Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

On the Interpretation of Quantum Physics: Energy Transfer Between Field and Matter According to the “Pairwise Interference Model” and a Quantum-Physical Measurement Problem

Wolfgang Tiefenbrunner

Published Jul 20, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In classical electrodynamic wave theory, the intensity of light is proportional to the square of the amplitude of the electric field; in quantum theory, according to the conventional interpretation, the probability of detecting a light particle (and hence, ultimately, the photon density) is given by the square of the probability amplitude (as prescribed by the Born rule, which itself lacks a deeper theoretical justification). A mathematical formulation equivalent to the path integral provides, within the framework of the Pairwise Interference Model (PIMOQ), an alternative interpretation that is mutually exclusive with the conventional one. According to this interpretation, quantum physics, within the scope considered here, describes the local (at the detector), intrinsically bidirectional, quantised energy transfer between field and matter (apart from quantisation this is in direct analogy with classical physics). In the case of constructive interference, this transfer is unidirectional, occurring exclusively from matter to the field, whereas in the case of destructive interference the two opposing energy fluxes are equal in magnitude. However, it appears that in the macroscopic world only the net balance of these two antagonistic and complementary fluxes is experimentally observable, whereas the individual contributions cannot be measured independently. This limitation is referred to here as a quantum-physical measurement problem. From this perspective, quantum physics constitutes a subdiscipline of thermodynamics with a correspondingly limited domain of applicability. Although the principle discussed is as fundamental as, for example, the principle of conservation of energy, this does not imply that the underlying physical processes must necessarily be identical in every situation in which the principle applies. This interpretation is further elaborated through a discussion of interference experiments employing coherent and incoherent light sources, as well as the generation of coherent light in the laser.

DOI
10.20944/preprints202607.1351.v1

Related papers

Some Fundamental Modifications to Einstein’s Model of the Absorption and Emission of Radiation by Matter

W. A. Tiefenbrunner

In 1916, A. Einstein developed a model of the absorption and emission of radiation from which he derived M. Planck’s radiation law. He postulated light-induced (stimulated) emission, because within the framework of classical physics an oscillator can, depending on the phase difference, both extract energy from the electromagnetic field and transfer energy to it. In a non-coherent field, α = β should hold, where α denotes the kinetic constant of absorption and β that of stimulated emission. This assumption is indispensable for deriving the radiation law from his model. In this context, it is problematic that a certain degree of field coherence follows necessarily from his model, which implies that α ≠ β. Moreover, the model cannot readily be generalised to fields of arbitrary coherence. An alternative model for the absorption and emission of radiation by matter is therefore developed here. On the one hand, it is based on the assumption that, within a blackbody, quanta of different energies may recombine freely; on the other hand, it employs the “pairwise interference model of quantum theory” (PIMOQ). The alternative model of the interaction between light and matter allows the radiation law to be derived for thermal equilibrium in a non-coherent field, under which conditions, according to the model, no stimulated emissions occur. It also describes the behaviour of systems with a coherent field (interference experiment, laser). Furthermore, considerations are presented regarding the energy distribution within a blackbody and the explanatory scope of A. Einstein’s model in this respect.

•Mar 12, 2026•1 citation

The ‘Pairwise Interference Model’ of Light–Matter Interaction and the Wave Properties of the Photon

Wolfgang Tiefenbrunner

Within the framework of the ‘Pairwise Interference Model’ of light–matter interaction, it is postulated that light particles follow definite trajectories, and thus, for example, in the double-slit experiment, a particle can pass through only one of the two slits. On this premise, the interference of two photons is examined in greater detail. It is hypothesized that the interference of a photon pair requires the involvement of matter and, initially, that both molecular excitations and photons oscillate at the same frequency and that the continuity of the oscillation is not disrupted by absorption and emission. The molecular excitations in the light source are supposed to oscillate synchronously. Both photons arrive at the same point on the detector but may travel along different paths and therefore arrive at different times. Under these conditions, their phase difference, φ(2) – φ(1), is always zero. Consequently, no interference pattern can form on the detector screen and therefore the assumptions made are incorrect. Alternatively, one may assume that only the photon oscillates, whereas the excitation stores the phase, φ, possessed by the photon at the instant of absorption. In this case, φ(2) – φ(1) corresponds to the difference in travel times modulo the oscillation period, and an interference pattern can form. However, this assumption is problematic for some reasons: the nature of the matter-based memory remains unclear; according to the special theory of relativity, no time elapses for a particle travelling at the speed of light, meaning that it cannot oscillate; and the assumption contradicts Bohr’s correspondence principle. In a classical wave, the phase information propagates away from the source at the wave velocity without changing. This leads to the alternative possibility that the excitations oscillate, whereas the photons do not. Instead, the photons transport information about the phase of the excitation at the instant of emission. As can be shown, in this case, φ(2) – φ(1) likewise corresponds to the difference in travel times modulo the oscillation period. However, this hypothesis contradicts the de Broglie postulate, according to which all particles exhibit wave properties, and the relation ε = hν must therefore be interpreted differently. It also raises the question of how the dimensions of a laser, specifically the mirror separation, can influence the wavelength of the amplified light if a photon has no wavelength. Using replicator dynamics and the ‘Pairwise Interference Model’ of light–matter interaction, a simulation demonstrates that, in a simplified laser model, assuming that photons do not oscillate whereas excitations do, self-organisation gives rise to a phase pattern in the sequence of photons within the emitted light beam that corresponds to the pattern obtained by discretising a classical wave. Thus, coherent light can exhibit wave properties even if photons themselves do not. Finally, the possibility of how incoherent light acquires wave properties is briefly discussed.

•Oct 22, 2026•0 citations

A Particle-Only Interpretation of the Double-Slit Experiment: Energy Waves in the Electromagnetic Field as a Guiding Mechanism

Paul Sammut

## AbstractA deterministic interpretation of the double-slit experiment is proposed, in which the electron is treated as a localized particle at all times. The observed interference pattern is attributed to a real physical energy wave in the electromagnetic field, generated by the electron's accelerated motion through the field. This energy wave reaches the slit barrier, where the slit geometry creates coherent waves that merge to form a constructive interference wave. This wave redistributes energy in the field, creating an Electron-EMF coupled pathway that guides the particle to the detector. The apparent randomness of individual impacts arises from incomplete knowledge of the initial conditions, not from intrinsic indeterminism. The measurement effect is modelled as a disturbance of the coherent energy waves, either preventing the formation of the coupled pathway or destroying it after formation. The model is extended to the quantum eraser experiment, where the restoration of coherence via a polarizer naturally explains the reappearance of interference. A further extension to the delayed-choice quantum eraser is proposed, introducing the Entangled Constructive Interference Wave (ECIW) as a physical mechanism for entanglement within the model. The mechanism is shown to apply across geometries beyond the double slit. Predictions include a correlation between landing position and flight time, offering a testable distinction from standard quantum mechanical interpretations. A preliminary, illustrative mathematical framework is provided, situating the model within the pilot-wave tradition. **Keywords: ** Double-slit experiment, pilot wave, electromagnetic field, quantum interpretation, determinism, hidden variables, measurement problem, energy wave, coupled pathway, quantum eraser, delayed-choice quantum eraser, entanglement.

•Jul 7, 2026•0 citations

The Monochromatic Resonator and the Interaction Between Light and Matter Under the Assumption That Photons Follow Classical Trajectories

W. Tiefenbrunner

According to R. Feynman 1963-1965 [10], the interference pattern that appears on the observation screen in the double-slit experiment with light cannot be explained by classical physics. The detection probability is supposed to result from the superposition of all paths that the photon can take from the source to the detector, the light quantum is self-interfering. However, Jin et al. 2010 [11] showed that this is not necessarily the case. In their computer simulation, they assumed that the trajectory of a photon corresponds to that of a classical particle. Thus, the interference only occurs at the detector with the participation of several photons. Not every photon causes a detection.Tiefenbrunner 2024 [17] investigated the detector further and recognized that particle interference under this and some other conditions presupposes a monochromatic resonator (all permissible energy levels are integer (ℕ0) multiples of a basal energy unit ε, where ε is also referred to as the ‘colour’ of the resonator). A monochromatic two-state system, e.g. a molecule that can only exist in two energetic states (ground and excited) and can only absorb one quantum (with respect to one ‘colour’), is, however, not sufficient for this. This prompted an evaluation of the significance of the monochromatic resonator for the Boltzmann-factor and Planck's radiation law. It turns out that the Boltzmann-factor and thus also the radiation law require resonators and hence are incompatible with two-state systems. The radiation law is derived using a kinetic model for the interaction of light with matter and without a priori use of the Boltzmann-factor, whereby it is also assumed that photons follow classical trajectories.

•Feb 20, 2025•3 citations

Some Insight Into the Outcome of Double-Slit-Experiments

Hasmukh K. Tank

The particle-interference-experiments, with the photons and electrons have clearly shown that they are always detected as localized ‘particles’; and the density of their detections exhibit a pattern similar to the interference of waves. This experimental-observation is alternatively interpreted here, different from the current, ‘probabilistic interpretation’. The ‘particle’ is first mathematically characterized as an ‘impulse function’ in space; and then Fourier-transformed into the wave-number-domain, as a wide band of constituent-waves as shown in the fig. 1&2. The ‘particle’ is an ‘event’ of constructive-superimposition of a wide band of ‘pre-quantum-waves’. This ‘event’ occurs in space at regular distances; and at regular instances in time. In the particle-interference-experiments, they are the wide band of ‘pre-quantum-waves which interfere physically. This physical interference of the pre-quantum-waves determines the position and time of emergence of the ‘impulse in space’ detectable as the ‘particle’. In the real-world-situation, the ‘pre-quantum-waves of a wide bandwidth arrive from all the directions, so the amplitude and phase of every constituent wave keep changing; so the place of constructive superimposition of all the spectral-components, keep varying unpredictably; and only the ‘probability’ of detection in a given volume is possible in practice. Thus, form the theoretical view-point, there are only the pre-quantum-waves; and ‘particle’ is a specific situation of constructive-superimposition of all the spectral-components of pre-quantum-waves; so there is no wave-particle-duality. The ‘probabilistic-interpretation’ is only a ‘practical-limitation’, detector being able to detect only the ‘particle’, and not the spectrum of constituent waves.

•Jan 1, 2014•0 citations

Interference in Quantum Mechanics, A Violation of the Law of Conservation of Energy

Thomas Alexander Meyer

All measurable phenomena in physics are irreducibly particle like and the wave picture of physical systems only arises when explaining a statistically relevant set of measurements of individual systems as an average. The wave picture arises in the effects of interference which can always be explained in the context of the state description of the interfering system, interference necessitates that the measurement outcomes be calculated by squaring the amplitudes after adding and non-interference is calculated by squaring before adding. Even though the calculation for each is independently valid, the change in the statistics when one modulates between interference and noninterference, as in the quantum eraser, requires a violation of the law of conservation of energy. There is no “driving force ” in the change of statistics. It is always a change in preparation that leads to the change of interference statistics, whilst in the calculation there is only a change in the state description. The irreducibly particle like nature of the quanta requires that there be a causal “driving force ” in the change in statistics and a mere change in description is an insufficient explanation by the standards of energy conservation. We present the argument that indeed this has already all been proven in the historic 1991 study of the ZWM papers of quantum coherence. Wave Particle Duality by Statistical Correspondence The first conceptual argument to arise in the history of quantum mechanics is that which questions how the

•May 1, 2013•0 citations
In classical electrodynamic wave theory, the intensity of light is proportional to the square of the amplitude of the electric field; in quantum theory, according to the conventional interpretation, the probability of detecting a light particle (and hence, ultimately, the photon density) is given by the square of the probability amplitude (as prescribed by the Born rule, which itself lacks a deeper theoretical justification). A mathematical formulation equivalent to the path integral provides, within the framework of the Pairwise Interference Model (PIMOQ), an alternative interpretation that is mutually exclusive with the conventional one. According to this interpretation, quantum physics, within the scope considered here, describes the local (at the detector), intrinsically bidirectional, quantised energy transfer between field and matter (apart from quantisation this is in direct analogy with classical physics). In the case of constructive interference, this transfer is unidirectional, occurring exclusively from matter to the field, whereas in the case of destructive interference the two opposing energy fluxes are equal in magnitude. However, it appears that in the macroscopic world only the net balance of these two antagonistic and complementary fluxes is experimentally observable, whereas the individual contributions cannot be measured independently. This limitation is referred to here as a quantum-physical measurement problem. From this perspective, quantum physics constitutes a subdiscipline of thermodynamics with a correspondingly limited domain of applicability. Although the principle discussed is as fundamental as, for example, the principle of conservation of energy, this does not imply that the underlying physical processes must necessarily be identical in every situation in which the principle applies. This interpretation is further elaborated through a discussion of interference experiments employing coherent and incoherent light sources, as well as the generation of coherent light in the laser.
In 1916, A. Einstein developed a model of the absorption and emission of radiation from which he derived M. Planck’s radiation law. He postulated light-induced (stimulated) emission, because within the framework of classical physics an oscillator can, depending on the phase difference, both extract energy from the electromagnetic field and transfer energy to it. In a non-coherent field, α = β should hold, where α denotes the kinetic constant of absorption and β that of stimulated emission. This assumption is indispensable for deriving the radiation law from his model. In this context, it is problematic that a certain degree of field coherence follows necessarily from his model, which implies that α ≠ β. Moreover, the model cannot readily be generalised to fields of arbitrary coherence. An alternative model for the absorption and emission of radiation by matter is therefore developed here. On the one hand, it is based on the assumption that, within a blackbody, quanta of different energies may recombine freely; on the other hand, it employs the “pairwise interference model of quantum theory” (PIMOQ). The alternative model of the interaction between light and matter allows the radiation law to be derived for thermal equilibrium in a non-coherent field, under which conditions, according to the model, no stimulated emissions occur. It also describes the behaviour of systems with a coherent field (interference experiment, laser). Furthermore, considerations are presented regarding the energy distribution within a blackbody and the explanatory scope of A. Einstein’s model in this respect.
Within the framework of the ‘Pairwise Interference Model’ of light–matter interaction, it is postulated that light particles follow definite trajectories, and thus, for example, in the double-slit experiment, a particle can pass through only one of the two slits. On this premise, the interference of two photons is examined in greater detail. It is hypothesized that the interference of a photon pair requires the involvement of matter and, initially, that both molecular excitations and photons oscillate at the same frequency and that the continuity of the oscillation is not disrupted by absorption and emission. The molecular excitations in the light source are supposed to oscillate synchronously. Both photons arrive at the same point on the detector but may travel along different paths and therefore arrive at different times. Under these conditions, their phase difference, φ(2) – φ(1), is always zero. Consequently, no interference pattern can form on the detector screen and therefore the assumptions made are incorrect. Alternatively, one may assume that only the photon oscillates, whereas the excitation stores the phase, φ, possessed by the photon at the instant of absorption. In this case, φ(2) – φ(1) corresponds to the difference in travel times modulo the oscillation period, and an interference pattern can form. However, this assumption is problematic for some reasons: the nature of the matter-based memory remains unclear; according to the special theory of relativity, no time elapses for a particle travelling at the speed of light, meaning that it cannot oscillate; and the assumption contradicts Bohr’s correspondence principle. In a classical wave, the phase information propagates away from the source at the wave velocity without changing. This leads to the alternative possibility that the excitations oscillate, whereas the photons do not. Instead, the photons transport information about the phase of the excitation at the instant of emission. As can be shown, in this case, φ(2) – φ(1) likewise corresponds to the difference in travel times modulo the oscillation period. However, this hypothesis contradicts the de Broglie postulate, according to which all particles exhibit wave properties, and the relation ε = hν must therefore be interpreted differently. It also raises the question of how the dimensions of a laser, specifically the mirror separation, can influence the wavelength of the amplified light if a photon has no wavelength. Using replicator dynamics and the ‘Pairwise Interference Model’ of light–matter interaction, a simulation demonstrates that, in a simplified laser model, assuming that photons do not oscillate whereas excitations do, self-organisation gives rise to a phase pattern in the sequence of photons within the emitted light beam that corresponds to the pattern obtained by discretising a classical wave. Thus, coherent light can exhibit wave properties even if photons themselves do not. Finally, the possibility of how incoherent light acquires wave properties is briefly discussed.
## AbstractA deterministic interpretation of the double-slit experiment is proposed, in which the electron is treated as a localized particle at all times. The observed interference pattern is attributed to a real physical energy wave in the electromagnetic field, generated by the electron's accelerated motion through the field. This energy wave reaches the slit barrier, where the slit geometry creates coherent waves that merge to form a constructive interference wave. This wave redistributes energy in the field, creating an Electron-EMF coupled pathway that guides the particle to the detector. The apparent randomness of individual impacts arises from incomplete knowledge of the initial conditions, not from intrinsic indeterminism. The measurement effect is modelled as a disturbance of the coherent energy waves, either preventing the formation of the coupled pathway or destroying it after formation. The model is extended to the quantum eraser experiment, where the restoration of coherence via a polarizer naturally explains the reappearance of interference. A further extension to the delayed-choice quantum eraser is proposed, introducing the Entangled Constructive Interference Wave (ECIW) as a physical mechanism for entanglement within the model. The mechanism is shown to apply across geometries beyond the double slit. Predictions include a correlation between landing position and flight time, offering a testable distinction from standard quantum mechanical interpretations. A preliminary, illustrative mathematical framework is provided, situating the model within the pilot-wave tradition. **Keywords: ** Double-slit experiment, pilot wave, electromagnetic field, quantum interpretation, determinism, hidden variables, measurement problem, energy wave, coupled pathway, quantum eraser, delayed-choice quantum eraser, entanglement.
According to R. Feynman 1963-1965 [10], the interference pattern that appears on the observation screen in the double-slit experiment with light cannot be explained by classical physics. The detection probability is supposed to result from the superposition of all paths that the photon can take from the source to the detector, the light quantum is self-interfering. However, Jin et al. 2010 [11] showed that this is not necessarily the case. In their computer simulation, they assumed that the trajectory of a photon corresponds to that of a classical particle. Thus, the interference only occurs at the detector with the participation of several photons. Not every photon causes a detection.Tiefenbrunner 2024 [17] investigated the detector further and recognized that particle interference under this and some other conditions presupposes a monochromatic resonator (all permissible energy levels are integer (ℕ0) multiples of a basal energy unit ε, where ε is also referred to as the ‘colour’ of the resonator). A monochromatic two-state system, e.g. a molecule that can only exist in two energetic states (ground and excited) and can only absorb one quantum (with respect to one ‘colour’), is, however, not sufficient for this. This prompted an evaluation of the significance of the monochromatic resonator for the Boltzmann-factor and Planck's radiation law. It turns out that the Boltzmann-factor and thus also the radiation law require resonators and hence are incompatible with two-state systems. The radiation law is derived using a kinetic model for the interaction of light with matter and without a priori use of the Boltzmann-factor, whereby it is also assumed that photons follow classical trajectories.
The particle-interference-experiments, with the photons and electrons have clearly shown that they are always detected as localized ‘particles’; and the density of their detections exhibit a pattern similar to the interference of waves. This experimental-observation is alternatively interpreted here, different from the current, ‘probabilistic interpretation’. The ‘particle’ is first mathematically characterized as an ‘impulse function’ in space; and then Fourier-transformed into the wave-number-domain, as a wide band of constituent-waves as shown in the fig. 1&2. The ‘particle’ is an ‘event’ of constructive-superimposition of a wide band of ‘pre-quantum-waves’. This ‘event’ occurs in space at regular distances; and at regular instances in time. In the particle-interference-experiments, they are the wide band of ‘pre-quantum-waves which interfere physically. This physical interference of the pre-quantum-waves determines the position and time of emergence of the ‘impulse in space’ detectable as the ‘particle’. In the real-world-situation, the ‘pre-quantum-waves of a wide bandwidth arrive from all the directions, so the amplitude and phase of every constituent wave keep changing; so the place of constructive superimposition of all the spectral-components, keep varying unpredictably; and only the ‘probability’ of detection in a given volume is possible in practice. Thus, form the theoretical view-point, there are only the pre-quantum-waves; and ‘particle’ is a specific situation of constructive-superimposition of all the spectral-components of pre-quantum-waves; so there is no wave-particle-duality. The ‘probabilistic-interpretation’ is only a ‘practical-limitation’, detector being able to detect only the ‘particle’, and not the spectrum of constituent waves.
All measurable phenomena in physics are irreducibly particle like and the wave picture of physical systems only arises when explaining a statistically relevant set of measurements of individual systems as an average. The wave picture arises in the effects of interference which can always be explained in the context of the state description of the interfering system, interference necessitates that the measurement outcomes be calculated by squaring the amplitudes after adding and non-interference is calculated by squaring before adding. Even though the calculation for each is independently valid, the change in the statistics when one modulates between interference and noninterference, as in the quantum eraser, requires a violation of the law of conservation of energy. There is no “driving force ” in the change of statistics. It is always a change in preparation that leads to the change of interference statistics, whilst in the calculation there is only a change in the state description. The irreducibly particle like nature of the quanta requires that there be a causal “driving force ” in the change in statistics and a mere change in description is an insufficient explanation by the standards of energy conservation. We present the argument that indeed this has already all been proven in the historic 1991 study of the ZWM papers of quantum coherence. Wave Particle Duality by Statistical Correspondence The first conceptual argument to arise in the history of quantum mechanics is that which questions how the