Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1812.07601 · Research

Experimental Test of Tracking the King Problem

Cheng-Qiu Hu, Jun Gao, Lu-Feng Qiao, Ruo-Jing Ren, Zhu Cao, Zeng-Quan Yan, Zhi-Qiang Jiao, Hao Long Tang, Zhihao Ma, Xian-Min Jin

Published Jan 1, 2019• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In quantum theory, the retrodiction problem is not as clear as its classical counterpart because of the uncertainty principle of quantum mechanics. In classical physics, the measurement outcomes of the present state can be used directly for predicting the future events and inferring the past events which is known as retrodiction. However, as a probabilistic theory, quantum-mechanical retrodiction is a nontrivial problem that has been investigated for a long time, of which the Mean King Problem is one of the most extensively studied issues. Here, we present the first experimental test of a variant of the Mean King Problem, which has a more stringent regulation and is termed "Tracking the King." We demonstrate that Alice, by harnessing the shared entanglement and controlled-not gate, can successfully retrodict the choice of King's measurement without knowing any measurement outcome. Our results also provide a counterintuitive quantum communication to deliver information hidden in the choice of measurement.

DOI
10.34133/2019/3474305

Related papers

Quantum-mechanical retrodiction through an extended mean king problem

Amir Kalev, A. Mann, M. Revzen

The mean King problem is a conditional retrodiction problem. In this problem Alice prepares a two prime-dimensional particles state and avails one of the particles to the King who measures its state in one of mutually unbiased bases of his choice. The King tells Alice his choice of basis after she completes a control measurement on his particle. Conditioned on this knowledge, she now infers the state observed by the King by utilizing the outcome of her control measurement. In the extended mean King problem, studied in this paper, the King does not tell Alice his measurement basis, but instead both the King and Alice repeat their measurements. Proper ordering of these allows Alice to deduce both the basis used by the King and the outcome of his first measurement, with the King reticent throughout, i.e., this protocol effects a complete (almost) retrodiction of the King's first measurement.

arXiv:1310.2543•Europhysics Letters (EPL)•Dec 1, 2013•7 citations

The Mean King's Problem: Experimental Realization

O. Schulz, Ruprecht Steinhübl, Markus Weber +3 more

In the Mean King's Problem a ship-wrecked physicist is challenged to infer the outcome of an intermediate spin measurement by a suitable preparation in conjunction with an appropriate control measurement -- the 1987 spin retrodiction puzzle of Vaidman, Aharonov, and Albert. We report the experimental realization of a quantum-optical version in which the outcome of an intermediate polarization projection is inferred by exploiting single-photon two-qubit states. The experimental success probability is consistently above the 90.2% threshold of the optimal one-qubit strategy, with an average success probability of 95.6%.

•Sep 24, 2002•1 citation

Meaner king uses biased bases

Michael Reimpell, Reinhard F. Werner

The mean king problem is a quantum mechanical retrodiction problem, in which Alice has to name the outcome of an ideal measurement made in one of several different orthonormal bases. Alice is allowed to prepare the state of the system and to do a final measurement, possibly including an entangled copy. However, Alice gains knowledge about which basis was measured only after she no longer has access to the quantum system or its copy. We give a necessary and sufficient condition on the bases, for Alice to have a strategy to solve this problem, without assuming that the bases are mutually unbiased. The condition requires the existence of an overall joint probability distribution for random variables, whose marginal pair distributions are fixed as the transition probability matrices of the given bases. In particular, in the qubit case the problem is decided by Bell's original three variable inequality. In the standard setting of mutually unbiased bases, when they do exist, Alice can always succeed. However, for randomly chosen bases her success probability rapidly goes to zero with increasing dimension.

arXiv:quant-ph/0612035•Physical Review A•Jun 28, 2007•16 citations

Quantum trajectory of a spin oscillator, continuous retrodiction beyond the Heisenberg uncertainty relation

Peiying Li, Junlei Duan, Suotang Jia +2 more

The Heisenberg uncertainty relation in quantum mechanics limits the precision of predicting the outcome of measurements of any non-commuting observables. However, this restriction does not apply to retrodictive guessing of the outcomes of past measurements. Here, we experimentally demonstrate this using a spin oscillator consisting of $ 5.17 \times 10^{10}$ rubidium atoms. Through weak continuous measurements, we monitor canonical spin observables $\hat{x}_{\mathrm{A}}$ and $\hat{p}_{\mathrm{A}}$ with $[\hat{x}_{\mathrm{A}},\hat{p}_{\mathrm{A}}] = i\hbar$. By combining information obtained before and after time $t$, we retrodict the outcomes of measurements of $\hat{x}_{\mathrm{A}}$ and $\hat{p}_{\mathrm{A}}$ at time $t$ with variances that remain, concurrently over 1.4 hours, $\sim$ 1.01 dB below the bound set by the Heisenberg uncertainty relation. We also infer and demonstrate the ability to retrodict, with the same precision, the measurement outcomes for arbitrary quadratures of the spin oscillator. This brings interesting prospects for further research on quantum measurements, and for quantum-enhanced sensing that combines trajectory and entanglement strategies.

arXiv:2611.08104•Nov 5, 2026•0 citations

Experimental solutions to the high-dimensional mean king’s problem

Tareq Jaouni, Xiaoqin Gao, Sören Arlt +2 more

Vaidman, Aharanov, and Albert [ Phys. Rev. Lett. 58 ( 14 ), 1385 ( 1987 ) 10.1103/PhysRevLett.58.1385 ] put forward a puzzle called the mean king’s problem (MKP) that can be solved only by harnessing quantum entanglement. Prime-powered solutions to the problem have been shown to exist, but they have not yet been experimentally realized for any dimension beyond two. We propose a general first-of-its-kind experimental scheme for solving the MKP in prime dimensions ( D ). Our search is guided by the digital discovery framework Pytheus , which finds highly interpretable graph-based representations of quantum optical experimental setups; using it, we find specific solutions and generalize to higher dimensions through human insight. As proof of principle, we present a detailed investigation of our solution for the three-, five-, and seven-dimensional cases. We obtain maximum success probabilities of 82.3%, 56.2%, and 35.5%, respectively. We therefore posit that our computer-inspired scheme yields solutions that implement Alice’s strategy with quantum advantage, demonstrating its promise for experimental implementation in quantum communication tasks.

arXiv:2307.12938•Optica Quantum•Nov 17, 2023•2 citations

Experimental retrodiction of trajectories of single photons in double interferometers

Yuan Yuan, Zhibo Hou, Kang‐Da Wu +3 more

When a photon passes through an interferometer, quantum mechanics does not provide a clear answer as to its past. Quantum retrodiction is a quantitative theory, which endeavors to make statements about the past of a system based on present knowledge. Quantum retrodiction may be used to analyze the past of a photon, that is, its trajectory. Here we experimentally retrodict the trajectories of single photons in double interferometers by measuring the final state of the photon. A sequence of measurements is made on a photon to determine which path the photon followed, so a series of retrodiction of measurement results can be regarded as a photon trajectory. We obtain information about the partial trajectory and the entire trajectory of the photon. Furthermore, we also observe the effect of different measurements in the extraction of trajectory information. Our experiment highlights the application of retrodiction theory to the study of the photon's past, and provides potential application in quantum communications.

Physical Review A•Jun 15, 2018•3 citations
In quantum theory, the retrodiction problem is not as clear as its classical counterpart because of the uncertainty principle of quantum mechanics. In classical physics, the measurement outcomes of the present state can be used directly for predicting the future events and inferring the past events which is known as retrodiction. However, as a probabilistic theory, quantum-mechanical retrodiction is a nontrivial problem that has been investigated for a long time, of which the Mean King Problem is one of the most extensively studied issues. Here, we present the first experimental test of a variant of the Mean King Problem, which has a more stringent regulation and is termed "Tracking the King." We demonstrate that Alice, by harnessing the shared entanglement and controlled-not gate, can successfully retrodict the choice of King's measurement without knowing any measurement outcome. Our results also provide a counterintuitive quantum communication to deliver information hidden in the choice of measurement.
The mean King problem is a conditional retrodiction problem. In this problem Alice prepares a two prime-dimensional particles state and avails one of the particles to the King who measures its state in one of mutually unbiased bases of his choice. The King tells Alice his choice of basis after she completes a control measurement on his particle. Conditioned on this knowledge, she now infers the state observed by the King by utilizing the outcome of her control measurement. In the extended mean King problem, studied in this paper, the King does not tell Alice his measurement basis, but instead both the King and Alice repeat their measurements. Proper ordering of these allows Alice to deduce both the basis used by the King and the outcome of his first measurement, with the King reticent throughout, i.e., this protocol effects a complete (almost) retrodiction of the King's first measurement.
In the Mean King's Problem a ship-wrecked physicist is challenged to infer the outcome of an intermediate spin measurement by a suitable preparation in conjunction with an appropriate control measurement -- the 1987 spin retrodiction puzzle of Vaidman, Aharonov, and Albert. We report the experimental realization of a quantum-optical version in which the outcome of an intermediate polarization projection is inferred by exploiting single-photon two-qubit states. The experimental success probability is consistently above the 90.2% threshold of the optimal one-qubit strategy, with an average success probability of 95.6%.
The mean king problem is a quantum mechanical retrodiction problem, in which Alice has to name the outcome of an ideal measurement made in one of several different orthonormal bases. Alice is allowed to prepare the state of the system and to do a final measurement, possibly including an entangled copy. However, Alice gains knowledge about which basis was measured only after she no longer has access to the quantum system or its copy. We give a necessary and sufficient condition on the bases, for Alice to have a strategy to solve this problem, without assuming that the bases are mutually unbiased. The condition requires the existence of an overall joint probability distribution for random variables, whose marginal pair distributions are fixed as the transition probability matrices of the given bases. In particular, in the qubit case the problem is decided by Bell's original three variable inequality. In the standard setting of mutually unbiased bases, when they do exist, Alice can always succeed. However, for randomly chosen bases her success probability rapidly goes to zero with increasing dimension.
The Heisenberg uncertainty relation in quantum mechanics limits the precision of predicting the outcome of measurements of any non-commuting observables. However, this restriction does not apply to retrodictive guessing of the outcomes of past measurements. Here, we experimentally demonstrate this using a spin oscillator consisting of $ 5.17 \times 10^{10}$ rubidium atoms. Through weak continuous measurements, we monitor canonical spin observables x^A\hat{x}_{\mathrm{A}}x^A​ and p^A\hat{p}_{\mathrm{A}}p^​A​ with [x^A,p^A]=iℏ[\hat{x}_{\mathrm{A}},\hat{p}_{\mathrm{A}}] = i\hbar[x^A​,p^​A​]=iℏ. By combining information obtained before and after time ttt, we retrodict the outcomes of measurements of x^A\hat{x}_{\mathrm{A}}x^A​ and p^A\hat{p}_{\mathrm{A}}p^​A​ at time ttt with variances that remain, concurrently over 1.4 hours, ∼\sim∼ 1.01 dB below the bound set by the Heisenberg uncertainty relation. We also infer and demonstrate the ability to retrodict, with the same precision, the measurement outcomes for arbitrary quadratures of the spin oscillator. This brings interesting prospects for further research on quantum measurements, and for quantum-enhanced sensing that combines trajectory and entanglement strategies.
Vaidman, Aharanov, and Albert [ Phys. Rev. Lett. 58 ( 14 ), 1385 ( 1987 ) 10.1103/PhysRevLett.58.1385 ] put forward a puzzle called the mean king’s problem (MKP) that can be solved only by harnessing quantum entanglement. Prime-powered solutions to the problem have been shown to exist, but they have not yet been experimentally realized for any dimension beyond two. We propose a general first-of-its-kind experimental scheme for solving the MKP in prime dimensions ( D ). Our search is guided by the digital discovery framework Pytheus , which finds highly interpretable graph-based representations of quantum optical experimental setups; using it, we find specific solutions and generalize to higher dimensions through human insight. As proof of principle, we present a detailed investigation of our solution for the three-, five-, and seven-dimensional cases. We obtain maximum success probabilities of 82.3%, 56.2%, and 35.5%, respectively. We therefore posit that our computer-inspired scheme yields solutions that implement Alice’s strategy with quantum advantage, demonstrating its promise for experimental implementation in quantum communication tasks.
When a photon passes through an interferometer, quantum mechanics does not provide a clear answer as to its past. Quantum retrodiction is a quantitative theory, which endeavors to make statements about the past of a system based on present knowledge. Quantum retrodiction may be used to analyze the past of a photon, that is, its trajectory. Here we experimentally retrodict the trajectories of single photons in double interferometers by measuring the final state of the photon. A sequence of measurements is made on a photon to determine which path the photon followed, so a series of retrodiction of measurement results can be regarded as a photon trajectory. We obtain information about the partial trajectory and the entire trajectory of the photon. Furthermore, we also observe the effect of different measurements in the extraction of trajectory information. Our experiment highlights the application of retrodiction theory to the study of the photon's past, and provides potential application in quantum communications.