Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Comptes Rendus Physique

Quantum entanglement by gravity as tests of gravitational collapse models à la Diósi and Penrose

Markus Aspelmeyer

Published Nov 24, 2025• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

I provide a simple argument that the experimental observation of gravitationally induced entanglement rules out the validity of current gravitational collapse models. This is consistent with the recent claim to the contrary in [Trillo and Navascués, Phys. Rev. D , 111, (2025)], if one takes into account the physical constraints of actual table-top gravity experiments.

DOI
10.5802/crphys.270

Related papers

A no-go theorem on the nature of the gravitational field beyond quantum theory

Thomas D. Galley, Flaminia Giacomini, John H. Selby

Recently, table-top experiments involving massive quantum systems have been proposed to test the interface of quantum theory and gravity. In particular, the crucial point of the debate is whether it is possible to conclude anything on the quantum nature of the gravitational field, provided that two quantum systems become entangled solely due to the gravitational interaction. Typically, this question has been addressed by assuming a specific physical theory to describe the gravitational interaction, but no systematic approach to characterise the set of possible gravitational theories which are compatible with the observation of entanglement has been proposed. Here, we remedy this by introducing the framework of Generalised Probabilistic Theories (GPTs) to the study of the nature of the gravitational field. This framework enables us to systematically study all theories compatible with the detection of entanglement generated via the gravitational interaction between two systems. We prove a no-go theorem stating that the following statements are incompatible: i) gravity is able to generate entanglement; ii) gravity mediates the interaction between the systems; iii) gravity is classical. We analyse the violation of each condition, in particular with respect to alternative non-linear models such as the Schrödinger-Newton equation and Collapse Models.

arXiv:2012.01441•Quantum•Aug 17, 2022•78 citations

Decoherence effects in non-classicality tests of gravity

Simone Rijavec, Matteo Carlesso, Angelo Bassi +2 more

Abstract The experimental observation of a clear quantum signature of gravity is believed to be out of the grasp of current technology. However, several recent promising proposals to test the possible existence of non-classical features of gravity seem to be accessible by the state-of-art table-top experiments. Among them, some aim at measuring the gravitationally induced entanglement between two masses which would be a distinct non-classical signature of gravity. We explicitly study, in two of these proposals, the effects of decoherence on the system’s dynamics by monitoring the corresponding degree of entanglement. We identify the required experimental conditions necessary to perform successfully the experiments. In parallel, we account also for the possible effects of the continuous spontaneous localization (CSL) model, which is the most known among the models of spontaneous wavefunction collapse. We find that any value of the parameters of the CSL model would completely hinder the generation of gravitationally induced entanglement.

arXiv:2012.06230•New Journal of Physics•Mar 31, 2021•73 citations

On the effectiveness of the collapse in the Diósi–Penrose model

Laria Figurato, Marco Dirindin, José Luis Gaona-Reyes +3 more

Abstract The possibility that gravity plays a role in the collapse of the quantum wave function has been considered in the literature, and it is of relevance not only because it would provide a solution to the measurement problem in quantum theory, but also because it would give a new and unexpected twist to the search for a unified theory of quantum and gravitational phenomena, possibly overcoming the current impasse. The Diósi–Penrose model is the most popular incarnation of this idea. It predicts a progressive breakdown of quantum superpositions when the mass of the system increases; as such, it is susceptible to experimental verification. Current experiments set a lower bound R 0 ≳ 4 Å for the free parameter of the model, excluding some versions of it. In this work we search for an upper bound, coming from the request that the collapse is effective enough to guarantee classicality at the macroscopic scale: we find out that not all macroscopic systems collapse effectively. If one relaxes this request, a reasonable (although to some degree arbitrary) bound is found to be: R 0 ≲ 10 6 Å. This will serve to better direct future experiments to further test the model.

arXiv:2406.18494•New Journal of Physics•Oct 29, 2024•15 citations

A testable prediction from entropic gravity

Mehmet Süzen

I have shown conceptually that quantum state has a direct relationship to gravitational constant due to entropic force posed by Verlinde's argument and part of the Newton-Schrödinger equation (N-S) in the context of gravity induced collapse of the wavefunction via Diósi-Penrose proposal. This direct relationship can be used to measure gravitational constant using state-of-the-art mater-wave interferometry to test the entropic gravity argument.

arXiv:1612.00288•Nov 27, 2016•0 citations

Pre-registration v2: Does gravity carry entanglement? A dated pick and kill conditions for massive-superposition experiments

John Rodarte

A dated pre-registration, fixed on 11 November 2026, before any result from massive-superposition or gravitational-entanglement experiments at 1e-15 kg or above. The Folman–Vedral–Penrose quantum free-fall experiment (Science Advances, 2026) confirmed the equivalence principle for an atom in superposition. Heavier tests will decide between three endings: (1) Diósi–Penrose gravitational collapse; (2) quantum gravity, where two masses entangle through gravity; (3) classical-quantum gravity (Oppenheim et al.), where gravity stays classical, decoheres matter and itself diffuses. Pick: ending 2 — gravity carries entanglement, with no gravity-specific decoherence of a mass superposition. The basis is stated as an assumption: in the author's "gravity from the notes" chain (entanglement area law plus Jacobson 1995), the metric is a coherent collective mode of the vacuum's entangled field modes. The open threat (Jacobson's local-equilibrium assumption) is named, not claimed resolved. Key numbers (first principles): at 1e-14 kg the saturated Diósi–Penrose collapse time is about 0.012 s, roughly 200 times shorter than the 2.5 s needed to build the 0.066 rad entangling phase. The minimal-decoherence kernel of classical-quantum gravity is the Diósi–Penrose kernel, so endings 1 and 3 share one decoherence curve in the split size (rising, bending near twice the object radius, then saturating). One interferometer therefore decides ending 2 versus not-2. Kill conditions: K-QG1 — gravity-specific decoherence following the Diósi–Penrose curve, after known channels are budgeted out. K-QG2 — a clean null at ~1e-14 kg and ~2.5 s, with coherence verified and a demonstrated witness sensitivity of 0.02 rad or better, where 0.066 rad is expected. Recommended designs: a split-size sweep (0.05–250 µm), a mass sweep, and a two-duration run. Separating ending 1 from 3 is not claimed. Code to reproduce every number is included. Analysis assistance from Claude (Anthropic); the numbers were checked over several rounds by an independent AI reviewer.

•Nov 11, 2026•0 citations

A demonstration that classical gravity does not produce entanglement

Mike D. Schneider, Nick Huggett, Niels Linnemann

Once again, dispute has arisen over the interpretation of proposed quantum information theory experiments to probe the quantum nature of gravity by testing for gravitationally induced entanglement (GIE) between two spatially separated massive particles ([2] vs. [16, 17]; further contributions in [11, 13]). The confusion appears to reside in interpreting applications of a Hamiltonian formalism. But classical gravity cannot mediate entanglement on independent grounds. A Newton-Cartan analysis shows that if gravity is classical, a mediator, and entanglement is observed as an outcome of performing a GIE experiment, something other than gravity must have supplied the (virtual) force needed during the experiment to produce the effect.

quant-pharXiv:2511.19242•Nov 25, 2025
I provide a simple argument that the experimental observation of gravitationally induced entanglement rules out the validity of current gravitational collapse models. This is consistent with the recent claim to the contrary in [Trillo and Navascués, Phys. Rev. D , 111, (2025)], if one takes into account the physical constraints of actual table-top gravity experiments.
Recently, table-top experiments involving massive quantum systems have been proposed to test the interface of quantum theory and gravity. In particular, the crucial point of the debate is whether it is possible to conclude anything on the quantum nature of the gravitational field, provided that two quantum systems become entangled solely due to the gravitational interaction. Typically, this question has been addressed by assuming a specific physical theory to describe the gravitational interaction, but no systematic approach to characterise the set of possible gravitational theories which are compatible with the observation of entanglement has been proposed. Here, we remedy this by introducing the framework of Generalised Probabilistic Theories (GPTs) to the study of the nature of the gravitational field. This framework enables us to systematically study all theories compatible with the detection of entanglement generated via the gravitational interaction between two systems. We prove a no-go theorem stating that the following statements are incompatible: i) gravity is able to generate entanglement; ii) gravity mediates the interaction between the systems; iii) gravity is classical. We analyse the violation of each condition, in particular with respect to alternative non-linear models such as the Schrödinger-Newton equation and Collapse Models.
Abstract The experimental observation of a clear quantum signature of gravity is believed to be out of the grasp of current technology. However, several recent promising proposals to test the possible existence of non-classical features of gravity seem to be accessible by the state-of-art table-top experiments. Among them, some aim at measuring the gravitationally induced entanglement between two masses which would be a distinct non-classical signature of gravity. We explicitly study, in two of these proposals, the effects of decoherence on the system’s dynamics by monitoring the corresponding degree of entanglement. We identify the required experimental conditions necessary to perform successfully the experiments. In parallel, we account also for the possible effects of the continuous spontaneous localization (CSL) model, which is the most known among the models of spontaneous wavefunction collapse. We find that any value of the parameters of the CSL model would completely hinder the generation of gravitationally induced entanglement.
Abstract The possibility that gravity plays a role in the collapse of the quantum wave function has been considered in the literature, and it is of relevance not only because it would provide a solution to the measurement problem in quantum theory, but also because it would give a new and unexpected twist to the search for a unified theory of quantum and gravitational phenomena, possibly overcoming the current impasse. The Diósi–Penrose model is the most popular incarnation of this idea. It predicts a progressive breakdown of quantum superpositions when the mass of the system increases; as such, it is susceptible to experimental verification. Current experiments set a lower bound R 0 ≳ 4 Å for the free parameter of the model, excluding some versions of it. In this work we search for an upper bound, coming from the request that the collapse is effective enough to guarantee classicality at the macroscopic scale: we find out that not all macroscopic systems collapse effectively. If one relaxes this request, a reasonable (although to some degree arbitrary) bound is found to be: R 0 ≲ 10 6 Å. This will serve to better direct future experiments to further test the model.
A dated pre-registration, fixed on 11 November 2026, before any result from massive-superposition or gravitational-entanglement experiments at 1e-15 kg or above. The Folman–Vedral–Penrose quantum free-fall experiment (Science Advances, 2026) confirmed the equivalence principle for an atom in superposition. Heavier tests will decide between three endings: (1) Diósi–Penrose gravitational collapse; (2) quantum gravity, where two masses entangle through gravity; (3) classical-quantum gravity (Oppenheim et al.), where gravity stays classical, decoheres matter and itself diffuses. Pick: ending 2 — gravity carries entanglement, with no gravity-specific decoherence of a mass superposition. The basis is stated as an assumption: in the author's "gravity from the notes" chain (entanglement area law plus Jacobson 1995), the metric is a coherent collective mode of the vacuum's entangled field modes. The open threat (Jacobson's local-equilibrium assumption) is named, not claimed resolved. Key numbers (first principles): at 1e-14 kg the saturated Diósi–Penrose collapse time is about 0.012 s, roughly 200 times shorter than the 2.5 s needed to build the 0.066 rad entangling phase. The minimal-decoherence kernel of classical-quantum gravity is the Diósi–Penrose kernel, so endings 1 and 3 share one decoherence curve in the split size (rising, bending near twice the object radius, then saturating). One interferometer therefore decides ending 2 versus not-2. Kill conditions: K-QG1 — gravity-specific decoherence following the Diósi–Penrose curve, after known channels are budgeted out. K-QG2 — a clean null at ~1e-14 kg and ~2.5 s, with coherence verified and a demonstrated witness sensitivity of 0.02 rad or better, where 0.066 rad is expected. Recommended designs: a split-size sweep (0.05–250 µm), a mass sweep, and a two-duration run. Separating ending 1 from 3 is not claimed. Code to reproduce every number is included. Analysis assistance from Claude (Anthropic); the numbers were checked over several rounds by an independent AI reviewer.
Once again, dispute has arisen over the interpretation of proposed quantum information theory experiments to probe the quantum nature of gravity by testing for gravitationally induced entanglement (GIE) between two spatially separated massive particles ([2] vs. [16, 17]; further contributions in [11, 13]). The confusion appears to reside in interpreting applications of a Hamiltonian formalism. But classical gravity cannot mediate entanglement on independent grounds. A Newton-Cartan analysis shows that if gravity is classical, a mediator, and entanglement is observed as an outcome of performing a GIE experiment, something other than gravity must have supplied the (virtual) force needed during the experiment to produce the effect.