Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Beyond Dualism: The History of the Photon and the Relational Mathematics of Wave-Particle Duality

Yassin Tanan

Published Jul 13, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The centuries-old debate over the nature of light—from Newton’s corpuscles to Einstein’s quanta—has generated the paradox of wave-particle duality. This article demonstrates that such duality is an artifact of classical mathematical syntax (the symmetric equals sign). Through the Topological Grammar of Becoming, the photon is redefined as a thermodynamic process of coupling. By elevating the mathematical formalism to include noncommutative geometries and completely positive trace-preserving (CPTP) flows, Formal Lemmas are introduced to rigorously decode propagation as frictional resonance and interaction as informational saturation (Topological Jamming).

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.21337202

Related papers

Light Without Particles: Reassessing Wave–Particle Duality Through Field Geometry

Daniel Avilés Hurtado

For over a century, physics has taught that light is “both wave and particle,” with the photon elevated to a fundamental constituent of nature. This article revisits how thecorpuscular picture of light became dominant—from Newton and Huygens to Einstein’s photoelectric effect and Compton’s scattering—and argues that much of the alleged evidence for photons as “particles” can be reinterpreted more economically in a purely wave-based framework. We highlight a conceptual tension of twentieth-century quantum rhetoric: electrons and photons are routinely described as if they “knew” our experimental intentions, while any serious discussion of consciousness beyond humans is dismissed as unscientific. Building on a recently proposed geometric reinterpretation of the Compton effect—where the wavelength shift arises from field–structure coupling rather than particle–particle collisions—we show how the photoelectric effect and double-slit experiments can likewise be understood without attributing ontological particle status to light. Discreteness emerges not from light being made of corpuscles, but from quantized field modes and the event-like nature of charge in matter. The electromagnetic field remains a wave throughout; only matter clicks. This work integrates new conceptual insights, including two revealing paradoxes of the standard narrative and three implicit principles that guide our geometric reinterpretation, while preserving the full depth and detail of the original analysis.

•Mar 10, 2026•0 citations

BEYOND WAVE-PARTICLE DUALITY: AN ONTOLOGICAL DISTINCTION BETWEEN ENERGY AND INTERACTION

Ricardo de la Flor

Wave-particle duality has remained, for more than a century, an unresolved logical problem. Einstein transferred the contradiction into the concept of the photon; the orthodox interpretation deferred it as "complementarity." This article proposes an ontological reinterpretation: what moves as a particle is energy (concentrated at a point); what spreads and interferes is interaction (distributed in space). They are two distinct entities, not two aspects of the same entity. This distinction dissolves the ontological enigmas of duality — retrocausality, destructive interference, and superposition — without abandoning the confirmed equations of the quantum method. The collapse of measurement, following (Flor, 2026a), is dissolved as a characteristic of the probabilistic method. Under the demarcation framework of (Flor, 2026h), the classical formulation of duality violates the non-negotiable pillar of logical consistency; the proposed distinction restores it and occupies the legitimate antechamber of scientific speculation, awaiting the experimental test proposed in Section 10. The proposal connects to the field-medium model (Flor, 2026l), where c is a local property of the field resulting from interactions. The onset of interaction is not limited by c; only its peak is. This produces a falsifiable prediction and the honest acknowledgment that the proposal implies, in principle, the possibility of superluminal transmission of information. The article is programmatic: it dissolves the logical paradox, proposes an experimental test, and defers the quantitative reconstruction of the quantum formalism and the definition of the nature of light to future articles. A note on the originality of the distinction is included in the introduction.

•Oct 12, 2026•0 citations

A Causal Photon without Duality

Chandrasekhar Roychoudhuri

This chapter attempts to establish that a classical wave packet, using a specific shape in time and space, can bring the conceptual continuity between the divergent quantum-photon and classical-photon wave packet, while maintaining logical congruence between observed facts without asking nature to be non-causal, albeit statistical. It proposes a structure of the photon as a superexponential pulse that propagates by diffractively spreading, modeled precisely by the Huygens–resnel integral. Isaac Newton and Huygens gave birth to the concept of wave–corpuscular or modern wave–particle duality. The spell of wave–particle duality reemerged exactly a century after Young’s experiment, with the revolutionary success of Max Planck. While modeling the “thermalized” spontaneously emitted radiation inside a blackbody, S. N. Bose in 1924 was the first to recognize the need for a completely new statistical methodology of counting the states of photons if they are really indivisible quanta.

CRC Press eBooks•May 7, 2014•0 citations

Two Crucial Experiments on the Nature of Light: Beyond the Bounds of Wave-Particle Duality

Christian C. Emedolu, Cardinal Ihejirika, Basil Sunday Nnamdi

The wave-particle duality of light has been hanging over the clouds of science as an insuperable mystery. Debates have gone on for centuries as to which of the two aspects of light best represents the natural property of light. On the one hand, the particle theory of light camp made its own submissions a long time ago with many experimental demonstrations to confirm its position. On the other hand, the wave theory of light camp did organize or face some experiments to corroborate its own position. But then, a middle ground interpretation was shoveled-in by Niels Bohr during the second decade of the 20th Century. For him, the two aspects of light are complementary and Louis de Broglie popularized it, despite the halting beginnings of the complementarity Thesis. A double-slit experiment was, however, organized to show that light has these dual aspects. The central thesis of this paper is that though light exhibits these dual aspects, it is fundamentally a wave. The paper adopts the historiographical approach in navigating this lingering issue of the nature of light in the history of science.

AFRREV IJAH An International Journal of Arts and Humanities•Apr 28, 2020•2 citations

Resolving wave-particle duality could accelerate the mass production of quantum computers

Chandrasekhar Roychoudhuri, Narasimha S. Prasad

Quantum computers, hypothesized in 1980s, use concepts of superposition and entanglement phenomena. Although theoretical propositions and associated search algorithms for accurate measurements are being generated, the development of practical quantum computers themselves are advancing very slowly requiring enormous time and investments. The underlying concepts of a quantum computer are not new to the optical domain. However, the crucial enabling concepts of Entanglement and Superposition Principle are remaining clouded under the unresolved postulates, Wave-Particle Duality (WPD), and Wave Packet Reduction (WPR), implicating incompleteness in the interpretations of the mathematical formalism behind Quantum Mechanics. The WPD debate started during late1600 between Newton and Huygens. Young’s resolution of WPD through his double-slit experiment in 1802 was effectively overturned by Einstein’s interpretation of photoelectric effect as due to “indivisible light quanta”. However, Einstein disowned his “light quanta” postulate shortly before his death in1955, even though it had earned him the Nobel Prize. We resolve WPD by synthesizing Newton’s and Maxwell’s concepts and assume atoms do emit quanta but propagate as time-finite exponential pulses. This assumption also resolves WPR for light-matter interaction with the assumption that Schrodinger’s ψ represents atom’s internal dipolar amplitude stimulations. This over-turns Born’s interpretation that ψ only represents the abstract mathematical probability amplitude, rather than the physical “internal amplitude stimulation” of the quantum entity. However, our concept of atomic pulse emission forces us to re-derive the expression for the N-slit grating-spectrometer response since the classical derivation uses CW light, which does not exist. This pulsespectrometric response function strengthens our postulate since the grating response to the exponential pulse appears to be the convolution of a Lorentzian spectrum with the classical CW response function of the grating. The Fourier Transform of an exponential function is Lorentzian and QM predicts spontaneous emission line width to be Lorentzian. Then, conceptually one can extend the grating-expression (with N=2) to get the double-slit pattern. This approach preserves the classical causality that each of the two slits, like the N-signals out of a grating, are physically real and jointly stimulate the quantum detector array at the far field to generate the “Local” cosine fringes. The detector array executes the square modulus operation on its imposed dipolar amplitude stimulation and absorbs the necessary energy to fill up their quantum cups. Hence the double-slit pattern must also be “Local”, just as the N-slit grating spectrum is generated locally at the exit spectral-plane of the spectrometer. This removes the need to believe that “single photons” mysteriously generate the double slit pattern.

Quantum Computing, Communication, and Simulation•Mar 12, 2024•2 citations

On the Nature of the Photon

Barry Kieran Radcliffe

This paper presents a conceptual reinterpretation of the photon within the Relational Lens framework. While preserving the established mathematics of Maxwell's equations, Special Relativity, and Quantum Electrodynamics, it proposes that the photon is more naturally understood as a delocalized relational process bounded by localized emission and absorption interactions, rather than as a continuously localized object propagating through preexisting spacetime. This relational ontology provides a unified conceptual interpretation of wave-particle duality, interference, quantum measurement, entanglement, the null spacetime interval, and the roles of wavelength, frequency, and energy. The work is interpretive rather than mathematical, offering an alternative ontological perspective that remains fully consistent with established experimental physics while suggesting a broader relational foundation for the emergence of operational spacetime.

•Jul 22, 2026•0 citations
The centuries-old debate over the nature of light—from Newton’s corpuscles to Einstein’s quanta—has generated the paradox of wave-particle duality. This article demonstrates that such duality is an artifact of classical mathematical syntax (the symmetric equals sign). Through the Topological Grammar of Becoming, the photon is redefined as a thermodynamic process of coupling. By elevating the mathematical formalism to include noncommutative geometries and completely positive trace-preserving (CPTP) flows, Formal Lemmas are introduced to rigorously decode propagation as frictional resonance and interaction as informational saturation (Topological Jamming).
For over a century, physics has taught that light is “both wave and particle,” with the photon elevated to a fundamental constituent of nature. This article revisits how thecorpuscular picture of light became dominant—from Newton and Huygens to Einstein’s photoelectric effect and Compton’s scattering—and argues that much of the alleged evidence for photons as “particles” can be reinterpreted more economically in a purely wave-based framework. We highlight a conceptual tension of twentieth-century quantum rhetoric: electrons and photons are routinely described as if they “knew” our experimental intentions, while any serious discussion of consciousness beyond humans is dismissed as unscientific. Building on a recently proposed geometric reinterpretation of the Compton effect—where the wavelength shift arises from field–structure coupling rather than particle–particle collisions—we show how the photoelectric effect and double-slit experiments can likewise be understood without attributing ontological particle status to light. Discreteness emerges not from light being made of corpuscles, but from quantized field modes and the event-like nature of charge in matter. The electromagnetic field remains a wave throughout; only matter clicks. This work integrates new conceptual insights, including two revealing paradoxes of the standard narrative and three implicit principles that guide our geometric reinterpretation, while preserving the full depth and detail of the original analysis.
Wave-particle duality has remained, for more than a century, an unresolved logical problem. Einstein transferred the contradiction into the concept of the photon; the orthodox interpretation deferred it as "complementarity." This article proposes an ontological reinterpretation: what moves as a particle is energy (concentrated at a point); what spreads and interferes is interaction (distributed in space). They are two distinct entities, not two aspects of the same entity. This distinction dissolves the ontological enigmas of duality — retrocausality, destructive interference, and superposition — without abandoning the confirmed equations of the quantum method. The collapse of measurement, following (Flor, 2026a), is dissolved as a characteristic of the probabilistic method. Under the demarcation framework of (Flor, 2026h), the classical formulation of duality violates the non-negotiable pillar of logical consistency; the proposed distinction restores it and occupies the legitimate antechamber of scientific speculation, awaiting the experimental test proposed in Section 10. The proposal connects to the field-medium model (Flor, 2026l), where c is a local property of the field resulting from interactions. The onset of interaction is not limited by c; only its peak is. This produces a falsifiable prediction and the honest acknowledgment that the proposal implies, in principle, the possibility of superluminal transmission of information. The article is programmatic: it dissolves the logical paradox, proposes an experimental test, and defers the quantitative reconstruction of the quantum formalism and the definition of the nature of light to future articles. A note on the originality of the distinction is included in the introduction.
This chapter attempts to establish that a classical wave packet, using a specific shape in time and space, can bring the conceptual continuity between the divergent quantum-photon and classical-photon wave packet, while maintaining logical congruence between observed facts without asking nature to be non-causal, albeit statistical. It proposes a structure of the photon as a superexponential pulse that propagates by diffractively spreading, modeled precisely by the Huygens–resnel integral. Isaac Newton and Huygens gave birth to the concept of wave–corpuscular or modern wave–particle duality. The spell of wave–particle duality reemerged exactly a century after Young’s experiment, with the revolutionary success of Max Planck. While modeling the “thermalized” spontaneously emitted radiation inside a blackbody, S. N. Bose in 1924 was the first to recognize the need for a completely new statistical methodology of counting the states of photons if they are really indivisible quanta.
The wave-particle duality of light has been hanging over the clouds of science as an insuperable mystery. Debates have gone on for centuries as to which of the two aspects of light best represents the natural property of light. On the one hand, the particle theory of light camp made its own submissions a long time ago with many experimental demonstrations to confirm its position. On the other hand, the wave theory of light camp did organize or face some experiments to corroborate its own position. But then, a middle ground interpretation was shoveled-in by Niels Bohr during the second decade of the 20th Century. For him, the two aspects of light are complementary and Louis de Broglie popularized it, despite the halting beginnings of the complementarity Thesis. A double-slit experiment was, however, organized to show that light has these dual aspects. The central thesis of this paper is that though light exhibits these dual aspects, it is fundamentally a wave. The paper adopts the historiographical approach in navigating this lingering issue of the nature of light in the history of science.
Quantum computers, hypothesized in 1980s, use concepts of superposition and entanglement phenomena. Although theoretical propositions and associated search algorithms for accurate measurements are being generated, the development of practical quantum computers themselves are advancing very slowly requiring enormous time and investments. The underlying concepts of a quantum computer are not new to the optical domain. However, the crucial enabling concepts of Entanglement and Superposition Principle are remaining clouded under the unresolved postulates, Wave-Particle Duality (WPD), and Wave Packet Reduction (WPR), implicating incompleteness in the interpretations of the mathematical formalism behind Quantum Mechanics. The WPD debate started during late1600 between Newton and Huygens. Young’s resolution of WPD through his double-slit experiment in 1802 was effectively overturned by Einstein’s interpretation of photoelectric effect as due to “indivisible light quanta”. However, Einstein disowned his “light quanta” postulate shortly before his death in1955, even though it had earned him the Nobel Prize. We resolve WPD by synthesizing Newton’s and Maxwell’s concepts and assume atoms do emit quanta but propagate as time-finite exponential pulses. This assumption also resolves WPR for light-matter interaction with the assumption that Schrodinger’s ψ represents atom’s internal dipolar amplitude stimulations. This over-turns Born’s interpretation that ψ only represents the abstract mathematical probability amplitude, rather than the physical “internal amplitude stimulation” of the quantum entity. However, our concept of atomic pulse emission forces us to re-derive the expression for the N-slit grating-spectrometer response since the classical derivation uses CW light, which does not exist. This pulsespectrometric response function strengthens our postulate since the grating response to the exponential pulse appears to be the convolution of a Lorentzian spectrum with the classical CW response function of the grating. The Fourier Transform of an exponential function is Lorentzian and QM predicts spontaneous emission line width to be Lorentzian. Then, conceptually one can extend the grating-expression (with N=2) to get the double-slit pattern. This approach preserves the classical causality that each of the two slits, like the N-signals out of a grating, are physically real and jointly stimulate the quantum detector array at the far field to generate the “Local” cosine fringes. The detector array executes the square modulus operation on its imposed dipolar amplitude stimulation and absorbs the necessary energy to fill up their quantum cups. Hence the double-slit pattern must also be “Local”, just as the N-slit grating spectrum is generated locally at the exit spectral-plane of the spectrometer. This removes the need to believe that “single photons” mysteriously generate the double slit pattern.
This paper presents a conceptual reinterpretation of the photon within the Relational Lens framework. While preserving the established mathematics of Maxwell's equations, Special Relativity, and Quantum Electrodynamics, it proposes that the photon is more naturally understood as a delocalized relational process bounded by localized emission and absorption interactions, rather than as a continuously localized object propagating through preexisting spacetime. This relational ontology provides a unified conceptual interpretation of wave-particle duality, interference, quantum measurement, entanglement, the null spacetime interval, and the roles of wavelength, frequency, and energy. The work is interpretive rather than mathematical, offering an alternative ontological perspective that remains fully consistent with established experimental physics while suggesting a broader relational foundation for the emergence of operational spacetime.