Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Light Without Particles: Reassessing Wave–Particle Duality Through Field Geometry

Daniel Avilés Hurtado

Published Mar 10, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

For over a century, physics has taught that light is “both wave and particle,” with the photon elevated to a fundamental constituent of nature. This article revisits how thecorpuscular picture of light became dominant—from Newton and Huygens to Einstein’s photoelectric effect and Compton’s scattering—and argues that much of the alleged evidence for photons as “particles” can be reinterpreted more economically in a purely wave-based framework. We highlight a conceptual tension of twentieth-century quantum rhetoric: electrons and photons are routinely described as if they “knew” our experimental intentions, while any serious discussion of consciousness beyond humans is dismissed as unscientific. Building on a recently proposed geometric reinterpretation of the Compton effect—where the wavelength shift arises from field–structure coupling rather than particle–particle collisions—we show how the photoelectric effect and double-slit experiments can likewise be understood without attributing ontological particle status to light. Discreteness emerges not from light being made of corpuscles, but from quantized field modes and the event-like nature of charge in matter. The electromagnetic field remains a wave throughout; only matter clicks. This work integrates new conceptual insights, including two revealing paradoxes of the standard narrative and three implicit principles that guide our geometric reinterpretation, while preserving the full depth and detail of the original analysis.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.18930980

Related papers

Light Without Duality: A Semiclassical Model for Electrical Engineering Education

Jürgen Michael Grimm

AbstractWave–particle duality is often presented as an intrinsic property of light, a fundamental enigma of quantum mechanics that requires accepting light as both wave and particle depending on the experiment. This paper challenges that narrative by demonstrating that duality is not a law of nature but a didactic artifact — one that obscures a far simpler and more consistent physical reality. Light behaves as a classical electromagnetic wave, while the discreteness observed in interactions arises exclusively from the quantised nature of matter, not the field itself. The semiclassical model, in which a classical electromagnetic field interacts with quantised detectors, fully explains all optoelectronic phenomena relevant to electrical engineering, from the photoelectric effect to the behavior of CMOS sensors, without ever invoking the concept of light as a particle. Historical and experimental evidence supports this view: Fowler’s 1931 measurements revealed that the photoelectric threshold smears at temperatures above absolute zero due to the Fermi–Dirac statistics of electrons in metals, not because of any quantisation of light. Hübel’s 1987 school experiments confirmed these findings in an accessible educational setting, while Herrmann’s 1994 framework demonstrated that the external photoelectric effect can be described as a three-step process — penetration depth of radiation, escape depth of electrons, and the work function — none of which require the existence of photons. A simple and inexpensive experiment, costing around 150 euros and fitting on a kitchen table, illustrates this clearly: a laser pointer, a precision double slit, and a lensless digital camera separate the three phases of the process — emission as a quantised matter process, propagation as a classical Maxwell wave, and detection through the band structure of the silicon sensor. The only limitation of this model, second-order intensity correlations, lies far beyond the scope of typical electrical engineering applications. In conclusion, for electrical engineers, the photon is best understood as a finite electromagnetic wave train. The discreteness of interaction with matter does not originate from the wave train but from the matter itself. This paper argues for replacing the duality narrative with a semiclassical model that is physically precise, didactically clearer, and professionally essential for understanding modern optoelectronics.

•Jul 1, 2026•0 citations

The Origin of the "Particle Nature" of Light — How a Continuous Transverse Wave Manifests Discrete Behavior when Coupled to Matter

卓冰 蒋

Quantum field theory describes the particle nature of electromagnetic radiation using the "photon," but has never explained why a fundamental particle exhibits such perfect wave behavior. This paper provides a complete alternative explanation: the photoelectric effect, Compton scattering, and antibunching experiments — landmark experiments considered proof of photon particle nature — require no photon concept. Quantization is not a property of light itself, but of the discrete energy level structure governing how bound electrons emit and absorb energy. Light remains a continuous transverse wave; discreteness results from electrons as "prisoners" in atomic "cages" that can only transition between specific energy steps. Waves propagate continuously and are emitted and absorbed in quantized form — the photon is not a particle, but the name of an energy-exchange event.

•Jun 18, 2026•0 citations

Are there photons in fact?

Sergey A. Rashkovskiy

There are two opposing points of view on the nature of light: the first one manifests the wave-particle duality as a fundamental property of the nature; the second one claims that photons do not exist and the light is a continuous classical wave, while the so-called “quantum” properties of this field appear only as a result of its interaction with matter. In this paper we show that many quantum phenomena which are traditionally described by quantum electrodynamics can be described if light is considered within the limits of classical electrodynamics without quantization of radiation. These phenomena include the double-slit experiment, the photoelectric effect, the Compton effect, the Hanbury Brown and Twiss effect, the so-called multiphoton ionisation of atoms, etc. We show that this point of view allows also explaining the “wave-particle duality” of light in Wiener experiments with standing waves. We show that the Born rule for light can easily be derived from Fermi’s golden rule as an approximation for low-intense light or for short exposure time. We show that the Heisenberg uncertainty principle for “photons” has a simple classical sense and cannot be considered as a fundamental limitation of accuracy of simultaneous measurements of position and momentum or time and energy. We conclude that the concept of a “photon” is superfluous in explanation of light-matter interactions.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Sep 10, 2015•13 citations

Reinterpreting the Compton Effect: A Geometric Explanation Without Particles

Daniel Avilés Hurtado

The Compton effect is conventionally represented as a collision between a photon and an electron, with the observed wavelength shift determined by energy--momentum conservation and scattering geometry. This article revisits the event from a complementary perspective. Beginning from the experimental relation itself and from the wave side of wave--particle duality, we explore the Compton encounter as a finite dynamical process involving geometry, response, coupling, reorganization, and characteristic times. Two heuristic encounters guide the analysis. A stone striking a responsive surface foregrounds deformation, resistance, and relaxation, while a gravitational assist foregrounds trajectory and path-dependent exchange. These perspectives are then returned to a vortical reading of the electron and electromagnetic radiation. We distinguish an interaction time \(\tau_{\rm int}\) from a relaxation time \(\tau_{\rm relax}\), introduce the provisional ratio \(\mathcal R_{\tau}=\tau_{\rm int}/\tau_{\rm relax}\), and organize geometry, energetic cost, and coupling into a dynamical grammar of the encounter. The comparison is then extended to the photoelectric effect. Placing the naked experimental features of both phenomena side by side reveals a common radiation--matter interaction structure together with different accessible outcomes. This motivates the speculative possibility that Compton scattering and photoelectric emission occupy neighbouring regimes within a broader landscape of radiation--matter encounters. A provisional quantity, \(R_{\rm avail}\), is introduced as a possible measure of the capacity of an electronic structure and its local environment to accommodate and redistribute an incoming perturbation within a given regime. The article therefore proposes an enlargement of the Compton problem: from reproducing the observed scattering relation to investigating the physical dynamics that may connect distinct radiation--matter outcomes.

•Jan 9, 2026•0 citations

A QED-compatible wave theory of light, electrons, and their interactions

Henry H. Lindner

The photoelectric effect, the Compton effects, and now anticorrelation experiments have been claimed to prove that light consists of particles flying through a void. However the particle model is decisively falsified by the known wave qualities of electromagnetic radiation. Quantum Electrodynamics also uses spreading wave amplitudes; not flying particles. The evidence indicates that light is a wave and electrons are electromagnetic wave-structures that absorb and emit light in discrete wave-packets. These wave-quanta are emitted directionally and then spread in space in proportion to their wavelength. Their waves superposition with all other waves in space. In low intensity experiments, the waves that an electron in a photodetector absorbs come from the superpositioning of the source wave-quanta and background radiation. The importance of background radiation is evidenced by "dark counts". Treating electrons and the quanta they absorb and emit as particles when they are composed of waves is the source of all the paradoxes, unreality and confusion in Quantum Mechanics. The word "photon" should be replaced by "quantum" in the description of this particular electronic process. The conceptual model presented here explains the known phenomena without producing paradoxes and unifies quantum and classical electromagnetics.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Sep 8, 2011•1 citation

Recent Developments in Quantum Mechanics

E. U. Condon

The fundamental fact for quantum physics which has emerged from experimental investigations in the field is a double duality of wave and particle concepts. The wave theory of light, firmly grounded by the wave explanations of interference and diffraction and by Maxwell’s electromagnetic theory of light waves, is now recognized as giving but one aspect of the nature of radiation. The corpusclar aspect of radiation is revealed in the photoelectric effect and in the Compton effect. In these effects Planck’s constant appears as a universal constant which connects the wave and particle modes of description of the same radiation.

Science•Aug 31, 1928•1 citation
For over a century, physics has taught that light is “both wave and particle,” with the photon elevated to a fundamental constituent of nature. This article revisits how thecorpuscular picture of light became dominant—from Newton and Huygens to Einstein’s photoelectric effect and Compton’s scattering—and argues that much of the alleged evidence for photons as “particles” can be reinterpreted more economically in a purely wave-based framework. We highlight a conceptual tension of twentieth-century quantum rhetoric: electrons and photons are routinely described as if they “knew” our experimental intentions, while any serious discussion of consciousness beyond humans is dismissed as unscientific. Building on a recently proposed geometric reinterpretation of the Compton effect—where the wavelength shift arises from field–structure coupling rather than particle–particle collisions—we show how the photoelectric effect and double-slit experiments can likewise be understood without attributing ontological particle status to light. Discreteness emerges not from light being made of corpuscles, but from quantized field modes and the event-like nature of charge in matter. The electromagnetic field remains a wave throughout; only matter clicks. This work integrates new conceptual insights, including two revealing paradoxes of the standard narrative and three implicit principles that guide our geometric reinterpretation, while preserving the full depth and detail of the original analysis.
AbstractWave–particle duality is often presented as an intrinsic property of light, a fundamental enigma of quantum mechanics that requires accepting light as both wave and particle depending on the experiment. This paper challenges that narrative by demonstrating that duality is not a law of nature but a didactic artifact — one that obscures a far simpler and more consistent physical reality. Light behaves as a classical electromagnetic wave, while the discreteness observed in interactions arises exclusively from the quantised nature of matter, not the field itself. The semiclassical model, in which a classical electromagnetic field interacts with quantised detectors, fully explains all optoelectronic phenomena relevant to electrical engineering, from the photoelectric effect to the behavior of CMOS sensors, without ever invoking the concept of light as a particle. Historical and experimental evidence supports this view: Fowler’s 1931 measurements revealed that the photoelectric threshold smears at temperatures above absolute zero due to the Fermi–Dirac statistics of electrons in metals, not because of any quantisation of light. Hübel’s 1987 school experiments confirmed these findings in an accessible educational setting, while Herrmann’s 1994 framework demonstrated that the external photoelectric effect can be described as a three-step process — penetration depth of radiation, escape depth of electrons, and the work function — none of which require the existence of photons. A simple and inexpensive experiment, costing around 150 euros and fitting on a kitchen table, illustrates this clearly: a laser pointer, a precision double slit, and a lensless digital camera separate the three phases of the process — emission as a quantised matter process, propagation as a classical Maxwell wave, and detection through the band structure of the silicon sensor. The only limitation of this model, second-order intensity correlations, lies far beyond the scope of typical electrical engineering applications. In conclusion, for electrical engineers, the photon is best understood as a finite electromagnetic wave train. The discreteness of interaction with matter does not originate from the wave train but from the matter itself. This paper argues for replacing the duality narrative with a semiclassical model that is physically precise, didactically clearer, and professionally essential for understanding modern optoelectronics.
Quantum field theory describes the particle nature of electromagnetic radiation using the "photon," but has never explained why a fundamental particle exhibits such perfect wave behavior. This paper provides a complete alternative explanation: the photoelectric effect, Compton scattering, and antibunching experiments — landmark experiments considered proof of photon particle nature — require no photon concept. Quantization is not a property of light itself, but of the discrete energy level structure governing how bound electrons emit and absorb energy. Light remains a continuous transverse wave; discreteness results from electrons as "prisoners" in atomic "cages" that can only transition between specific energy steps. Waves propagate continuously and are emitted and absorbed in quantized form — the photon is not a particle, but the name of an energy-exchange event.
There are two opposing points of view on the nature of light: the first one manifests the wave-particle duality as a fundamental property of the nature; the second one claims that photons do not exist and the light is a continuous classical wave, while the so-called “quantum” properties of this field appear only as a result of its interaction with matter. In this paper we show that many quantum phenomena which are traditionally described by quantum electrodynamics can be described if light is considered within the limits of classical electrodynamics without quantization of radiation. These phenomena include the double-slit experiment, the photoelectric effect, the Compton effect, the Hanbury Brown and Twiss effect, the so-called multiphoton ionisation of atoms, etc. We show that this point of view allows also explaining the “wave-particle duality” of light in Wiener experiments with standing waves. We show that the Born rule for light can easily be derived from Fermi’s golden rule as an approximation for low-intense light or for short exposure time. We show that the Heisenberg uncertainty principle for “photons” has a simple classical sense and cannot be considered as a fundamental limitation of accuracy of simultaneous measurements of position and momentum or time and energy. We conclude that the concept of a “photon” is superfluous in explanation of light-matter interactions.
The Compton effect is conventionally represented as a collision between a photon and an electron, with the observed wavelength shift determined by energy--momentum conservation and scattering geometry. This article revisits the event from a complementary perspective. Beginning from the experimental relation itself and from the wave side of wave--particle duality, we explore the Compton encounter as a finite dynamical process involving geometry, response, coupling, reorganization, and characteristic times. Two heuristic encounters guide the analysis. A stone striking a responsive surface foregrounds deformation, resistance, and relaxation, while a gravitational assist foregrounds trajectory and path-dependent exchange. These perspectives are then returned to a vortical reading of the electron and electromagnetic radiation. We distinguish an interaction time τint\tau_{\rm int}τint​ from a relaxation time τrelax\tau_{\rm relax}τrelax​, introduce the provisional ratio Rτ=τint/τrelax\mathcal R_{\tau}=\tau_{\rm int}/\tau_{\rm relax}Rτ​=τint​/τrelax​, and organize geometry, energetic cost, and coupling into a dynamical grammar of the encounter. The comparison is then extended to the photoelectric effect. Placing the naked experimental features of both phenomena side by side reveals a common radiation--matter interaction structure together with different accessible outcomes. This motivates the speculative possibility that Compton scattering and photoelectric emission occupy neighbouring regimes within a broader landscape of radiation--matter encounters. A provisional quantity, RavailR_{\rm avail}Ravail​, is introduced as a possible measure of the capacity of an electronic structure and its local environment to accommodate and redistribute an incoming perturbation within a given regime. The article therefore proposes an enlargement of the Compton problem: from reproducing the observed scattering relation to investigating the physical dynamics that may connect distinct radiation--matter outcomes.
The photoelectric effect, the Compton effects, and now anticorrelation experiments have been claimed to prove that light consists of particles flying through a void. However the particle model is decisively falsified by the known wave qualities of electromagnetic radiation. Quantum Electrodynamics also uses spreading wave amplitudes; not flying particles. The evidence indicates that light is a wave and electrons are electromagnetic wave-structures that absorb and emit light in discrete wave-packets. These wave-quanta are emitted directionally and then spread in space in proportion to their wavelength. Their waves superposition with all other waves in space. In low intensity experiments, the waves that an electron in a photodetector absorbs come from the superpositioning of the source wave-quanta and background radiation. The importance of background radiation is evidenced by "dark counts". Treating electrons and the quanta they absorb and emit as particles when they are composed of waves is the source of all the paradoxes, unreality and confusion in Quantum Mechanics. The word "photon" should be replaced by "quantum" in the description of this particular electronic process. The conceptual model presented here explains the known phenomena without producing paradoxes and unifies quantum and classical electromagnetics.
The fundamental fact for quantum physics which has emerged from experimental investigations in the field is a double duality of wave and particle concepts. The wave theory of light, firmly grounded by the wave explanations of interference and diffraction and by Maxwell’s electromagnetic theory of light waves, is now recognized as giving but one aspect of the nature of radiation. The corpusclar aspect of radiation is revealed in the photoelectric effect and in the Compton effect. In these effects Planck’s constant appears as a universal constant which connects the wave and particle modes of description of the same radiation.