Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

European Journal of Physics

The little-known non-orthogonality of hydrogenic radial wavefunctions: an ℓ -dependent operator perspective

Devdatta Meghasham Mankame

Published Mar 12, 2026• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract It is often assumed that hydrogenic radial wavefunctions R nℓ ( r ) inherit universal orthogonality from the total wavefunctions ψ nℓm . This leads to the inference that all R nℓ are eigenfunctions of a single universal radial operator and thus form an orthonormal basis for L 2 ([0, ∞), r 2 d r ). We demonstrate this is false: orthogonality holds only within fixed- ℓ subspaces, where all R nℓ share the same self-adjoint operator h ˆ ℓ . For ℓ ≠ ℓ ′ , radial functions belong to distinct Sturm–Liouville families with operators differing in their centrifugal terms ∝ ℓ ( ℓ + 1)/ r 2 . This structural difference—not numerical artifact—explains the non-zero radial overlap (e.g. the 2 s –2 p overlap equals − 3 / 2 ). We classify all radial overlap integrals into four cases based on ( n , n ′ , ℓ , ℓ ′ ) , demonstrate non-orthogonality with explicit counterexamples, and explain the operator-family origin of this behavior. This perspective prevents subtle errors in basis expansions and perturbation theory for hydrogenic systems.

DOI
10.1088/1361-6404/ae5139

Related papers

Comment on ‘Little-known non-orthogonality of hydrogenic radial wavefunctions: an ℓ -dependent operator perspective’

Gregory L. Bason, Bruce Cameron Reed

Abstract Following the recent discussion of Mankame (2026 Eur. J. Phys. 47 025405), we consider the orthogonality of the radial parts of the hydrogen atom wavefunctions, R n , ℓ ( r ) . As Mankame showed, these functions are not in general orthogonal. By this we mean that the overlap integral of the product of two of them weighted by the square of the radial coordinate may be non-zero if the two angular momentum quantum numbers differ. Orthogonality does hold in the case where the two angular momentum quantum numbers are the same, providing that the principal quantum numbers differ. Here we offer an alternate proof of this result, describe some analytic examples to complement Mankame’s numerical ones, and point out some further references on this issue.

European Journal of Physics•Jul 20, 2026•0 citations

On the Nonorthogonality of Generalized Momentum Eigenfunctions in Quantum Mechanics

Peter D. Robinson

The orthogonality requirement usually specified for the eigenfunctions φ of a quantum-mechanical operator P which has a continuous spectrum of eigenvalues λ, is ∫φ*(λ)φ(λ′) dλ=δ(λ−λ′). The derivation of this result is examined; it is seen to be merely a sufficient, but not a necessary condition for the consistent expansion of a bound-state wavefunction ψ in the form ∫ a(λ)φ(λ) dλ. The situation when P is a generalized momentum operator is investigated in detail. Such operators were discussed in the preceding paper. It is shown that any two of the corresponding momentum eigenfunctions are not usually orthogonal. Nevertheless, with the help of Fourier analysis, a consistent expansion ψ=∫ a(λ)φ(λ) dλ is established. The theory is illustrated with the familiar examples of a ``particle in a box'' and a ground-state hydrogen atom. When a space coordinate has a finite range, a quantum condition can be imposed on the generalized momentum eigenvalues so that the momentum eigenfunctions form a complete discrete orthogonal set. We attempt to justify the belief that such quantization is not essential unless it is necessary to ensure single-valued eigenfunctions.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Mar 1, 1963•3 citations

Matrix representation of vectors and operators in nonorthogonal basis vectors

S. D. Deshpande, R. B. Pode

The bases used in quantum mechanics, in general, are orthonormal. The relations in orthonormal basis vectors are simpler than those in nonorthogonal basis vectors. Also, the operators that represent different physical quantities are Hermitian and the eigenvectors of these operators belonging to different eigenvalues are orthonormal to each other. But, in many cases, such as sets of screened hydrogenic wavefunctions, nonorthogonal sets of basis vectors occur. It is, therefore, necessary to consider the representation of vectors and operators in nonorthogonal bases. Making use of the set of vectors reciprocal to the given set of nonorthogonal base vectors, the expression for the norms of vectors and for the matrix elements has been found. Also, adjoint and Hermitian matrices in nonorthogonal bases have been worked out using a set of reciprocal basis vectors.

American Journal of Physics•Apr 1, 1988•8 citations

From self-adjoint to non-self-adjoint harmonic oscillators: Physical consequences and mathematical pitfalls

Fabio Bagarello

Using as a prototype example the harmonic oscillator we show how losing self-adjointness of the Hamiltonian $H$ changes drastically the related functional structure. In particular, we show that even a small deviation from strict self-adjointness of $H$ produces two deep consequences, not well understood in the literature: First of all, the original orthonormal basis of $H$ splits into two families of biorthogonal vectors. These two families are complete but, contrarily to what often claimed for similar systems, none of them is a basis for the Hilbert space $\mathcal{H}$. Second, the so-called metric operator is unbounded, as well as its inverse. In the second part of the paper, after an extension of some previous results on the so-called $\mathcal{D}$ pseudobosons, we discuss some aspects of our extended harmonic oscillator from this different point of view.

arXiv:1309.5065•Physical Review A•Sep 30, 2013•34 citations

Exact solutions of Dirac equation for hydrogen atom using the linear combination of orthogonal Laguerre basis functions

Shudong Wu

The associated Laguerre polynomials are very popular in the Schrödinger equation of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics. However, the situation is quite different in the case of the Dirac equation of relativistic quantum mechanics. The exact solutions of the Dirac equation for three-dimensional (3D) hydrogen atom have been obtained using the wavefunction expansion method. The exact solutions of the radial wavefunctions are found in the form of a linear combination of the orthogonal Laguerre basis function spinors. According to the equality of coefficients in Laguerre series on both sides of the equations, the exact eigenenergies and exact expressions of the corresponding eigenstates of the Dirac equation for 3D hydrogen atom are obtained, which are the same as the power series solutions. Additionally, a comparison with the results from Dirac and Schrödinger equations for 3D hydrogen atom is discussed. Due to the relativistic effects, the Dirac bispinor occurs, and there are the tiny differences of the results between Dirac and Schrödinger equations. For the Dirac states with n r = 0, there is one set of the Dirac bispinor. However for the Dirac states with n r ≠ 0, there is a combination of two sets of the Dirac bispinor. For degenerate Dirac states, their exact expansion coefficients are commutative symmetric. These results show that the linear combination of the orthogonal Laguerre basis functions is the exact solutions of the Dirac equation for 3D hydrogen atom.

Scientific Reports•May 8, 2025•1 citation

Radial matrix elements and the angular momentum technique

Dmitry A. Varshalovich, A. V. Karpova

For hydrogen wave functions, it is shown that radial matrix elements of type 〈nl|r k |nl′〉 can be expressed in terms of the Clebsch-Gordan coefficients, which characterize the relation between angular momenta l and l′, but in a nonphysical region of their arguments.

Optics and Spectroscopy•Jan 1, 2015•4 citations
Abstract It is often assumed that hydrogenic radial wavefunctions R nℓ ( r ) inherit universal orthogonality from the total wavefunctions ψ nℓm . This leads to the inference that all R nℓ are eigenfunctions of a single universal radial operator and thus form an orthonormal basis for L 2 ([0, ∞), r 2 d r ). We demonstrate this is false: orthogonality holds only within fixed- ℓ subspaces, where all R nℓ share the same self-adjoint operator h ˆ ℓ . For ℓ ≠ ℓ ′ , radial functions belong to distinct Sturm–Liouville families with operators differing in their centrifugal terms ∝ ℓ ( ℓ + 1)/ r 2 . This structural difference—not numerical artifact—explains the non-zero radial overlap (e.g. the 2 s –2 p overlap equals − 3 / 2 ). We classify all radial overlap integrals into four cases based on ( n , n ′ , ℓ , ℓ ′ ) , demonstrate non-orthogonality with explicit counterexamples, and explain the operator-family origin of this behavior. This perspective prevents subtle errors in basis expansions and perturbation theory for hydrogenic systems.
Abstract Following the recent discussion of Mankame (2026 Eur. J. Phys. 47 025405), we consider the orthogonality of the radial parts of the hydrogen atom wavefunctions, R n , ℓ ( r ) . As Mankame showed, these functions are not in general orthogonal. By this we mean that the overlap integral of the product of two of them weighted by the square of the radial coordinate may be non-zero if the two angular momentum quantum numbers differ. Orthogonality does hold in the case where the two angular momentum quantum numbers are the same, providing that the principal quantum numbers differ. Here we offer an alternate proof of this result, describe some analytic examples to complement Mankame’s numerical ones, and point out some further references on this issue.
The orthogonality requirement usually specified for the eigenfunctions φ of a quantum-mechanical operator P which has a continuous spectrum of eigenvalues λ, is ∫φ*(λ)φ(λ′) dλ=δ(λ−λ′). The derivation of this result is examined; it is seen to be merely a sufficient, but not a necessary condition for the consistent expansion of a bound-state wavefunction ψ in the form ∫ a(λ)φ(λ) dλ. The situation when P is a generalized momentum operator is investigated in detail. Such operators were discussed in the preceding paper. It is shown that any two of the corresponding momentum eigenfunctions are not usually orthogonal. Nevertheless, with the help of Fourier analysis, a consistent expansion ψ=∫ a(λ)φ(λ) dλ is established. The theory is illustrated with the familiar examples of a ``particle in a box'' and a ground-state hydrogen atom. When a space coordinate has a finite range, a quantum condition can be imposed on the generalized momentum eigenvalues so that the momentum eigenfunctions form a complete discrete orthogonal set. We attempt to justify the belief that such quantization is not essential unless it is necessary to ensure single-valued eigenfunctions.
The bases used in quantum mechanics, in general, are orthonormal. The relations in orthonormal basis vectors are simpler than those in nonorthogonal basis vectors. Also, the operators that represent different physical quantities are Hermitian and the eigenvectors of these operators belonging to different eigenvalues are orthonormal to each other. But, in many cases, such as sets of screened hydrogenic wavefunctions, nonorthogonal sets of basis vectors occur. It is, therefore, necessary to consider the representation of vectors and operators in nonorthogonal bases. Making use of the set of vectors reciprocal to the given set of nonorthogonal base vectors, the expression for the norms of vectors and for the matrix elements has been found. Also, adjoint and Hermitian matrices in nonorthogonal bases have been worked out using a set of reciprocal basis vectors.
Using as a prototype example the harmonic oscillator we show how losing self-adjointness of the Hamiltonian HHH changes drastically the related functional structure. In particular, we show that even a small deviation from strict self-adjointness of HHH produces two deep consequences, not well understood in the literature: First of all, the original orthonormal basis of HHH splits into two families of biorthogonal vectors. These two families are complete but, contrarily to what often claimed for similar systems, none of them is a basis for the Hilbert space H\mathcal{H}H. Second, the so-called metric operator is unbounded, as well as its inverse. In the second part of the paper, after an extension of some previous results on the so-called D\mathcal{D}D pseudobosons, we discuss some aspects of our extended harmonic oscillator from this different point of view.
The associated Laguerre polynomials are very popular in the Schrödinger equation of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics. However, the situation is quite different in the case of the Dirac equation of relativistic quantum mechanics. The exact solutions of the Dirac equation for three-dimensional (3D) hydrogen atom have been obtained using the wavefunction expansion method. The exact solutions of the radial wavefunctions are found in the form of a linear combination of the orthogonal Laguerre basis function spinors. According to the equality of coefficients in Laguerre series on both sides of the equations, the exact eigenenergies and exact expressions of the corresponding eigenstates of the Dirac equation for 3D hydrogen atom are obtained, which are the same as the power series solutions. Additionally, a comparison with the results from Dirac and Schrödinger equations for 3D hydrogen atom is discussed. Due to the relativistic effects, the Dirac bispinor occurs, and there are the tiny differences of the results between Dirac and Schrödinger equations. For the Dirac states with n r = 0, there is one set of the Dirac bispinor. However for the Dirac states with n r ≠ 0, there is a combination of two sets of the Dirac bispinor. For degenerate Dirac states, their exact expansion coefficients are commutative symmetric. These results show that the linear combination of the orthogonal Laguerre basis functions is the exact solutions of the Dirac equation for 3D hydrogen atom.