IEEE Conference on Computer Communications (INFOCOM)
Security Analysis of BB84 and E91 QKD Protocols Using Unified Security Framework
Kanwalinderjit Kaur, Pablo Rodriguez Quinonez
Abstract
This work presents a rigorous comparison of BB84 and E91 quantum key distribution protocols using modern composable security analysis and realistic hardware modeling. The framework implements sophisticated collective/coherent attack settings in the model and finite-key security bounds suitable for practical implementations. Under identical hardware assumptions (70% detector efficiency, 0.2 dB/km fiber attenuation, SPAD detectors) and equal quantum resources (5000 events per trial), BB84 with decoy states achieves significantly higher key rates than E91 (16.75% vs 1.39% mean rate, p−8, Cohen’s d = 0.890). At practical distances, BB84 generates 5.7× more keys at 1 km and 102× more at 10 km. Both protocols remain vulnerable to detector blinding attacks, highlighting the critical importance of implementation security. The unified comparative framework eliminates confounding variables through identical experimental conditions across multiple attack scenarios and transmission distances, enabling robust protocol evaluation. The analysis provides practical insights for QKD system deployment through bootstrap confidence intervals, effect size analysis, and Benjamini-Hochberg correction.