Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

AIP conference proceedings

Comparison of error-rate between BB84 and E91 QKD protocol

Vani Jayasri Geddada, Prof. P.V. Lakshmi

Published Jan 1, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

This paper focuses on the implementation and comparative analysis of two widely studied QKD protocols. The BB84 and E91 protocols are security measures that were devised back in the 1980s and 90s by experts like Charles Bennett and Ekaterina S. Ekert. This paper demonstrates with Qiskit protocol implementation documentation and simulation results together with extensive security analysis how BB84 and E91 protocols can be utilized through an open-source quantum computing framework developed by IBM. This paper aims to examine the BB84 and E91 protocol resistance to eavesdropping invasions while testing their performance across different communication ranges. We utilize quantum superposition to encode information into qubits during BB84 protocol implementation which allows us to simulate an intercept-resend attack to determine its vulnerability. Research shows that BB84 provides simpler execution yet suffers from more eavesdropping attacks especially at extended distances through increased error rates from interception methods. E91 protocol achieves detection of eavesdropping by distributing entangled qubits between two parties so measurements of those qubits reveal tampering through their outcome correlations. Our experimental findings confirm that E91 delivers enhanced security capabilities through its ability to keep errors minimal across longer distances thus demonstrating resistance against distance-related threats. The comparative analysis underscores the strengths and limitations of each protocol. BB84, despite its simplicity and ease of implementation, shows diminished security over longer distances. E91, which uses the non-local properties of entangled qubits, offers enhanced protection for long-distance communication, making it a more practical choice for robust QKD systems.

DOI
10.1063/5.0327178

Related papers

Development of Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) with E91 Protocol for Future Secure Quantum Networks

Muhammad Fajri Zulfa, Khoirul Anwar

Abstract This paper investigates practical performances of the Ekert 91 protocol (E91) for future secure quantum networks. To seek future possible improvement, we investigate the important different principles of E91 and Bennet-Brasard (BB84) protocols. We perform a series of computer simulations to evaluate the performances of them and investigate the practical parameters. Furthermore, we simulate the E91 protocol using real-world practical scenarios involving eavesdropping and quantum channel errors. We present two scenarios: (1) the performance with eavesdropper interception under a perfect channel and (2) the performances with eavesdropper interception combined with channel errors. We found that: (i) the E91 protocol produces fewer keys compared to the BB84 protocol but does not require verification between two parties, (ii) the E91 protocol enhances security due to the utilization of Clauser, Horne, Shimony, and Holt (CHSH) inequality, and (iii) both eavesdropper and channel errors can impact the less production of keys obtained during the keys production.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Apr 1, 2025•16 citations

Elementary Quantum Key Distribution Study of BB84 and E91 Protocols

Bhavesh B. Prajapati

Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) is a ground-breaking solution to secure communication that uses fundamental quantum mechanics principles to allow for the exchange of cryptographic keys with provable security. BB84 and E91, two of the first and most significant QKD systems, presented two different approaches to using quantum characteristics to prevent eavesdropping and maintain confidentiality. A brief literature review of these two fundamental protocols is presented in this paper. Bennett and Brassard created the BB84 protocol in 1984. It uses polarized photons and detects interception using the uncertainty principle. On the other hand, Bell's theorem and entangled photon pairs are used in the E91 protocol, which was first presented by Ekert in 1991, to guarantee the integrity of the shared key. Each protocol's theoretical foundations, methods of implementation, and relative benefits has been explored in addition to how they have influenced contemporary quantum cryptography systems. This paper attempts to give a basic understanding of QKD and its early advancements by examining the similarities and differences between BB84 and E91.

International Journal of Scientific Research in Computer Science Engineering and Information Technology•Oct 30, 2018•0 citations

A Novel Approach Based on Quantum Key Distribution Using BB84 and E91 Protocol for Resilient Encryption and Eavesdropper Detection

Noor Ul Ain, Muhammad Waqar, Anas Bilal +4 more

Quantum cryptography is anticipated to drive substantial advancements in cybersecurity. The impending arrival of quantum cryptography compromises current encryption methods, possibly compromising the effectiveness of traditional key management-based security protocols. One fundamental Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) protocol, BB84, encounters challenges when operating with fewer Quantum bits (Qubits) and bases that only support up to 8 Qubits. This limitation weakens the system’s security, making brute force, intercept, and resend attacks less challenging. Consequently, this study proposes a method to enhance the security of the BB84 protocol, to reduce susceptibility to attacks and eavesdropping. The improved BB84 protocol utilizes 9, 12, and 16 quantum bits along with two, and three bases to significantly bolster security. This allows authorized parties to eliminate the use of compromised keys. Additionally, the study implements the E91 QKD protocol utilizing the Entanglement Pair Generation (EPR) method to produce secure keys. While the existing E91 protocol ensures security through Bell’s theorem and Bell’s inequality, it overlooks the impact of noise, leading to inaccuracies in eavesdropper detection. To address this, the study introduces an additional security measure. Whenever an eavesdropper attempts to measure the quantum state, the proposed E91 protocol collapses its state from$\vert 10\rangle $to$\vert 11\rangle $, setting the first Qubit to$\vert 1\rangle $and the other Qubit to$\vert 0\rangle $, thus providing the eavesdropper with incorrect information, accompanied by a phase angle of$15\pi $/8. This leads to a misconception, preventing eavesdroppers from obtaining useful details about transferred quantum states. Additionally, considering that the proposed E91 protocol relies on entangled particles and utilizes double Qubit gates, which are inherently noisier than single Qubit gates and more susceptible to quantum decoherence, this study employs error mitigation techniques during the final measurement to predict outcomes more efficiently.

IEEE Access•Jan 1, 2025•49 citations

Quantum Key Distribution Using BB84 and E91 Protocols with QIS-Kit

The rapid advancement of quantum computing poses a significant threat to classical cryptographic systems that form the backbone of modern digital security.Algorithms such as RSA and ECC, which rely on the computational difficulty of integer factorization and discrete logarithm problems, become vulnerable to quantum attacks, particularly Shor's algorithm.This project presents a comprehensive Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) Simulator that implements the BB84 and E91 protocols using IBM's Qiskit quantum computing framework, providing an interactive platform for understanding, simulating, and analyzing quantum-safe key exchange mechanisms.The simulator features a full-stack architecture with a FastAPI backend powered by Python and Qiskit for quantum circuit execution, and a React 19 frontend with TypeScript for interactive visualization.The BB84 protocol implementation supports configurable qubit counts, multiple measurement bases (Z, X, and Diagonal), Eve's intercept-resend attack simulation with adjustable interception rates, and Quantum Bit Error Rate (QBER) calculation with a security threshold of 8.5%.The E91 protocol implementation uses entangled Bell state pairs with configurable measurement angles, CHSH inequality violation testing for quantum security verification, and reverse gate anti-eavesdropping mechanisms.Additionally, the system includes an AES encryption module that uses quantum-generated keys from BB84 and E91 simulations to perform AES-128, AES-192, and AES-256 encryption, with privacy amplification for keys shorter than the required length.A simulation history system with SQLite and PostgreSQL support enables experiment tracking, comparison, and analysis.The project demonstrates the practical application of quantum mechanics principles to cryptographic security and serves as an educational tool for understanding the transition from classical to quantum-safe cryptography.

International Research Journal of Modernization in Engineering Technology and Science•Apr 3, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Bit Error Rate Analysis in BB84 Quantum Key Distribution: Measurement, Statistical Estimation, and Eavesdropping Detection

Jaydeep Rath, Prajwal Panth, P. S. N. Bhaskar

Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) provides information-theoretic security by exploiting the principles of quantum mechanics. Among QKD protocols, the BB84 scheme remains the most widely adopted for both theoretical research and practical implementation. A critical parameter determining the reliability and security of BB84 is the Quantum Bit Error Rate (QBER), which quantifies errors in the sifted key arising from channel noise or potential eavesdropping. This paper presents a systematic review and analysis of QBER within the BB84 protocol, examining its calculation, statistical estimation methods, and role in detecting eavesdropping activity. Simulation results, corroborated by reported experimental observations, reveal a near-linear relationship between eavesdropping intensity and QBER, with values approaching 25% under full intercept-resend attacks. Four confidence interval estimation methods, Wald, Wilson, Clopper-Pearson, and Hoeffding's inequality, are compared for robust QBER analysis in finite-key scenarios. Protocol enhancements, including decoy-state methods, hybrid cryptographic models, and quantum-resistant authentication, are discussed as mechanisms to mitigate errors and strengthen resilience across fiber, free-space, underwater, and satellite QKD systems. Open challenges in distinguishing noise-induced errors from malicious eavesdropping, and the role of adaptive error correction and machine-learning-assisted QBER estimation in future quantum networks, are identified as key directions for further research.

quant-pharXiv:2603.27278•Mar 31, 2026•1 citation

Digital Inclusion and Workforce-Readiness Interventions in Emerging Economies : A Review

Uchechi Mary-Linda Unamma, Funmilayo Ashore-Onisemo, Uzoamaka Azuka Iwuanyanwu +1 more

Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) is a ground-breaking solution to secure communication that uses fundamental quantum mechanics principles to allow for the exchange of cryptographic keys with provable security. BB84 and E91, two of the first and most significant QKD systems, presented two different approaches to using quantum characteristics to prevent eavesdropping and maintain confidentiality. A brief literature review of these two fundamental protocols is presented in this paper. Bennett and Brassard created the BB84 protocol in 1984. It uses polarized photons and detects interception using the uncertainty principle. On the other hand, Bell's theorem and entangled photon pairs are used in the E91 protocol, which was first presented by Ekert in 1991, to guarantee the integrity of the shared key. Each protocol's theoretical foundations, methods of implementation, and relative benefits has been explored in addition to how they have influenced contemporary quantum cryptography systems. This paper attempts to give a basic understanding of QKD and its early advancements by examining the similarities and differences between BB84 and E91.

International Journal of Scientific Research in Computer Science Engineering and Information Technology•Nov 1, 2018•4 citations
This paper focuses on the implementation and comparative analysis of two widely studied QKD protocols. The BB84 and E91 protocols are security measures that were devised back in the 1980s and 90s by experts like Charles Bennett and Ekaterina S. Ekert. This paper demonstrates with Qiskit protocol implementation documentation and simulation results together with extensive security analysis how BB84 and E91 protocols can be utilized through an open-source quantum computing framework developed by IBM. This paper aims to examine the BB84 and E91 protocol resistance to eavesdropping invasions while testing their performance across different communication ranges. We utilize quantum superposition to encode information into qubits during BB84 protocol implementation which allows us to simulate an intercept-resend attack to determine its vulnerability. Research shows that BB84 provides simpler execution yet suffers from more eavesdropping attacks especially at extended distances through increased error rates from interception methods. E91 protocol achieves detection of eavesdropping by distributing entangled qubits between two parties so measurements of those qubits reveal tampering through their outcome correlations. Our experimental findings confirm that E91 delivers enhanced security capabilities through its ability to keep errors minimal across longer distances thus demonstrating resistance against distance-related threats. The comparative analysis underscores the strengths and limitations of each protocol. BB84, despite its simplicity and ease of implementation, shows diminished security over longer distances. E91, which uses the non-local properties of entangled qubits, offers enhanced protection for long-distance communication, making it a more practical choice for robust QKD systems.
Abstract This paper investigates practical performances of the Ekert 91 protocol (E91) for future secure quantum networks. To seek future possible improvement, we investigate the important different principles of E91 and Bennet-Brasard (BB84) protocols. We perform a series of computer simulations to evaluate the performances of them and investigate the practical parameters. Furthermore, we simulate the E91 protocol using real-world practical scenarios involving eavesdropping and quantum channel errors. We present two scenarios: (1) the performance with eavesdropper interception under a perfect channel and (2) the performances with eavesdropper interception combined with channel errors. We found that: (i) the E91 protocol produces fewer keys compared to the BB84 protocol but does not require verification between two parties, (ii) the E91 protocol enhances security due to the utilization of Clauser, Horne, Shimony, and Holt (CHSH) inequality, and (iii) both eavesdropper and channel errors can impact the less production of keys obtained during the keys production.
Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) is a ground-breaking solution to secure communication that uses fundamental quantum mechanics principles to allow for the exchange of cryptographic keys with provable security. BB84 and E91, two of the first and most significant QKD systems, presented two different approaches to using quantum characteristics to prevent eavesdropping and maintain confidentiality. A brief literature review of these two fundamental protocols is presented in this paper. Bennett and Brassard created the BB84 protocol in 1984. It uses polarized photons and detects interception using the uncertainty principle. On the other hand, Bell's theorem and entangled photon pairs are used in the E91 protocol, which was first presented by Ekert in 1991, to guarantee the integrity of the shared key. Each protocol's theoretical foundations, methods of implementation, and relative benefits has been explored in addition to how they have influenced contemporary quantum cryptography systems. This paper attempts to give a basic understanding of QKD and its early advancements by examining the similarities and differences between BB84 and E91.
Quantum cryptography is anticipated to drive substantial advancements in cybersecurity. The impending arrival of quantum cryptography compromises current encryption methods, possibly compromising the effectiveness of traditional key management-based security protocols. One fundamental Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) protocol, BB84, encounters challenges when operating with fewer Quantum bits (Qubits) and bases that only support up to 8 Qubits. This limitation weakens the system’s security, making brute force, intercept, and resend attacks less challenging. Consequently, this study proposes a method to enhance the security of the BB84 protocol, to reduce susceptibility to attacks and eavesdropping. The improved BB84 protocol utilizes 9, 12, and 16 quantum bits along with two, and three bases to significantly bolster security. This allows authorized parties to eliminate the use of compromised keys. Additionally, the study implements the E91 QKD protocol utilizing the Entanglement Pair Generation (EPR) method to produce secure keys. While the existing E91 protocol ensures security through Bell’s theorem and Bell’s inequality, it overlooks the impact of noise, leading to inaccuracies in eavesdropper detection. To address this, the study introduces an additional security measure. Whenever an eavesdropper attempts to measure the quantum state, the proposed E91 protocol collapses its state from$\vert 10\rangle tototo\vert 11\rangle ,settingthefirstQubitto, setting the first Qubit to,settingthefirstQubitto\vert 1\rangle andtheotherQubittoand the other Qubit toandtheotherQubitto\vert 0\rangle $, thus providing the eavesdropper with incorrect information, accompanied by a phase angle of$15\pi $/8. This leads to a misconception, preventing eavesdroppers from obtaining useful details about transferred quantum states. Additionally, considering that the proposed E91 protocol relies on entangled particles and utilizes double Qubit gates, which are inherently noisier than single Qubit gates and more susceptible to quantum decoherence, this study employs error mitigation techniques during the final measurement to predict outcomes more efficiently.
The rapid advancement of quantum computing poses a significant threat to classical cryptographic systems that form the backbone of modern digital security.Algorithms such as RSA and ECC, which rely on the computational difficulty of integer factorization and discrete logarithm problems, become vulnerable to quantum attacks, particularly Shor's algorithm.This project presents a comprehensive Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) Simulator that implements the BB84 and E91 protocols using IBM's Qiskit quantum computing framework, providing an interactive platform for understanding, simulating, and analyzing quantum-safe key exchange mechanisms.The simulator features a full-stack architecture with a FastAPI backend powered by Python and Qiskit for quantum circuit execution, and a React 19 frontend with TypeScript for interactive visualization.The BB84 protocol implementation supports configurable qubit counts, multiple measurement bases (Z, X, and Diagonal), Eve's intercept-resend attack simulation with adjustable interception rates, and Quantum Bit Error Rate (QBER) calculation with a security threshold of 8.5%.The E91 protocol implementation uses entangled Bell state pairs with configurable measurement angles, CHSH inequality violation testing for quantum security verification, and reverse gate anti-eavesdropping mechanisms.Additionally, the system includes an AES encryption module that uses quantum-generated keys from BB84 and E91 simulations to perform AES-128, AES-192, and AES-256 encryption, with privacy amplification for keys shorter than the required length.A simulation history system with SQLite and PostgreSQL support enables experiment tracking, comparison, and analysis.The project demonstrates the practical application of quantum mechanics principles to cryptographic security and serves as an educational tool for understanding the transition from classical to quantum-safe cryptography.
Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) provides information-theoretic security by exploiting the principles of quantum mechanics. Among QKD protocols, the BB84 scheme remains the most widely adopted for both theoretical research and practical implementation. A critical parameter determining the reliability and security of BB84 is the Quantum Bit Error Rate (QBER), which quantifies errors in the sifted key arising from channel noise or potential eavesdropping. This paper presents a systematic review and analysis of QBER within the BB84 protocol, examining its calculation, statistical estimation methods, and role in detecting eavesdropping activity. Simulation results, corroborated by reported experimental observations, reveal a near-linear relationship between eavesdropping intensity and QBER, with values approaching 25% under full intercept-resend attacks. Four confidence interval estimation methods, Wald, Wilson, Clopper-Pearson, and Hoeffding's inequality, are compared for robust QBER analysis in finite-key scenarios. Protocol enhancements, including decoy-state methods, hybrid cryptographic models, and quantum-resistant authentication, are discussed as mechanisms to mitigate errors and strengthen resilience across fiber, free-space, underwater, and satellite QKD systems. Open challenges in distinguishing noise-induced errors from malicious eavesdropping, and the role of adaptive error correction and machine-learning-assisted QBER estimation in future quantum networks, are identified as key directions for further research.
Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) is a ground-breaking solution to secure communication that uses fundamental quantum mechanics principles to allow for the exchange of cryptographic keys with provable security. BB84 and E91, two of the first and most significant QKD systems, presented two different approaches to using quantum characteristics to prevent eavesdropping and maintain confidentiality. A brief literature review of these two fundamental protocols is presented in this paper. Bennett and Brassard created the BB84 protocol in 1984. It uses polarized photons and detects interception using the uncertainty principle. On the other hand, Bell's theorem and entangled photon pairs are used in the E91 protocol, which was first presented by Ekert in 1991, to guarantee the integrity of the shared key. Each protocol's theoretical foundations, methods of implementation, and relative benefits has been explored in addition to how they have influenced contemporary quantum cryptography systems. This paper attempts to give a basic understanding of QKD and its early advancements by examining the similarities and differences between BB84 and E91.