Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The issue of retrodiction in Bohm's theory

Yakir Aharonov, Dietrich Albert

Published Jan 1, 1987• 8 citations
OpenAlex

Related papers

The issue of retrodiction in Bohm's theory: Y. Aharonov and D. Albert

Basil J. Hiley, F. David Peat

Routledge eBooks•Jun 25, 2012•0 citations

Reply to Comment on "Surrealistic Bohm Trajectories"

Berthold‐Georg Englert, Marlan O. Scully, Georg Süssmann +1 more

Let us begin with a response to the summary of the Comment by D. Durr, W. Fusseder, S. Goldstein, and N. Zanghi [1]. We are accused to not stay inside orthodox quantum but to employ a naive, largely incoherent operationalism instead. We think that this charge is not justified, because we did apply standard quantum theory correctly and also followed the rules of Bohmian Mechanics (BM) carefully. In the following we react to the more essential points of the Comment in some detail. The Comment suggests that we have conceded many virtues to BM and that we have admitted that standard quantum theory is plagued by notorious conceptual difficulties. This is not the case. On the contrary, we maintain that BM is not needed to have the Schrodinger equation embedded into a physical theory. Standard quantum theory has already clarified the significance of Schrodinger's wave function as a tool used by theoreticians to arrive at probabalistic predictions. It is quite unnecessary, and indeed dangerous, to attribute any additional meaning to the (/^-function. The semantic difference between inconsistent and surrealistic is not the issue. It is the purpose of our paper to show clearly that the interpretation of the Bohm trajectory as the real retrodicted history of the atom observed on the screen is implausible, because this trajectory can be macroscopically at variance with the detected, actual way through the interferometer. And yes, we do have a framework to talk about path detection; it is based upon the local interaction of

Zeitschrift für Naturforschung A•Dec 1, 1993•22 citations

THE THEORY OF BOHM AND BUB

Frederik Jozef Belinfante

Elsevier eBooks•Jan 1, 1973•1 citation

Comments on the theory of the Aharonov-Bohm effect

Heinz J. Rothe

Nuovo cimento della Società italiana di fisica. A, Nuclei, particles and fields•Mar 1, 1981•14 citations

Quantum retrodiction

John Jeffers, Daniel K. L. Oi, Thomas Brougham

Quantum retrodiction, in which the state of a quantum system prior to a measurement is assigned based on the results of that measurement, has had a long history and has been used in quantum optics research for decades. Here we summarize the theory and point out some of the more interesting results, before applying the theory to state identification from multiple shots of an experiment. One surprising result is that we show that a photodetector with low quantum efficiency can discriminate between photonic states better than a detector with a higher efficiency.This article is part of the theme issue 'The quantum theory of light'.

Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Dec 24, 2024•2 citations

Experimental Test of Tracking the King Problem

Cheng-Qiu Hu, Jun Gao, Lu-Feng Qiao +7 more

In quantum theory, the retrodiction problem is not as clear as its classical counterpart because of the uncertainty principle of quantum mechanics. In classical physics, the measurement outcomes of the present state can be used directly for predicting the future events and inferring the past events which is known as retrodiction. However, as a probabilistic theory, quantum-mechanical retrodiction is a nontrivial problem that has been investigated for a long time, of which the Mean King Problem is one of the most extensively studied issues. Here, we present the first experimental test of a variant of the Mean King Problem, which has a more stringent regulation and is termed "Tracking the King." We demonstrate that Alice, by harnessing the shared entanglement and controlled-not gate, can successfully retrodict the choice of King's measurement without knowing any measurement outcome. Our results also provide a counterintuitive quantum communication to deliver information hidden in the choice of measurement.

arXiv:1812.07601•Research•Jan 1, 2019•4 citations
Let us begin with a response to the summary of the Comment by D. Durr, W. Fusseder, S. Goldstein, and N. Zanghi [1]. We are accused to not stay inside orthodox quantum but to employ a naive, largely incoherent operationalism instead. We think that this charge is not justified, because we did apply standard quantum theory correctly and also followed the rules of Bohmian Mechanics (BM) carefully. In the following we react to the more essential points of the Comment in some detail. The Comment suggests that we have conceded many virtues to BM and that we have admitted that standard quantum theory is plagued by notorious conceptual difficulties. This is not the case. On the contrary, we maintain that BM is not needed to have the Schrodinger equation embedded into a physical theory. Standard quantum theory has already clarified the significance of Schrodinger's wave function as a tool used by theoreticians to arrive at probabalistic predictions. It is quite unnecessary, and indeed dangerous, to attribute any additional meaning to the (/^-function. The semantic difference between inconsistent and surrealistic is not the issue. It is the purpose of our paper to show clearly that the interpretation of the Bohm trajectory as the real retrodicted history of the atom observed on the screen is implausible, because this trajectory can be macroscopically at variance with the detected, actual way through the interferometer. And yes, we do have a framework to talk about path detection; it is based upon the local interaction of
Quantum retrodiction, in which the state of a quantum system prior to a measurement is assigned based on the results of that measurement, has had a long history and has been used in quantum optics research for decades. Here we summarize the theory and point out some of the more interesting results, before applying the theory to state identification from multiple shots of an experiment. One surprising result is that we show that a photodetector with low quantum efficiency can discriminate between photonic states better than a detector with a higher efficiency.This article is part of the theme issue 'The quantum theory of light'.
In quantum theory, the retrodiction problem is not as clear as its classical counterpart because of the uncertainty principle of quantum mechanics. In classical physics, the measurement outcomes of the present state can be used directly for predicting the future events and inferring the past events which is known as retrodiction. However, as a probabilistic theory, quantum-mechanical retrodiction is a nontrivial problem that has been investigated for a long time, of which the Mean King Problem is one of the most extensively studied issues. Here, we present the first experimental test of a variant of the Mean King Problem, which has a more stringent regulation and is termed "Tracking the King." We demonstrate that Alice, by harnessing the shared entanglement and controlled-not gate, can successfully retrodict the choice of King's measurement without knowing any measurement outcome. Our results also provide a counterintuitive quantum communication to deliver information hidden in the choice of measurement.