Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

IEEE Conference on Computer Communications (INFOCOM)

Security Analysis of BB84 and E91 QKD Protocols Using Unified Security Framework

Kanwalinderjit Kaur, Pablo Rodriguez Quinonez

Published May 18, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

This work presents a rigorous comparison of BB84 and E91 quantum key distribution protocols using modern composable security analysis and realistic hardware modeling. The framework implements sophisticated collective/coherent attack settings in the model and finite-key security bounds suitable for practical implementations. Under identical hardware assumptions (70% detector efficiency, 0.2 dB/km fiber attenuation, SPAD detectors) and equal quantum resources (5000 events per trial), BB84 with decoy states achieves significantly higher key rates than E91 (16.75% vs 1.39% mean rate, p−8, Cohen’s d = 0.890). At practical distances, BB84 generates 5.7× more keys at 1 km and 102× more at 10 km. Both protocols remain vulnerable to detector blinding attacks, highlighting the critical importance of implementation security. The unified comparative framework eliminates confounding variables through identical experimental conditions across multiple attack scenarios and transmission distances, enabling robust protocol evaluation. The analysis provides practical insights for QKD system deployment through bootstrap confidence intervals, effect size analysis, and Benjamini-Hochberg correction.

DOI
10.1109/infocom59046.2026.11571723

Related papers

Security Bounds for Efficient Decoy-State Quantum Key Distribution

Marco Lucamarini, J. F. Dynes, Bernd Fröhlich +2 more

Information-theoretical security of quantum key distribution (QKD) has been convincingly proven in recent years and remarkable experiments have shown the potential of QKD for real-world applications. Due to its unique capability of combining high key rate and security in a realistic finite-size scenario, the efficient version of the BB84 QKD protocol endowed with decoy states has been subject of intensive research. Its recent experimental implementation finally demonstrated a secure key rate beyond 1 Mb/s over a 50 km of optical fiber. However, the achieved rate holds under the restrictive assumption that the eavesdropper performs collective attacks. Here, we review the protocol and generalize its security. We exploit a map by Ahrens to rigorously upper bound the hypergeometric distribution resulting from a general eavesdropping. Despite the extended applicability of the new protocol, its key rate is only marginally smaller than its predecessor in all cases of practical interest.

arXiv:1503.07335•IEEE Journal of Selected Topics in Quantum Electronics•Jan 26, 2015•34 citations

Composable Security and Finite-Key Analysis ofMulti-Basis BB84 and Phase-Engineered E91Protocols Under Noisy Quantum Channels

Monelli Ayyavaraiah, Katari Balakrishna, Swathi M +4 more

Abstract Purpose : Practical quantum key distribution (QKD) deployments remain constrainedby finite-key effects, hardware noise, and limited adversarial attackmodeling. This work aims to close the gap between theoretical composable securityguarantees and realistic hardware performance by developing noise-resilient,multi-basis QKD protocols with provable finite-key security bounds. Methods : A generalized multi-basis BB84 protocol (MB-BB84) and a phaseengineeredE91 entanglement-based scheme (PE-E91) are developed with composablesecurity guarantees under depolarizing and amplitude-damping noisechannels. Finite-key security bounds are derived using the smooth min-entropyframework. Zero-noise extrapolation (ZNE) error mitigation is integrated intothe composable security analysis. Experimental validation is performed usinghardware-calibrated noise models derived from superconducting quantum processors. Results : The 3-basis MB-BB84 achieves a composable finite-key rate 7.4%higher than standard BB84 at a block size of one million signals, while increasingintercept-resend eavesdropper detection probability from 75.0% to 83.3%.PE-E91 improves the CHSH Bell parameter by 4.2% over standard E91. ZNE mitigationextends the practical security threshold by 30–40% in terms of maximumtolerable gate error rate on superconducting hardware. All analytical predictionsare confirmed within 3–5% of semidefinite-programming-computed key ratebounds. Conclusion : The proposed unified framework bridges theoretical composablesecurity and practical hardware constraints, providing explicit design guidelinesfor scalable, noise-resilient QKD architectures suitable for next-generationquantum communication networks.

•Sep 17, 2026•0 citations

Comparison of error-rate between BB84 and E91 QKD protocol

Vani Jayasri Geddada, Prof. P.V. Lakshmi

This paper focuses on the implementation and comparative analysis of two widely studied QKD protocols. The BB84 and E91 protocols are security measures that were devised back in the 1980s and 90s by experts like Charles Bennett and Ekaterina S. Ekert. This paper demonstrates with Qiskit protocol implementation documentation and simulation results together with extensive security analysis how BB84 and E91 protocols can be utilized through an open-source quantum computing framework developed by IBM. This paper aims to examine the BB84 and E91 protocol resistance to eavesdropping invasions while testing their performance across different communication ranges. We utilize quantum superposition to encode information into qubits during BB84 protocol implementation which allows us to simulate an intercept-resend attack to determine its vulnerability. Research shows that BB84 provides simpler execution yet suffers from more eavesdropping attacks especially at extended distances through increased error rates from interception methods. E91 protocol achieves detection of eavesdropping by distributing entangled qubits between two parties so measurements of those qubits reveal tampering through their outcome correlations. Our experimental findings confirm that E91 delivers enhanced security capabilities through its ability to keep errors minimal across longer distances thus demonstrating resistance against distance-related threats. The comparative analysis underscores the strengths and limitations of each protocol. BB84, despite its simplicity and ease of implementation, shows diminished security over longer distances. E91, which uses the non-local properties of entangled qubits, offers enhanced protection for long-distance communication, making it a more practical choice for robust QKD systems.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Adaptive BB84 Quantum Key Distribution Framework: A Comprehensive Implementation and Analysis Platform

Momin Shiraz Shafi, Vivek Parashar Pandey, Momin Rayyan +3 more

With the rapid development of quantum computing, traditional encryption techniques are expected to face serious security challenges in the near future. By depending on the principles of quantum physics rather than computing complexity, Quantum Key Distribution (QKD), and specifically the BB84 protocol, provides a radically new method of secure communication. In this project, an adaptive BB84-based framework is implemented and analyzed under realistic conditions, including channel noise and multiple eavesdropping strategies. The system integrates error correction, privacy amplification, finite-key analysis, and decoy-state mechanisms to reflect practical deployment scenarios. Three major attack models—intercept-resend, photon number splitting, and Trojan horse—are simulated to evaluate protocol robustness. The experimental results show that during normal communication the average Quantum Bit Error Rate (QBER) remains close to 3–4%, whereas the presence of active eavesdropping increases the QBER beyond the commonly accepted 11% threshold, resulting in protocol termination. Additional statistical testing under varying noise conditions confirms stable secret key generation and reliable detection of malicious interference. Overall, the proposed framework serves as a comprehensive simulation platform for studying the security behavior of BB84 in controlled experimental environments.

IEEE International Conference on Advances in Computing Research on Science Engineering and Technology (ACROSET)•Sep 1, 2026•0 citations

Security and Efficiency of Quantum Key Distribution Protocols: A Comprehensive Review

Saanvi Grover

Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) protocols offer a revolutionary approach to secure communication, leveraging the principles of quantum mechanics to enable theoretically unbreakable encryption. This comprehensive review examines the security and efficiency of various QKD protocols, including BB84, E91, and Continuous Variable QKD. We analyze the fundamental principles underpinning these protocols, their implementation challenges, and the practical considerations for real-world deployment. Special emphasis is placed on the security proofs of QKD, addressing potential vulnerabilities such as photon number splitting attacks and detector blinding attacks. Additionally, we explore the efficiency of QKD systems in terms of key generation rates, distance limitations, and integration with existing communication infrastructures. Recent advancements in QKD technology, including satellite-based QKD and quantum repeaters, are also discussed. Our findings highlight the critical role of QKD in future-proofing communication security and the ongoing efforts to enhance its practicality and scalability. This review aims to provide a detailed understanding of the current state of QKD protocols, offering insights into their potential to transform secure communications in the quantum era.

Journal of Quantum Science and Technology.•Jul 2, 2024•3 citations

Quantum Key Distribution Protocols: Security Analysis and Real-World Implementations

Murali Krishna Pasupuleti

Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) has emerged as a critical component of secure communication in the post-quantum era. This study provides a comparative security and performance analysis of leading QKD protocols—BB84, E91, and Continuous Variable QKD—using experimental and simulated data from terrestrial and satellite-based implementations. Key metrics such as secret key rate, bit error rate, and resistance to quantum attacks are analyzed. Regression and predictive modeling are used to quantify performance decay over distance and noise. The results indicate BB84's robustness and broad applicability, while CV-QKD offers throughput advantages in short-range networks. Keywords: Quantum Key Distribution, QKD, BB84, E91, Continuous Variable QKD, Cryptographic Security, Quantum Communication, Post-Quantum Security

International Journal of Academic and Industrial Research Innovations(IJAIRI)•Jun 27, 2025•1 citation
This work presents a rigorous comparison of BB84 and E91 quantum key distribution protocols using modern composable security analysis and realistic hardware modeling. The framework implements sophisticated collective/coherent attack settings in the model and finite-key security bounds suitable for practical implementations. Under identical hardware assumptions (70% detector efficiency, 0.2 dB/km fiber attenuation, SPAD detectors) and equal quantum resources (5000 events per trial), BB84 with decoy states achieves significantly higher key rates than E91 (16.75% vs 1.39% mean rate, p−8, Cohen’s d = 0.890). At practical distances, BB84 generates 5.7× more keys at 1 km and 102× more at 10 km. Both protocols remain vulnerable to detector blinding attacks, highlighting the critical importance of implementation security. The unified comparative framework eliminates confounding variables through identical experimental conditions across multiple attack scenarios and transmission distances, enabling robust protocol evaluation. The analysis provides practical insights for QKD system deployment through bootstrap confidence intervals, effect size analysis, and Benjamini-Hochberg correction.
Information-theoretical security of quantum key distribution (QKD) has been convincingly proven in recent years and remarkable experiments have shown the potential of QKD for real-world applications. Due to its unique capability of combining high key rate and security in a realistic finite-size scenario, the efficient version of the BB84 QKD protocol endowed with decoy states has been subject of intensive research. Its recent experimental implementation finally demonstrated a secure key rate beyond 1 Mb/s over a 50 km of optical fiber. However, the achieved rate holds under the restrictive assumption that the eavesdropper performs collective attacks. Here, we review the protocol and generalize its security. We exploit a map by Ahrens to rigorously upper bound the hypergeometric distribution resulting from a general eavesdropping. Despite the extended applicability of the new protocol, its key rate is only marginally smaller than its predecessor in all cases of practical interest.
Abstract Purpose : Practical quantum key distribution (QKD) deployments remain constrainedby finite-key effects, hardware noise, and limited adversarial attackmodeling. This work aims to close the gap between theoretical composable securityguarantees and realistic hardware performance by developing noise-resilient,multi-basis QKD protocols with provable finite-key security bounds. Methods : A generalized multi-basis BB84 protocol (MB-BB84) and a phaseengineeredE91 entanglement-based scheme (PE-E91) are developed with composablesecurity guarantees under depolarizing and amplitude-damping noisechannels. Finite-key security bounds are derived using the smooth min-entropyframework. Zero-noise extrapolation (ZNE) error mitigation is integrated intothe composable security analysis. Experimental validation is performed usinghardware-calibrated noise models derived from superconducting quantum processors. Results : The 3-basis MB-BB84 achieves a composable finite-key rate 7.4%higher than standard BB84 at a block size of one million signals, while increasingintercept-resend eavesdropper detection probability from 75.0% to 83.3%.PE-E91 improves the CHSH Bell parameter by 4.2% over standard E91. ZNE mitigationextends the practical security threshold by 30–40% in terms of maximumtolerable gate error rate on superconducting hardware. All analytical predictionsare confirmed within 3–5% of semidefinite-programming-computed key ratebounds. Conclusion : The proposed unified framework bridges theoretical composablesecurity and practical hardware constraints, providing explicit design guidelinesfor scalable, noise-resilient QKD architectures suitable for next-generationquantum communication networks.
This paper focuses on the implementation and comparative analysis of two widely studied QKD protocols. The BB84 and E91 protocols are security measures that were devised back in the 1980s and 90s by experts like Charles Bennett and Ekaterina S. Ekert. This paper demonstrates with Qiskit protocol implementation documentation and simulation results together with extensive security analysis how BB84 and E91 protocols can be utilized through an open-source quantum computing framework developed by IBM. This paper aims to examine the BB84 and E91 protocol resistance to eavesdropping invasions while testing their performance across different communication ranges. We utilize quantum superposition to encode information into qubits during BB84 protocol implementation which allows us to simulate an intercept-resend attack to determine its vulnerability. Research shows that BB84 provides simpler execution yet suffers from more eavesdropping attacks especially at extended distances through increased error rates from interception methods. E91 protocol achieves detection of eavesdropping by distributing entangled qubits between two parties so measurements of those qubits reveal tampering through their outcome correlations. Our experimental findings confirm that E91 delivers enhanced security capabilities through its ability to keep errors minimal across longer distances thus demonstrating resistance against distance-related threats. The comparative analysis underscores the strengths and limitations of each protocol. BB84, despite its simplicity and ease of implementation, shows diminished security over longer distances. E91, which uses the non-local properties of entangled qubits, offers enhanced protection for long-distance communication, making it a more practical choice for robust QKD systems.
With the rapid development of quantum computing, traditional encryption techniques are expected to face serious security challenges in the near future. By depending on the principles of quantum physics rather than computing complexity, Quantum Key Distribution (QKD), and specifically the BB84 protocol, provides a radically new method of secure communication. In this project, an adaptive BB84-based framework is implemented and analyzed under realistic conditions, including channel noise and multiple eavesdropping strategies. The system integrates error correction, privacy amplification, finite-key analysis, and decoy-state mechanisms to reflect practical deployment scenarios. Three major attack models—intercept-resend, photon number splitting, and Trojan horse—are simulated to evaluate protocol robustness. The experimental results show that during normal communication the average Quantum Bit Error Rate (QBER) remains close to 3–4%, whereas the presence of active eavesdropping increases the QBER beyond the commonly accepted 11% threshold, resulting in protocol termination. Additional statistical testing under varying noise conditions confirms stable secret key generation and reliable detection of malicious interference. Overall, the proposed framework serves as a comprehensive simulation platform for studying the security behavior of BB84 in controlled experimental environments.
Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) protocols offer a revolutionary approach to secure communication, leveraging the principles of quantum mechanics to enable theoretically unbreakable encryption. This comprehensive review examines the security and efficiency of various QKD protocols, including BB84, E91, and Continuous Variable QKD. We analyze the fundamental principles underpinning these protocols, their implementation challenges, and the practical considerations for real-world deployment. Special emphasis is placed on the security proofs of QKD, addressing potential vulnerabilities such as photon number splitting attacks and detector blinding attacks. Additionally, we explore the efficiency of QKD systems in terms of key generation rates, distance limitations, and integration with existing communication infrastructures. Recent advancements in QKD technology, including satellite-based QKD and quantum repeaters, are also discussed. Our findings highlight the critical role of QKD in future-proofing communication security and the ongoing efforts to enhance its practicality and scalability. This review aims to provide a detailed understanding of the current state of QKD protocols, offering insights into their potential to transform secure communications in the quantum era.
Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) has emerged as a critical component of secure communication in the post-quantum era. This study provides a comparative security and performance analysis of leading QKD protocols—BB84, E91, and Continuous Variable QKD—using experimental and simulated data from terrestrial and satellite-based implementations. Key metrics such as secret key rate, bit error rate, and resistance to quantum attacks are analyzed. Regression and predictive modeling are used to quantify performance decay over distance and noise. The results indicate BB84's robustness and broad applicability, while CV-QKD offers throughput advantages in short-range networks. Keywords: Quantum Key Distribution, QKD, BB84, E91, Continuous Variable QKD, Cryptographic Security, Quantum Communication, Post-Quantum Security