arXiv:2610.19106
Gravity from generalized entropy
Hussain Gohar
Abstract
Gravity from entropy (GfE) identifies its Lagrangian with the geometric quantum relative entropy (GQRE) between the spacetime metric and a metric induced by matter and curvature, treating the metric itself as a quantum operator. We extend this construction to the Tsallis, Rényi, and Sharma-Mittal families, which we call gravity from generalized entropy (GfGE), and determine their common Einstein limit, weak-field spectra, auxiliary-field formulation, and horizon entropy. The entropy choice controls the leading higher-curvature terms and additional modes. We confirm that the linearized GfE spectrum contains a healthy scalar and a Planck-scale tachyonic spin-2 ghost. We identify the conditions that remove this ghost: curvature must enter through its scalar trace, or the entropy generator must be flat to quadratic order at the identity. The latter gives exact general relativity for Tsallis at $q=0$ and ghost-free $f(R,L_m)$ theories for Rényi and Sharma-Mittal. On shell, the auxiliary G-field is proportional to the tensor in Wald's entropy formula. For analytic entropy functions, horizons with a single curvature scale have an area term followed by constant and inverse-area corrections. We also extend the volume-constraint cosmological constant to the full family; its leading entropy dependence is set by the scalar mass. A finite set of entropy-function derivatives controls the leading weak-curvature departures from general relativity.
AI Summary
The paper asks which predictions of “gravity from entropy,” a local metric action built from a geometric relative-entropy functional, survive replacing the logarithm by Tsallis, Rényi, or Sharma–Mittal functions. It studies actions $\mathcal L=\Psi[-\mathrm{Tr}F(N)]$, where $N$ combines spacetime geometry, curvature, and Dirac–Kähler matter. Normalizing $F'(1)=\Psi'(0)=1$ preserves the Einstein–Hilbert term and leading matter coupling. A curvature expansion and linearized propagator analysis determine the Minkowski spectrum. For the original logarithmic theory, the calculation reproduces a healthy scalar with $m_0^2\simeq90M_P^2$ and a tachyonic spin-2 ghost with $m_2^2\simeq-181M_P^2$. With the original curvature blocks, Sharma–Mittal gives $m_2^2=-6/(5q\beta)$ and $m_0^2=33/[\beta(27r+28q)]$, with $\beta=G/(48\pi)$. For a common generator across form sectors, the massive spin-2 pole disappears only if curvature enters through its scalar trace or $F''(1)=0$. At $q=0$, Tsallis becomes exactly GR; Rényi and Sharma–Mittal reduce to scalar-tensor-type $f(R,\mathcal L_m)$ models. An algebraic auxiliary-field construction relates the G-field to the curvature derivative entering Wald entropy. Analyticity implies area, constant, and inverse-area horizon-entropy terms for single-curvature-scale horizons, rather than modified leading area powers. A volume constraint supplies a constant cosmological term; its leading entropy-dependent trace correction is controlled by the scalar mass. The results are primarily classical and perturbative. The paper leaves nonlinear Hamiltonian stability and Lorentzian spectral-domain questions open, and distinguishes treating Planck-scale extra poles as fundamental modes from removing them by effective-field-theory order reduction.
Error found: The q=0 Rényi and Sharma–Mittal theories are not unconditionally ghost-free with the allowed nonminimal matter coupling: a constant massless scalar on Minkowski space can make the graviton kinetic coefficient 3β−αξ|φ0|² negative while N=I. For nonzero ξ and matter, the Wald tensor has an additional contribution from the explicit curvature dependence of the matter operator, so the abstract's unqualified G-field identification and the displayed horizon formula require a restriction or correction. The claimed equality condition for the completed Tsallis divergence is false on the admitted non-diagonalizable Lorentzian domain, where a nonzero nilpotent perturbation N−I can give zero divergence.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 19 pages, 1 figure, 2 tables