Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1309.5065 · Physical Review A

From self-adjoint to non-self-adjoint harmonic oscillators: Physical consequences and mathematical pitfalls

Fabio Bagarello

Published Sep 30, 2013• 34 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Using as a prototype example the harmonic oscillator we show how losing self-adjointness of the Hamiltonian $H$ changes drastically the related functional structure. In particular, we show that even a small deviation from strict self-adjointness of $H$ produces two deep consequences, not well understood in the literature: First of all, the original orthonormal basis of $H$ splits into two families of biorthogonal vectors. These two families are complete but, contrarily to what often claimed for similar systems, none of them is a basis for the Hilbert space $\mathcal{H}$. Second, the so-called metric operator is unbounded, as well as its inverse. In the second part of the paper, after an extension of some previous results on the so-called $\mathcal{D}$ pseudobosons, we discuss some aspects of our extended harmonic oscillator from this different point of view.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.88.032120

Related papers

A quantum system with a non-self-adjoint 2D-harmonic oscillator

Natália Bebiano, João da Providência, João P. da Providência

Abstract Non-self-adjoint operators with a real discrete spectrum exhibit, in general, a quite different behavior from the one of self-adjoint operators, with the same spectrum. This fact has serious mathematical and physical implications, namely in the rigorous formulation of quantum mechanics (QM), where self-adjointness plays a central role, in particular in the spectral analysis of the involved operators. In this framework, a non-self-adjoint 2D-harmonic oscillator is considered. Its eigenvalues and eigenfunctions, as well as those of its adjoint, are explicitly determined. Although the eigensystems are complete they may not form bases, a drawback for the mathematical formulation of the QM of the system. The existence of a metric operator defining an inner product which renders the Hamiltonian self-adjoint, is discussed.

Physica Scripta•Apr 24, 2019•2 citations

Some remarks on quasi-Hermitian operators

Jean-Pierre Antoine, Camillo Trapanı

A quasi-Hermitian operator is an operator that is similar to its adjoint in some sense, via a metric operator, i.e., a strictly positive self-adjoint operator. Whereas those metric operators are in general assumed to be bounded, we analyze the structure generated by unbounded metric operators in a Hilbert space. Following our previous work, we introduce several generalizations of the notion of similarity between operators. Then we explore systematically the various types of quasi-Hermitian operators, bounded or not. Finally, we discuss their application in the so-called pseudo-Hermitian quantum mechanics.

arXiv:1307.5644•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Jan 1, 2014•18 citations

A harmonic oscillator system with the generalized commutation relations

Shuji Watanabe

The system of a one-dimensional harmonic oscillator is discussed with the generalized commutation relations obtained by Wigner. The Hamiltonian is shown to have self-adjoint extensions. The domain of self-adjointness is explicitly specified in some cases. The proof is carried out by the use of the Lax–Milgram lemma. A suitable rigged Hilbert space is found for this system to reformulate the earlier arguments. The main difficulty is that the momentum and Hamiltonian operators contain the reflection Rψ(x)=ψ(−x) as well as singular terms.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Feb 1, 1989•8 citations

Metric Operators, Generalized Hermiticity and Lattices of Hilbert Spaces

Jean-Pierre Antoine, Camillo Trapanı

Pseudo-Hermitian quantum mechanics (QM) is a recent, unconventional, approach to QM, based on the use of non-self-adjoint Hamiltonians, whose self-adjointness can be restored by changing the ambient Hilbert space, via a so-called metric operator. The PT-symmetric Hamiltonians are usually pseudo-Hermitian operators, a term introduced a long time ago by Dieudonné for characterizing those bounded operators A that satisfy a relation of the form GA = A G, where G is a metric operator, that is, a strictly positive self-adjoint operator. This chapter explores further the structure of unbounded metric operators, in particular, their incidence on similarity. It examines the notion of similarity between operators induced by a bounded metric operator with bounded inverse. The goal here is to study which spectral properties are preserved under such a quasi-similarity relation. The chapter applies some of the previous results to operators on the scale of Hilbert spaces generated by the metric operator G.

Wiley eBooks•Jul 7, 2015•19 citations

The Schrödinger Representation

Ron Elber, Dmitrii E. Makarov, Henri Orland

Self-adjoint operators have very interesting mathematical properties, in particular, their left and right eigenvectors are identical, and they provide an orthonormal basis of the vector space. The Hamiltonian H is obviously self-adjoint, and therefore we will be able to use its orthonormal basis of eigenvectors to expand the probability distribution P(x, t). The eigenstates and eigenvalues of the quantum harmonic oscillator are known. There is a theorem in quantum mechanics which states that the ground-state wave function of any system is non-negative and is not degenerate. This statement is a special case of the Perron-Frobenius theorem, applied to the continuous case. For non-conservative systems, there is no such convergence theorem, and the system may exhibit various types of long time behavior. This chapter concludes that the transformation from Fokker–Planck to Schrödinger equation is possible only for conservative forces.

Wiley eBooks•Jan 28, 2020•0 citations

Hamiltonians Generated by Parseval Frames

Fabio Bagarello, S. Kużel

Abstract It is known that self-adjoint Hamiltonians with purely discrete eigenvalues can be written as (infinite) linear combination of mutually orthogonal projectors with eigenvalues as coefficients of the expansion. The projectors are defined by the eigenvectors of the Hamiltonians. In some recent papers, this expansion has been extended to the case in which these eigenvectors form a Riesz basis or, more recently, a ${\mathcal{D}}$ D -quasi basis (Bagarello and Bellomonte in J. Phys. A 50:145203, 2017, Bagarello et al. in J. Math. Phys. 59:033506, 2018), rather than an orthonormal basis. Here we discuss what can be done when these sets are replaced by Parseval frames. This interest is motivated by physical reasons, and in particular by the fact that the mathematical Hilbert space where the physical system is originally defined, contains sometimes also states which cannot really be occupied by the physical system itself. In particular, we show what changes in the spectrum of the observables, when going from orthonormal bases to Parseval frames. In this perspective we propose the notion of $E$ E -connection for observables. Several examples are discussed.

arXiv:2010.05043•Acta Applicandae Mathematicae•Dec 15, 2020•5 citations
Using as a prototype example the harmonic oscillator we show how losing self-adjointness of the Hamiltonian HHH changes drastically the related functional structure. In particular, we show that even a small deviation from strict self-adjointness of HHH produces two deep consequences, not well understood in the literature: First of all, the original orthonormal basis of HHH splits into two families of biorthogonal vectors. These two families are complete but, contrarily to what often claimed for similar systems, none of them is a basis for the Hilbert space H\mathcal{H}H. Second, the so-called metric operator is unbounded, as well as its inverse. In the second part of the paper, after an extension of some previous results on the so-called D\mathcal{D}D pseudobosons, we discuss some aspects of our extended harmonic oscillator from this different point of view.
Abstract Non-self-adjoint operators with a real discrete spectrum exhibit, in general, a quite different behavior from the one of self-adjoint operators, with the same spectrum. This fact has serious mathematical and physical implications, namely in the rigorous formulation of quantum mechanics (QM), where self-adjointness plays a central role, in particular in the spectral analysis of the involved operators. In this framework, a non-self-adjoint 2D-harmonic oscillator is considered. Its eigenvalues and eigenfunctions, as well as those of its adjoint, are explicitly determined. Although the eigensystems are complete they may not form bases, a drawback for the mathematical formulation of the QM of the system. The existence of a metric operator defining an inner product which renders the Hamiltonian self-adjoint, is discussed.
A quasi-Hermitian operator is an operator that is similar to its adjoint in some sense, via a metric operator, i.e., a strictly positive self-adjoint operator. Whereas those metric operators are in general assumed to be bounded, we analyze the structure generated by unbounded metric operators in a Hilbert space. Following our previous work, we introduce several generalizations of the notion of similarity between operators. Then we explore systematically the various types of quasi-Hermitian operators, bounded or not. Finally, we discuss their application in the so-called pseudo-Hermitian quantum mechanics.
The system of a one-dimensional harmonic oscillator is discussed with the generalized commutation relations obtained by Wigner. The Hamiltonian is shown to have self-adjoint extensions. The domain of self-adjointness is explicitly specified in some cases. The proof is carried out by the use of the Lax–Milgram lemma. A suitable rigged Hilbert space is found for this system to reformulate the earlier arguments. The main difficulty is that the momentum and Hamiltonian operators contain the reflection Rψ(x)=ψ(−x) as well as singular terms.
Pseudo-Hermitian quantum mechanics (QM) is a recent, unconventional, approach to QM, based on the use of non-self-adjoint Hamiltonians, whose self-adjointness can be restored by changing the ambient Hilbert space, via a so-called metric operator. The PT-symmetric Hamiltonians are usually pseudo-Hermitian operators, a term introduced a long time ago by Dieudonné for characterizing those bounded operators A that satisfy a relation of the form GA = A G, where G is a metric operator, that is, a strictly positive self-adjoint operator. This chapter explores further the structure of unbounded metric operators, in particular, their incidence on similarity. It examines the notion of similarity between operators induced by a bounded metric operator with bounded inverse. The goal here is to study which spectral properties are preserved under such a quasi-similarity relation. The chapter applies some of the previous results to operators on the scale of Hilbert spaces generated by the metric operator G.
Self-adjoint operators have very interesting mathematical properties, in particular, their left and right eigenvectors are identical, and they provide an orthonormal basis of the vector space. The Hamiltonian H is obviously self-adjoint, and therefore we will be able to use its orthonormal basis of eigenvectors to expand the probability distribution P(x, t). The eigenstates and eigenvalues of the quantum harmonic oscillator are known. There is a theorem in quantum mechanics which states that the ground-state wave function of any system is non-negative and is not degenerate. This statement is a special case of the Perron-Frobenius theorem, applied to the continuous case. For non-conservative systems, there is no such convergence theorem, and the system may exhibit various types of long time behavior. This chapter concludes that the transformation from Fokker–Planck to Schrödinger equation is possible only for conservative forces.
Abstract It is known that self-adjoint Hamiltonians with purely discrete eigenvalues can be written as (infinite) linear combination of mutually orthogonal projectors with eigenvalues as coefficients of the expansion. The projectors are defined by the eigenvectors of the Hamiltonians. In some recent papers, this expansion has been extended to the case in which these eigenvectors form a Riesz basis or, more recently, a D{\mathcal{D}}D D -quasi basis (Bagarello and Bellomonte in J. Phys. A 50:145203, 2017, Bagarello et al. in J. Math. Phys. 59:033506, 2018), rather than an orthonormal basis. Here we discuss what can be done when these sets are replaced by Parseval frames. This interest is motivated by physical reasons, and in particular by the fact that the mathematical Hilbert space where the physical system is originally defined, contains sometimes also states which cannot really be occupied by the physical system itself. In particular, we show what changes in the spectrum of the observables, when going from orthonormal bases to Parseval frames. In this perspective we propose the notion of EEE E -connection for observables. Several examples are discussed.