signature of g_OT; it enters through the calibrated readout branch.This distinction is compatible with the broader operational idea that physical reference frames and records may themselves be quantum systems rather than external classical structures (Bartlett, Rudolph & Spekkens, 2007; Giacomini, Castro-Ruiz & Brukner, 2019), while the specific record-to-geometry ordering is a commitment of the OT-GKSL architecture Horizontal connection and holonomy bridge: A central result of the paper is the typed separation between native state-space geometry and readout geometry. Let ∇^OT denote the Levi-Civita connection of the applicable OT metric. The connection relevant for the geometric bridge is the projected connection on the horizontal bundle, ∇^H_X Y = P_H ∇^OT_X Y.Its curvature R^H is not generally the restriction of the ambient OT curvature R^OT. In particular, R^OT ≠ 0 does not by itself imply R^H ≠ 0.The readout bridge therefore transports the horizontal connection, rather than silently identifying ambient OT curvature with spacetime curvature. With a local section s and soldering map Ω, the transferred connection has the standard inhomogeneous transformation structure, Γ_B,s = Ω (s*Γ_H) Ω^(-1) - (dΩ) Ω^(-1).It may then be compared with the independently constructed readout connection. The corresponding bridge defect is controlled on the declared certified domain. For a fixed loop C, a connection-level defect gives a length-type transport estimate of Duhamel form. An area-type small-loop estimate requires the stronger input of curvature control, a suitable small contractible loop, and compatible gauge/trivialization data. The paper therefore distinguishes four statements: ambient OT curvature; horizontal curvature and holonomy; transferred/readout holonomy; detector-visible holonomic response. None is identified with the next without an explicit bridge or visibility condition.3. This separation is related conceptually to earlier geometric treatments of mixed-state parallel transport and quantum holonomy (Uhlmann, 1986; Andersson & Heydari, 2014), although the OT-GKSL horizontal/readout bridge is an architecture-specific construction. Finite holonomy and preparation sensitivity. The consolidated formulation distinguishes a nontrivial finite loop signal from its sensitivity to preparation. A finite holonomy may satisfy H(ρ*) ≠ I while nevertheless Dρ H(ρ*) = 0. Thus anontrivial background holonomy does not prove that the holonomy varies under the preparation tested by an experiment.Two operational observables are accordingly kept distinct.Y_H^fin = L_H^fin(H - I) is a finite-loop detector. A body-fixed or Maurer-Cartan response may instead use Ξ_H = L̂_H(H^(-1) ∇_prep H).These are distinct calibrated observables. They coincide only under an explicitly declared translation/calibration relation. Preparation differentiation must also be gauge controlled, by freezing a physical record-defined frame, differentiating a gauge-invariant functional, or using a covariant derivative.Source-side constitutive branch The source/matter descendant is constructed independently of the geometric descendant. Within the Dirac/HS-NJL working class considered in the paper, an internal operator Y defines the positive quadratic tracer κ_Y = Tr(Y†Y). A frozen calibration maps this quantity to an operational coordinate p_κ. The scalar source-side constitutive law is written μ = μ(p_κ), with local susceptibility β_μ(p_κ) = - ∂_(pκ) ln μ(p_κ). A certification gate may determine whether the working point remains admissible, but its derivative is not part of the physical constitutive susceptibility in the certified interior. The scalar constitutive channel and the holonomic channel are mathematically distinct and possess different experimental symmetry handles. Einstein lock: The observed gravitational branch is constrained by an Einstein lock. The two-derivative gravitational kinetic block is fixed to the Einstein-Hilbert form,S_EH[g_ro; G0] = (c³ / 16πG0) ∫ d⁴x sqrt(-g_ro) R[g_ro], with G0 = constant.This is a branch-selection and recovery condition of the OT-GKSL corpus. It is not claimed to be the unique consequence of GKSL dynamics alone. The architecture forbids a readable preparation-dependent factor multiplying the Einstein-Hilbert curvature term on the locked branch. State dependence is instead carried by independently specified source, response, gauge, interface, readout, or higher-order sectors. The gravitational comparison is performed only after geometry and source data have beenindependently fixed: 4 C_E = G_μν[g_ro] - κ0 T^eff_μν - Δ^if_μν. A gravitational claim requires the residual C_E to satisfy its declared norm and tolerance. TheBianchi identity acts as a compatibility condition on these already constructed sectors; it does not define the source after the fact. The branch-resolved Trilemma: The central result is a local and conditional separation theorem for the visible constitutive and holonomic branches. On a finite-dimensional admissible test sector, define the kinematic analysis using the unweighted source coordinate and the holonomic preparation response, h → (dp_κ[h], ζ_H[h]). The constitutive coefficient β_μ is applied only after this kinematic conditioning. Consequently, testing β_μ,* = 0 does not make the underlying analysis map singular by definition. For a normed visible output space, the declared first-order closure has the form DO_vis[h] = N_E(β_μ,* dp_κ[h]) + N_H(ζ_H[h]) + B_oth[h] + R_aud[h]. Here B_oth contains independently constructed visible branches not removed by the frozen protocol, and R_aud is the declared audit remainder. The factorization of the scalar constitutive term through β_μ is an explicit visible/source closure assumption; it is not derived solely from OT variational calculus. At a working point where β_μ,* = 0, if, for a tested variation h, ||N_H(ζ_H[h])|| > ||B_oth[h] + R_aud[h]||, then DO_vis[h] ≠ 0. The final implication follows from the reverse triangle inequality. The nontrivial content lies upstream: construction of the regular record/geometric quotien

•Feb 22, 2026•0 citations

Gravity from generalized entropy

Hussain Gohar

Gravity from entropy (GfE) identifies its Lagrangian with the geometric quantum relative entropy (GQRE) between the spacetime metric and a metric induced by matter and curvature, treating the metric itself as a quantum operator. We extend this construction to the Tsallis, Rényi, and Sharma-Mittal families, which we call gravity from generalized entropy (GfGE), and determine their common Einstein limit, weak-field spectra, auxiliary-field formulation, and horizon entropy. The entropy choice controls the leading higher-curvature terms and additional modes. We confirm that the linearized GfE spectrum contains a healthy scalar and a Planck-scale tachyonic spin-2 ghost. We identify the conditions that remove this ghost: curvature must enter through its scalar trace, or the entropy generator must be flat to quadratic order at the identity. The latter gives exact general relativity for Tsallis at $q=0$ and ghost-free $f(R,L_m)$ theories for Rényi and Sharma-Mittal. On shell, the auxiliary G-field is proportional to the tensor in Wald's entropy formula. For analytic entropy functions, horizons with a single curvature scale have an area term followed by constant and inverse-area corrections. We also extend the volume-constraint cosmological constant to the full family; its leading entropy dependence is set by the scalar mass. A finite set of entropy-function derivatives controls the leading weak-curvature departures from general relativity.

gr-qcCross-listedarXiv:2610.19106•Oct 15, 2026
The Ledger Outlives the Metric: Wall Species, the Reciprocity Obstruction, and a Measured Crossing Behind an Operator-Side Reading of Entropic Gravity We identify the operator-side object that licenses two recent programmes deriving gravity from relative entropy, and we measure where that license expires and what survives its expiration. For a family of projectors Π(θ), a metric–curvature inequality holds if and only if a quadratic form Q built from the round-trip transition amplitudes is positive semidefinite — guaranteed when Π is self-adjoint, and losing that guarantee, not the inequality itself, otherwise. We prove this is one of three distinct wall species of differing codimension, with a licence locus 4 det g ≥ Ω² nested strictly inside the metric-definiteness locus det g ≥ 0. We identify a reciprocity obstruction: for B-symmetric generators under B-symmetric probes, the round-trip form is forced to a perfect square, and det g vanishes identically at every parameter value and every degree of non-Hermiticity — not approximately, not on a measure-zero set. Measured on a hyperboloidal Pöschl–Teller generator, the gauge-invariant witness W sits at the instrument floor (≤1.1×10⁻⁷) across 28 operating points, seven orders of magnitude below a non-reciprocal control. Breaking reciprocity lifts W linearly in the perturbation, log-log slope 1.000 against a pre-registered prediction of 1.00 ± 0.15. The paper's central measurement crosses the metric wall directly. On a six-dimensional generator with a tunable dial, det g changes sign at κ* = 0.627127751476while the contour eigenvalue count and the regularised trace-log log-determinant — the ledger — hold at 4.4×10⁻¹⁶ and 6.7×10⁻¹⁶ respectively, identically on both sides of the wall and at it. The metric fails; the ledger does not notice. We extend the record layer to two further checkpoints, each posed with its bar stated before the measurement. The ledger's response kernel on a gapless three-dimensional lattice generator extrapolates to 4πrG(r) → 1.001, the Newtonian potential, with its Hessian the inverse-square law; gapping the same generator gives a Yukawa kernel with the predicted mass. The trace-log of a region scales as an area with a logarithmic correction at the gapless point (Widom form, fit to 0.2–1.1%) while its count scales as the volume, splitting the record's two halves across the two plateaus classically expected of an entropy and a charge. A companion result, proved independently in normalised Hamming space, shows why this robustness cannot be accidental: a regularised trace-log that is Lipschitz in a metric forgiving local surgery is thereby disqualified from marking any wall in that metric — the same property, read from two sides, as both the survival and the metric's failure. Twenty-two further theorems and measured results are established, including a positive semidefinite reading of the metric as a symmetrised pairing of two families (self-adjointness recovering the Gram structure exactly), an eta-invariant argument placing the surviving quantity inside established Atiyah–Patodi–Singer index theory, and a clock exponent — 1 for semidefinite generators, 1/2 for indefinite ones — matching the two known horizon lapse laws structurally rather than by fit. The junction with entropic gravity is stated at the grade it has earned. What is proved is that a relative entropy and the operator ledger are both built from a trace of a matrix logarithm, that neither requires a definite pairing, and that both remain finite exactly where a Gram determinant changes sign — which is, at the level the mathematics supports, why the recent horizon-entropy programmes' substitution of an entropy for a metric works where it does. No horizon is derived here, and no claim is made that any of the generators tested is a spacetime. That identification is stated as a reading, graded accordingly, and left as the paper's open problem. 63 pages, 8 figures, 22 theorems/propositions, 30 numerically gated results with captured scripts and output, complete reproduction package included.
For a region of a free-fermion ground state the entanglement Hamiltonian K_A = log[(1 - C_A) C_A^-1] splits into a part proportional to the identity and a trace-free remainder. The identity part shifts every level rigidly, so every observable built from level differences is blind to it. This paper is about that part. It is not a bulk quantity. The block carries one ladder per entangling cut, the trace is the difference of the two cut-phase charges, and on the exactly dimerised chain with a single cut carrying the whole charge it has the closed form 2 artanh(v / sqrt(v^2 + t^2)), derived in one line and measured to 10^-11. In exact arithmetic the trace is a definite number: zero to thirty-three digits when the two cut phases agree, and 0.786153199019314523 when they do not. The apparent divergence reported in earlier work was double-precision truncation of a finite sum, and is retired here. Along the two lines through the Rice-Mele plane where the half-line entanglement Hamiltonian is known in closed form, it is proportional to the Bisognano-Wichmann deformation T = (1/2){X, H} with no additive constant, and the ladder spacing and phase are fixed by the literature. Between those lines the commuting operator survives, measured at 10^-13 against controls that fail at 1.5 and 29, but the proportionality does not: the level map acquires an intercept b that is zero to 3 x 10^-9 on both lines and of order 10^-1 in the interior, and is identical whether the region has one entangling cut or two. That intercept is the measured failure of exact Bisognano-Wichmann proportionality. At first order in the staggering v the intercept is derived rather than fitted. The symbol's determinant is det(z - P) = z(z - 1) independently of momentum, so the factorisation is canonical everywhere; its logarithm is affine in an involution R = H/E with R^2 = I; the abelian Szego-type boundary functional is identically even in v and therefore cannot carry an odd intercept; and the first-order piece follows from the chiral zero mode of the dimerised chain, whose amplitudes are (-r)^j C(2j,j) 4^-j in closed form. The result is b/v = 2(E' - K')/(1 - r^2) + K', K' = K(1 - r^2), E' = E(1 - r^2), r = t1/t2, whose expansion in the modulus u is, in exact rationals, h(u)/(pi/8) = 1 - (5/8) u^2 - (9/64) u^4 - (65/1024) u^6 - (595/16384) u^8 - ... So pi/8, -5/8 and -9/64 are consequences rather than recognitions, and the natural elliptic candidate [9E - K]/16 - pi/8 is excluded by 7.7 percent on the first coefficient it does not get to choose. The closed form agrees with direct measurement extrapolated to v -> 0 by two to three orders better than the fitted series it replaces; a previously reported u^6 coefficient of -0.0648 is corrected here to -65/1024 and identified as truncation. The trace-free half is treated in parallel. A Clausius relation with a single temperature holds exactly when that half is proportional to the region's own Hamiltonian. At a ground state it never is, and the measured temperature is zero, which is correct rather than a failure. In a thermal state the same instrument returns 1/beta to five significant figures, and the boundary of the region where it does so collapses onto two dimensionless ratios. Two further results are included. The offset vanishes when the two cuts sit at the same phase in the unit cell, without requiring chirality, time reversal, inversion or cleanliness, and a mirror-symmetrised disordered chain gives a larger offset than its unsymmetrised control, which rules reflection out as the mechanism. And in two dimensions the offset is exactly additive along the boundary for a transverse coupling proportional to the identity in sublattice space, for a reason short enough to state, with a derived crossing past which additivity fails and a sigma_z coupling that breaks it smoothly. Every claim carries one of four grades: [T] proven here, [V] computationally verified with stated controls and a stated failure mode, [C] imported from the cited literature, [H] interpretation. The two exact lines, the commuting deformation, the boundary-locality of the entanglement spectrum, and the first law of entanglement entropy are not this work's and are used as given. Sixteen retired claims, including two withdrawn from earlier versions of this manuscript, are listed with the measurement that killed each. Files in this deposit: the_offset_belongs_to_the_boundary_v8_submission.pdf — 35 pages, gate output verbatim, script listings supplied separately. the_offset_belongs_to_the_boundary_v8_complete.pdf — 59 pages, identical body with all scripts printed inline. offset_v8_scripts.zip — 23 files. Every number quoted in the paper is printed by one of them; the two gate files reproduce their stored output byte for byte. KEYWORDS entanglement Hamiltonian; entanglement spectrum; modular Hamiltonian; Bisognano-Wichmann; Rice-Mele model; SSH model; free fermions; boundary charge; cut-phase charge; corner transfer matrix; Toeplitz operators; Wiener-Hopf factorisation; Szego-Widom asymptotics; algebraic Heun operator; complete elliptic integrals; entanglement first law; area law; Landau-Widom counting function ADDITIONAL NOTES Supersedes earlier versions of this manuscript. Two claims present in versions 1 to 3 are withdrawn and recorded in the kill list: that the incommensurate offset has no value, and that the offset is one quantum. Both were double-precision truncation of a finite sum. The u^6 coefficient of the shape function reported in the companion results ledger is likewise superseded by the derived value. Computational verification, gating and drafting assistance by an AI collaborator (Claude, Anthropic). Every gate is independently re-runnable from the ancillary scripts.
When a system of electrons is cut into a region and the rest, its correlation matrix has a cross block, X_A = C_AB C_BA: the weight between the two sides of the cut. This paper proves what that weight can and cannot say, and then studies where opened (non-Hermitian) matter leaves the disk of its occupation chart. The weight between. X_A is positive and never larger than 1/4. Both sides of the cut see the same positive spectrum. It is stable under small changes, with a certified count. It sits below the local defect C_A − C_A², and for a pure Gaussian (Slater) state, where C is an orthogonal projector, the two are equal. Four times its trace bounds the Gaussian mutual information across the cut from below, with a sharp constant, and there is no upper constant without a spectral margin. Exact examples show that a one-body record does not in general determine correlations outside the quasi-free class. The signed boundary offset τ = log det(I − C_A)/det C_A moves no faster than τ̇² ≤ 4gS, and two preparations with the same census, offset, cross weight and coupling saturate this bound in opposite directions. The exit line. On the PT-symmetric Su–Schrieffer–Heeger chain, the band-averaged Petermann factor equals 2 exactly on the line E(0)E(π) = u², equivalently (w² − v²)² = 2u²(w² + v²). Exits predicted from that line before the run match the measured census exits of finite blocks to about 5e-8 in these runs. A linearly weighted operator, T = ½{X + ½, H}, commutes entrywise with the half-chain correlation block; the proof uses only H(k)² = E(k)²I, so it holds without Hermiticity. At 200 sampled gapped parameter points, its tested low-index edge eigenvectors exhibit an equally spaced entanglement ladder ε_j = jΔ + iθ, with a spacing Δ = 2πK′/K taken from a Hermitian band hidden inside the opened one and a shared phase θ given by an elliptic (Abel) formula. For this proposed ladder, the paper proves that it crosses the rim of the disk all at once, and that its phase reaches a quarter turn exactly on the Petermann line, in both directions. The dimer limit is proved exactly. Plain finite blocks give a census rotation equal to the same phase to within 7e-7. An analytic derivation of the ladder for the coupled chain remains open, and the paper states it as open. Related numerical work on the same model (Rottoli, Fossati and Calabrese, 2024) is cited and compared. Every claim carries a grade (proved, Lean-checked algebraic subclaim, verified numerically, known result, or open), and every number comes from a script included in the archive, with the reference-run environment recorded. Files: the paper (PDF); a web edition (HTML) with an interactive view of the proposed ladder model; and a zip holding the LaTeX source, the Python scripts and their outputs, the figure, the Lean proofs, and a README mapping each Lean grade to its theorem. Prepared with AI assistance (Claude, Anthropic; and OpenAI tools for parts of the formal development); the ideas and research direction are the author's.
The Parity-Entanglement Bound (PEB) fixes the clock-system mutual information of a ℤ₂ constrained bipartite pure state at exactly two bits. We show that this invariant functions as the zero point of a metric geometry built from information. Six results are given. (i) The deviation Π = 1 - 1/2 I is the unique local-unitary (LU) invariant of the minimal state (pure, ℤ₂, bipartite); relaxing each hypothesis adds a definite number of further axes, which we count numerically (mixedness +1, ℤn+(n-2), tripartite +2; a continuous gauge group opens a continuous axis), (ii) The correlation quantity d = -ln κ is non-negative, symmetric, and vanishes in the coincidence limit; in the gapped regime, at separations above a floor r*(m), it obeys the triangle inequality and is a metric. (iii) The validity window is mapped: the floor r*(m) grows with the gap and the window closes entirely once the correlation length falls below the lattice scale (m ≥ 1.7 in 1D, ≥ 2 in 2D, lattice units); in the opposite, gapless limit the inequality survives with growing slack (0 violations atm m = 0.02) and an asymptotic argument establishes it analytically in the logarithmic regime. Non-Gaussianity per se does not damage the inequality: on a φ⁴ chain the observed violations are reproduced quantitatively by a free field of matched effective gap. (iv) Local noise acts on d as an exactly additive per-region dilation, d → d + δA + δB with δ ≥ 0; pure dephasing leaves d exactly invariant, and local noise can only increase the triangle slack, so the metric is noise-robust by construction. (v) The PEB value equals a combinatorial crossing number of stabiliser generators, hence is independent of system size, clock size, and clock position; it is formally analogous to a topological entanglement entropy. (vi) Following the Dirac-equation construction [6], the two-dimensionality dim ℋC = 2 underlies a distance/time split. The construction is verified by exact and Monte-Carlo simulation (geodesic locking 60/60 across five seeds; zero triangle violations above the floor in more than 1.6 × 10⁴ triples spanning gapped, near-critical, interacting, and noisy regimes) and, as a proof of concept, by a state-preparation study on quantum hardware (IBM FEZ). Formal correspondences to gravitational behaviour geodesic bending in a non-uniform gap and a volume-to-area transition in the crossing count are recorded in Sec. no gravitational derivation is claimed. Statements are labelled [P] proved, [K] known-with-citation, [N] numerical, or [0] open.
Jacobson's entanglement-equilibrium argument derives the Einstein equation from (i) an area law with finite Newton constant, (ii) a first law for the matter modular Hamiltonian, and (iii) stationarity of the vacuum entropy of small geodesic balls at fixed volume. We test these ingredients on a solvable family of network states: a pair sector whose entanglement encodes a Riemannian metric, combined with the Gaussian ground state of a scalar field on the same weighted graph, for which entropies and modular Hamiltonians of arbitrary regions are computed exactly. Every assumption is isolated as a hypothesis and classified as proved, derived, computed, or imposed by construction. (1) Derivation (conditional). The wave-packet quadratic form of the exact massless modular Hamiltonian of a ball, computed by Longo and Morsella, is identical to the bulk form K_bulk = 2π ∫ κ T_00^(min) + (2π ξ_c n / ℓ) ∫ φ^2 exhibited by the lattice data; the contact-term coefficient χ = 2π ξ_c and the response R = 1 + ξ_c n(n+2)/(ωℓ/c)^2 are identified, not fitted. The step from the continuum identity to the lattice is a modular-convergence statement (Conjecture C1) which we do not prove: a proved proposition on the non-analyticity of the entropy function at the band edge, together with a heuristic accumulation argument, shows why the spectral convergence of the matter sector does not imply it. The lattice data support C1: q_∞ = 1.02 ± 0.02 in n = 2 (up to 1.09 in n = 3 at the accessible radii ℓ ≤ 8). (2) Geometry (recovered, not emergent). The metric is imposed on the pair sector by construction; what is tested is the inverse map. An identifiability lemma shows the entropic distance matrix determines the manifold up to isometry; on S^2 the blind pipeline recovers the dimension (c_2 = 3.13 ≈ π), detects curvature through the negative tail of the MDS spectrum, and measures the curvature radius to 4%. (3) Causal structure (bounded, then computed). For the oscillator sector we prove a field-commutator cone bound with explicit constants, valid on arbitrary point sets, with cone velocity v_φ = 3.05 = 3.1 c_lat; the exact field commutator shows the physical front propagates at c_lat, with Lorentz violation controlled by β = γ(6,m)/16γ(4,m) = 0.384 as (kξ)^2. (4) Equilibrium. The equilibrium postulate is proved equivalent to the reconstructed metric having constant scalar curvature (Einstein only in n = 2); passivity supplies an exact constrained second-variation identity: at fixed geometry and fixed modular energy the vacuum is a local maximum of the generalised entropy along every constrained matter direction. The entropic flow whose fixed points are the equilibrium geometries is defined, not derived; in n = 2 it coincides with the normalised Ricci flow, whose convergence is Hamilton's theorem. (5) Spectral convergence (leading order, black box). For deterministic quasi-uniform sequences on curved manifolds the form-consistency step is proved explicitly, and eigenvalue convergence is obtained only conditionally by citing the graph discretisation of the Laplace–Beltrami operator as a black box. The curvature renormalisation of the speed of sound, c_eff^2 = c^2(1 - R_s γ(n+4,m)ξ^2 / 6n γ(n+2,m)), is verified on S^2 to 1%. For non-uniform random point sets the raw operator converges to a drift operator, and a blind density correction computed from entropic ball counts repairs it, recovering the manifold spectrum to within 0.2–2.3% plus a counting bias of order 1 / N̄_(r_b). All numbers are generated by the programs distributed with this work.
Overview: This paper develops the state-to-geometry interface of the OT–GKSL architecture for open quantum sources. Its starting point is a familiar low-energy tension: classical general relativity couples spacetime geometry to matter through the Einstein equations, whereas quantum matter may be open, coherent, correlated, preparation dependent, or subject to measurement and environmental records. Semiclassical gravity and stochastic-gravity approaches have long made clear that the relation between quantum sources and classical geometry is not conceptually trivial (Page & Geilker, 1981; Kuo & Ford, 1993; Hu & Verdaguer, 2008). The OT–GKSL architecture addresses this problem by not assuming classical spacetime as part of the native quantum state description. Instead, it separates a persistent quantum/open-state domain from later classical descendants. At the native level, states belong to a faithful finite-dimensional working stratum, ρ ∈ D°(H_eff), and evolve under a declared GKSL dynamics, dρξ/dξ = L*(ρξ). The completely positive Markovian structure follows the standard theory of Gorini, Kossakowski & Sudarshan (1976) and Lindblad (1976). On a faithful reversible detailed-balance component, the dissipative generator admits the noncommutative optimal-transport gradient representation developed in the quantum Markov setting by Carlen & Maas (2017): L*_db(ρ) = - grad_gOT D(ρ || π). Here g_OT is a positive state-space metric and D(ρ || π) = Tr[ρ(log ρ - log π)] is the relative entropy to a faithful stationary state π. The detailed-balance entropy production is σ_db(ρ) = ||grad_gOT D(ρ || π)||²_gOT ≥ 0. This identity concerns the detailed-balance dissipative component, not automatically the complete GKSL trajectory. If L* = L_coh + L_db + L*_rem, then the full relative-entropy balance retains the coherent and remainder contributions separately. The native evolution parameter ξ, the accumulated entropic ordering variable t_ent, and physical readout time t_ro are therefore distinct: ξ ≠ t_ent ≠ t_ro. A physical clock requires a stabilized and calibrated clock record. Its identification with the temporal sector of the Lorentzian spacetime readout requires the additional clock–coframe and proper-time compatibility conditions of the certified spacetime branch. From records to geometric readout: Classical geometry is not identified directly with the native OT geometry. The architecture first constructs physical records. Protocol-complete certified records determine event identity, while a separate geometric coarse-graining determines which event distinctions are used for localization. A 2 rank-D family then supplies local geometric coordinates. On the observed spacetime branch, D = 4. native states → certified physical records → event classes → geometric coarse-graining → rank-D coordinate records → horizontal readout sector → section and soldering →Lorentzian coframe → classical metricThe important distinction is complete event-record content ≠ rank-D coordinate content.Additional records may encode matter properties, preparation data, measurement outcomes, orientation, gauge information, clock information, or internal structure without becoming additional spacetime dimensions. On a regular geometric patch, the coordinate map defines a vertical sector and its OT-orthogonalhorizontal complement, V = ker DΠ_coord, H = V^(⊥ gOT). A local section selects native representatives and a calibrated soldering map transfers the readablehorizontal data to the physical frame bundle. The physical coframe e^a then defines g_ro = η_ab e^a ⊗ e^b, with η_ab = diag(-1,+1,+1,+1)on the observed Lorentzian branch. The positive metric g_OT and the Lorentzian metric g_ro are therefore different mathematical objects with different domains and physical roles. Lorentzian signature is not obtained by changing the signature of g_OT; it enters through the calibrated readout branch.This distinction is compatible with the broader operational idea that physical reference frames and records may themselves be quantum systems rather than external classical structures (Bartlett, Rudolph & Spekkens, 2007; Giacomini, Castro-Ruiz & Brukner, 2019), while the specific record-to-geometry ordering is a commitment of the OT-GKSL architecture Horizontal connection and holonomy bridge: A central result of the paper is the typed separation between native state-space geometry and readout geometry. Let ∇^OT denote the Levi-Civita connection of the applicable OT metric. The connection relevant for the geometric bridge is the projected connection on the horizontal bundle, ∇^H_X Y = P_H ∇^OT_X Y.Its curvature R^H is not generally the restriction of the ambient OT curvature R^OT. In particular, R^OT ≠ 0 does not by itself imply R^H ≠ 0.The readout bridge therefore transports the horizontal connection, rather than silently identifying ambient OT curvature with spacetime curvature. With a local section s and soldering map Ω, the transferred connection has the standard inhomogeneous transformation structure, Γ_B,s = Ω (s*Γ_H) Ω^(-1) - (dΩ) Ω^(-1).It may then be compared with the independently constructed readout connection. The corresponding bridge defect is controlled on the declared certified domain. For a fixed loop C, a connection-level defect gives a length-type transport estimate of Duhamel form. An area-type small-loop estimate requires the stronger input of curvature control, a suitable small contractible loop, and compatible gauge/trivialization data. The paper therefore distinguishes four statements: ambient OT curvature; horizontal curvature and holonomy; transferred/readout holonomy; detector-visible holonomic response. None is identified with the next without an explicit bridge or visibility condition.3. This separation is related conceptually to earlier geometric treatments of mixed-state parallel transport and quantum holonomy (Uhlmann, 1986; Andersson & Heydari, 2014), although the OT-GKSL horizontal/readout bridge is an architecture-specific construction. Finite holonomy and preparation sensitivity. The consolidated formulation distinguishes a nontrivial finite loop signal from its sensitivity to preparation. A finite holonomy may satisfy H(ρ*) ≠ I while nevertheless Dρ H(ρ*) = 0. Thus anontrivial background holonomy does not prove that the holonomy varies under the preparation tested by an experiment.Two operational observables are accordingly kept distinct.Y_H^fin = L_H^fin(H - I) is a finite-loop detector. A body-fixed or Maurer-Cartan response may instead use Ξ_H = L̂_H(H^(-1) ∇_prep H).These are distinct calibrated observables. They coincide only under an explicitly declared translation/calibration relation. Preparation differentiation must also be gauge controlled, by freezing a physical record-defined frame, differentiating a gauge-invariant functional, or using a covariant derivative.Source-side constitutive branch The source/matter descendant is constructed independently of the geometric descendant. Within the Dirac/HS-NJL working class considered in the paper, an internal operator Y defines the positive quadratic tracer κ_Y = Tr(Y†Y). A frozen calibration maps this quantity to an operational coordinate p_κ. The scalar source-side constitutive law is written μ = μ(p_κ), with local susceptibility β_μ(p_κ) = - ∂_(pκ) ln μ(p_κ). A certification gate may determine whether the working point remains admissible, but its derivative is not part of the physical constitutive susceptibility in the certified interior. The scalar constitutive channel and the holonomic channel are mathematically distinct and possess different experimental symmetry handles. Einstein lock: The observed gravitational branch is constrained by an Einstein lock. The two-derivative gravitational kinetic block is fixed to the Einstein-Hilbert form,S_EH[g_ro; G0] = (c³ / 16πG0) ∫ d⁴x sqrt(-g_ro) R[g_ro], with G0 = constant.This is a branch-selection and recovery condition of the OT-GKSL corpus. It is not claimed to be the unique consequence of GKSL dynamics alone. The architecture forbids a readable preparation-dependent factor multiplying the Einstein-Hilbert curvature term on the locked branch. State dependence is instead carried by independently specified source, response, gauge, interface, readout, or higher-order sectors. The gravitational comparison is performed only after geometry and source data have beenindependently fixed: 4 C_E = G_μν[g_ro] - κ0 T^eff_μν - Δ^if_μν. A gravitational claim requires the residual C_E to satisfy its declared norm and tolerance. TheBianchi identity acts as a compatibility condition on these already constructed sectors; it does not define the source after the fact. The branch-resolved Trilemma: The central result is a local and conditional separation theorem for the visible constitutive and holonomic branches. On a finite-dimensional admissible test sector, define the kinematic analysis using the unweighted source coordinate and the holonomic preparation response, h → (dp_κ[h], ζ_H[h]). The constitutive coefficient β_μ is applied only after this kinematic conditioning. Consequently, testing β_μ,* = 0 does not make the underlying analysis map singular by definition. For a normed visible output space, the declared first-order closure has the form DO_vis[h] = N_E(β_μ,* dp_κ[h]) + N_H(ζ_H[h]) + B_oth[h] + R_aud[h]. Here B_oth contains independently constructed visible branches not removed by the frozen protocol, and R_aud is the declared audit remainder. The factorization of the scalar constitutive term through β_μ is an explicit visible/source closure assumption; it is not derived solely from OT variational calculus. At a working point where β_μ,* = 0, if, for a tested variation h, ||N_H(ζ_H[h])|| > ||B_oth[h] + R_aud[h]||, then DO_vis[h] ≠ 0. The final implication follows from the reverse triangle inequality. The nontrivial content lies upstream: construction of the regular record/geometric quotien
Gravity from entropy (GfE) identifies its Lagrangian with the geometric quantum relative entropy (GQRE) between the spacetime metric and a metric induced by matter and curvature, treating the metric itself as a quantum operator. We extend this construction to the Tsallis, Rényi, and Sharma-Mittal families, which we call gravity from generalized entropy (GfGE), and determine their common Einstein limit, weak-field spectra, auxiliary-field formulation, and horizon entropy. The entropy choice controls the leading higher-curvature terms and additional modes. We confirm that the linearized GfE spectrum contains a healthy scalar and a Planck-scale tachyonic spin-2 ghost. We identify the conditions that remove this ghost: curvature must enter through its scalar trace, or the entropy generator must be flat to quadratic order at the identity. The latter gives exact general relativity for Tsallis at q=0q=0q=0 and ghost-free f(R,Lm)f(R,L_m)f(R,Lm​) theories for Rényi and Sharma-Mittal. On shell, the auxiliary G-field is proportional to the tensor in Wald's entropy formula. For analytic entropy functions, horizons with a single curvature scale have an area term followed by constant and inverse-area corrections. We also extend the volume-constraint cosmological constant to the full family; its leading entropy dependence is set by the scalar mass. A finite set of entropy-function derivatives controls the leading weak-curvature departures from general relativity.