Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Pre-registration v2: Does gravity carry entanglement? A dated pick and kill conditions for massive-superposition experiments

John Rodarte

Published Nov 11, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A dated pre-registration, fixed on 11 November 2026, before any result from massive-superposition or gravitational-entanglement experiments at 1e-15 kg or above. The Folman–Vedral–Penrose quantum free-fall experiment (Science Advances, 2026) confirmed the equivalence principle for an atom in superposition. Heavier tests will decide between three endings: (1) Diósi–Penrose gravitational collapse; (2) quantum gravity, where two masses entangle through gravity; (3) classical-quantum gravity (Oppenheim et al.), where gravity stays classical, decoheres matter and itself diffuses. Pick: ending 2 — gravity carries entanglement, with no gravity-specific decoherence of a mass superposition. The basis is stated as an assumption: in the author's "gravity from the notes" chain (entanglement area law plus Jacobson 1995), the metric is a coherent collective mode of the vacuum's entangled field modes. The open threat (Jacobson's local-equilibrium assumption) is named, not claimed resolved. Key numbers (first principles): at 1e-14 kg the saturated Diósi–Penrose collapse time is about 0.012 s, roughly 200 times shorter than the 2.5 s needed to build the 0.066 rad entangling phase. The minimal-decoherence kernel of classical-quantum gravity is the Diósi–Penrose kernel, so endings 1 and 3 share one decoherence curve in the split size (rising, bending near twice the object radius, then saturating). One interferometer therefore decides ending 2 versus not-2. Kill conditions: K-QG1 — gravity-specific decoherence following the Diósi–Penrose curve, after known channels are budgeted out. K-QG2 — a clean null at ~1e-14 kg and ~2.5 s, with coherence verified and a demonstrated witness sensitivity of 0.02 rad or better, where 0.066 rad is expected. Recommended designs: a split-size sweep (0.05–250 µm), a mass sweep, and a two-duration run. Separating ending 1 from 3 is not claimed. Code to reproduce every number is included. Analysis assistance from Claude (Anthropic); the numbers were checked over several rounds by an independent AI reviewer.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.24150403

Related papers

A Witness Is Not a Verdict: Sealed Simulation Tests of Instruments for Gravity-Mediated Entanglement, and a Coherence Fingerprint of Classical Gravity

Masanori Watabe, Kurado (Claude Opus 5.5)

The Bose-Marletto-Vedral (BMV) proposal infers that gravity is quantum if two masses, each in a spatialsuperposition, become entangled through gravity alone. No such experiment has been performed. Its reading has twoweak points: non-gravitational interactions (Casimir-Polder, electric dipoles) also entangle, and a classicalgravitational channel can imprint the Newtonian phase without entangling. We simulated the two-spin experiment(10^-14 kg nanodiamonds, 250 um superpositions, 2.5 s, six separations from 125 to 800 um, nine-settingtomography) under quantum gravity, classical channels and no gravitational phase, with unknown Casimir strength(x0.2-20), dipoles, terms of the wrong power, calibration and mass errors, dephasing and finite shots, and measuredeach instrument's false-alarm rate before trusting it. In sealed runs a lone witness called classical-gravity worldsquantum in 10.7% of cases (data-tuned bases 15.4%), and reading only the 1/r shape of the phase did so in 68.3% ofclassical-channel worlds. A three-valued instrument (W1) that demands entanglement beyond what non-gravity alonecan produce together with the Newtonian coefficient, and that needs an independent dipole calibration, never called aclassical world quantum (0 of 16,500 over four seals). A first claim that a null result can read "classical" rested on aclassical channel whose phase had the wrong sign; corrected, the channel hid behind its own decoherence and theclaim became Unresolved. Classical channels must pay coherence for the phase, and that cost grows as the massesapproach, so the dependence of coherence on separation is a fingerprint. Fixing its shape as phi^2 failed a seal(Falsified: 25 of 1022), although the signal was present in 1020 of them; with the power left free the final seal gave Ron all five claims: a time-sliced classical channel never seen before was called classical in 996 of 996 worlds,quantum worlds never (0 of 1500), and classical worlds overall in 57.0%. All results are simulated. ※ Data and code. All scripts (AGPL-3.0-or-later, GNU Affero General Public License v3.0 or later), the four seal documents with their SHA-256 files, develop logs andresult files are provided as Bridge_Paper_A_Witness_Is_Not_a_Verdict_scripts_v1.0.0.zip; every world isregenerated from its seed. ※ AI use. Designs, code, analyses and text were produced by Kurado (Claude Opus 5.5,Anthropic) working with M. Watabe, who chose every direction.

•Nov 3, 2026•2 citations

Tabletop Quantum Gravity: Probing Spacetime via Massive Superposition — E8 Intelligence Research

Andrew Stewart Caldin

FINDING: Quantum gravity experiments are transitioning from theoretical speculation to tabletop-scale tests probing the quantum nature of spacetime via superposition of massive systems. MATH: The core experimental framework relies on the quantum superposition of a mass \( m \) in two spatial locations separated by \( \Delta x \), generating a gravitational phase shift \( \Delta \phi = \frac{G m^2 \Delta t}{\hbar \Delta x} \) (for two masses in superposition, per Bose–Marletto–Vedral proposal). The decoherence timescale for gravitational entanglement is \( \tau \sim \frac{\hbar \Delta x}{G m^2} \). Penrose's criterion for gravitationally-induced collapse: \( E_G = \frac{G m^2}{\Delta x} \) compared to \( \hbar/\tau \). CONNECTION: The ratio \( \frac{G m^2}{\hbar c} \) (gravitational coupling) is dimensionless and tiny (~\(10^{-45}\) for protons), but the experimental geometry uses harmonic oscillator frequencies and lattice-like trap spacings — the optimal \( \Delta x \) often scale Author: Andrew Stewart Caldin, Independent Researcher, UK. Part of the E8 Intelligence Research series. Platform: e8intelligence.com

•Sep 21, 2026•0 citations

Feasibility considerations for free-fall tests of gravitational decoherence

Rainer Kaltenbaek

Space offers exciting opportunities to test the foundations of quantum physics using macroscopic quantum superpositions. It has been proposed to perform such tests in a dedicated space mission (MAQRO) using matter-wave interferometry with massive test particles or monitoring how the wave function of a test particle expands over time. Such experiments could test quantum physics with sufficiently high precision to resolve potential deviations from its unitary evolution due to gravitational decoherence. For example, such deviations have been predicted by the Diósi–Penrose (DP) model and the Károlyházy (K) model. The former predicts the collapse of massive or large superpositions due to a nonlinear modification of quantum evolution. The latter predicts decoherence because of an underlying uncertainty of space time. Potential advantages of a space environment are (1) long free-fall times, (2) low noise, and (3) taking a high number of data points over several years in a dedicated space mission. In contrast to interferometric tests, monitoring wave function expansion is less complex, but it does face some practical limitations. Here, we will discuss limitations of such non-interferometric experiments due to the limited number of data points achievable during a mission lifetime. Our results show that it will require an interferometric approach to conclusively test for gravitational decoherence as predicted by the DP or K models. In honor of the Nobel prize of Sir Roger Penrose, we will focus our discussion on the Diósi–Penrose model.

arXiv:2111.01483•AVS Quantum Science•Feb 4, 2022•6 citations

The volume in the matter-wave bound on postquantum-classical gravity is set by a smearing length, not the wavepacket

Dat Tan Nguyen

Lower bounds on the diffusion constant D2 of postquantum-classical gravity come from matter-wave coherence through the formula tau = D2 c^3 V / (2 G^2 N^(2/3) M^2), in which the volume V has been chosen in different ways, moving the bound by many orders of magnitude. For the local decoherence kernel behind this formula, the decoherence rate between two centre-of-mass positions does not depend on the wavepacket within each branch; it is fixed by the body's mass density convolved with the length l over which the theory smears mass, which the theory leaves free. The decoherence term then has the form of the mass-proportional CSL term with rC = l, as noted before, and we translate collapse-model limits into D2 >= 2 G^2 m0^2 / [c^3 lambda_max(l) (4 pi l^2)^(3/2)]. For the 2026 sodium-cluster interferometer (7482 atoms, 133 nm grating period) we compute the floor as a function of l by a pair sum over a bcc cluster. It is 1.3e-66 at l = 0.1 nm, flattens near 1.1e-66, is 0.7e-66 at 1 nm, and then falls as l^-3 and l^-5, while below 0.1 nm it rises as individual nuclei are resolved; the choice V = d^3 used in the latest summary of bounds corresponds to l = 5 nm. On matter-wave data alone, l < 2 nm is excluded against the gravitational-wave ceiling on tensor diffusion, and only l < 0.1 nm, marginally, against the scalar ceiling. If the decoherence is Markovian up to X-ray frequencies, which the theory's authors doubt, the XENONnT limit excludes l < 0.3 to 0.6 um against the tensor and full-positivity scalar ceilings. Otherwise the LISA Pathfinder collapse-model limit, proportional to l^-1, sets the lower edge above 0.14 um. One consistent way to keep the trade-off, used by Tilloy and Diosi, smears the Newtonian coupling at the same l; then short-range gravity tests limit l from above. The viable window is a region in the (D2, l) plane rather than an interval in D2.

•Nov 9, 2026•0 citations

A New Approach for Testing the Quantum Nature of Gravity

Shan, Gao

The quantum nature of gravity is one of physics' greatest unsolved problems, with existing experimental proposals facing formidable challenges in maintaining spatial superpositions of massive objects against decoherence. We propose a fundamentally different approach that bypasses these difficulties. The central insight is that a quantum gravitational field can imprint a gauge-invariant phase on a particle's wavefunction even along an open trajectory, arising from the quantum backreaction of the source. This phase, which manifests prior to the final recombination stage of an interferometer and cannot be generated by a classical gravitational field, provides an operationally direct witness to the quantumness of gravity. Our experimental design uses a single photon whose accumulated gravitational phase due to the Earth is transferred via absorption to auxiliary atoms near the end of the interferometer sequence, preserving the open-path character essential for the test. We scale the interferometer to yield a detectable phase of order $10^{-3}$ rad and show how non-local correlation measurements on the atoms can access this gauge-invariant signature. Leveraging established quantum optical and atomic techniques, this proposal offers a feasible path to distinguish quantum from classical gravity. A positive result would provide the first experimental evidence for the quantum nature of gravitational fields, with profound implications for quantum gravity theories.

•Nov 8, 2025•2 citations

Does the Gravitational Field Follow the Quantum State or Its Expectation Value? A Tunable-Probability Page-Geilker Experiment

Koorosh Karimi

Matter-wave interferometry has confirmed the superposition principle for objects as large as fullerenes and, most recently, nanoparticles of thousands of atoms. Because every massive object sources a gravitational field, a long-standing question follows: does the gravitational field of a delocalized quantum system track the realized quantum state, or the probability-weighted expectation value of its mass distribution (semiclassical gravity)? We first revisit a distant-observer thought experiment in which gravitational which-path information appears to threaten complementarity, and summarize its modern resolution, which turns the apparent paradox into an argument for the quantization of the gravitational field. We then propose a variant of the 1981 Page–Geilker experiment that generalizes a protocol of Kent: the position of a macroscopic source mass is controlled by a quantum random trigger whose firing probability p is continuously tunable, a precision gravimeter monitors the local field, and an otherwise identical run with a classical pseudo-random trigger serves as a control. For no-collapse semiclassical gravity we derive, for a repeated protocol with reset, the field offset in intervals without a release and the suppression of the gravimeter step at quantum-triggered releases; both depend on p, whereas every event-sourced theory predicts a p-independent, event-following field, and the control run cancels systematics that scale with the release rate. Order-of-magnitude estimates indicate that a superconducting gravimeter and a 100–1000 kg source can bound the fraction of “counterfactual” mass that gravitates at the 10−3 level as a function of p. We state which hypotheses the experiment can falsify, why decoherence restricts its scope to no-collapse semiclassical theories, and how the design could be migrated to mesoscopic masses, where the question remains open. Version 2 (September 2026) of a manuscript first written in June 2026. 10 pages, 1 table, 44 references. Also submitted to arXiv (quant-ph, cross-list gr-qc).

•Sep 4, 2026•0 citations
A dated pre-registration, fixed on 11 November 2026, before any result from massive-superposition or gravitational-entanglement experiments at 1e-15 kg or above. The Folman–Vedral–Penrose quantum free-fall experiment (Science Advances, 2026) confirmed the equivalence principle for an atom in superposition. Heavier tests will decide between three endings: (1) Diósi–Penrose gravitational collapse; (2) quantum gravity, where two masses entangle through gravity; (3) classical-quantum gravity (Oppenheim et al.), where gravity stays classical, decoheres matter and itself diffuses. Pick: ending 2 — gravity carries entanglement, with no gravity-specific decoherence of a mass superposition. The basis is stated as an assumption: in the author's "gravity from the notes" chain (entanglement area law plus Jacobson 1995), the metric is a coherent collective mode of the vacuum's entangled field modes. The open threat (Jacobson's local-equilibrium assumption) is named, not claimed resolved. Key numbers (first principles): at 1e-14 kg the saturated Diósi–Penrose collapse time is about 0.012 s, roughly 200 times shorter than the 2.5 s needed to build the 0.066 rad entangling phase. The minimal-decoherence kernel of classical-quantum gravity is the Diósi–Penrose kernel, so endings 1 and 3 share one decoherence curve in the split size (rising, bending near twice the object radius, then saturating). One interferometer therefore decides ending 2 versus not-2. Kill conditions: K-QG1 — gravity-specific decoherence following the Diósi–Penrose curve, after known channels are budgeted out. K-QG2 — a clean null at ~1e-14 kg and ~2.5 s, with coherence verified and a demonstrated witness sensitivity of 0.02 rad or better, where 0.066 rad is expected. Recommended designs: a split-size sweep (0.05–250 µm), a mass sweep, and a two-duration run. Separating ending 1 from 3 is not claimed. Code to reproduce every number is included. Analysis assistance from Claude (Anthropic); the numbers were checked over several rounds by an independent AI reviewer.
The Bose-Marletto-Vedral (BMV) proposal infers that gravity is quantum if two masses, each in a spatialsuperposition, become entangled through gravity alone. No such experiment has been performed. Its reading has twoweak points: non-gravitational interactions (Casimir-Polder, electric dipoles) also entangle, and a classicalgravitational channel can imprint the Newtonian phase without entangling. We simulated the two-spin experiment(10^-14 kg nanodiamonds, 250 um superpositions, 2.5 s, six separations from 125 to 800 um, nine-settingtomography) under quantum gravity, classical channels and no gravitational phase, with unknown Casimir strength(x0.2-20), dipoles, terms of the wrong power, calibration and mass errors, dephasing and finite shots, and measuredeach instrument's false-alarm rate before trusting it. In sealed runs a lone witness called classical-gravity worldsquantum in 10.7% of cases (data-tuned bases 15.4%), and reading only the 1/r shape of the phase did so in 68.3% ofclassical-channel worlds. A three-valued instrument (W1) that demands entanglement beyond what non-gravity alonecan produce together with the Newtonian coefficient, and that needs an independent dipole calibration, never called aclassical world quantum (0 of 16,500 over four seals). A first claim that a null result can read "classical" rested on aclassical channel whose phase had the wrong sign; corrected, the channel hid behind its own decoherence and theclaim became Unresolved. Classical channels must pay coherence for the phase, and that cost grows as the massesapproach, so the dependence of coherence on separation is a fingerprint. Fixing its shape as phi^2 failed a seal(Falsified: 25 of 1022), although the signal was present in 1020 of them; with the power left free the final seal gave Ron all five claims: a time-sliced classical channel never seen before was called classical in 996 of 996 worlds,quantum worlds never (0 of 1500), and classical worlds overall in 57.0%. All results are simulated. ※ Data and code. All scripts (AGPL-3.0-or-later, GNU Affero General Public License v3.0 or later), the four seal documents with their SHA-256 files, develop logs andresult files are provided as Bridge_Paper_A_Witness_Is_Not_a_Verdict_scripts_v1.0.0.zip; every world isregenerated from its seed. ※ AI use. Designs, code, analyses and text were produced by Kurado (Claude Opus 5.5,Anthropic) working with M. Watabe, who chose every direction.
FINDING: Quantum gravity experiments are transitioning from theoretical speculation to tabletop-scale tests probing the quantum nature of spacetime via superposition of massive systems. MATH: The core experimental framework relies on the quantum superposition of a mass m m m in two spatial locations separated by Δx \Delta x Δx, generating a gravitational phase shift Δϕ=Gm2ΔtℏΔx \Delta \phi = \frac{G m^2 \Delta t}{\hbar \Delta x} Δϕ=ℏΔxGm2Δt​ (for two masses in superposition, per Bose–Marletto–Vedral proposal). The decoherence timescale for gravitational entanglement is τ∼ℏΔxGm2 \tau \sim \frac{\hbar \Delta x}{G m^2} τ∼Gm2ℏΔx​. Penrose's criterion for gravitationally-induced collapse: EG=Gm2Δx E_G = \frac{G m^2}{\Delta x} EG​=ΔxGm2​ compared to ℏ/τ \hbar/\tau ℏ/τ. CONNECTION: The ratio Gm2ℏc \frac{G m^2}{\hbar c} ℏcGm2​ (gravitational coupling) is dimensionless and tiny (~10−4510^{-45}10−45 for protons), but the experimental geometry uses harmonic oscillator frequencies and lattice-like trap spacings — the optimal Δx \Delta x Δx often scale Author: Andrew Stewart Caldin, Independent Researcher, UK. Part of the E8 Intelligence Research series. Platform: e8intelligence.com
Space offers exciting opportunities to test the foundations of quantum physics using macroscopic quantum superpositions. It has been proposed to perform such tests in a dedicated space mission (MAQRO) using matter-wave interferometry with massive test particles or monitoring how the wave function of a test particle expands over time. Such experiments could test quantum physics with sufficiently high precision to resolve potential deviations from its unitary evolution due to gravitational decoherence. For example, such deviations have been predicted by the Diósi–Penrose (DP) model and the Károlyházy (K) model. The former predicts the collapse of massive or large superpositions due to a nonlinear modification of quantum evolution. The latter predicts decoherence because of an underlying uncertainty of space time. Potential advantages of a space environment are (1) long free-fall times, (2) low noise, and (3) taking a high number of data points over several years in a dedicated space mission. In contrast to interferometric tests, monitoring wave function expansion is less complex, but it does face some practical limitations. Here, we will discuss limitations of such non-interferometric experiments due to the limited number of data points achievable during a mission lifetime. Our results show that it will require an interferometric approach to conclusively test for gravitational decoherence as predicted by the DP or K models. In honor of the Nobel prize of Sir Roger Penrose, we will focus our discussion on the Diósi–Penrose model.
Lower bounds on the diffusion constant D2 of postquantum-classical gravity come from matter-wave coherence through the formula tau = D2 c^3 V / (2 G^2 N^(2/3) M^2), in which the volume V has been chosen in different ways, moving the bound by many orders of magnitude. For the local decoherence kernel behind this formula, the decoherence rate between two centre-of-mass positions does not depend on the wavepacket within each branch; it is fixed by the body's mass density convolved with the length l over which the theory smears mass, which the theory leaves free. The decoherence term then has the form of the mass-proportional CSL term with rC = l, as noted before, and we translate collapse-model limits into D2 >= 2 G^2 m0^2 / [c^3 lambda_max(l) (4 pi l^2)^(3/2)]. For the 2026 sodium-cluster interferometer (7482 atoms, 133 nm grating period) we compute the floor as a function of l by a pair sum over a bcc cluster. It is 1.3e-66 at l = 0.1 nm, flattens near 1.1e-66, is 0.7e-66 at 1 nm, and then falls as l^-3 and l^-5, while below 0.1 nm it rises as individual nuclei are resolved; the choice V = d^3 used in the latest summary of bounds corresponds to l = 5 nm. On matter-wave data alone, l < 2 nm is excluded against the gravitational-wave ceiling on tensor diffusion, and only l < 0.1 nm, marginally, against the scalar ceiling. If the decoherence is Markovian up to X-ray frequencies, which the theory's authors doubt, the XENONnT limit excludes l < 0.3 to 0.6 um against the tensor and full-positivity scalar ceilings. Otherwise the LISA Pathfinder collapse-model limit, proportional to l^-1, sets the lower edge above 0.14 um. One consistent way to keep the trade-off, used by Tilloy and Diosi, smears the Newtonian coupling at the same l; then short-range gravity tests limit l from above. The viable window is a region in the (D2, l) plane rather than an interval in D2.
The quantum nature of gravity is one of physics' greatest unsolved problems, with existing experimental proposals facing formidable challenges in maintaining spatial superpositions of massive objects against decoherence. We propose a fundamentally different approach that bypasses these difficulties. The central insight is that a quantum gravitational field can imprint a gauge-invariant phase on a particle's wavefunction even along an open trajectory, arising from the quantum backreaction of the source. This phase, which manifests prior to the final recombination stage of an interferometer and cannot be generated by a classical gravitational field, provides an operationally direct witness to the quantumness of gravity. Our experimental design uses a single photon whose accumulated gravitational phase due to the Earth is transferred via absorption to auxiliary atoms near the end of the interferometer sequence, preserving the open-path character essential for the test. We scale the interferometer to yield a detectable phase of order 10−310^{-3}10−3 rad and show how non-local correlation measurements on the atoms can access this gauge-invariant signature. Leveraging established quantum optical and atomic techniques, this proposal offers a feasible path to distinguish quantum from classical gravity. A positive result would provide the first experimental evidence for the quantum nature of gravitational fields, with profound implications for quantum gravity theories.
Matter-wave interferometry has confirmed the superposition principle for objects as large as fullerenes and, most recently, nanoparticles of thousands of atoms. Because every massive object sources a gravitational field, a long-standing question follows: does the gravitational field of a delocalized quantum system track the realized quantum state, or the probability-weighted expectation value of its mass distribution (semiclassical gravity)? We first revisit a distant-observer thought experiment in which gravitational which-path information appears to threaten complementarity, and summarize its modern resolution, which turns the apparent paradox into an argument for the quantization of the gravitational field. We then propose a variant of the 1981 Page–Geilker experiment that generalizes a protocol of Kent: the position of a macroscopic source mass is controlled by a quantum random trigger whose firing probability p is continuously tunable, a precision gravimeter monitors the local field, and an otherwise identical run with a classical pseudo-random trigger serves as a control. For no-collapse semiclassical gravity we derive, for a repeated protocol with reset, the field offset in intervals without a release and the suppression of the gravimeter step at quantum-triggered releases; both depend on p, whereas every event-sourced theory predicts a p-independent, event-following field, and the control run cancels systematics that scale with the release rate. Order-of-magnitude estimates indicate that a superconducting gravimeter and a 100–1000 kg source can bound the fraction of “counterfactual” mass that gravitates at the 10−3 level as a function of p. We state which hypotheses the experiment can falsify, why decoherence restricts its scope to no-collapse semiclassical theories, and how the design could be migrated to mesoscopic masses, where the question remains open. Version 2 (September 2026) of a manuscript first written in June 2026. 10 pages, 1 table, 44 references. Also submitted to arXiv (quant-ph, cross-list gr-qc).