Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Resolving the Representation Crisis in Relativistic Quantum Mechanics_ The Relational Event-Coordination Framework

Muhammad yahya

Published Jan 1, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The Dirac and Foldy-Wouthuysen (FW) representations of relativistic quantum mechanics produce conflicting predictions for fundamental observables like location, spin, and probability density, creating a fundamental stalemate. This representation crisis undermines quantitative results across the field, yet researchers continue to work within restrictive methodologies—low-dimensional models, paraxial approximations, or classical circuit simulations—that mask rather than resolve the underlying mathematical tension. We propose the Relational Event-Coordination (REC) framework, which redefines position as a relational property emerging from a Hilbert space of spacetime events rather than an intrinsic particle operator. Within this framework, Lorentz symmetry acts as a geometric unitary, and observables arise from covariant clock POVMs conditioned against spacetime foliation. The REC framework recovers the Dirac density where covariance and continuity requirements dominate, while mapping to FW variables when classical alignment becomes necessary. Neither representation holds privileged status; both describe the same underlying events under different conditioning regimes. We identify testable predictions involving twisted electron beams in non-inertial frames and high-energy particles in intense laser fields, offering pathways toward empirical resolution of the representation paradox. Keywords: Dirac representation, Foldy–Wouthuysen transformation, relational quantum mechanics, relativistic observables, Event-Hilbert Space, Newton–Wigner localization, POVM, representation crisis

DOI
10.17605/osf.io/qmu3v

Related papers

Geometric Event-Based Quantum Mechanics

Vittorio Giovannetti, Seth Lloyd, Lorenzo Maccone

Abstract We propose a special relativistic framework for quantum mechanics. It is based on introducing a Hilbert space for events. Events are taken as primitive notions (as customary in relativity), whereas quantum systems (e.g. fields and particles) are emergent in the form of joint probability amplitudes for position and time of events. Textbook relativistic quantum mechanics and quantum field theory can be recovered by dividing the event Hilbert spaces into space and time (a foliation) and then conditioning the event states onto the time part. Our theory satisfies the full Lorentz symmetry as a ‘geometric’ unitary transformation, and possesses relativistic observables for space (location of an event) and time (position in time of an event).

arXiv:2206.08359•New Journal of Physics•Jan 31, 2023•23 citations

A Dissolution of the Problem of Locality

Simon W. Saunders

Relativistic quantum theory poses a number of conceptual problems over and above the non-relativistic mechanics. From a purely mathematical point of view it is also much more sophisticated. Even the kinematic theory poses considerable difficulties: locality, antimatter, negative energy, and charge are already systematically linked in ways that cannot simply be paraphrased. A further complication is that in the midst of this structure we have what is usually called the Newton-Wigner representation (or, in the case of the Dirac theory, the Foldy-Wouthuysen representation), in which fields and states are no longer covariantly described and where the “local” self-adjoint quantities (NW-local observables) do not obey microcausality, but only satisfy equal-time commutators with respect to a particular inertial frame. If we pass to this represenation, we obtain at a stroke the basic structure of non-relativistic quantum field theory; it is not too hard to descend from that to a many-particle mechanics, and to recover the usual definitions of localization.

PSA Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association•Jan 1, 1994•13 citations

Spacetime Localization Without a Global Frame: Quantum Reference Frames, Relational Observables, and Domain-Restricted Covariance for Localizing Records

Tomoyuki Uchida

This paper is the thirty-first in a sequence developing an interpretive framework that redescribes physical reality as a causally consistent history of information updates rather than as a collection of independently existing objects. It is the third panel — the capstone — of the eighth grouping, a foundational-physics trilogy. Its subject is spacetime localization: where and when a record or system is — its position, orientation, relative phase, and time. The claim is that localization is real but not authoritatively global. There is no Global Frame: no physically privileged reference system that fixes absolute location and orientation, a privileged global simultaneity, a classical frame standing outside quantum theory, and one physically privileged, globally valid perspectival gauge-fixing. Localization is relational: positions and times are defined relative to a declared quantum reference frame (QRF), itself a quantum system that may be superposed and entangled with what it localizes (Giacomini, Castro-Ruiz, & Brukner, 2019; Loveridge, Miyadera, & Busch, 2018). What keeps this objective rather than subjective is a strict typing of cross-frame comparison: a single gauge-invariant relational (Dirac) observable has one invariant prediction, its perspectival representations intertwined by a frame-change map (case A); distinct relational observables form a relationally consistent web (case B); and where two frames share no common refinement their claims are declared incomparable (case C). "Objective" means invariance of the physical predictions under the declared symmetry group and the frame-change groupoid over the admissible frame family, to a declared tolerance — never frame-independence in an absolute sense. The flagship R-A is a dynamics-independent kinematic existence witness: a finite-dimensional discrete-ring model exhibits one physical state and two admissible ideal QRFs under which the localization profile and the entanglement structure differ — a sharp product relative to one particle; an entangled state with a delocalized, mixed marginal relative to another — while the distribution of the same relational observable is preserved. R-B splits into a domain covariance on shared refinements (ideal QRFs compose and agree on shared Dirac predictions) and a model-dependent global-perspective obstruction: where a globally valid relational gauge-fixing fails, as in known Gribov-type models (Vanrietvelde, Höhn, & Giacomini, 2023), no single perspective covers the whole physical state space — which is neither the same as, nor a consequence of, the absence of a privileged frame, and does not preclude a perspective-neutral description. R-C places Paper 8's relational time as the time-translation special case, with its finite-resolution-clock, conditional-covariance, and record–clock qualifications, separating the retired claim (no global clock) from the deferred one (relativistic foliation with dynamical geometry). R-D identifies and transports the frame-representable localization sector of certain Paper-30 grains, partially discharging that paper's grain-coherence deferral while leaving interaction, fragmentation, redundancy, and history-family structure grain-relative. This completes the trilogy's dismantling of the Global Bookkeeper while keeping geometry fixed: the quantum-mechanics–gravity interface is prepared, not entered. Localization is frame-relative but objective: no absolute frame, no globally gauge-fixed perspective claimed beyond what models establish, and no anarchy. ALAC Paper 31. Third panel (capstone) of the eighth grouping — a foundational-physics trilogy (29 Public Quantum Records -> 30 Classicality Without a Global Classicalizer -> 31 Spacetime Localization Without a Global Frame). Part of the Consistency-Constrained Information History (Akashic Ledger Architecture Cosmology) series. Presents no new quantum mechanics; results are interpretive (L2) on imported physics (L1).

•Jun 30, 2026•2 citations

Asymptotic Locality: Rectifying Newton--Wigner and Foldy--Wouthuysen Localization

E. J. Thompson

Relativistic quantum theory supports two competing notions of particle locality. Newton--Wigner localization provides a sharp position operator on the one-particle Hilbert space but is not Lorentz covariant and leads to instantaneous spreading for positive-energy states. Foldy--Wouthuysen localization, widely used in precision experiments, yields a robust quasi-classical particle description but is representation-dependent and does not coincide with strict field-theoretic locality. We show that this tension is not a paradox in UV-complete nonlocal quantum field theories whose ultraviolet physics is encoded by an entire-function regulator. In such theories the physically accessible observables form a quasi-local algebra generated by regulated smearings with an intrinsic nonlocality length. Sharp Newton--Wigner projectors are not operationally realistic, and Newton--Wigner and Foldy--Wouthuysen localization become equivalent non-singular notions of locality in the same measurement algebra.

•Jan 27, 2026•3 citations

Poincaré Group and Operators of Position and Spin

Alexander J. Silenko, Pengfei Zhang, Liping Zou

Abstract Fundamental properties of the position and spin operators in relativistic quantum mechanics are defined with the Poincaré group. Quantum-mechanical counterparts of the classical position and spin variables are the corresponding operators in the Foldy–Wouthuysen representation but not in the Dirac one. The probabilistic interpretation is valid only for Foldy–Wouthuysen wave functions. The relativistic operators of the position and spin are discussed.

Physics of Particles and Nuclei•Nov 29, 2023•0 citations

Equivalence of Approaches to Relational Quantum Dynamics in Relativistic Settings

Philipp A. Höhn, Alexander R. H. Smith, Maximilian P. E. Lock

We have previously shown that three approaches to relational quantum dynamics—relational Dirac observables, the Page-Wootters formalism and quantum deparametrizations—are equivalent. Here we show that this “trinity” of relational quantum dynamics holds in relativistic settings per frequency superselection sector. Time according to a clock subsystem is defined via a positive operator-valued measure (POVM) that is covariant with respect to the group generated by its (quadratic) Hamiltonian. This differs from the usual choice of a self-adjoint clock observable conjugate to the clock momentum. It also resolves Kuchař's criticism that the Page-Wootters formalism yields incorrect localization probabilities for the relativistic particle when conditioning on a Minkowski time operator. We show that conditioning instead on the covariant clock POVM results in a Newton-Wigner type localization probability commonly used in relativistic quantum mechanics. By establishing the equivalence mentioned above, we also assign a consistent conditional-probability interpretation to relational observables and deparametrizations. Finally, we expand a recent method of changing temporal reference frames, and show how to transform states and observables frequency-sector-wise. We use this method to discuss an indirect clock self-reference effect and explore the state and temporal frame-dependence of the task of comparing and synchronizing different quantum clocks.

arXiv:2007.00580•Frontiers in Physics•Jun 18, 2021•120 citations
The Dirac and Foldy-Wouthuysen (FW) representations of relativistic quantum mechanics produce conflicting predictions for fundamental observables like location, spin, and probability density, creating a fundamental stalemate. This representation crisis undermines quantitative results across the field, yet researchers continue to work within restrictive methodologies—low-dimensional models, paraxial approximations, or classical circuit simulations—that mask rather than resolve the underlying mathematical tension. We propose the Relational Event-Coordination (REC) framework, which redefines position as a relational property emerging from a Hilbert space of spacetime events rather than an intrinsic particle operator. Within this framework, Lorentz symmetry acts as a geometric unitary, and observables arise from covariant clock POVMs conditioned against spacetime foliation. The REC framework recovers the Dirac density where covariance and continuity requirements dominate, while mapping to FW variables when classical alignment becomes necessary. Neither representation holds privileged status; both describe the same underlying events under different conditioning regimes. We identify testable predictions involving twisted electron beams in non-inertial frames and high-energy particles in intense laser fields, offering pathways toward empirical resolution of the representation paradox. Keywords: Dirac representation, Foldy–Wouthuysen transformation, relational quantum mechanics, relativistic observables, Event-Hilbert Space, Newton–Wigner localization, POVM, representation crisis
Abstract We propose a special relativistic framework for quantum mechanics. It is based on introducing a Hilbert space for events. Events are taken as primitive notions (as customary in relativity), whereas quantum systems (e.g. fields and particles) are emergent in the form of joint probability amplitudes for position and time of events. Textbook relativistic quantum mechanics and quantum field theory can be recovered by dividing the event Hilbert spaces into space and time (a foliation) and then conditioning the event states onto the time part. Our theory satisfies the full Lorentz symmetry as a ‘geometric’ unitary transformation, and possesses relativistic observables for space (location of an event) and time (position in time of an event).
Relativistic quantum theory poses a number of conceptual problems over and above the non-relativistic mechanics. From a purely mathematical point of view it is also much more sophisticated. Even the kinematic theory poses considerable difficulties: locality, antimatter, negative energy, and charge are already systematically linked in ways that cannot simply be paraphrased. A further complication is that in the midst of this structure we have what is usually called the Newton-Wigner representation (or, in the case of the Dirac theory, the Foldy-Wouthuysen representation), in which fields and states are no longer covariantly described and where the “local” self-adjoint quantities (NW-local observables) do not obey microcausality, but only satisfy equal-time commutators with respect to a particular inertial frame. If we pass to this represenation, we obtain at a stroke the basic structure of non-relativistic quantum field theory; it is not too hard to descend from that to a many-particle mechanics, and to recover the usual definitions of localization.
This paper is the thirty-first in a sequence developing an interpretive framework that redescribes physical reality as a causally consistent history of information updates rather than as a collection of independently existing objects. It is the third panel — the capstone — of the eighth grouping, a foundational-physics trilogy. Its subject is spacetime localization: where and when a record or system is — its position, orientation, relative phase, and time. The claim is that localization is real but not authoritatively global. There is no Global Frame: no physically privileged reference system that fixes absolute location and orientation, a privileged global simultaneity, a classical frame standing outside quantum theory, and one physically privileged, globally valid perspectival gauge-fixing. Localization is relational: positions and times are defined relative to a declared quantum reference frame (QRF), itself a quantum system that may be superposed and entangled with what it localizes (Giacomini, Castro-Ruiz, & Brukner, 2019; Loveridge, Miyadera, & Busch, 2018). What keeps this objective rather than subjective is a strict typing of cross-frame comparison: a single gauge-invariant relational (Dirac) observable has one invariant prediction, its perspectival representations intertwined by a frame-change map (case A); distinct relational observables form a relationally consistent web (case B); and where two frames share no common refinement their claims are declared incomparable (case C). "Objective" means invariance of the physical predictions under the declared symmetry group and the frame-change groupoid over the admissible frame family, to a declared tolerance — never frame-independence in an absolute sense. The flagship R-A is a dynamics-independent kinematic existence witness: a finite-dimensional discrete-ring model exhibits one physical state and two admissible ideal QRFs under which the localization profile and the entanglement structure differ — a sharp product relative to one particle; an entangled state with a delocalized, mixed marginal relative to another — while the distribution of the same relational observable is preserved. R-B splits into a domain covariance on shared refinements (ideal QRFs compose and agree on shared Dirac predictions) and a model-dependent global-perspective obstruction: where a globally valid relational gauge-fixing fails, as in known Gribov-type models (Vanrietvelde, Höhn, & Giacomini, 2023), no single perspective covers the whole physical state space — which is neither the same as, nor a consequence of, the absence of a privileged frame, and does not preclude a perspective-neutral description. R-C places Paper 8's relational time as the time-translation special case, with its finite-resolution-clock, conditional-covariance, and record–clock qualifications, separating the retired claim (no global clock) from the deferred one (relativistic foliation with dynamical geometry). R-D identifies and transports the frame-representable localization sector of certain Paper-30 grains, partially discharging that paper's grain-coherence deferral while leaving interaction, fragmentation, redundancy, and history-family structure grain-relative. This completes the trilogy's dismantling of the Global Bookkeeper while keeping geometry fixed: the quantum-mechanics–gravity interface is prepared, not entered. Localization is frame-relative but objective: no absolute frame, no globally gauge-fixed perspective claimed beyond what models establish, and no anarchy. ALAC Paper 31. Third panel (capstone) of the eighth grouping — a foundational-physics trilogy (29 Public Quantum Records -> 30 Classicality Without a Global Classicalizer -> 31 Spacetime Localization Without a Global Frame). Part of the Consistency-Constrained Information History (Akashic Ledger Architecture Cosmology) series. Presents no new quantum mechanics; results are interpretive (L2) on imported physics (L1).
Relativistic quantum theory supports two competing notions of particle locality. Newton--Wigner localization provides a sharp position operator on the one-particle Hilbert space but is not Lorentz covariant and leads to instantaneous spreading for positive-energy states. Foldy--Wouthuysen localization, widely used in precision experiments, yields a robust quasi-classical particle description but is representation-dependent and does not coincide with strict field-theoretic locality. We show that this tension is not a paradox in UV-complete nonlocal quantum field theories whose ultraviolet physics is encoded by an entire-function regulator. In such theories the physically accessible observables form a quasi-local algebra generated by regulated smearings with an intrinsic nonlocality length. Sharp Newton--Wigner projectors are not operationally realistic, and Newton--Wigner and Foldy--Wouthuysen localization become equivalent non-singular notions of locality in the same measurement algebra.
We have previously shown that three approaches to relational quantum dynamics—relational Dirac observables, the Page-Wootters formalism and quantum deparametrizations—are equivalent. Here we show that this “trinity” of relational quantum dynamics holds in relativistic settings per frequency superselection sector. Time according to a clock subsystem is defined via a positive operator-valued measure (POVM) that is covariant with respect to the group generated by its (quadratic) Hamiltonian. This differs from the usual choice of a self-adjoint clock observable conjugate to the clock momentum. It also resolves Kuchař's criticism that the Page-Wootters formalism yields incorrect localization probabilities for the relativistic particle when conditioning on a Minkowski time operator. We show that conditioning instead on the covariant clock POVM results in a Newton-Wigner type localization probability commonly used in relativistic quantum mechanics. By establishing the equivalence mentioned above, we also assign a consistent conditional-probability interpretation to relational observables and deparametrizations. Finally, we expand a recent method of changing temporal reference frames, and show how to transform states and observables frequency-sector-wise. We use this method to discuss an indirect clock self-reference effect and explore the state and temporal frame-dependence of the task of comparing and synchronizing different quantum clocks.